Has anyone found a good time series forecasting model that can incorporate media spend and give us anything remotely accurate beyond 90 days? ALTERNATIVE QUESTION: how are you helping with forecasts for your brands?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I just input details into DSP and see the AI forecast. Other alternative is to guess the rates and calculate based on past campaigns?!

likefunny

In your terms, what does accurate look like? Is it being around 95% of what you forecasted? Cause that's kinda hard 90 days out.

Our data science team provides tools for campaign managers. They previously used tools like Meta's Prophet or Uber's Orbit but now we've switched to a a tool developed in-house that has been more consistent to what we needed to optimize ROAS. Can do 85%+ accuracy for most campaigns that don't forgo any structural changes whilst they're running.

It's doable but requieres a fair amount of software engineering. We don't trust the ad platforms forecasts BTW.

like

Sorry not being to help with that. This was mostly done via experimentation and over time.

Prophet?

helpful

I do not understand this question.

Nobody should be forecasting media spend. Name your independent variables and dependent variables and research which models would fit the criteria.

What are you trying to forecast? What is considered accurate? How are you looking to validate?

If your model periods are quarterly, you could easily get 90 dates out, if your periods are daily it might be harder… but usually MMMs do weekly periods, to which forecasting 90 days is trivial.

If you’re straight-up forecasting you could use ARIMAX? That’s quick and easy

I’m sorry, I misread your original post. Thank you for listing out your IVs and DVs.

I don’t think your variables are spot-on.

With such models, we assume a closed system: there isn’t anything else outside your variables that can affect revenue. However, in your list of variables, none accounts for competitor activity. Your revenue is probably more affected by what a competitor did instead of number of sessions. By that logic, Share of Spend (SOS) outweighs straight-up spend. You’d want to look at SOS and SOM instead of these IVs.

It’s also better to pick non-correlated variables. In your IVs, I believe sessions, CVR, AOV, orders would be highly correlated.

like

What’s the timeframe of your predictions. Like within 10/15 days etc or on daily basis?

Related Posts

So, how many days left before you start the holiday seasons? What are your biggest priorities for the new year?

Hi all!
What kind of information would you like to find in this bowl?

My niece is an environmental engineer, working on green energy as an intern in the Netherlands and just graduated from her Masters in Environmental studies. I’m wondering if anyone is willing to refer her to entey level jobs in her field in the Netherlands? She is proficient in English and learning Dutch now.

like

Recently joined PwC and very overwhelmed with the constant overwork and late night working. I didn't expect this to be a norm in EU. Anyone else has faced this?

like

Anyone knows about the base for chase PCA?

like

Hello..need an idea as to what is the ideal salary at B7.2 level,having around 8 YOE.Also, what the bonus to expect.

like

I just had my first behavioural interview with VCA for a Digital Consulting Manager role and the Dir said he was going to progress me to the next round.

I have never worked in consulting before, my background is all project management/marketing/advertising and I have an MBA. Wondering if anyone can give me an idea of the type of case questions they've been asked during their interviews for VCA.

Thanks in advance!

like

FCB Health? Thoughts?

likefunny

Hello, I’m an associate (almost at the one year mark) at a midsize firm on the EPL team. I did about 2 years of employment law as a clerk during school and know that’s what I want to go into. I’ve asked for more EPL work but keep catching PI cases. I second-chaired an employment trial but don’t see any EPL work for the foreseeable future and wasn’t getting as much EPL exposure as I wanted before the trial. Any advice on a lateral move to a bigger firm with a broader range of EPL work?

like

Can we have a side hustle while employed at Barclays. Can't find anything in the contract or offer letter.

like

Great use of the AP Style Book and Libel Manual here… “Let’s just be clear. ‘Diversity and Inclusion’ is not about black or white or brown. Not about melatonin. Not color at all because I’m not sure how to ‘call’ my Persian, Indian or Thai friends. Would you say ‘yellow?’ I don’t think so. Token token token is broken broken broken broken. It is about opportunity. A fair opportunity and right to the same opportunity. This is what is broken. It goes deeper. Much deeper. Get real. Emancipation.

like

Anyone who moved from offshore audit practices to industry for better WLB?

like

I am in final rounds with a company. They asked for my comp. expectations last week. I dodged this and got their range instead, which is lower than expected. They now want to chat about next (cont’d)

like

Got a temp offer for less than a year without promise of turning into full-time. Wanted to know what ppl think about temp jobs (looks bad on resume if I don't turn full-time later within the company?) and what comp should look like (e.g. 1.2× of regular comp?).

Got another perm offer in a different industry for similar salary, but I might have to relocate and I'm concerned the work may involve translation instead of pure legal work.

like

Hi fishes

Need a reality check-
Profile-
Btech (mech) + MBA (non-IIM top 15)
4 years enterprise account management- US based personal computing OEM
1 year Management Consulting- Sales transformation

Input required on-
1. What is my profile fit for account executive role like?
2. What is the salary I can target? (Current- 19.6 fix+ 3.5 JB+ 4 variable) I am gunning for at least 30% jump on fixed.

like

Anyone from Deloitte requested premium i140 filing?

What’s everyone doing this weekend 🧐

like

Any advice on broaching the subject of working on Sundays as a committed Christian?

like

Hi Guys,

Can anyone refer me to BCG

TIA

like

Additional Posts in Data and Analytics in Advertising & Marketing

What is a typical salary for a Data Scientist at a management level that’s 1 or 2 levels above entry? Looking for insight both within the tech side and tech consulting if possible.

like

Just learned about Monte Carlo analysis thru a colleague , where can I find out about other analytic methodologies?

like

Is it just me or is the YouGov Profiles tool completely unintuitive to use?

likefunny

Hii! Question for everyone, how much should a UX Researcher (quantitative) with 5 years experience + PhD should be making? NYC based

like

Anyone from or at client side data analytics/media science? Wondering how the worlds differ, agency vs client.

What advice would you give to a 3year exp Data consultant from Europe willing to relocate in the US?

like

Hello 👋🏻
Anybody with retention marketing experience (particularly adopting a new CRM system in their organization - SalesForce Marketing Cloud) or in contact with a retention marketing folk. I’d like to have a small chat around understanding this exercise. Let me know. Thanks 🤘🏻

like

Top companies or types of companies for consumer insights/analytics? E.g. in terms of opportunities to learn, general progression, salary, etc

like

Accepted job offer starting Jan 11. Should I let my boss know now so there is more time to transition my workload/approve replacement hire? Want to leave on good terms as I may do some freelance work for them.

like

What's a good use for a personal LinkedIn profile's cover photo/banner real estate? Feels like a waste to have abstract art up there, but I've had my profile critiqued and not sleek enough when I had my value prop in text up there

like

I have below offers in hand with 9years of experience.
1. MassMutual (India) 25LPA +3L joining bonus
2. Synechron Tech 28LPA (only fixed)
3. TCS 28LPA
4. Tech M 30LPA
Can anyone please suggest which one to join.

like

Are there any AGENCY folks at small/mid-size shops that are using CDP's? If so, how are you staffing the team and how are you integrating the CDP with your DSP's etc?

like

I recently graduated with a masters degree in Data Analytics from University of Texas at San Antonio with a CGPA of 4.0. I am also awarded distinguished graduate student award for great academic standing and leadership skills. I have worked in india for 3 years for Uber and Amazon as Risk Analyst and quality specialist respectively. I am currently in my F1 OPT and have 30 days left before I submit my offer letter to USCIS. I can share my resume and any help is really appreciated. Thank you!

like

Hello, I am currently looking for entry level data analytics roles in Advertising and Marketing in Chicago or remote. I am currently an apprentice in a program that is data analytics focused through which I have completed certifications in Google Data Analytics and Google Analytics. I am also familiar with programming languages like SQL, Python, and R. I would love to see if you guys have any leads, it would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!

like

Does Microsoft gives phone bill and internet reimbursements?
Microsoft

I feel like for the first time in a long time, I just bombed my first interview.

like

looking for any resources about creating messaging matrices for brands. links are appreciated!

like

Anybody got any good recos on stats/coding courses for beginners? I’m an extremely client-facing analytics guy with knowledge of these things but not really the technical skills to execute.

helpfullike

[Facebook Ads Data VS Google Analytics Data] 🤯

How can I merge FB and GA data? Some clients of mine believe that Facebook doesn't bring us results 'cause GA says so. The difference between the two of them is A LOT. Facebook says we have 100 conversions and GA only reports 2. How can I prove to them that Facebook does its job? What data can I show?

like

Best resource to learn SQL?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal