What’s harder - plaintiff’s side or defense side?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I actually have done both and it’s so different that it’s really too hard to compare as I said above.

On defense, there is an absurd amount of busy work/paperwork and reporting. And if you actually do it right, the billing/collections is super tedious and annoying. I have seen many plaintiff lawyers try it and they just throw their hands up and have to quit because it drives them absolutely insane. They can’t stand doing busy work that doesn’t advance the file at all and entering time in 6 minute intervals. Although everything is reactive on defense and sometimes you can just kick the can down the road or get an easy case where you just have a small player in the case (a ride along sit through defendant), you can’t control the tempo of the case like the other side can. When many big cases are simultaneously on fire and you can’t do anything about it, it’s brutal.

On the plaintiff side you spend an inordinate amount of time reviewing potential cases that end up going nowhere and never getting off the ground, and it feels like you are just wasting your time. You also have to do the work for years to get paid out and there’s a chance you wont. You sometimes have to handle cases that just aren’t very good because someone else at the firm already brought it in and didn’t consider the significant weaknesses. That can also feel like you’re wasting your time. The clients can be insufferably annoying and unreasonable/unrealistic and even flat out insane and delusional. It causes a lot of stress dealing with some individual clients, and only the very best plaintiff firms get to cherry pick the best cases and clients. For every home run type cases there are like 500 grounders to the pitcher or foul tips. There can be more volume than you think. You also have no ride along cases. It’s on you and you alone to move the file and take the deps and prove your case. Your work doesn’t really have to be great though since it’s pretty easy to get past MtD or Msj in a Pi case. Also you get to control the tempo of the case most of the time. You work when you want to work. You press the files when you feel like pressing them and you can get a major head start on the Defense by properly working up and pleading your case with help of experts before the defense counsel even knows there’s a case.

Pay on defense is very consistent and easily predictable, and in time your salary can be way higher than what plaintiffs lawyers get. That’s what I like about it. I can’t bring myself to switch because my salary is pretty much at least double than what plaintiff firms want to give. But unless you have a nice book, you have a ceiling ans the comp tops out. There’s no ceiling in plaintiffs work and the bonus potential can be huge. Importantly also no billables. It’s amazing to just work in a case and not worry about justifying spending a lot of time on something. But sometimes you get a shit base salary and can work for big egos who screw you out of money. Like every big plaintiff firm I know ends up in some litigation against a former partner or employee and those cases are like ugly divorces.

It’s all a trade off. They are just so different. You also need a totally different mindset as a plaintiff lawyer. A lot of defense lawyers simply don’t have it and never will.

like

I’m thankful to work for a company that doesn’t require billing (but I hope if I ever do switch companies and have to bill, I’ll pick up on that quickly!!!).

Defense. Billable hours and reporting bs. Plus in NYC, very plaintiff-friendly laws and venues

like

We suffer from plaintiff friendly outcomes outside of DC here too. Do hurt people deserve money? Yes. Do they deserve 100x their meds? It depends.

like

There is so much more involved as a plaintiff attorney that isn’t even legal work. You need to be a people person and be able to hustle to be successful. Your client isn’t a billion dollar entity anymore and you’re dealing with real people. It adds a ton of stress

like

I'm a first year. Gonna wait and see what I get offered for year 2. If it's not commensurate to my work ethic, and production I'm out.

Defense for sure. Billable hours suck. Insurance carriers suck even more.

like

I’ve done both and dealing with plaintiffs and hustling cases toward settlement is far more difficult than I thought before I had plaintiffs experience.

like

Yea I feel like they are so different it’s hard to compare

like

In ohio plaintiff's side is definitely the harder side and even the defense lawyers admit it.

Related Posts

I'm an game developer who trying to make a great portfolio and what to get some advise on what I should be doing to make one. What should I be creating?

How long IBM background verification takes up and when can I expect Offer Letter. I have submitted documents today. Kindly respond.@IBM

like

Hi

Can anybody tell mw what will be inhand

Post Photo
like

Stocks markets are crashing, crypto prices are cut in half. What does everyone think on where the consulting businesses are headed?

like

Hi guy please help i got laptop from publicis which is very old. Can i ask them to change it?

like

Looking to move to SG from US for personal reasons. Does anyone have a headhunter that they’d recommend? Experience in consulting and HF. Thanks

What is the target utilization for a Senior 2? Or number of chargeable hours goal? Is this ever hard to meet?

like

How is S&P Global?.
Pros and cons
Employee benefits and Culture

Thanks in Advance! 😊S&P Global

Just out of curiosity, have you ever started a new job and thought what the hell am I getting myself into?!?
If it was the wrong fit how long did you grin and bear it? 6 months / 1 year / longer?
Did it get better with time or worse? (For instance just a case of lack of know-how)
If you left did you find securing a new job difficult due to only being there for so little time?

likefunny

Hi

Has anyone from the cognizant registered BH for a car in Pune or Maharashtra? And are they allowing it? As per rules its allowed but I heard RTO is declining the request

Wrote a small poem (which i feel) for first time 🙂

My standard of sweetness is your voice
My standard of perfection is your face
My standard of happiness is your presence
All the above are lies 😂

Will continue writing depending on your reacts

like

Anyone been to bluebird cafe in Nashville? Worth the hype? I’ve done the honky tonks on a prior trip and looking for something new to check out

likehelpful

What’s so good about the Georgia Tech OMSC and OMSA? Is it just the cost? Seems to be recommended by most of reddit

likehelpful

When should I tell my manager / “recommendor” I am planning to apply to bschool? Applying R1 this fall

like

📌 In hackerrank, code pair interview. Interviewer knows about hints, possible way to solve problem or solution in advance ?

How to give best or impress interviewer in code pair interview ?

Your inputs please.

like
like

Just got word that my position is bring eliminated, would love to get some leads in the L&D space if possible! Thank you in advance!

like

Can I get likes to unlock the DMs please 🙏

Post Photo
likesmartuplifting

Game of horse, anyone? 😆

Post Photo
funnylike

Additional Posts in Personal Injury Lawyers

As a former Corporate Counsel, now mostly solo practitioner in Federal Court specialty practice is a mixture of Bankruptcy, Immigration, Business Transactions and Employment law.
My question is could I affiliate "of counsel" on part of my practice like say only Employment Law?

like

I know this is a broad question but how much should a 3 year PI attorney going into their 4th year make approx. I’m in Chicago, a range is fine too.

like

Good Morning. Any recommendations for private investigator in personal injury? Good, reliable, quick responsive person with great prices. Thanks

like

I received a job offer from a PI firm (MVA and tractor trailer cases) in Houston, Texas; the bonus proposed was 2.5% of attorney’s fees for any cases settled each quarter. We are assigned 50 cases a quarter and the top attorney clears $25K each quarter. This is my first time working at a PI firm. Can anyone share any guidance? Is 2.5% industry standard? Is it realistic to settle/resolve that many cases? I am trying to learn more about this niche before I counter-offer and attempt to negotiate.

like

Anyone work for Morgan & Morgan? Do you know if they allow you to work remotely/hybrid? I’d like to apply with them but the closest office is an hour away and I don’t want that commute. I have a young child.

like

I have a dumb question... I have my first jury trial coming up in a few months. It's a 3-day auto accident trial. I'm the plaintiff attorney. My question is, should I have my client present the entire three days, or am I okay to tell them that they're fine to leave after they testify?

like

In an auto accident trial, can you inform the jury in any way that the at-fault driver had insurance? I have a hard time believing a jury would award 7-figure damages if they thought the little old lady defendant had to personally pay. I’m just starting to do PI on the side by myself at my firm, so this is probably a very dumb and obvious question.

like

What’re the primary differences in PI when practicing in NJ v. NY? Benefits? Drawbacks? Which do you prefer?

likehelpful

We lost an interim payment application for a client who has Steven Johnson's disease from a negligent prescription

Disappointed we lost

Anyone work in personal injury department for Morgan and Morgan in Orlando or any other central Florida office? If so, what is pay/salary for a 4th year? What can I expect case load wise? Easy transition from defense to Plaintiff? Any thoughts/experiences would be appreciated.

like

Looking to hire a lawyer with 0-3 years experience for our PI practice in Charlotte, NC. Any suggestions on where to post the job? (besides the local law schools)

like

I’m a 3L applying in NYC for post grad employment. Which plaintiffs PI/Med firms have the best opportunities for a junior? Everything I find, including my past summer job, is a small shop with 3 partners max and a handful of established associates. I would really like plaintiffs side.

likesmart

Definitely going to be a noobie question!

My client's medical provider asked for his PIP ledger: how do I get that? Just send a LOR to the carrier and ask?

like

Hi all, new-ish associate here at a Virginia firm - quick question: if a pleadings filing deadline for a GDC case ends up being on a Saturday or Sunday, does that mean that it can actually be filed by that following Monday since the court and clerk's office will be open then?

like

Anyone know a Connecticut or 2nd circuit case for this rule? I can’t find one to save my life. A defendant generally is liable for all harmful results that are the normal incidents of and within the increased risk caused by their negligent acts. If a defendant's negligence was a substantial factor in producing the plaintiff's injuries, the element of proximate cause has been satisfied and the defendant would not be relieved from liability for those injuries even though another force concurred..

like

4th year at a mid size PI firm. Got pulled from litigating MVAs to help this solo we hired start a med Mal/nursing home practice. 1 year in and it looks like I’m two steps backwards in terms of getting paid because we’re a year or more out from a lot of the fees hitting. I respect the solo a lot, he’s a mentor, but I’ve got kids and I gotta get paid. Trying not to burn bridges, but I can’t wait years to get cut in. Advice?

like

🍂November JOB THREAD!

Do you know of an opening or opportunity?

Share it in the comments below! Help another Fish. 🤝

like

Chicago attorneys: what is the base salary of a 3 year associate? What % of fee do they get on cases they bring in? Do they get paid any money on cases they’re working on but didn’t bring in? I know it varies, looking for info based on personal experience/knowledge.

like

What’s a good LA or NY business litigation firm and salary to expect? I’m a 2yr with quite frankly a lot of experience across civ rights, PI, excessive force, wrongful death, employment defense, K dispute, corp. structure dispute, professional licensure. Write every kind of brief, appeals, argue motions, take depos. Am the only associate working directly under partner on all cases. In house or M&A/Real Estate Transactional are likely the end goal but want to get the litigation out of me first.

funny

What % of settlements do you take home as an associate? Trying to gauge what I should be seeking in my next contract. Currently at 3% split prorated with all handling attys. Is this normal?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal