Any tips on deposing the defendant driver in a PI case? I’m plaintiff’s counsel.

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’m an associate at a large insurance defense firm in Austin, TX. I’ve defended a massive amount of depos of drivers and I’ve seen good and bad. I think the best Plaintiffs attorneys sit down with a case skeleton. Put the elements of your cause of action, likely negligence, negligence per se, and gross negligence. Fill in what you need for each element. Keep a clean record. I always organize my depos by topics: (1) Intro; (2) Background; (a) education; (b) criminal; (c) job history; (3) Current job; (a) safety training/policies; (b) prior issues; (4) accident. Be polite and cordial. It does not have to be in that order. You catch more bees with honey. Most importantly, LISTEN. My clients drop nuggets of negligence that attorneys too tied to an outline miss. With any depo, know why you’re taking it. Go through their discovery responses. On a lot of PI cases, the defense attorney is so overwhelmed with cases they barely go over the disco responses with their client. You can burn them with that. Also, you can use Reptile tactics (a worthwhile read if you haven’t checked it out) and get clients to agree to broad theme statements: “You agree that drivers have a duty to drive safely” “When a driver is unsafe, it puts other drivers at risk” etc. Good luck!

likehelpful

This is great advice and honestly I’m happy to see it’s coming from someone who is on the opposite side of the bar. Thank you.

Case is a rear end collision with major medical bills upwards of half a million dollars. Driver was in the scope of employment at the time driving a huge freight liner. We have claims for vicarious liability and negligent hiring of Defendant.

Half million dollar case? Nice! Are you second chair?

If it isnt intruding on your privacy, why are you not interested in taking it to trial? I’d think a case with 500k in specials would be likely to pull a 1-2mil verdict at trial.

like

We deposed the driver now the next deposition is someone from the company who hired the driver. We have a claim for respondent superior and direct negligence.

(1) your question is very broad, (2) other plaintiffs’ counsel would be ill advised to lay out any meaningful strategy for you here where the dark side is also reading. Reach out to your local (or statewide) plaintiffs bar. If you’d like to talk general strategy, you’re welcome to call me at 9196160603.

Related Posts

I only have limited time in Copenhagen, and can only choose between Glyptoteket or National Gallery of Denmark. Which one would you recommend and why?

like

Can anyone refer me in Wipro. Thanks in advance.

Had the interview 2 weeks ago, the recruiter called today and gave me positive feedback, but said they need to complete the process with other candidates before making the decision. No rejection yet, but not a good sign of getting the offer?

like

What would your reaction be if the company you applied to asked for you to get permission from your current firm before moving forward? The situation is the company you're applying to is a client of your current firm, and you've already gone through the interview process with the new company. Thoughts?

like

My response to the Associate Consultant:

You called me a Bhakt, thereby initiating your ritual of name calling. I never started politicization of this bowl, it existed much before me, dominated by the left-leaning so-called liberals and communists. So don't blame me for that. Our very own bowl leader is politically biased. Now hear my answers:

1. India should be a truly secular country without any minority appeasement. Things start to get murky when you.. (Contd)..

likefunny

If you could right now, would you buy a house in full cash or invest in the market?

like
like
like

Anyone here hiring for an Account Supervisor? 😊

like

Has anyone worked as a medical assistant for a temp agency? If so how was it? Likes? Dislikes?

like

Any EYP folks on here?

like

What are some nomad options in NY if you don’t want to sign a lease?

like

Goldman fish, does anyone have a view into the total comp and bonus for associates / snr associates? Would be for GM or Ops

like

What is the general interview process for Novartis for a lateral hire? I had an initial discussion with HR around salary expectations but the range I'm looking for was crossing the range Novattis offers for SA. Do they revert back in such cases?

Steve Wozniak isn't afraid to critique Apple devices, and said he couldn't tell the difference between the newly released iPhone 13 and its predecessor, the iPhone 12.

like

How do I start the divorce process? Do I have to get a lawyer? Help...!

GF is 32 and I’m 28. She wants kids within 2 years, understandably. I never envisioned having kids that early (more like late 30s), but I like her a lot. Anyone else gone through something similar?

like

Anyone want to bar crawl the beltline tonight? I moved here during the pandemic and have no friends around

like

Can anyone provide a link or resources for best recommended resume templates for product managers trying to get into FAANG companies? Thank you!! 🙏🙏

like

Thoughts on offer. 5.5 YOE in BV / M&A. Broad experience over that time in Valuation advisory and strong network within current firm - anticipating 5-7 yrs to partner where I am. CPA / ABV. M2 current. Current salary $125k. Offered $150k + $7.5k SOB for a lateral move to much bigger (not b4) PA firm. Probably weaker prospects of accelerated partner track.

like

Additional Posts in Personal Injury Lawyers

4th year at a mid size PI firm. Got pulled from litigating MVAs to help this solo we hired start a med Mal/nursing home practice. 1 year in and it looks like I’m two steps backwards in terms of getting paid because we’re a year or more out from a lot of the fees hitting. I respect the solo a lot, he’s a mentor, but I’ve got kids and I gotta get paid. Trying not to burn bridges, but I can’t wait years to get cut in. Advice?

like

Definitely going to be a noobie question!

My client's medical provider asked for his PIP ledger: how do I get that? Just send a LOR to the carrier and ask?

like

3P Policy Limits: $100k
Liability has been accepted
Property Damage: $10k
Current Medical Bills: $65k
MRI findings (lumbar): 4mm
Client has received 3 injections and a surgery rec for laser discectomy

Sent 2 policy limits demands. Adjuster offered $60k both times because they don’t see a “causal relationship” without offering us any articulated supporting facts.

The insured is a Radiologist, he appears to own a home valued over $2M.

Is this policy open? Best approach? Thoughts?

like

In an auto accident trial, can you inform the jury in any way that the at-fault driver had insurance? I have a hard time believing a jury would award 7-figure damages if they thought the little old lady defendant had to personally pay. I’m just starting to do PI on the side by myself at my firm, so this is probably a very dumb and obvious question.

like

Thinking about starting my own plaintiff shop. What’s the best way to generate clients with a low marketing budget?

like

For Plaintiff's attorneys, how big is your caseload? What kind of cases are the majority of them and are they in suit? I am currently handling 150+ mostly MVAs and premise liability cases, just about all in suit, (on top of about 10 DUIs and other small traffic matters) and I feel like I'm drowning and looking to jump ship. What is normal/to be expected? In NYC area if that matters

like

I'm a 6th year attorney in NYC. Strictly defense work; started out with the City Law Dept, did a year and a half of med mal/construction, and for past year and a half have been at a well known defense firm working on high exposure construction accident cases. Contemplating taking a couple interviews at plaintiff's firms to see if there is a good fit. Does anyone have any advice on how approach discussions about compensation and what a market level comp package would or should look like?

like

Has anyone ever dealt with Geico UM case where they insist that a release needs to be signed? Geico extended our client’s policy limits but wants him to sign a release. We offered to sign an acknowledgment of receipt of funds but Geico said without a release signed, they will not issue payment.

like

Any NY state plaintiffs lawyers regularly handle $25k policy MVA cases? Any tips for profitably handling these? Thanks!

like

Anyone work in personal injury department for Morgan and Morgan in Orlando or any other central Florida office? If so, what is pay/salary for a 4th year? What can I expect case load wise? Easy transition from defense to Plaintiff? Any thoughts/experiences would be appreciated.

like

How much support staff is reasonable to expect? Plaintiff PI, med mal/aviation and we’ve lost 2/4 “paralegals” in the last month. Lack of support staff really beginning to feel like it will limit my ability to handle the usual caseload. Was on an island before, and only going to get worse…

like

Plaintiffs PI attorneys, how many cases on average are you assigned to at any given time?

like

Mates- I’m getting a new iPad Pro and trying to decide between the Smart Keyboard and the magic keyboard. Also has anyone tried the white keyboard? I’m getting it tonight. Your thoughts would be appreciated

like

What are good KPIs for personal injury support staff?

like

Anyone work for Morgan & Morgan? Do you know if they allow you to work remotely/hybrid? I’d like to apply with them but the closest office is an hour away and I don’t want that commute. I have a young child.

like

What’s a good LA or NY business litigation firm and salary to expect? I’m a 2yr with quite frankly a lot of experience across civ rights, PI, excessive force, wrongful death, employment defense, K dispute, corp. structure dispute, professional licensure. Write every kind of brief, appeals, argue motions, take depos. Am the only associate working directly under partner on all cases. In house or M&A/Real Estate Transactional are likely the end goal but want to get the litigation out of me first.

funny

Does anyone like ID work? Currently doing work at a PI/Medmal plaintiffs firm while in school and trying to figure out where I’ll be happiest post-grad. I LOVE it, but don’t know if ID will provide more security. For context, I had a, albeit, short career prior to law school and will 30 when I graduate in May. Comp and WLB are important given my later start.

like

What do you guys send as gifts to referral sources for attorneys and/or former client referral sources?

*Assume in my jurisdiction there are no ethical issues associated with this

likehelpful

When y’all have bench trials, what are typical awards?

Here in my jx, in little league/entry level court, it’s pretty typical judges award 2x the medical bills.

like

Hi everyone - I'm contemplating an offer from a large PI firm. I'm a little more than halfway through completing my 2nd year of practice, and I'm currently at a small firm with a low salary that's just no longer cutting it.

The offer from the large firm is for a pre-suit position, base salary of $100K - is this salary pretty standard for this kind of position?

Any insight is appreciated, thank you!!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal