Potentially have 2 offers.. one meaningfully higher comp than other but have preference for lower comp role/company. Any suggestions on how to approach negotiation and what is reasonable to ask for?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

My perspective:

To the lower comp role, let them know you have a competitive offer from another company and share the amount. Ask nicely if there is anything they can do to bring their offer closer to the other offer. Emphasize that you are very excited about the role and would love to work with them, but you just need a little help with the financial part given what you are leaving behind here and the other offer you have on the table.

To the higher comp role, just do a standard negotiation without mentioning the lower comp role. They might budge 5-10% and that can be a sweetener in case you end up taking it.

like

Please lay out the offers so we can help

like

Like M1 said, we need more details.

I had the same situation recently and went with the lower option. They came all the way up to my negotiation ask which cut the difference in half. However, they really wanted me and had been looking for a long time without success.

like

Thank you, all. Have verbals and will follow up with more detail when clear. Appreciate the perspectives!

like

so you don’t have any offers

Related Posts

1. Currently working as backend developer. Is it good to join Cisco Appdynamics for technical support role ?
2. How is the job security at Appdynamics specially for technical support role ?
3. Chances of moving internally to development role after one year ?
Kindly don't skip

CCTC - 17 LPA
Tech stack - Java, Spring Boot, Microservices Backend developer
Yoe - 4
Offered role in cisco - Software engineer G8
Offered package - 26.5 base + 1.85 variable + 5 lakhs jb

Cisco AppDynamics EPAM Systems

like

What should be the salary of a tester with 6.5yrs experience?

like

What is your favorite parent communication tool and why? I used Seesaw this last year and it worked fine, but I’m considering checking out class dojo. Thoughts?

Can I waive into other UBE jurisdictions using my NY UBE license at any time? Or is there an expiration date for my bar exam score, after which point I won't be able to waive in?

like

Been thinking about the other post about ADHD jobs. Any other job hoppers here or people with non linear careers? Or maybe you got a specific degree and are now doing something completely different? This has been a decade-long struggle for me.

like

Any of you successfully transitioned from consulting to AWS? If so, would you share your experience?

likehelpful
like

Hey everyone, pleased to make your acquaintance! I have almost 3 yrs of experience in Accounting and I'm looking to transition into a more people-oriented role like Recruitment or Community. Any advice or references? Thanks in advance!

like

Anyone have the newer, smaller Cartier JUC? If so, is it a practical don’t take off/wear it everyday bracelet? Would it work to stack with the Love (if you have it)? Thank you in advice for any advice. :)

like

Who did the schizophrenia ads? They’re pretty cool tbh

like

Is there a way for me to automate creating columns to do this so I can drag across and create my columns? For example--
1Q2021 2Q2021 3Q2021 4Q2021 2021 1Q2022?

likesmart

Hello there!

help me open dm's

Thanks (:

like

Hi fishes,

I joined Accenture this week and recived my laptop today, wanted to know what are the peripheral i should receive as my start up kit, i only received a laptop and nothing else like mouse or headphones. Is there anyone i can connect to get clarification?

like

Hi fishes,
Want some feedback for Employees Assistant Program (EAP) by Capgemini which provides facilities to connect with Therapist.
Actually I am going through some tough times(going through a divorce), want to connect to EAP to discuss my mental health issues.
I had connected once and they say that the conversations are strictly confidential.
Just wanted to know do they really keeps stuff confidential or can they inform my Manager regarding the personal conversations.

like

I want to know how UBS (UK) reach out to you for interview purposes I mean through a phone call or over the email.

like

Hi everyone. I’m trying to transition from working at a non-profit to a more profitable position within research. My current title at my org is as a CR-assistant. Any suggestions of good transitional positions within clinical research? (That could be done remotely). Thank you!!

How does a role in clinical affairs differ from clinical research? Any clinical affairs manager out there to shed some light? Wondering if clinical affairs will have more sciencey roles.

like

Hi Everyone!

A company has made an offer and I wanted to understand if i'm being made a fool.

The monthly compensation is 1,37,500 (16,50,000 yearly) and Variable component (Bonus) is 1,50,000.

However in the offer it says "You shall be paid an annual compensation of Rs. 16,50,000/- per annum Cost to Company."

Which to me sounds like it doesn't consider 1,50,000 to be a part of CTC which is suspicious to me.

How should I deal with this?

Thank you!

like

Asking for my husband…

We both think he’s underpaid.

Masters degree in architectural engineering (focus on mechanical)

Works on large job sites doing commissioning and project management as a “commissioning engineer” (large in sq footage and high profile jobs for a large Midwest city)

8 YOE on large projects in the Midwest

He’s making 75K.

like

Hi team,

I left wipro and joined new company a month before. In new company's form 11 ita asking whether you have been part of epf and eps in last organization?
Epf i am sure i need to give yes. But what do i need to give for Eps? I am aware that wipro contributed 8.33% of pf to eps. Can i transfer that too?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal