During negotiation with counter offer do I need to give another company offer letter to negotiating company HR?

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

HRs ask for other offers in hand as a proof to give you a higher salary but its not ethical to share an offer letter as its confidential. But people do and almost every company's hr asks for it.

like

Are there any chances that company will revoke existing offer if we approach with counter offer?

Ideally they would want to hire you as they have invested time to go through the rounds, my advice don't be greedy always show what you can bring to the table and always be prepared to say NO. HRs will always tell you if they can't increase after a certain amount.

like

Related Posts

JPMorgan Chase recently introduced a policy change to increase the notice period to 60 days. I'm a 602 and resigned recently and yet my LWD is showing up as 30 days from now. Anyone recently resigned can confirm if they are facing the same or new policy is in effect. This is causing confusion with the next companies I'm interviewing with.

like

Hi folks, have anyone got job offer from Canada by applying from India? If so can anyone guide how to crack interview while applying from India?

I recently joined FIL as Lead BA. Is there any chance of on-site travel? Is there any team where on-site movement is easy?

like

How often do people actually go into the office? I’m about to get an offer as a CE and I live about 90 minutes from the office. Google will give me relocation but if I just need to go in 1-2 a week, I’d be open to stomaching the commute. Any info would be helpful!

like

Why are some entries on the creative circle shortlist in red? Have they accidentally leaked the gold award winners?

like

How much time bny takes to provide laptop post date of joining? As onboarding is virtual.

like
likeuplifting

Does Steve Ballmer own up to his mistakes at Microsoft these days?

like

I’m seriously enatkng to get into an SE role and have been searching for Associate Sales Engineers that do NOT require SE experience since I’ve none. It’s proving to be difficult. Most companies for some reason are requiring 2-3 years of experience for the Associate role. 😭 Any Sales Engineers who know of companies hiring those with no experience? I am in tech as a BDR already.

like

Who are the top 5 strategy firms in today’s market? Go!

How do I find reviews on a particular company?

While you switching company what you expect the most from new company?

like

Please suggest.

Both giving permanent WFH.
Senior Software QA engineer profile.

1. US Product Based company from Bangalore (not a big name) offering 20 LPA fixed. Work related to QA and Ruby Capybara

2. FWC providing deputation to customer Emerson (Mohali loc) offering 24.5 LPA fixed. Work related to UFT.

Please provide your valuable suggestions based on your experience. I am currently working in Product Based company. Not sure if I should join a contract job or a service based company.

like

Do you think logistics and supply chain management is an industry that can function effectively 100% remotely?

like

I am prior military and went to law school. I had a family to take care of while I was a student, hence I went as fast as possible to get to a paycheck, graduating in 2 years, and bypassing the standard summer clerkships. How could I get some experience strictly remote? I am w-2 working as an accountant in healthcare, have passed the bar and am working on my CPA license (studying starts at 3 am, then work FT). I would like to eventually hang a shingle as a tax lawyer, but need experience. TIA!

Hi,

Anyone has any idea about how working model in
Cognizant is currently? Work from home? Or hybrid?
Location: Coimbatore, Tamilnadu

like

Any tips to manage third party vendors and their employees from a contractual point of view to make sure they deliver well.

Men- if you text a girl you “like” but have never asked out on a date that you missed her and she responds “you could ask me out on a date”. How would you respond?

like

Any tips on assessing if the hiring manager will be a good manager and person to work with?

I’d be hoping to learn a lot from them, as they would be pretty much be all of my day-to-day interactions and team. I’ve received an offer but have asked for another convo as I’m still unsure on culture, WLB and training etc as it’s a new team so no other people in comparable roles to talk to.

like

Just about ready to sign a lease in Fort Greene, Brooklyn. Any thoughts or comments on the area/neighborhood?

It’ll be me and my husband. We like the proximity to Manhattan but can get a little more bang for our buck. Also seems like the surrounding area is lively enough that we’ll have things to do without having to go far.

like

Additional Posts in Consulting India

Hi Fishes, Please help me decide which company to choose Only criteria is learning for me. itron, ecolab digital, LTI, Publicis Sapient, Cognizant, Harman

like

Hello Sharks ,

How is scope for SAP RAR / SAP FICO in market ?
How to prepare while switching ?
What they except from 2 year experience candidate ?


There is not much info available about SAP modules interview preparation and all
So please experience people , please share your thoughts .



Is Certification is necessary for higher packages in SAP ?

Job security in Infosys? How's it?

Which company to choose between PWC and TCS having same Offer from both. I heard PWC has long working hours(No work life balance)..Is it true?

like

How is the culture and WLB at Moody's Corp? Specifically the Gurgaon office. Also, what kind of Joining Kit can one expect while joining?

A fad that is spreading wildly among consultants.

I have seen "ESG" be a common tag in everyone's linkedIn, nowadays. This same person probably doesn't even know the full form, and yet boast of being ESG experts. 😂😂

Especially directors, they make the ESG experts work for them and then say they have executed ESG projects to perfection. 🤡

Post Photo
likefunny

Hello fishes,
Need your guidance. I have received an offer and i have mailed my acceptance. But the HR is asking me to sign the documents digitally. Is it ok to do this or i can wait until my first day in office in India.

like

Hi Fishes,
I got my Tata Consultancy offer letter 9.50 LPA two months ago, with that I put down my papers in CTS, now the problem is I got two good Offers Uplers - 14 LPA and Larsen & Toubro Infotech -13 LPA
can i ask TCS to match this offer, if so how can i ask them?
My joining date is 19Sep

Y.O.E -3.6 Yrs
TECH-STACK: react js , frond end developer

like

What tech startups are hiring ex consultants currently? And if you interviewed with them, what was the experience like?

like

i got an email from PWC for offer letter released but when i checked Candidate Portal i found nothing.can anyone guide me.

Sometimes it feels so lonely that you start questioning your existence. When you don't have people to talk to, you have friends but they don't have time. You're single and living in hometown. Life means stress, it's really difficult to live a happy and peaceful life. There is so much of chaos, anxiety and loneliness inside of you that you feel wierd.These are the emotions right now, and I feel them very often.
Many a times feel like growing up has been an injustice to myself. ☹️ sad life ☹️

like

Hi All,

My BRO has an offer from ATOS as a fresher. they've mentioned in the offer letter that there'll be training period of 24 months(reframed version of bond) and also they've mentioned that there'll be penalty of 70k if he wants to leave before this period. Is it compulsory to pay this penalty? Or is there any way we can avoid this, he wants to leave in case he gets a good job offer from other company. Current CTC is only 3.0 LPA and joining location is very far from home.
Plz suggest 🙏tq

like
like

Eknath Shinde is prime example of how leaving current employer is going to help your career.

likefunny

Hi Guys,

We do not the hr informs the interview results even of we are not selected? We are in dark for so many days after the rounds

like

Hi fishes , quick question : are you all taking up next day interviews (adjusting your schedule ) or asking to reschedule for a later day.?

I have only few more weeks to my LWD. I attended interview for 5 companies all cleared, but only 1 offer in hand, which I am not satisfied with. Others never came back with salary negotiation/confirmation. They just ask the expected CTC and never get back with update. It's a painful wait and demotivating. Do they come back or am I just waiting for nothing? My expectation is not out of the box too. Please suggest?

Hello fishes, company A offered me a role and based on that i resigned. Now i have got a better offer from a product based company and I'm planning to join it. When is it good time to inform company A that i won't be joining them. 15 days NP left. I currently have only these two offers in hand. Thanks for the reply in advance.

like

🤣🤣 Deloitte EY KPMG PwC

Post Photo
funnylike

I had cleared all rounds in Accenture and documents upload is also done but the recruiter never called after that, currently the status shown is as below:
"Owing to business reasons we foresee some delay in processing your candidature. Once we have a suitable demand, commensurating your background, experience and expertise, we shall reach out to you.
We highly appreciate your patience and continued interest in Accenture job opportunities."
Will I get offer or not?
Accenture

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal