For those of you who have worked under both Republican and Democratic regimes, in either state, federal, or local levels, which side is better at running things?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I've been all over the government as a fed, and now as a contractor, over the past 20+ years.

Both are routinely awful at running things. Shutdowns aside, neither side has proven able to get a budget out on time for the past 10+ years, regardless of who is in control of the House, so the whole ongoing CR fiasco that's been the status quo over the past few administrations is one of the truly nonpartisan things in DC.

At the legislative level, both parties are utterly divorced from reality and produce legislation that is often utterly incoherent and relies on the administrative apparatus to not only interpret the utter nonsense produced on the Hill, but also figure out how to implement said nonsense.

At the administrative level, Congress' inability to produce well-written legislation results in many agencies having to massively stretch to interpret and implement those laws, which in turn lends itself to a lot of administrative overreach that tends to get smacked down by the courts when challenged.

At the political appointees level, they routinely range from jaw droppingly awful to fantastic on a thoroughly bipartisan basis, with corresponding results on the agencies and orgs they run.

On top of all that, the negative "unintended consequences" that come from the actually 100% foreseeable consequences of implementing the garbage laws that Congress passes in the pursuit of pleasing their special interests and base poison the well in terms of public support, sentiment, and trust for the government.

From a governance standpoint, I give both parties a solid F-.

like

The one that didn’t attempt an armed coup

likefunny

It’s mostly been the same, with onebig exception:

The shutdowns. Republicans keep holding the federal government’s budget hostage. All the shutdowns over the last decade have been because of the Republican Party. That’s not like, partisan rhetoric, it’s literally what happened.

Moreover, even when it doesn’t shut down, it only gets extended for a handful of months. It’s very rare that a full, stable, long term budget is put in place.

This has huge logistical ramifications. It means certain agencies can’t PLAN for anything. They can’t hire, they can’t implement new policies beyond what they’re doing, etc. for example, I know library of congress has wanted to upgrade their systems for years, but a project that should have been completed years ago keeps getting stalled because they never have the full budget to implement it.


So yeah. Republicans have been awful for the federal government, in my experience.

like

It’s all the same.

As a contractor (not in the defense sector), I’ve seen notable differences in the managerial capabilities in the appointee ranks from one President to another, but I can’t say that one party or the other has a lock on appointee quality.

The administrative state—the actual govt employees and career leaders—are overwhelmingly democrats, so you don’t really feel any meaningful difference from one administration to the next. Republicans generally aren’t very strategic about this stuff the way democrats have been for about 50 years. Trump didn’t have the focus, awareness, or opportunity to do anything about this and I don’t get the impression GWB even cared. Suppose Desantis wins in 2028 he would be the first GOP president since Reagan to have the wherewithal and managerial capacity to actually do anything that would register at the contractor level.

Tbh I don’t think it has to do with any kind of strategy from the Democratic Party.

Government employees just happen to, almost by definition, be people who 1. Are low-to-mid middle class 2. Believe in the power, or at least the potential power, of the government providing services.

I feel like they’re generally more open to unions as well.

Related Posts

What do you wish you knew before you began the home buying process for the first time? What would change if you could go back to the beginning of the process?

like

I’m building my first iOS app. I only have experience in material design. I’m looking for easy to comprehend specs around standard design elements: headers, chips, buttons, etc. The iOS UI support material is nearly impossible to understand. Any advice for the best place to find that info? I’ve tried survival kits that aren’t very consistent. I’d also be willing to buy a quality iOS kit. Thanks in advance for the help!

like

Gauging activity of web3 professionals in Miami… like or comment below. Thanks

like

Hey Guys, I have cleared all the rounds for SDET position of a company.I have 2 years and 7 months of experience in Manual, Automation and API testing.How much CTC should I ask.I have HR discussion tomorrow.Please help your fellow mate.Thanks in advance.Accenture Tata Consultancy Deloitte Infosys

I have been overworked and overwhelmed at my current job for quite a while. This is my first position out of law school, small firm with large caseload, and in my second year of practice. I often think I should look for another opportunity elsewhere but I don't know that any other firms would give me the potential for growth and experience that I am getting here. What are other 2nd year associates doing at other firms? Trying to gauge if I really am getting more opportunities here

like

I need out of the legal field for a job with independence, interesting and challenging issues to solve and a decent amount of pay. Halp!

like

Is $250 (all in) for a bed and breakfast worth it? My GF seems think so but that’s a 3pm check in and 11am check out. Not sure the value is there?

funny

Hi all - hope all is well, just want to know your opinion or suggestion, is it the right blend of investment of my 401K savings?

Post Photo
like

What provider does BDO use for its 401k plan? (Fidelity, Vanguard etc.)

likehelpful

I am talking with my company about a layoff. package. There is a non compete clause in my contract, if my company wants to enforce a non compete, should they pay me? The reason is that my employment would be limited if they try to enforce that

like

Anyone stuck in BOS Terminal 1?

like

Anyone traveled or traveling to Peru anytime?

like

Moving from Deloitte to Keste Consulting. Thoughts ? Yay or nah

funny

What kind of resources are useful to prepare for Alixpartners online assessment? Any insights are appreciated. Thanks

like

How much of a total comp increase would you leave consulting for (E.g., 20%, 30%)? Trying to figure out what’s a good offer and tipping point for me.

like

Does studying for top consulting firms’ case interviews help in any way for interviews with other firms (e.g., FAANG case interviews) ?

like

PwC, are you butthurt because you weren't a paratrooper?

like

Anyone gone through Amazon AWS’ military apprenticeship?

like

McKinsey & Company Anyone at McKinsey & Company willing to refer a Marine veteran (OIF, I swear I will not eat all the crayons. "Crayons" are for art is what my wife tells me to tell myself)

5yrs Marines (Sgt, Comm maint tech w infantry Bn)
8yrs in Oil & Gas (engr coordinator, qty surveying and proj ctrl)
CM undergrad
MBA (professional program, graduated May 2022)

I'm looking for a role in McK serving O&G, industrial, capital projects clients. Open to generalist roles as well. Can review for vetting.

likefunny

Anyone use a lawyer to get increased disability? If so, any recommendations?

Additional Posts in Federal, Government, and Public Sector

How long does it take to adjudicate a closer investigation for secret clearance?

like

Does a C/S/TS/SCI clearance denial screw you over for public trust?

What’s your worst proposal writing experience?

How much of a salary bump does a secret clearance get? What are the salary bumps for popular certifications (PMP, agile, scrum master, etc.)? I’ve heard $10k for secret and $10k for scrum

Looking at jobs at Booz Allen Hamilton and noticed many are listed as “Mid.” Like “Strategy Consultant, Mid” and “Project Manager, Mid.” What does “Mid” mean?

like

How competitive are promotions at Deloitte GPS?

AFS manager salary? Interviewing now and would like to know what I should negotiate for.

like

Has anyone ever tried to use their PIV card to book the GSA rate for a personal hotel stay

Can someone remind me what the deal is regarding elections for federal contractors? Can I donate/canvass for a 2020 presidential candidate? Thanks in advance!

Recently relocated IT cloud engineer looking for a new position in the DC area around the December time frame. Is hiring slow for IT in the area this time of the year?

Hi all, which companies in the Federal space can I target that work in the healthcare implementation space? Most openings I see are on the strategy/advisory side.
I have a lot of experience in the Medicaid world and have led and managed implementation projects there. Thanks.

like

Looking for senior Business Analyst for a technology consulting project (robotics process automation). Small fast paced team with great client, salary range 100-130k. CBP badge required (active is preferred, recent or equivalent clearance is OK too). DM me for details and job posting

like

Anyone leave Deloitte for Booz Allen? Thoughts or experiences? Utilization and compliance are absolutely doing my head in.

like

Is there a website that shares announcements of recent contract wins by federal contractors across all federal agencies?

Sometimes the leadership does not even inform you on the status of a submitted proposal unless we win the work. I get why they are doing it but it would be great if there was an external source/website that would share this info instead of us waiting around to hear from them.

like

Has anybody had any luck with flexible work arrangement (FWA)? I am looking to eventually be part time but still remain on higher level projects. Has anybody had luck at any other firms?

Anyone that works for DOD have trouble getting their CAC? I work with the Navy and haven't heard anything about issuing a CAC. Did they stop issuing out CACs?

like

They reduced the therapy questions on the secret clearance form so that you don't have to disclose therapy except in specific circumstances. Is it still on the TS form?

like

I love what I do and I have an offer to stay in International Development and be a manager with 86k, focusing on my technical area + lots of travel. But I also have offers from Deloitte and EY to be a GPS consultant at ~100k. Is it worth it to move to D or EY? Have personal financial goals that i need to reach for my family and thats why i started considering EY and D.

like
like

hey, I joined Deloitte in June 2020 as an GPS SA analyst, I just staffed on internal project only providing me adjusted utilization. Now my standard util is 40 and my adjusted is 105... and this project last in another month... by then my standard util might be 20.. will my promotion be affected by this? My target promotion year on TOD is 2022. My manager said we might sell to client and extend this project in September but nothing guaranteed.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal