Big law associates were just better law students. But mid-law associates are, on balance, better lawyers.

likefunnysmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

It's great that you've revealed this so that the entire legal market can turn upside down and start bringing all their most important work to smaller firms with lower billing rates.

likefunny

As someone that started in mid law and now works at a v10, this is just not true. Sorry to burst your bubble.

I did get a lot of responsibility as a young associate at my mid law firm, so when I lateraled, I was better at running matters than a lot of my new big law peers, but I was not getting trained as well substantively. I’ve been at my new firm for about 4 years now and I have just learned so much more than I ever could have at my mid law firm. I’m a better attorney now as an 8th year associate than 95% of the partners at my old firm and so are most of the other senior associates I work with.

likehelpful

This is the first time I hear someone say they’re an 8th year associate.

like
Recent IconRecent

Not in my experience. They may have had greater responsibility at an earlier point in their career, but I have seen serious mistakes occur in Mid Law that I didn’t see in Big Law — like simply not reading the statute at issue, or using overturned case law.

like

I chuckled. Please note that any "midlaw" counsel/junior partner litigator likely can do the job of a Biglaw counsel or junior partner. I've worked in both. Midlaw=more experience. Biglaw = super confident/overconfident attitude because you're typically spoiled (great schools, clerkships, BIG paychecks/clients who listen - mostly). Not saying youre not also great attorneys (most who survive to counsel/junior partner are), but there are others just as good, if not better, at "midlaw" firms.

My source: I've worked in BIGlaw and midlaw, so lived it.

like

All lawyers are losers

likefunnyuplifting

It’s your inconsistent usage of hyphens that really gets me.

funnylike

You prefer to do it differently… but it doesn’t mean that my approach was incorrect. You’re welcome to rebut. The bottom line is that you were trying to split hairs and be cutesy. Do you!

like

Cope

like

And seethe.

like

That has not been my experience as a purchaser of legal services. There are types of work the big law does not do. Mid law firms are better at those types of work.

likesmart

As another purchaser of legal services, I’ve seen inexcusable work from both big law and mid law, and fantastic work from both. At the end of the day, I’m purchasing the attorney’s services, not the firm’s, so I’m going to find who does the best work regardless of firm size. We have a good bench of big law and mid law depending on the work we want done. I am more inclined to use big law or boutiques for more niche work though just because midlaw might not have the resources to fully support more niche practice groups.

like

Depends on the firm. You might start with less responsibility at Big Law with more hours expected, but more practice on the foundation. There's more resources, other associates, tools, and prior in-house cases/transactions from which you can crib/learn. Midsize is not bad, just a different animal.

like

I agree, different animals. I wouldn’t want a mid law associate touching my corporate finance work. Similarly, I wouldn’t want a big law associate touching my supplier issues.

like

#hottake

like

biglaw is t14 and mid law is tier 2 toilet. you are trying to justify billing biglaw hours for in house pay like the tier 2 law student justifying their conditional scholarship and tuition at a tier 2 over going to t14

like

Maybe maybe not but I just want to go where I get paid more

like

lawyers r dweebs who cant take risks like the chad technepreneur

likehelpful

It's not our decision to take the risk. We're always representing someone else's interests.
Imagine if we made the call to risk the client's money...

That and we have to role the dice all the time in difficult situations where we can't get certainty.

like

It’s a mixed bag at both. I’ve never worked in “Biglaw” but was in two AmLaw 200 firms for years. I once had a Biglaw partner ask whether it was necessary for a trust to have a trustee to exist, and argue that a potentially $10 million mistake his firm committed should be ignored.

I will, though, admit that there are typically more sophisticated projects and training available at BigLaw firms, but a lot of BigLaw gets trained there and then flees to mid-law to have a life, so it’s possible to have very good people at mid-law firms. On the other hand, some of the worst attorneys/partners I’ve ever worked with were at the AmLaw200 firms. They just assumed they were right, when they weren’t. (Admittedly that’s not “BigLaw” in the strictest sense, but I have sat across the table from attorneys at V10 firms and caught them in errors.)

As always, it’s down to the individual attorney, not necessarily the firm. But if you don’t already have an attorney in a niche area and need a specialist, it makes sense to start in BigLaw for your search if you have the budget.

likehelpful

Weerd

like

Cope

like

I don’t know about this. I worked in small and mid law for four years before joining big law. Big law lawyers are brilliant, and its partially because of the resources their firm equips them with. The staff is also consistently trained and efficient. When you have good support, you can do your job as a lawyer better.

like

No way.

biglaw supremacy in the firm realm

It's probably just because I do CapM and mid law tries to do that but can't get enough volume to learn it and do it well, but this has def not been my experience being across from them, even when they're just investor's counsel...

This makes a point—you’ll be exposed to much better, higher-level work at big law. I think associates in mid-law are likely better trial lawyers, but big-law work will often be much more cerebral. But there are smaller law firms that are priced at big law levels and capable of doing actually the best work in certain matters.

LOL. Nope.

Related Posts

Thoughts on AdEx ?

Any 🐠 work at Pay Governance? I am interested in networking and getting to know the company.

Does Pepsi not pay well? Just got quoted pretty low for an internal Strategy role.

like

Any EY PPMD 🐠 willing to chat/connect? Interested in learning more about the cyber practice. I’m a new campus hire in the Hoboken office. Thanks in advance!

like

If you didn't go to college, how did you learn what you know now in marketing?

like

Can anyone refer for program manager/pmo role. I have 5 years experience in this domain. Thanks.

like

Anyone working or know about the company ‘TietoEvry’. A friend of mine got an interview call and wanted to know about company culture and pay range etc.

like

Friend is hosting a party where I will only know the host. Presumably host will be busy with others. How do I mingle and make conversation with a bunch of people who know each other?

likehelpful
like

I have an offer in hand from 1 org and negotiating with another for a better pay.
However the other organisation is asking to share the offer letter.
Should I share?

like

Who are your favorite non-Union VO talent agents that you reach out to for casting submissions?

like

I need an opinion, which field is better in terms of compensation and work/ life balance , a sales producer or adjuster ??

like

I did a consult with a junior planner the other day and he kept referring to how long I’d been in the industry 🥹 Just how old AM I? I feel old now.

like

Just wanted to brag a little. This may not be much for some but I’m super excited. I graduated with a B.A in chemistry July 2022 and I start my job this Monday with a salary of 60K! This is the most money I’ve ever made 😱😱. Really proud of myself even though I know some people would rather make more. I’m hoping to hit 100K within 3-4 years. Don’t give up recent grads!!

likeuplifting

Remember The Woo? Yeah, me neither. Well, they cut everyone’s pay (except mgmt of course) by 1/4 to get the small biz gov loan, and used it to hire a $500k/yr mgmt head. Agency still working barebones

like

What “self help” books are you guys reading? I just read Untamed by Glennon Doyle and wow, I want to start from the beginning again, but feel like I should read something else. Would love any suggestions.

like
like

Hi Folks,

What is the difference between EY India and EY GDS?

What are the pros and cons?

Thanks in advance :)

like

Additional Posts in Law

Idk, maybe it’s time we bring these engineers and techs down. If my 🧠 links to a 💻 , all of my non-billable work will come to light. 😤

Post Photo
like

As lawyers are there ways to get paid for connecting clients?

like

If you use the pomodoro method for time focus and tracking, do you bill in those increments or just keep your billablr timer going the whole time? For example, I work in 25 minute increments for large projects then I get a break. Do I bill .5 for that increment and restart my billing or keep my billing continuously going thereby not rounding up for those 5 min? I have just kept my timer going.

like

That time of year... friends in the office giving me funny/cool gifts. I’ll need to reciprocate but am just brain dead these days.

What are some of the best “office” gifts you’ve received in the past?

like

What’s average salary in ID firm mid size (NY) about 350 attorneys ? Class of 2019 but was in public sector (criminal law) for 2 years! 2000 billable hours minimum

like

California 🐟 does your vacation payout when you leave your job get taxed at regular wage, or bonus, levels? Does your employer have discretion to choose?

like

Family law litigator looking to transition to in-house? Any tips?

like

What is the expectation at your firms about coming into work after making your billable hours requirement? Asking especially for those who do not get a bonus per extra hour billed over the minimum.

like

I want to get out of ID so badly. I don’t mind the work but the hours are just killing me. I just started at a new firm less than 6 months ago and I am already desperate to get out. It is not the firm or the people. I just hate the high billables. I have been applying to other jobs but I think I may need a recruiter for help. Any recommendation for a great recruiter in NYC?

like

What is everyone’s: (1) billable hours this year; (2) practice group; (3) year; and (4) size of law firm?

like

Transactional junior associate in biglaw. Working for a dedicated practice group rather than in an associate pool. For the past few months, I’ve been loaned to another practice group for a good chunk of time. While the people are decent and the hours aren’t terrible, I detest the work and don’t see a future in this new practice. My main partner says it should end in the next month, but I don’t expect that to happen. Is it a terrible idea to ask to be taken off?

like

Hi new here. Idk what my value is and if I’m getting paid an amount that reflects my hard work. I am a paralegal for a small law firm (family and immigration) w only 1 attorney. I have about 20 files or more in my rotation at a time. I work on various types of cases at once. Some are simple, others are extensive. I feel like it’s very unstructured and one of the managers micromanages. It’s like every man for himself. Take home pay is $50k. I am working on my bachelors deg. Do I get paid enough?

like

Any thoughts on Phillips Lytle? If you could please provide insight on culture/billable requirements? Thank you.

like

Hardest part of navigating maternity leave and WLB as a junior partner?

like

Is there an appropriate way to turn down an assignment because it is non-billable? Two of the partners I work for keep asking me to write client bulletins and articles with them, which is great, but now I’m starting to worry about meeting my billable hours requirement.

like

Any insight on Gordon Rees pay for 2-3 year associate in a non-major market? I know they don’t pay market, but there are no BigLaw firms in my city

like

Thinking about getting a MBA, partly for personal enrichment but also for professional reasons. I know schools all have different “cognates” but do people have recommendations that pair well with corporate/securities/financial legal practice fields?

like

Has anyone been admitted to Massachusetts by transfer of UBE score? I submitted my application in July and took and passed the state law exam today. How long after this were you admitted? Thanks!

like

What is a reasonable pay increase? This will be my first pay increase. I make 70k now and will be starting my second year at big law. I had 3 years of prior experience before joining the firm.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal