is a “good faith deposit” normal for apartment applications? basically they’re asking for a month rent along with the application fee and said it is fully refundable if i don’t get the apartment… the agent seems legit (listed on company site, got good reviews, spoke to him on the phone as well)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I don't like handing over cash unless that lease is signed.

like

Don’t do it even if they are legit. This is a scam tactic and so you mention that you are just protecting yourself from potential scammers. Deposit only after lease is signed

like

Is the broker asking for it, or the owner. I have provided to the later, called 311 on the former after walking out of a showing and calling them a criminal.

like

If it wasn’t clear. I agree with everyone here. If a broker asks for good faith, walk away. If the landlord asks for it, good chance they are scumbags (e.g. BLDG, Lisa Mngt, Solil etc)

like

I had a good faith deposit on my apartment last year, but it was only 1/3 of monthly rent. I only paid in full for security deposit and first months rent after we signed the lease…not sure if it’s just because of how crazy the market is now but I don’t think it’s completely unheard of

like

Idk what all these people are talking about but I’ve signed two NYC leases and both required a month of rent payment prior to lease signing. Especially in this market, people are willing to pay everything upfront to get it off the market before someone else does. Telling an agent you aren’t going to give them a deposit is a great way to never get an apartment at the moment

like

Not me reading this and I just paid a good faith deposit that’s one month’s rent 😳😳

like

I haven’t heard of this personally. I’ve only handed deposits over once the lease is signed and both parties were binded.

It shows you’re both serious and don’t have a dozen applications pending. I’d try to offer $500-$1000 though.

Haha wat? In this market the odds of having other applications in is slim. "Good faith" is not a legally binding term in this scammy market.

A small amount if they’re also going to take the place off the market isn’t unheard of. A month’s rent is steep though.

I did a good faith deposit via Nooklyn when I got my apartment (security deposit, and application fee). Was a little apprehensive but it turned out alright in the end

It’s not normal. The first month’s rent and security deposit should be paid when the lease is signed.

I did this for my first NYC apartment. I was skeptical but fortunately everything worked out ok. Wasn’t asked for one on my current one & honestly don’t think I would do one again.

Did you see the apartment in person? If not high likelihood to be a scam. The “agent” could be impersonating a real agent they found online.

I think this became illegal actually in the recent renter protection law

Be very very careful that the payee of your deposit is actually the owner of the apartment

You could be getting scammed

Reference check everyone and everything.

Don't pay anything except a nominal application fee without legal documents - a lease

Related Posts

Recommendations for a great L&E big law recruiter in NYC?

like

Does anyone know of any good CLEs that address complex issues re:multi-state employers/remote employees?

like

How do you guys deal with anxiety in the workplace? Struggling a bit.

likehelpful

How do we bring back civil society when community engagement is so low and division so high?

like

Klick - would you go? Why or why not?

Car collision repair shop recommendations? No idea where to start. 🫠

like

I rented a house that had been vacant for a bit & the prior tenant didn’t do a thorough job cleaning up. Agent indicated the owner would be open to having the house cleaned but I would need to have the house professionally cleaned when I moved out (that was fine w me). I just received the bill from the owner for $250, which is super annoying bc there was no expectation communicated that I would foot the bill for this, more so bc the cleaner did a LOUSY job. More in the comment below

like

Has anyone ever negotiated/been offered a signing bonus and/or relocation bonus with the Big 4?

like

For a male, I have extremely skinny wrists (think skinny girl wrists) but I’m looking to invest in a nice watch. What do you all recommend? Leather bands are preferable

like

One more day before tgif! Whats on your wrist?

Post Photo
like

The more I think about it the more I like the idea, so unless bowl leader shoots it down: let’s build him a watch. We can select a parts list, I’ll document the process, and then we can donate it in recognition of the work that goes into making this a great space.

like

How many days Deloitte India takes to release offer letter. I tried to contact HR she said that they are trying to get approvals and it is in progress. It's been a week that i have uploaded my docs.

like

I’ll be a student again so no income and no guarantors that meet income requirement. How do I secure housing? Do landlords take full payment on the lease? Any places that don’t have income verification?

like

How much should be the Lead Business Intelligence Analyst in Adobe? L4 level.
Fixed + variable + joining bonus?

like

Is 85K base salary a fair offer for an MS&T Process engineer at Moderna or Takeda in Massachusetts? I have 2 YOE in process development and need help evaluating an offer. Based on Glassdoor salary insights it seems some people are getting above 90K?

like

Midtier Valuation Advisory to Banking? I have an offer from a midtier accounting firm (BDO) for their Associate position in the Valuation Advisory team.

I’m thinking to switch to the Advisory role as a stepping stone to break into banking in a few years, or if that’s not possible then into Big 4. However, still considering accepting the offer because will be getting a 25% pay cut.

I’ve been working in Sales in a non-finance field for few months after finishing BBA in Finance & CFA L1.

like

What is the minimum experience required for associate salesforce consultant?

like

Is it true that KPMG has the biggest FDD practice because their audit clients are so small that there's hardly any independence issue with bigger clients?

likefunny

Can anybody refer me for pwc jaipur.
M wrking as finance executive
Yoe 1 years
Education ca final 1st group cleared

like

Additional Posts in New York City

Has anyone gotten movers within the city and had them pack your apartment? What was the cost for packing (for a studio or 1 BR)?

like

Looking for freelance writing opportunities for small businesses or bloggers who need additional support. I currently work in healthcare PR and have extensive experience with ghost writing for senior executive teams on a wide range of topics including healthcare and business. Will send examples of work if anyone is interested.

like

What are some nomad options in NY if you don’t want to sign a lease?

like

How much does it cost to put a pressurized wall? Any recommendations with good prices?

like

Any recs for good thrifting/vintage shopping in Manhattan? Looking for unique things for my new apt ☺️

like

Best month to find an apartment? Currently a nomad working abroad so want to strategically time my move back to NYC. Lived here for 5 years but always stuck in the summer rental cycle

like

I’ll be a student again so no income and no guarantors that meet income requirement. How do I secure housing? Do landlords take full payment on the lease? Any places that don’t have income verification?

like

Looking for a 3-4 week short term apartment rental in NYC - any suggestions on where to look for short term sub-lets / rentals?

Currently exploring options through AirBnB.

Thank you!

like

Are bars now open later in the city? Saw people still hanging out at places after midnight, on my way back from a friend's. Curious what the deal is

like

Will NYC be quarantined??

like

Does anyone know of a place to get something notarized in the area of Grand Central? Tried Chase bank but they won’t notarize a deed.

like

See post below

Post Photo
like

Moving- Will be flying in with a lot of suitcases, will be going on several grocery and furniture errands my first days. What is the best transportation solution? Avis is ~$500 for 3 days 😵‍💫

like

Can someone tell me about the water taxi from williamsburg to the city? Feasible to make it to the office (1-2 x / week)? Winter?

like

23F, work location is not really a consideration rn but curious to hear which neighborhood is better to live in, FiDi vs. Kips Bay?

like

Any recommendations on how to find a roommate in NYC?

Have a 2 BR in midtown east, if anyone is looking! I’m a pretty easy going 25 year old M looking to have fun in NYC outside of work. Clean and respectful. Classic hobbies... gym, sports, trying restaurants, etc

like

is there any store where you can buy pickles in bulk and fill your own container? i love pickles and eat quite a lot of them, and i’d love to bring my own containers because i’ve accumulated so many glass jars.

likefunnyuplifting

Need your help 🐠 I feel like I‘m always sick (flue like symptoms ~2x per month). The doctors either just treat the symptoms or give me referral for a specialist for one or more symptoms, I feel like I‘m getting nowhere with that. Any advice on what tests I can ask for that helped you in the past? Any recommendations for a more complete checkup in Manhattan (ideally covered by most insurances)? TIA!

like

Any dry cleaner recommendations for West Village?

like

My boyfriend has been playing duets with a neighbor of ours for the past ~8 months. His wife is due to have a baby girl in a week. What might be a nice gift? We don’t know her that well so want to play it safe!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal