Muslims — I’d love your thoughts.
How do you approach the issue of halal vs. haram income when working in big consulting firms? Do you feel confident it’s fine, or do doubts linger?

We often hear that “the dust of riba is everywhere,” but at what point should we really question whether we’re indirectly supporting systems or clients that cause harm — like defense contractors or corporations that break laws knowing they can just pay the fines?

Curious to hear how others reason. 🙏🏿

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I think about it too sometimes and I don’t have an answer but I try to steer clear of projects with banks for example.

like

Work hard, prove yourself to be a team player and be a strong communicator. Push to rise up through the corporate ranks and yes definitely stay away from haram (alcohol etc) but don’t distract yourself with every single thing. Nothing wrong with consulting.
Early on in my career I got carried away with these too many things which in reality were just an easy justification for me to be lazy and introvert at work.

like

This is the very opposite of what I think I should do. To be frank. But that’s for sharing your life experience and advice.

like

I will refuse to work on clients that don’t align with my values like alcohol, lottery, tobacco.

like

Don’t really believe in haram income tbh in that sense. To me as long as you’re not deceiving others to get it you’re fine. Such as selling illegal substances, human trafficking, etc.

For example…Interest income is helping out people in the modern day, lending money to allow others to achieve their personal or business goals is so rewarding on both fronts. I feel like the concept of interest is haram is severely outdated and impractical nowadays.

I wouldn’t put defense contractors in that either as majority of the money they make is used to defend our country from foreign threats that are our enemies, i.e. terrorism. I would actually put that is a noble industry of work tbh because it is actually cleaning up most of the bad that exists in our home countries such as US involvement in Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan which have eliminated dictators, cleared extremist political rule, and ultimately gave freedom to millions of people.

Back after some weeks.

This was not a post aimed at shaming anyone, or calling for some mass exodus. We are all in charge of ourselves.

I have no qualms about the quality or quantity of my work. (Ok I do, but that’s more my own self growth standards/gaps rather than me short-changing the firm).

Something from a recent khutba has stayed with me: aiding an oppressor, even in the smallest way, is still sharing in their oppression.

Surah Hūd (11:113):

“And do not incline toward those who do wrong, lest the Fire touch you, and you have no protectors other than Allah, nor shall you be helped.”

Imām al-Ṣādiq ():

“Beware of assisting the oppressor, even if it is as small as sharpening his pen. Whoever does so will be raised with that oppressor on the Day of Judgment.”

When I think about our work in big consulting firms, it feels like we do far more than just “sharpening the pen.” Our projects are often about smoothing the way for global corporations — sometimes at the expense of vulnerable people or entire regions. The money we’re paid isn’t neatly separated by client either; it’s pooled, redistributed, and we all benefit from it.

For me, this isn’t about judging anyone else. It’s about my akhirah. It’s about jannah or jahannam, and asking myself honestly: where are the red lines? What would the Prophet do? What guidance has he already given us?

When I read some of these strategy reports — “streamlining exports,” “reducing political friction,” “unlocking emerging markets” — I can’t help but hear echoes of the same old colonial project, just dressed in modern business language. And that scares me.

I raise it here because “ there’s nothing new under the sun “, so I’m positive someone has thought/felt/pondered the same

I relate, OP. I think the lines like this will continue to blur, but we as Muslims know this world is not the final abode and there will continue to be chaos in the world. I have a question for you - outside of your work, how do you spend your time? Last year instead of thinking I need to find a job that fulfills everything for me - I started volunteering and doing more with my time. I still avoid any projects that don’t align with my values, but how I spend my time more has given me a greater sense of direction

Related Posts

can anyone let me know about Hashmap. The company has been acquired by NTT data and they are offering ntt data offer.

YOE is 6. Profile is senior cloud engineer-ETL

like

Attended multiple first rounds for mphasis(full time - Texas location). But still I didn’t hear any feedbacks from any of the interview panels/consultancy companies. Seems like they are conducting interviews for name sake and letting us to get wait for the results (for more than a month)
Seriously! positions are available? or I don’t know what’s happening around me. It’s frustrating!

What’s the hiring process of Mphasis?

helpful

Hey All...

I am planning to change my profession from fixed asset accounting to Business Analyst...

Is this wise decision?!!!

like

How do I figure out spending with my SO? Initially I was paying for 90% of stuff (no actual bills, just going out). I talked to her and said we need to be more even. She was never proactive. She kind of got offended but we ended on a good note to split things. It went well for a couple weeks but now it's back to normal. She never takes out her card and only venmos me if I send her the request. She lets Venmos sit for weeks before paying them. I still let a lot of things slide.

like

I am an Engg. (2004-2008) then went for MBA from UPES, Dehradun in Oil and Gas (2012-2014 : Regrettable decision). No connection though with O&G industry. Approx 10 years of work exp. Thinking of pursuing ISB MBA for a career jump. Present CTC 12.75. Any suggestions on which course shall I go for or any other alternatives. I can go for regular MBA too. (My age is 36, if it helps).

like

What is the pay difference at consultant level between Dubai and Riyadh? Thanks

Hello People,
I am actively looking for Job opportunity in O2C- Accounts Receivable profile.
I do have relevant experience of 3 years 9 months in collections, billing & cash application.

Would really appreciate referrals from anyone or if someone can just let me know if there any vacancies available.

like

Hi

Has anyone from the cognizant registered BH for a car in Pune or Maharashtra? And are they allowing it? As per rules its allowed but I heard RTO is declining the request

Cousin got offers from IBM and TCS in pune. Which one is better? IBM is paying slightly less salary and not ready to match.

likefunny

What is the salary range that Salesforce offers for SFMC consulant role?

like

Does TCS AWS service line and Data Analytics unit has good python projects.They asked Core Python, Pandas and asked if you have experience in Azure.Will they give project in same or python data engineer project?

like

What band does managing consultant belongs to and what is the pay range

like

after receiving the portal link to accept the offer letter, what is the deadline to I accept it?

like

Looking for Ramadan specials to watch and bond with my family. Anybody have good suggestions? Thank you in advance

like

Got a referral to BCG and still haven’t had anybody follow up to screen or interview me. It’s been two weeks now. Lol do I give up all hope? How long does this usually take?

like

Fallon NYC, how’s it like? Are there opportunities for creatives? Is there mentorship?

MAGA!!!
America first!!!
Winning!!!

Post Photo
likehelpfulfunny

Anyone here diagnosed with gum disease (periodontitis)?? What’re you doing to improve your gum & general oral health? Any recs for toothpaste / mouth wash? Thank you!

like

Deloitte 🐠 - did anyone get selected in the H1B lottery this year? I have only heard of rejections so far sent from BAL

like

Additional Posts in Muslim Consultants

How do you single 🐟 find time to meet people and get to know them when working these crazy hours? Feel like I'm putting that part of my life on hold due to my job, and it's kind of freaking me out 😣

like

Anyone talk to a Muslim therapist? Muslim matters because I’d like to talk about marital issues, and not sure others will get the religious context. NYC preferred. TIA!

like

Chewy TUMS: These look so good but its not clear to me if its halal. How do you determine from these ingredients? Especially when the first ingredient is alcohol ammonium which i know its not alcohol but any clarification on these ingredients would be appreciated!

like

Something to brighten your day 🤗
I was listening to a Mufti Menk lecture yesterday on this topic. Surah Nashra is also about burdens we bear. Within this Surah,Allah SWT speaks about how He is the one that granted the cure, purity, and strength after the backs were about to break. Allah SWT takes us to this point to refine us. We never know our capabilities until we are tested and challenged. This is when we realize we can do it and we can get through it 🫶🏻! IA you got this 🫶🏻!

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Is working for a company that sells haram (Bank financial products, Walmart liquor products, etc) haram? Looking at an exit opportunity and part of (<10%) of their products are alcohol as a B2B seller. I want baraka in my earnings and want some help understanding this. Jazakallah

like

Does anyone here work in the Middle East? I am seeking opportunities in the healthcare consulting space and would appreciate any leads.

like

Anyone willing to give a referral for IBM and Deloitte canada, I am a new grad and looking to start my career in consulting

like

What are best high-end Halal places or places with Halal mean in GTA (Toronto and burbs)?

like

Salam. My cousin’s newborn son is going into surgery today. Please make dua for his recovery and remember him in your prayers everyone 🤲

like

Good day everyone, I was turned down by Accenture strategy last minute before offer due to the Macro uncertainties, any of you have referrals for MBB/Big4/@tier2? I am 8+ YOE in strategy & transactions I’m open to all offices THANK YOU!

like

Where my arabs at

like

Just came from a salatul janazah.. 😢 😔 😞

like

Where are you from?

like

Any tips on where to buy cotton that’s not from Xinjiang? It seems like all cotton comes from there ?

Have bad allergies and need to wear 100% cotton.

like

Jummah Mubarak Fam ☪️💚

like

Salam. 23M here - all my life I’ve had my back on our faith - never really prayed but had imaan (I guess). After bouts of depression from girl problems (🙄), issues within immediate family, being disappointed expectations I had for myself, etc. I’ve been working on bettering my situation over the years. Faith is the only area where I think I need more guidance. Having trouble relating to friends or family about this. Anyone else been thru something similar? How have you connected back to Islam?

likeuplifting

Accenture, you good mate? Too much turkey?

likefunnyuplifting

Jummah Mubarak Fam 💚

like

It’s been real uncle D, but the bag has called

like

What are peoples thoughts on working for a Banking Company in a Product or Tech role? I know there are mixed feelings since it’s not working directly with interest, etc.

If you currently work in banking, what was your reasoning (besides pay)?

If you don’t, would you ever accept an offer if it in a Tech or Product role?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal