I have been debating whether to refer an old coworker for an open role on my team at my new company. We worked well together before, but now it feels like more is on the line since my name would be attached to it. Part of me thinks it could be a great move for both of us, but part of me wonders what happens if it does not work out. Would you refer someone you used to work with, and what do you see as the biggest upside or risk?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Wow that's a good question, so many variables can help you with making that decision. First ask yourself why did you include risk? I feel like yes I would refer someone I used to work with to a position especially if I know their work ethics (great for the job expectation) and would be a great fit with the company. They are the ones that will get the job not you, they will be the one to keep that job not you. An referral is just what it is a referral it is all on that pacific person now. You should never feel bad about a good decision and the company should never hold you responsible for a risk. Hope this helps you.

like

That is a good way to frame it. If you trust their work ethic and culture fit, that removes most of the risk. At the end of the day they still own their performance. You are opening a door, not guaranteeing an outcome.

I referred an old colleague of mine from a previous company. She came in and she was great at a job, and everyone was really happy. I found another ally in my company, so it actually ended up working in the positive for me.

like

That is the ideal scenario. When it works, it strengthens your position because you bring in someone reliable who already aligns with you. Having a built in ally who performs well can make your life a lot easier.

I would say go for it. If you trust them and think they're good, great. If they underperform, nobody will blame you because a referral is only a fractional part of why they hire someone.

like

I agree to an extent, but reputation still feels tied to it. Even if referrals are just one piece of the decision, people remember who vouched. That is probably why it feels heavier than just recommending someone casually.

Are you confident in their ability to do the job? That's really what it boils down to. If you are, it's mutually beneficial: they get a job, you look good for helping find a capable candidate. The risk/downside really only comes into play if they screw up in a big way. And if you're confident in their abilities, that really shouldn't be a concern.

like

I am confident but of course can’t control everything.

Depending on the industry/role it might not matter. If they're just going in low level it's fine but if it's like a project manager it's a different story...

like

Role level definitely changes the stakes. Referring someone into an entry role feels different than backing them for something highly visible or strategic. The higher the impact of the role, the more thoughtful you have to be about it.

Referrals always feel personal because your reputation walks in with them. If I trusted their work ethic and attitude before, I’d refer them but be honest about what the role needs now so there are no surprises. Biggest upside is bringing in someone reliable. Biggest risk is if they underperform and it reflects on your judgment. If you would still vouch for them in a tough meeting, that’s usually your answer.

like

That point about reputation walking in with them is real. Being upfront about expectations protects both sides. If everyone is clear on what the role demands now, it reduces surprises later.

I hired my sister in law. She is my lead in the field and has me if my most solid team members. I’m so blessed to have her on my team.

like

When it works that well it almost becomes a cheat code. Knowing someone’s character and consistency ahead of time removes a lot of onboarding risk. Not everyone gets that outcome though.

I've done it twice. First referral went extremely well, the manager couldn't have been happier with the employee. Second person, disaster. The lady was totally unhinged. There were no previous indicators, at all. Stole things. Lying was second nature to her. Finally she told a lie concerning a family member of the owner, and was terminated. I feared it would reflect on me, but that didn't happen. The management staff recognized that her bad behavior was her own doing, and no one else was responsible. When she first came, she of course started off as a model employee....I was totally embarrassed. Since that day, I've never referred another employee, anywhere.

like

I’ve done it and it’s worked out well for me because I’ve worked with these ppl for 1+ years and I am confident in their abilities. Upside could be everyone knowing your referred a stellar employee and maybe even getting a referral bonus.

Long term track record changes everything. If you have seen them perform over time, that lowers uncertainty a lot. And yes, referral bonuses do not hurt either, but reputation capital is usually the bigger currency.

I would hire the co-worker you worked with before

I have referred people I worked with before for positions, I have given references to my employers when they asked about a.person I worked with before, that applied for a position.and I have hired people I worked with before. If you feel comfortable withbthe person, know they can and will do the job and you work well with them I would refer them. In this scenario you already have a step up in the new person process, you already know each other and can work together. Acclimating the new hire can be one of the most stressful parts.of hiring people and you are ahead of that curve.

That familiarity advantage is underrated. Hiring someone you have already worked with can skip months of adjustment because you already know communication style and standards. It makes scaling faster.

If I really knew the person and their work ethic, I would 100% recommend

Post Image

Related Posts

I’ve been working for a company for 25yrs, looking for advancement. I’m considered an SME, managing people, Vendors and working on large system conversions. Have provided long term goals. When requesting feedback I’m told I’m on the right path, no suggestions on what to improve. I asked about timelines for advancement and not being given anything concrete. Recently interviewed with another company as a Vendor Mgmt partner. Individual contributor, high visible position with potential. Thoughts?

like

Hi Fishes,

I am working in Google's vendor company in curated formats project. Can any of you refer me to Accenture / CTS with Google ads optimization process pls. Location: Gurgaon. Thanks. Need to change my job as I am extremely disappointed with my current job working for 13-14 hours a day.

like

Hey folks,

Is it good to ask 12-13LPA for 3 years experience. My current package is 7LPA

likesmart

Any good stories from 2008-2010?

like

EY Hey fish, has anyone recently got their H1B visa stamped in Dubai / Abu Dhabi, but is not a resident of UAE? Would love to hear about your experience. Thank you!

I'm thinking about starting something, but I want to be well versed in entrepreneurship before I do. Any recommended resources (websites, podcasts, books, etc.)? Thanks!

like

I heard there were recent comp changes at amazon.

What's would a L6.5 Finance Manager comp package look like now? I'm expecting an offer soon and wanted to make sure I'm equipped with the right info to negotiate.

like

Hi All,

I received a temporary employment contract from a very reputed company in Dubai based on my previous association with them.

I know only limited contract or an unlimited contract. What is this temporary employment contract? Can someone help me?

like

Hi Fishes,
I belong to construction industry with PGDM from NICMAR in Advance Construction Management having expirence of 2yrs. I want to know how can I boom my career even after so much of higher education and expirence industry has slow career growth and toxic work culture. Iam not getting how to move further with such underpaid industry even sometime I get the thoughts for switching the career with data science which again needs time and money investment please suggest DS scope for Civil eng

like

Do you actually take the time to reject people after initial interviews? Or do you wait for the candidate to reach back out to you? I’ve noticed a lot of agencies don’t seem to follow up

Who’s buying BB calls?

like

I took a temporary job as an attorney advisor at the SBA this past fall b/c it offered a regular paycheck, and my solo practice was suffering b/c of the pandemic. I like the work. I like working from home. Anyone have any insight into the possibility of this temp job becoming permanent. Did the SBA hire you permanently when your temp position ended? How did that happen?

Have any of you who are therapists/psychologists remained in touch with prior patients/clients? I would be interested to hear about your experience with this including what kind of boundaries you set. Thanks in advance!

like

how long it takes to start with project in global logic?

Any single nyc men ages 32-49 interested in dining with me at one of these phenomenal restaurants, once they open back up? F/39
Chikarashi Isso, Atera, Jungsik, Wayan, Atomix or Eleven Madison.

likefunny

How high can google go on signing bonus ( currently $25k) and equity (currently $65k) for L4 position.. total exp 4 years .. should I negotiate?

like

Any insights on Cloud consultant role in GCP PSO in terms of project pipeline, growth opps , wlb , etc.

like

Bored on a Sunday night, any female fish feel like chatting

like

Any 30+ female around? Would love to chat.

like

At MBB, level for level, do implementation practitioners make the same as generalists?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal