Constructive & Destructive criticism?
I guess this is more of a vent and/or I'm looking for perspective on how to deal with this. I work for a fed agency and this week I'm at a training for all attnys who have joined in the last x yrs. More senior attorneys in the org are serving as instructors, and 99% of them are the coolest, most down to earth people, and I've recieved some really good feedback on improving my courtroom presentation. But there's *1* instructor hell bent (cont. in comments)

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’m sorry. I too work in a federal agency. A lot of folks come here from private practice so we’re literally dealing with the same sort of people who make some private practice toxic. Just try your best to listen to the criticism, learn what you can, and power through. Unless it crosses the line to becoming downright mean or inappropriate, I think just push through it and then try not to work with that person ever again

like

I’m so sorry. Maybe ask your manager if you can talk with him/her about the reports and event overall? Manager should want to know if the event was helpful for you since it was for employee development. You could say how helpful most of the feedback was (and go into specific points) but how you noticed one of the instructors misunderstood the facts (by your and others’ observations) and her feedback was confusing and unhelpful as a result. Maybe end with asking for advice - how would your manager handle this type of situation in a training exercise?

like

Ugh that is the MOST awful feeling and as a starter just know you are SO not alone, I’ve definitely been there in terms of feeling just absolutely squashed by a work experience (and yet still have a thriving career). This definitely sounds to me like it’s a serious problem with HER - even if you got every little thing substantively wrong (which I’m sure you didn’t), her chosen response is so off the mark and says a heck of a lot more about her shortcomings as a trainer than about you as a trainee. Belittlement is never professional and never a good look, and I know when I see more senior attorneys punching down like that I lose a ton of respect for them instantly. I like Attorney 2’s response a lot.

All this sounds VERY shortsighted of the instructor given that she in fact is also in her place of work and has made herself look absolutely terrible in front of all of the your fellow trainees, and having a strategic but honest discussion with your manager in the way Attorney 2 says is a tactful way of ensuring that her abysmal performance as an actually helpful and effective trainer is not lost in the mix, as it shouldn’t be. And if nothing else, everyone around you most likely just made a little mental note of - never work with THAT person (the instructor). I like to believe the karma of being an asshole will catch-up eventually; at least in my agency, corridor reputation for being a nice and good to work with person actually matters a lot.

like

On tearing me down. During an exercise today, she nitpicked absolutely everything about my exercise, going as far as reversing her opinion on certain evidence from an earlier student's presentation, just to say I was using it incorrectly. (Speaking with other students afterward, I wasn't, and they were all bewildered when she lit into me.)
I know I should probably take her singular opinion with a huge helping of salt, but I'm currently sitting in my hotel room feeling 2in tall. I feel like I'm back at my toxic a$$ job in private, and I don't want to see anyone tomorrow. Until this, I had felt like this was a dream job, but I know the instructor reports go to my manager at the end of the week. How should I deal with this the last 2 days? Get some rest and pretend nothing happened? Give my manager a heads up and hope he doesn't take her report seriously?
I just feel immensely sad right now and know my current perspective is probably effed.

Related Posts

My boss is always making last minute changes to my schedule. Adding shifts or asking me to cover for other people. Any advice on how to handle this? I want to be a team player but the last minute changes stress me out.

like

15 days left for my joining but I did not received anything about onboarding, when do they send mail for this?

like

Looking for an average overview of weekly hours in PWM at each level? Any insight appreciated. NYC-based, preferably

like

I have got an offer from Siemens Technology Services of 35.5 LPA for Pune location.

Position- PL8
YOE- 12.3

Is Siemens low-balling me or is this standard in Siemens for this experience?

like
funnylike

What is salry slab for consultant specialist in hsbc ? Tech stack python backend ,Azure, kubernetes ..

like

What are some career paths you can take as a SF business analyst

like

Can someone share the salary for a UX designer with 5 years of experience in Microsoft. I have cleared all rounds and I am not sure what do I ask as my expected salary going by microsoft standards

like

Studied accounting and finance but worried about the future of this profession. Currently working in Forensic Consulting but want to leave. Should I go back to undergrad and get a computer science degree? I honestly want a career where I could at least potentially make 600 k per year. I feel in accounting it’s near impossible. Additionally, I’m sick of people looking down on me. My gf is getting a PhD in a social science and gets way more respect then me. I am 25 also. HELP

likefunny

What’s the hourly pay for others as a quality transaction specialist? I’m at $19.18 and feel it’s low for the inflation rate. HR and leadership refuse to give the salary range definitions and will say if I’m either in the low or median range of pay.

like

Hi @AIRBUS fishes, Can someone throw some light on the the different grades/designations ? I see E4 , Technology Lead mentioned in my offer letter.

like

How does late timesheet impact at Deloitte?. I am worried since this is 3rd one. I have been on top of it after I missed 2 earlier last year when I join the firm in June. But somehow missed yesterday for some family reason and now I’m worried.

like

My two year anniversary of starting my career (in general) is coming up in the next 3 weeks.

Aug 2020- 65k base salary
Jan 2022- 80k base salary
July/Aug 2022- 110k base salary


Just posting as a reminder to LEAVE that job (within a reasonable time 😂) and go where the money is!

(p.s. I already know some of you have had higher increases in the same amount of time & I consider 6 months minimum is “within a reasonable time”)

likehelpful

#LTIMINDTREE is Hiring for Multiple Profiles.

Interested can DM Emailids with Jobcode to APPLY!!

Post Photo
like

People interested in B-school: what are your top schools and why?

like

What drives people to answer stackoverflow questions? I love them for doing so, but when will I feel the urge to contribute?

like

Hi all, I am looking for opportunities into AWS for a sysops admin,cloud engineer
Recently my AWS solution architect associate certification got expired and will be completing AWS sysops Associate certification by end of this month Nov 2022
Currently working as network/cloud support

Skill set : AWS EC2, RDS, ALB,S3,SES
Exp : 5.5 years
Relevant exp : 3.5 years
Current CTC : 6 lak
Expected CTC : 14 lak
Pref location : Chennai, banglore

Kindly help me find a right opportunity guys!

Recieved a hike of 10% with 2 rating.
KGS.
I see people getting 27% with the same rating.

like

Anyone do referrals for open positions in AT & T

Additional Posts in Federal Government Lawyers

Anyone work for the DOL and can provide any insights in the nature of the work, the work environment, etc?

I took a temporary job as an attorney advisor at the SBA this past fall b/c it offered a regular paycheck, and my solo practice was suffering b/c of the pandemic. I like the work. I like working from home. Anyone have any insight into the possibility of this temp job becoming permanent. Did the SBA hire you permanently when your temp position ended? How did that happen?

Any general anecdotes about moving from a market-paying law firm to government? What was the experience like? Any regrets? How bad did the pay cut sting?

like

I graduated in 2016, did a state court clerkship, and then was hired as a hearing officer. I’m looking to apply for an attorney advisor position but wonder if my lack of ‘traditional’ legal work will harm my chances. Thoughts?

How do I determine the likelihood of getting a Top Secret Security clearance? I am qualified for a number of federal jobs but haven’t applied because of an allegation of misconduct at my job five years ago. I have plenty of positive equities since then and evidence of rehabilitation for admission to the bar. I just have no idea how much forgiveness is possible in a TS security clearance.

I was recently approached by a recruiter about a position as a litigation attorney at the DOJ. Unfortunately, he didn’t have any more specific information other than what I would be doing is “generally commercial litigation.” Can anyone share insights on what this may entail? Is it normal for a recruiter to be placing people for these government repositions?

SOS, I got a govt offer & was let go from my current job. I was not given a clear reason for termination but it was not misconduct. How do I phrase this in a disclosure statement for background check

like

Does anyone feel like they’re selling themselves short by working in government? I graduated from a regional law school in 2018 and clerked for 2 years before moving into a GS-13 agency counsel role in DC back in October 2020. I love the work, and I love the work-life balance even more (I rarely work more than 45 hours per week, and almost never on the weekends). I’m 29, no kids, and no real responsibilities outside my student loans. (Continued below)…

like

Is NYC currently hiring ICE General attorneys? I applied in January and haven’t seen any updates since the referral to the local hiring manager.

Could anyone speak to what it’s like to work for HHS as an attorney advisory? Culture, substance of the work, would be interested to hear anything really. Thank you.

After completing 20 years as a Law Enforcement Officer with the Feds and on the way getting a JD and passing the Bar… trying to transition to an Immigration Attorney position… easier said than done!

like

Does anyone know the typical timeline for hiring more junior legal policy positions in a new administration? Is March the norm for junior hires?

Any pros/cons in taking a 3 year term appointment? I am curious if this would make me any more or less marketable when positioning for other federal positions down the line? TIA!

Any guidance on evaluation for GS-13/14 level attorney-adviser positions? Matching resume but credentials aren’t insane.

Anyone have experience at the FTC?

like

What’s the most valuable “soft skill” for any government lawyer? Looking to emphasize it in a cover letter

Anyone recently apply for a position with HHS and the background check is taking ages??

Any insight on working for the CFTC? I have some experience at the SEC, is it a similar kind of culture? Specifically interested in WLB and openness to telework. Thanks in advance!

like

For those that lateraled private practice to gov’t, what was the lag time between referral of your application to interview process?

like

Any suggestions for AUSA interviews? Entry Level?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal