Property Manager vs. Realtor: Which to Choose?

First-time landlord, SFH in San Jose:

• Property Manager (8%, $392/month): Full service: tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance, tenant issues.
• Realtor ($200/month for the first year or until tenant renews): Only handles tenant leads, no screening or ongoing management.

Not sure how often tenant issues arise or how frequently new tenants are needed. Your advice is welcome.

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

What's the point of the realtor if the dont screen? Why don't you just post on Zillow yourself?

like

Also struggling to see the point of what the realtor would be for in this scenario. I just went through Zillow as a renter, and it’s pretty easy to navigate, you can use their services for applications and such. I’d personally be more inclined for the property manager just so I had less to worry about and could hand it off to somebody with the experience for starters.

like

Agree and leaning towards that.. either do self with Zillow or do property manager..
realtor by itself is of not much value!

The Realtor is charging WAY too much. I’d do Zillow.

like

Posted in Zillow 10 days ago. Decent interest initially, 4 viewings but nothing converted. Now no interest as such.. so may be realtors network is stronger? But yea no more value than that..

Keep waiting. Is the rent in line with what you’re thinking? Also see if you have friends at the big tech companies who can post it on their boards for you

like

You’ll likely need a property manager anyways, unless you live close by and trust yourself to do maintenance on your own.

You can always relist on Zillow. Also, don’t be afraid to go “Old-School” - local community orgs, church bulletin boards, or newspaper ads are a great way to get older, long-term tenants.

Final outcome- I am starting this all on my own. Let’s see how this goes for the first year..

Property manager

You had me at FULL SERVICE, go with the property manager.

I’m debating the same. So my realtor claims she’s also a property manager. That can’t be true right?

Also if the house gets involved in any lawsuit, like tenant destroyed my wall, etc. Is the property manager responsible for this or me?

Either you or the tenant. Prop manager has zero liability except to fix it for you (at your cost)

like

Property manager for sure. Trust me on this. I have a friend who made the mistake of going realtor and had a tenant who didn't pay rrent for 6 months and it was impossible to get him out. Having someone to do screaning and eal with the issues is a good thing.

You can certainly land a tenant through Zillow but if this is an initial foray into being a landlord (in CA, and even more so in SF) you need to make sure you are following all legal guidelines. If the cost of the property manager isn’t going to hurt your bottom line, go that route. If you want to self manage make sure you get some input from a professional in drafting leases etc.

I'd do property manager. How much is your time worth? Do you want to screen, gather applicants, go show the apartment, and verify references and previous landlord references? Do you want to get a call while you are having dinner with your family because the toilet is overflowing or the AC went out and you have to find a contractor and get bids? I've done both -- one on my own and another property with a property manager, so seen both sides.

Related Posts

Can Somebody refer me for SAP SD position in GSK? I have applied twice in portal and it is sitting at recruiters review

Incoming multi-tier cringe

Post Photo
likefunny

Hey guys, I just found this group and I’m hoping for some guidance/advice! I’m hoping to get into one of the Big 4s or MBB and finally got a few referrals once joining FB. I am 29, have an MA in IOP, and 10 YEO. I have never worked for a non-Jewish company (despite trying pretty damn hard to get out) and I’m freaking out. I have no concept of normal professionalism, strategy for navigating the workplace and the real world in corporate USA,(cont. in comment)

like

Hi! Wondering about Morgan and their culture. Interviewing for a tech role. What’s the vibe?

I am about 100 nights away from reaching the lifetime grandfathered premier access, not sure if I can make it by year end. No longer on travel projects. Any tips? Any new updates from Marriott?

likehelpful

Hey Google 🐠, need some feedback on my offer (level + TC). Thanks!

180K Base / 15% Bonus / 180K Equity / 20K sign on
L5 Senior Finance Analyst
5.5 YOE

like

Is someone able to compare the culture of Google to Microsoft?

like

Hi Fishes,

Greetings for the day.

I am jobless from the past 7 months due to the recission. Need help. I am having 13 Years of experience into Internal audit, Internal Controls, SOX Compliance, Financial Risk, Risk Assessment, Risk Management, IT and Operational Risk Management. Kindly do refer me in case of any openings in your organization. I am open for Delhi NCR, Gurgaon, Pune and Bangalore location.

like

What does your asset allocation look like? Here's mine

Post Photo
likehelpful

I’ve been reading a lot of FIRE books lately and want somewhere to discuss. What are the biggest takeaways from your FIRE journey/ research?

like

Can someone refer me for business analyst

like

Hi All,

I am looking for a job in automobile after sales position. Please help me/refer me for any opportunity.

I have experience of 9 years in handling after sales operations.

like

Hi,
I am an Experienced Audit Associate looking for new opportunities, please let me know if there openings or referrals for Internal auditing.

like

If you had to choose between Microsoft and Facebook (in the Bay Area), which would you work for? Dreaming for the future...

like

Does anyone want a ticket to the Mets/Phillies game

like

I have offer in Genpact and Atos syntel.

Atos is offering 2 LPA more than Genpact.

I am offered to the role of 4B, Lead consultant in Genpact. How the work life balance/Hike/variable pay in genpact. Variable pay is payable 100% ?

Hi fishes,
What questions shall I expect during the VP round for Genpact??
Please help.

Change my mind: A motion to “clarify” one of the court’s orders is actually just a cute, roundabout way of asking for reconsideration.

like

Additional Posts in San Francisco Bay Area Bowl

How much are people paying for renters insurance in Bay Area, specifically East Bay?

Drop your insurance company names, if comfortable.

like

Very random- I need to buy my son a suit. 5’3, 120 lbs. Likely a very small sized men’s suit. He is not happy about wearing a suit so looking for a place to take him to try on lots of suits. Also not trying to spend a ton on a suit he will put grow in 6 months. Any suggestions? Best nordstroms rack in the Bay Area? Will drive!

like

Looking to do a solo trip for about a week somewhere that’s driving distance from San Francisco (anything within ~10 hours) this July/August. Looking for some good hiking and food. Last year I did Bend and it was great!

Any recommendations? Would’ve liked to do Yosemite, but pretty hard to find places to stay at this point.

like

Hi guys,
Going to my first 49ers game this weekend and was wondering what do you guys recommend for pre game, Tailgate in the parking lot? Or how early could I go have a couple beers in the bars by the gates. Thanks!

like

Anyone move from the bay side of the east bay to the 680 valley? We’ve been here for a year and are having a hard time adjusting to the weather and wondering if we’ll ever get used to it. We love getting outdoors but have felt like we’ve spent the better part of this summer inside just because of how hot it’s been. How do you keep up with the same level of activity with kids (running, cycling , hiking) while staying cool?

like

Probably a long shot
Anyone have 2 tickets to game 7? Want to take my wife but stub hub fees are insane!!!
Anyone want to help a fish out?

like

Good morning! What auto insurance do you recommend at Bay Area? Just moved here and my State Farm premium almost doubled. Thanks!

like

Any consulting companies with offices in the Bay Area feel they have a good in-person work culture? Being able to connect with colleagues matters a lot to me and I’m hoping to hear which companies have a strong and connected community out by SF! :)

Any facial recommendations in the city?

like

Been away from SF for 8 months. How is SF now?

like

Best neighborhoods for mid twenties couple for a decent price? Would prefer to be near good restaurants and hopefully around other young people. New to SF so not sure how common this is but love buildings with a gym!

like

Any good moving companies to move from socal to NorCal?

like

How much are you all paying for yard work and house help in the bay area? New to the city. New house. And no time to take care of these. But also worried about spending too much

like

What are the safest/best neighborhoods to live as a couple in their late 20s?

like

What's dating like in SF? New to the area.

Currently I pay $1900 for a brand new & modern 1BHK in the Greater NYC area. Moving to SF later this year. Any recommendations on how much to budget for SF? Will be working in Downtown area & currently got a car. I am little bit divided on whether to sell the car or move it to SF.

Looking for a good neighbourhood and ok with 30 minute commute to work.

like

I want a dog so badly but I can't imagine walking him up and down these hills every day T_T

best burger place with chicken options?

like

Any moms on here that absolutely love their company and feel 100% supported?

like

What is the best platform for housing in sf city? Craigslist?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal