Kpmg or Deloitte for Workday Consulting? Both have given offers and both seem like great places to work.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Deloitte has a more mature tech and human capital practice overall.

like

Why on earth will you call consider lower pay and lower titles? Even though Deloitte is mature I can’t find a justification of joining at lower title and lower pay. Plus at Deloitte churn is high.

like

Go to KPMG.

like

KPMG. When receiving offers from both KPMG and Deloitte, I chose KPMG because of its culture (granted both had the same pay). I don't regret my decision one bit - the leadership really looks out for you and I've found many mentors, informal and formal, through all the different projects here.

like

Deloitte would pay less though. Kpmg offered a higher title and 10K more yearly... but I get the feeling Deloitte is more mature

like

Deloitte

like

I’d go Deloitte with lower pay.

like

And try to negotiate upwards to get parity or close to from Deloitte

like

No - corporate services. Do a ton of system implementation work though (not with workday), but all the folks I've met from that practice are pretty solid

like

That’s good! Talked with a few people and the partner I met with was solid—really liked him.

like

Op you should talk to K1 or someone like him through burner to get feel for the practice. Usually during recruitment the leadership is always sweet. Your goal should be to understand how many solid projects they have done ( to understand if there’s some key folks from whom you can learn from as well).. if they have solid pipeline ....and last but mot least exit options.

like

Hello! I am in Deloitte’s Workday practice! Based on what I hear from my colleges that have migrated here from other firms, we typically match any “higher” offer you might receive (I have started off in this practice and have since remained in this practice). We have a very high demand for skilled Workday folks. Feel free to let me know if I can drop a burner for you, would be happy to talk on company culture, practice culture, etc.

like

I imagine Deloitte would match KPMG, workday is really growing here

like

* Workday is a ERP System

Yea it sounds like they have a lot of internal resources built out

Haha I just don’t want to end up in the situation I’m in now. The attrition rate in the Workday Practice is high and we are losing all of our experienced people. I would take a pay cut if it meant I’d have less headaches

Pay cut meaning kpmg vs Deloitte. Both are at least 10k higher than what I’m being paid now

Deloitte doesn’t have that kind of brand to justify lower pay and /title. If it paid more but lower title then its a different matter. Its a foolish move to go anywhere with lower pay and title. . For years to come a person will always be judged by what he is earning. As a tech consultant your value lies on the skill set that you know. And no company has that kind of additional value which can transform one person from crap to gold just by brand or internal methodology. But again these are all personal choices. I don’t know your capabilities. We learn from our-decisions. We can only provide some pointers. You can extend your offer to PwC1 and tell Deloitte HR “ would you like 2 for price of 1 “ and split your salary. Both of you will be happy with Deloitte brand and lower pay

Thank you AC1 that’s a good point. I also really enjoyed everyone I talked to at kpmg as well. Both seem like good places

KPMG.

Related Posts

like

Aiming to move back to NYC at the end of April. Anyone looking for a potential roomie? I personally can’t justify spending over $1,100 on rent and am open to different neighborhoods. I found some nice apartments entering Harlem around 112th if anyone is interested in getting to know each other more. I’m a 24F but open to all genders.

like

Anyone know the best way to get into the mid/ back office roles at a PE firm?
Currently in public accounting in FDD, realized front office roles are not in the cards at the moment, but thinking FP&A or something similar in the space interests me.

like

Moved into first home and planning to flip in couple of years. Does not want to spend much on blinds.From where I should get the cheapest blinds?

like

How is the work for senior QA in druva ?

like

Good afternoon ,
What is a tool you’ve used to source nurse practitioners and physicians assistants?

Any groups whether on LinkedIn or any other site that I should be a part of?

like

Salesforce Marketing Cloud - too few who knows the architecture, ins/outs and how to implement in an enterprise environment. struggle yet good opportunity for those who wants to get ahead

like

How much does a manager at an IB make? Like around what?

like

Due in 2 weeks with baby number two, husband just tested positive for Covid 😩 He’s been around me and our 2 year old the past 2 days, getting PCRs for me and my LO tomorrow. Freaking out is an understatement. We had our first in May 2020 and never thought we’d still be going through this 2 years later. Anyone know anyone whose delivered or had a c section with Covid? Looking for some encouragement everything will work out okay. This is crazily the first time we’ve had it!

like

Do creative directors have to manage people?
I don’t like managing people, especially juniors who are still figuring out their career paths. But at my company, in order to be considered a leader, you have to manage people. I see myself as a leader, contributing ideas and strategy… I just don’t want to deal with developing performance goals and compensation. Is this the case everywhere? Can I be a creative leader without managing?

like

Hello fishes,

I'm a data engineer working on our in house ETL tools and python scraping and I don't have any cloud knowledge. Is it good to learn "Azure synapse analytics" to upgrade and get into bigger roles with better packages. My yoe is 1 in data engineer role along with 4 years as content Analyst.

like

There’s a candidate I like who applied to a job posting but he didn’t write a cover letter as indicated on the posting...flag?

like

Hi

I am selected for Full stack developer in EY GDS. But I have offer of other companies like Optum, IBM. Can anyone give input on comparing these company with EY on technology POV. I have 4 years of experience.

like

Any tips on getting familiar with software like Kinaxis?

like

How do you keep interview rejections from companies and roles you really want from not breaking your heart? 😭

like

Hey all! I’m a copywriter in Chicago and considering relocating to Minneapolis. Any creatives who have done the same? What do you like/dislike about both cities? Looking for any advice and perspective

7 day breakfast challenge.
Post a picture of your breakfast. Can’t wait to see all of the pics!

like

Hi fishbowl! I am an award winning freelance creative behind a big viral campaign, I am available to start a new gig this Monday, my current freelance gig at a big pharma agency is ending. My expertise is big dangerous ideas as well as design. I take my ideas from concept to execution. Please reach out if you’d like to see my website / connect.

likefunny

Can vets treat humans?

like

Does anyone in here participate in a 529 for their kids? Is it true that you can deduct contributions from your state tax? If so? Is it 1:1? Trying to decide how much to contribute for maximum tax benefits. TIA!

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Anybody else having one of those "What's it all for?" moments?

I know we are incredibly, incredibly well paid and to have that is a priviledge - so let's get that out of the way.

Am just curious if this has been on anyone else's mind recently or even in the past, to understand how others have/do think about this profession as I think about my own plans...

like
like

Luxury babes! Drop some links to the most luxurious, softest, finest sheets you’ve ever slept on. I’m in desperate need of something amazing but the algorithm keeps giving me cheap cotton. I don’t want silk or satin, but something that feels like like that. And water resistant is important too.

likefunny

Hours real talk. I've always been very "bill what I work" so that means light weeks I'm destroying my own utilization/billing initiatives instead. Meanwhile peers bill 40-45 regardless. Am I an idiot?

like

Any top MDs / business owners actively take on mentees? How would you generally respond to cold calls and cold emails for noobs just trying to pick your brain and learn stuff? Happy to respond and have at length back and forth? Not worth your time or not enough time? Other?

like

I recently started at Big 4 and I am aware that my coach is not that great. What should I do? I really want to climb as high as I can at Big 4 but understand that having a good coach is essential

likefunny

How do you know when someone is smart but isn’t great at working?

How do you know when someone is great at working but not all that smart?

like

This is my season for grace, for favor, this is my season to reap what I have sown 🎧

like

For folks here in open relationships, how much (if at all) do you disclose to coworkers? How do you go about disclosing such info in a professional manner that's not deemed TMI? Reason for question in comments.

like

Any non-boutique consulting firms hiring in Miami or Tampa for strategic transformation or diligence competencies? I have 2 YOE in strategy / ops / innovation primarily financial services, both retail and commercial. I am industry agnostic though.

like

Does anyone know what industries / competencies got hit by the layoffs yesterday? A few people mentioned it, but no one gave any details.

like

Heated hotel bathroom floor = one feature I wish every hotel would adopt. What's yours?

like

What’s an appropriate salary for a PMO Manager role at Apple in California?

like

That time when the biggest decision of the day is where to continue sleeping- in your room or pool or on the beach. #problemsolver

like

many of us couldn’t live at home during or after college, and after working, graduated with debt. If you finished ugrad with student loans, how much in loans, what’s your current age and net worth

like

How often do folks at the SM level get asked to leave/fired?

like

Question for startup founders: when did you know it was time to make the leap and go for it?

like

Anyone that’s moved to Publicis Sapient at senior levels and can share your experience? Understand they’re trying to grow and seeking talent from well established firms. Saw some previous feedback here that were mixed to mediocre. Publicis Sapient

like

How do I seem to always get selected for “random” extra security checks at the airport? I know the answer already but it’s pretty annoying.

like

What’s going on? Wasn’t it supposed to go down?

Post Photo
funnylike

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal