Any tips for approaching adjuster to increase their offer? Just started doing PI cases

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

You need to know the case better than they do and know what a reasonable settlement figure actually is. What would a jury do with the case? Talk to some experienced lawyers in your state to determine these answers. If the adjuster is unreasonably low, then you can file suit.

like

I’m smaller cases I just never respond to them and file. I’ve heard from many ex adjusters this gets flagged for them. They’ll call you asking for an extension on the answer and doubling the offer or getting you to reasonable settlement territory.

If you have a good case that you want 5x the meds you have to write a good demand letter and get a letter opinion from your doctor. It just works the best imho. Otherwise that adjuster can’t get off of the 2x the meds chart in their system.

like
Recent IconRecent

Having a detailed demand letter with damages listed and explained helps because they can forward that comprehensive demand letter to their boss and get more authority. Calculate the economic damages and send evidence. They have bosses and have to CYA before they write checks, so they need the evidence in their file to justify the payout.

However, if the injuries are severe and damages are large then you will have to litigate and go through formal discovery. Again, adjusters just doing CYA before they write a really large check.

like

A4, depending on your state of practice those can obviate any potential bad faith. The insurer cannot force their insured to complete them. If you want affidavits send them earlier in the case.

like

Threaten to litigate and send a draft complaint.


Also sometimes I just choose to ignore letters/calls from the adjusters. You'd be surprised how often the unpredictability of talking a big game then literally doing nothing and going completely radio silent will result in better offers as some adjusters will bid against themselves just to get the case done quickly.

Edit: this works very well if you've already sent a draft complaint and a large demand. I am not advocating for ignoring the case. Work the case, get experts etc. But every now and then just ignore an adjuster for no apparent reason.

Be like Picasso in Robert Greene's book 48 laws of power.

like

I do this sometimes. Just ignore them. They keep calling and increase the offer on their own. This especially works for the older school companies that really need to go back and forth in small increments. It helps if you have, or your firm, has a good reputation already because then it's not assumed you're lazy but 1) busy and profitable and 2) not willing to play their game because you know you can just try it.

like

Include prior jury verdicts with similar injuries and basic facts to your case (including venue). This always helps to back up your demand and expectations

like

Westlaw Jury Verdicts and Settlements is huge

like

We focus on how we can provide sizable, hard numbers to the adjuster. Firm number on past medical, medical expert supporting future treatment in X amount, expert economic report, those sorts of things. The more concrete figures we rack up on the whiteboard and provide support for, the better chance with have to trend higher.

like

Thanks!

like

Have all the language in your written demand to build a bad faith case in the event they don’t settle at or within policy limits. If the language is in there, the insurance company freaks out and has an internal meeting about it.

What state?

like

I don’t know what the law is in DC but if they refuse to provide the policy, dec pages, or even tell me the limits, I send a letter politely telling them I’ll get that in suit and “are you really going to not provide basic information to protect your insured?” Catch them in bad faith on that a lot.

Just tell me man, it’s not going to change the facts of the case

likefunny

If the carrier is one of the big 3, good luck because their number is all based on some algorithm. List out all injuries and treatment in detail. Do some verdict searches where you’re venued and pass to the adjuster to show what they’d be up against at a trial.

like

I was referring to GEICO Allstate and State Farm, but progressive stinks too.

like

Send a nastygram

like

Depending on the circumstances, this. I have my adjusters I’m cool with, and I have my adjusters who offer crap and they know it. I also get the adjusters who offer $3k on a clear limits tender. Those are the ones that get my nastygram with a draft complaint that’s ready for filing.

like

Come in reasonable and be courteous with them. Some of them hold grudges depending on your approach. Obviously you’ll have marching orders by clients and supervisors on demands but knowing the case inside and out helps. Depending on threshold laws know if your client meets threshold or arguments you’re going to make for it.

like

You can determine the policy limits through 3rd party entities, other things that are helpful is to look for objective findings that support your clients injuries versus subjective complaints of pain, finally know how your client presents and whether your case is strong or is better off settling prelit, Ive been doing this for 9 years, know when your case is strong and just file if they are lowballing you, always be on the offensive

like

Send them the actual medicals and also draft petition. Build a good relationship and just let them know you practice in that venue/ jurisdiction and how cases turn out. They’ll likely engage defense counsel at that point who will likely back you up. If it’s a 30/60 policy don’t send a demand for policy limits, unless it’s a true policy limits case. Adjusters take that personally.

like

Following. Just started doing this on the side at my firm and on my second case. Progressive low balled is with a $200k offer when economic damages are $500k and there are another $100k in disability/medical bills, plus pain and suffering and future medical expenses. I demanded $1.2M. They have until Monday to respond or I’m filing suit, which looks like what I’ll have to do.

Not criticizing, but I had a mentor who would actually do the exact opposite. And throughout the two years (CA) the adjuster a be getting letter after letter after letter some would get CCd to 3rd party insured (driver at fault) with snail mail. There was multiple reasons for using that strategy and it was very effective, but I’ve seen/experienced it as you articulated and that’s just as effective.

Related Posts

Im an attorney registered with the Istanbul Bar Association. I need support on an issue. I have client resident in Turkey who currently has a legacy fund on a bank in California. Since my client was not aware of the estate, he did not apply to the US authorities to request a certificate of inheritance over the years. There is an application expiration period before this fund can be collected. Is there any attorney from California who able to assit to us on this issue?

like

Please suggest between two options for 8+ yrs exp. java microservices developer.

IBM band 7B (Senior system analyst)
Capgemini band C2 (senior consultant)

I am looking for long term association, probably for 3-4 years or more. My priorities are :
Job security > work culture > Appraisals

Please suggest with reasons.

like

Hi,
Have query related to Adobe Analytics.

I am checking reports on workspace.

I have evar1 and evar2 on most of the events. (Allocation- most recent (last) and expiration - visit)

I have event1, event2, event3 all have evar1 and evar2.

But on workspace while seeing reports for event1 I see evar values of other events too.

like

old people bad at email causing congressional hearings dot tumblr dot com

like

Looking for recommendations for a Tote, under $500 that is good for traveling and throwing stuff in

like

Lifted from r/. Who is your archenemy at work? Manager, sales, marketing?

like

6am flight out of LGA - what’s be the best way to get there? Are ubers available that early? Riding from Hudson yards

like

Hi fishes,

Recently I got an offer from Cognizant with a CTC of 11lpa..Can I ask the recruiter to make it 12lpa now without another offer in hand?

Thanks in advance

like

I feel like being a customs agent requires a special type of person. It seems like such a straining job that I want to commend them.

like

I'm looking for referral in hcl. Is any vacancies related to Informatica power center then please refer

like

Thoughts on JETS puts with the pop from the stim bill?

like

Is Life Insurance a scam?

Why or why not?

like

Hello guys, have been trying to apply for the role of a data analyst since 3 months with no luck. It would be of great help if you could refer me.

TC: 9.45L
YOE: 3
Location: Bangalore
Skills: Python, R, Data Analysis, AWS, Power BI, Datorama

like

Has anyone felt the difficulties of starting work at a very young age? (1-3 years younger than my peers at school)

likehelpful

Does anyone here work as a project manager at Becton Dickinson? If so, how is your experience at the company and how is your job? I applied to a project manager position at BD.

like

Thanks for this bowl!! Cheers 🥂

Post Photo
likefunny

I interviewed for first round at Bosch for SAP data migration role on 2nd Nov. The interview lasted 20 mins and went well.
I haven't received a response till now.
Shall I consider that I have not cleared round 1? Or is there still chance to get response?

like

Any commercial strategy folks on here?

like

I’ve been in a funk for quite some time, since maybe early Summer. I used to read the Bible and pray a lot in the AM, but barely read and lucky if I remember to pray during the day...

likeuplifting

Carol Baskin, amarite!?

like

Additional Posts in Personal Injury Lawyers

I am starting my own plaintiffs personal injury practice, but I'm in a major city with lots of competition. Any tips on how I can differentiate myself to bring in cases?

like

1st trial (1st yr lawyer) and no one’s overseeing me. What is the average number of Motions in Limine to file? (Defending employer-entity and the part-owner/alleged harasser on hostile work environment-sexual harassment case)

like

What metrics do you think are most important to measure for success of a Plaintiff’s firm? Obviously revenue, but what else is at the top of the list for you?

like

NYC area Personal Injury Lawyers:

What are some of the most well respected plaintiff’s personal injury firms in NYC, and why?

like

What would you say is a reasonable number of cases per number of staff in a PI firm? What number is manageable and what is a number you would say is going into the realm of malpractice. For example for about 150 cases I know of a firm that has about 3 attorneys and 4 support staff. But some have 400-500 with 2 attorneys & 1 support staffer. What are your thoughts or how many cases is your firm currently handling?

like

Good Morning. Any recommendations for private investigator in personal injury? Good, reliable, quick responsive person with great prices. Thanks

like

Should a company go out of business if it hurts consumers? 3M is facing lawsuits for their defective ear plugs, surgical blankets, firefighter foam, PFAs, etc. Someone just got $77.5 million on 1 earplug case and there are about 270,000 military personnel with tinnitus and hearing loss. At least 20,000 people who have had multiple surgeries from their blankets and some who have had limbs amputated, who knows how many have had cancer, etc from chemicals made by 3M. 3M market cap is 87 billion

like

Any Plaintiff 🐠 here use a record request service instead of doing it yourselves? (I’m based in Chicago, if that matters).

like

I do digital marketing for a PI firm. I want to chat about Yelp. Obviously it’s a platform built for consumers, not for businesses. Naturally, former clients go there to bash or rave about their experience. While I know Yelp’s algorithm, I was wondering if anyone has any advice on pushing the negative reviews down so they’re not the first few that populate? The review replies are specific, detailed, & to the point as to why they’d write it, the outcome of their case, etc. I appreciate any help!

Hi all, sorry to go off topic. Is anyone practicing PI law in New Hampshire? I'm currently practicing in SE PA and also NJ, but thinking about moving up to NH. Wondering how the industry is there.

like

How easy or difficult do you think it is to transfer from PI as a paralegal to corporate law?

like

I am looking into starting my own firm with one other attorney. I have never been a partner or solo so I am trying to figure out best practices right now. I would appreciate any advice on starting up, things to avoid, preferred software, which gods to pray to, etc. The goal is to be virtual and to primarily do PI with a small amount of business services (my current book is mostly business litigation/contacts/outside counsel work).

Thank you all in advance! This is pretty daunting.

like

Anyone have experience with line of duty injuries for NYC police officers? Trying to get a sense of settling in claim or inevitably having to litigate.

like

Question: ID, auto accident case, uncooperative client. I have tried multiple phone calls, texts, letters, emails, and sent an investigator out. I can’t get the client to respond / cooperate. I have discovery due and his depo coming up. What else can I do to try to reach him?

like

Left old firm to go solo PI. Old firm has 1 outside referring atty. Outside atty approached me and sent me cases directly. Old partner angry & threatening.“I should have called before accepting cases”

like

For Plaintiff's attorneys, how big is your caseload? What kind of cases are the majority of them and are they in suit? I am currently handling 150+ mostly MVAs and premise liability cases, just about all in suit, (on top of about 10 DUIs and other small traffic matters) and I feel like I'm drowning and looking to jump ship. What is normal/to be expected? In NYC area if that matters

like

How do associates and non-named partners obtain (plaintiff) personal injury cases? Do you advertise yourself, create a brand, all word of mouth through your network and family and friends, or something else? I get a great 40% of fees I bring in, but so far have only been able to bring in one minor MVA case (guy I went to high school with). I have been practicing for 1.5 years for reference. Trying to learn how to bring in cases

like

Anyone going to the AAJ conference in Vegas? It'll be my first time to an AAJ conference AND Vegas! Is it usually more fun or educational?

like

Has anyone dealt with medical malpractice claims regarding COVID? Just looking for some input or advice if so

like

Anyone know how to raise an estate on behalf of a defendant (as a plaintiff) in PA? I.e., how am I supposed to know some of the things normally included in a Petition such as SSN or names of heirs etc.?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal