Just wrapped my fourth interview with the same agency… after being in the process for over a month. Now they’ve asked me to complete a project that will take a few hours. I’ll be working on it at night because I have a job and little kids, so daytime hours aren’t an option. I’m genuinely excited about the role, but honestly… at what point does this stop being a hiring process and start feeling like free labor?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Send a quote with your hourly rate that they need to sign off on before you start

like

This. I’ve heard several people ask to be paid for their time for a take home project for an interview, especially if it’s related to the role / business, and most got it approved (or they changed the project to be indirectly related).

like

There’s rarely a “spec project” during the interview process that only takes “a few hours”… not literally. Or it shouldn’t IMHO.

I’ve done it several times before. Spent a ton of time on both, but shared with hiring managers that neither were good examples of what I could bring to the table because it was work done in a vacuum.

Our industry relies on having all the important info and context upfront, tools to do your job well (and may not have access to on a personal level, depending on role), and collaboration to make good ideas even better. You don’t know what you don’t know.

Got an offer in one case and didn’t in another. But I didn’t end up taking the offer because I was already freelancing elsewhere and got a FT offer from them once I shared I got an offer from the other place (which was a much lower offer btw).

TBH they both left a bad taste in my mouth.

Do you want to work for a place that expects “free” work from you upfront?

Will they give away the agency’s work for free too? If so, how will that impact their profitability (and, thus, your salary).

Are there other options to show your thinking (portfolio, decks, writing examples, etc)?

like

This is a red flag for a job that will likely not pan out. No matter how excited you are, unless you’re applying for the CEO role, assessing your skills for the position doesn’t take 5 SEPARATE interviews AND an assignment to determine. I think I even saw a thread where a spec idea was used in the real commercial, (without pay/permission). I know what the market’s like these days but even so, I’d bow out if they don’t agree to pay you a small amount for the spec work. They should practically start paying you for all the countless interview time. Good luck.

like

As a fellow parent I feel this completely

Make sure you *note at the bottom of EVERY page that they cannot use any portion of the information provided in your presentation unless they contract you or hire you full time.

Would you mind DM’ing me the name of the sh*tshow agency/company this is so I can avoid ever applying there?

like

It doesn't matter if they "honor" the slide. When they use it, and you sue them, they can't say they didn't know it wasn't their IP.

Just say no!

like

If they ask you for free work, shit on em. Name and shame.

I did a spec project for an experiential agency once. Spent the entire weekend doing it. I covered all bases from strategy to deck design to rendering to cost roll out, etc. they were blown away only to be told that they are not sure I’d be the right fit for the role. Turned out they never hired for the role. I will never do that shit again unless they are paying me how me time. Anyway, I hope you fare better than I did just did.

You’re not the only one! So remember that. It might be 5 candidates working on this “special project”.

Feels like they’re dragging you through a hiring freeze hoping money becomes available.

So how do you plan on doing work for them? All evenings, that’s not going to work them.

Related Posts

Anyone from Data and Analytics consulting practice in EY GDS?

like

What is the average % for annual appraisal and bonus will get in KGS?

like

My SO adds very little to our relationship. She has a dead end job. I cook. I work. I oversee finances. I plan trips. She doesn’t have a voice in the relationship. I’ve asked her to give her perspective but she always defaults to mine bc she thinks I’m smarter/worldly. She feels intimated by me and my social circle. Lately, I’ve found myself thinking for her. Anticipating her wants and needs and then adjusting my behavior to meet them. Which she appreciates but it’s frustrating 29M 27F

like

When picking up a J2, how much should you include about J1 on a background check?

like
like

Bain & Company Hello, I received an offer as a Senior Practice Manager at Bain. The profit sharing range is 0-12% in the offer letter. Is it typical to receive the midpoint (6%)? Also, what do the annual salary increases typically look like? Any insights are much appreciated. Bain & Company Boston Consulting Group McKinsey & Company

I have got an offer from S&P Global I want to know about following things

How much of Variable Pay is Paid ?? I got 15% of Base salary but how much will be paid like the usual norm i want to know

And what are the deductions from Base salary apart from PF ?
There are lot of allowances like internet reimbursement etc etc
Are they mandatorily credited or you need to claim ?

S&P Global Hey everyone, Heard this rumour that huge layoffs are going to happen in S&P global india....can anyone give heads up about this ?

S&P Global

helpful

Has anyone come to you for help?

Remember that these people asked Allah first, and Allah gave them your address for you to help them.

like

In your experience have engineering salaries posted on Glassdoor been accurate? I’m seeing many that seem low

like

Hi, I'm leaving Citi in 2 months.It's hard to make this decision. I have an offer from a small startup.In citi, my previous experience was not considered and was reskilled to different tech which is the reason for change.I don't like to exit citi. As I like the company so much.But considering my current knowledge,I am in the middle of the sea.I am afraid now that the new company's offer would be revoked due to this recession?Or can I take back my resignation in citi before the last working day.Is this wise decision?

like

Hello Connection,
Please Do not ignore this post .
My sister is looking for a job . She is BE graduate and well trained in SQL, manual testing and Java from recognised organization for 5 Months. kindly let me know if you have any opportunities.
She is struggling a lot , applying for 100s of jobs on daily basis but not getting response from anyone. Please help.
Hoping for positive response 🤞
Thanks in Advance!!

like
like

Anyone with experience with the snoo and any feedback on it? Have a friend that offered to let me borrow hers, so no cost considerations to think about, but have read that it could cause a flat head/other issues and just curious as to what experiences people have actually had with it. Thanks!

like
like

Kab tak aayega yaar yeh appraisal

like

How bad is it to sound shaky during the case interview? I got everything right and nailed the math but I feel like I sounded like I was about to cry even though I was confident 🤦🏻‍♀️

like
like

Congratulations on your stimulus check, pick any item from the bottom case.

Post Photo
likefunny

Hi everyone - I made it to the final round of interviews with Amazon for a Program Manager position. They initially asked if I would relocate and at the time I said yes - however, due to my husband’s new job I’m no longer able to relocate.
Has anyone ever negotiated to work remote for Amazon?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising Careers & Job Hunting

Asking for a friend: any AD openings in Dallas?

like

He is accepting notes.

Post Photo
like

AE’s looking for a new gig in your stocking? Great, longtime agency in Boulder...

Post Photo
like

Looking for a Japanese designer who is strong in typography and a copywriter too. Based in Tokyo or California. Please DM your books.

likefunny
like

These guys have had this job listing up for about a year, or seems...

Post Photo
like

What are your excuses to leave your current job early for an interview at another agency?

Anybody looking for a senior analyst?

Anyone in Portland down to chat? I have a small creative portfolio and a couple years of management experience. Been looking for PM roles (but am open to anything).

like

Anyone have any tips on finding great content creators? Ty in advance!

Is it just me or is production seriously that dry (fulltime or otherwise) in NYC these days? Can’t seem to find my next FL gig, even with ample experience and great names in my book! What gives!

like

Our client, a Manhattan pharmaceutical digital advertising agency is looking for a VP or SVP Brand Strategy.. Needs experience working on a brand with multiple indications in the oncology space (ideally) and be actively working on approx. $7 mil. of revenue.
1st. round of interviews will be internal. Candidate will be asked to present to the agency, then meet the client. On-going work will be remote. The salary range is $165 to $210++ negotiable
Contact us for job description
Stay Safe

like

Looking for a writer to help on a pretty straightforward assignment. Creating a language matrix, helping refine existing language, executional/not conceptual. $900/day for 2 months. Kicks off July 12, all remote. Please DM me if interested!

like

Any leads on CD positions north of Boston?

Got a verbal offer from a big agency a week ago and HR said written offer will come by EOD but no email. They did background check last week. Followed up last week no response, what should I do?

helpful

Any designers with ~4 years experience in nyc looking? Agency side but work is for a finance client. DM me for info and I’ll pass along books.

likehelpful

Hi Fishies, I’m looking for a Creative Strategist role (+ have copywriting bg). Lemme know if you know someone who’s hiring!

like

Got flaked on twice in a span of 3 hours by a recruiter.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal