May have dodged a bullet.

Got recruited by a head hunter for a big salaried CD agency position. I fit Job description. Head hunter sent 6 candidates (including me); in her opinion she thought all 6 were shoe-ins for interviews. All had stellar resumes, portfolios, and matched job description. Agency declined all candidates, “because none big agency/brand experience...” Head hunter was shocked that ALL high quality candidates were passed on.

This a normal thing or possibly a difficult agency?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Don’t think too hard about. It’ll rot your brain.

likeuplifting

You’re right.

Aren’t you ex W+K??? Lmao

like

Totally. But on the plus side, sounds like you dodged a bullet.

Welcoooooooome…. To the machiiiine.

like

This is the first time where all the options weren’t good enough for a 5-10 min conversation.

You’re already giving it too much thought. Move on

like

Maybe the agency is not into the kind of stuff we do and are looking more into a pharma/traditional big agency CD (which still seems like I'm making mental gymnastics to justify the feedback)

this was an agency trying to break into multiple spaces: experiential and advertising…

LOL, what would “big agency/brand experience” be then?

My guess is if the agency rejected all 6 candidates from a venerable, experienced head hunter it’s an agency with insane high expectations or poorly managed agency that is uncertain and inexperienced in what they want. Some would call it “a discovery expedition”. Those initiatives are the worst.

Related Posts

I do believe EY is d kindest when it comes to putting people first.Thank U Kelly.Resume travel based on CDC & facts, no layoffs in foreseeable future, extending trust when wfh& personal accountability

like

Can anybody please suggest me how to get an offer letter and how to apply for jobs in Australia while residing in India? I am looking for a job in Australia. Currently working in a big4 company.

like

After you are stealth laid off, other than job search, what do you do? I assume they won’t give you work and even if they do, you can politely decline? How do you feel about you are not progressing anymore and seeing other people progressing in their career? I have no intention to make partner, but still feel a bit stuck not doing that much.

like

Deloitte New Member makes me want to apply to Deloitte.

likefunny

Anyone who has 2+ years of experience in Salesforce. There are openings in Accenture.

likesmart

Where would you eat with an out-of-towner for a week?

like

Hi Guys
I will be joining IBM next week in Bangalore ( physical onboarding ) and my hometown is in West bengal , My father is having health problems , mother won't be able to handle everything and no such person we can rely on . Also I am getting married in January . Hence If i stay in Bangalore there will be no one to take responsibility for my marriage prep also . If i convey to my ibm manager will they consider for 4months of WFH?Any documents may have to show?
Need your suggestion please

like

Hello fishes, One of My friend having 5 yrs experience as plsql developer role.
Skill set : Oracle sql PLSQL unix. CCTC : 9.5. I don’t know whether it’s a decent pay or underpaid. What would be the expected CTC he can ask for next company? Need ur valuable suggestions. Thanks

like

I have joined BNP in June Month. I heard the bonus will be given on prorated basis. How much bonus and hike % I can expect for my first appraisal

like

What is the max salary offered by Wipro for B2 band?.....

like

Hello All - looking for links, resources , samples on interview prep/practice for sales , account management, partner management, practice management at FAANG companies like amazon, google, microsoft

like

Anyone looking for an apartment in LIC?

like

I’m in SF but nervous to officially come out to my friends even though I’m sure they all know/assume anyway. :(

like

I want to give a Christmas gift to the manager of the gym I go to. She’s awesome and I just really appreciate her. I can’t think of any ideas though! Can anybody think any good ones? I do not know much about her personal life except that she’s a single mother.

like

Hi all,

Currently, I am working in TCS and I have offer from CTS. Now, TCS trying to retain me with similar hike offered by CTS.

Is it better to stay back in TCS or move forward with CTS.

I have completed 7.5 years in TCS & my total year of experience is 9.

Please suggest. Thank you!

like

Cognizant Will cognizant give a Diwali bonus?

funnylike

I am on bench from 1 nov 2022. I am PA.

like

Anyone ever hire a promising creative into their group only to have them rage quit a month later and torch teammates & managers on their way out? I lead a UX group. Gave 0 indications. Background checks were clean. Had this happen only once before—a humble, hard-working Jekyll reveals himself to be a self-important, arrogant, belligerent Hyde. Anyone else?

like

Any place to go few hours drive from Austin? Have a 3.5 yo so want to keep it enjoyable/relaxing for us at the same time keep the kiddo engaged and happy. We just need a good change of scene.

like

Additional Posts in Creatives

When you know where you want to work, who do you reach out to first — the hr/talent/recruiter or directly to the CD or ECD depending on level? Or both?

like

GSP San Fran or Leo Chicago?

like

The industry is crumbling under our feet and I still can’t decide if I want to go in-house or not. I’m afraid it won’t be as exciting and I won’t travel as much. But also, I need a job. So 🤦‍♂️

like

A branding question. If FIFA stopped calling it the Women’s World Cup, would more of the world start treating it with as much reverence as the men’s World Cup, which is just called The FIFA World Cup?

likefunny

I have an associate's degree in graphic design and work designing wedding stationery. I've been at my company since 2016, and am now a design consultant - speaking to customers directly and creating custom artwork and designs for them. I know I'm underpaid (50k/year in the SF Bay Area) but I thought the benefits and stability were worth it. I'm now severely burnt out (most of my team is) and not sure which way to go, or how to grow. Any tips/advice?

Thanks!

like

Are Creative Directors rich?

likefunny

In person panel event - how Brands and Creators Win Together on TikTok. Let’s get together! DM @linkagency.official on IG if you would like to join

Post Photo
likefunny

I need help/advice/emotional support/literally anything.

I’m an in-house designer. My company decided to offer social media marketing packages to our clients. Today they asked me to take full ownership of that outside social media marketing on top of my current job duties.

I expressed a need for a promotion or raise to compensate for the major increase in responsibility, a responsibility that is not currently in my description.

They pushed back.

Wtf do I do

like

Anyone know of headhunters in publishing or entertainment, or good ones in our world who are savvy in such things?

Just me here hoping that slack never adds the “read” notification on messages.

likefunnysmart

**This week** Stay safe everyone! (Yes I made this meme)

Post Photo
likefunny

If you were offered a job at a great agency but working on just one brand, but it was a big one like Nike or McDonalds, would you do it? Being siloed sucks, but maybe worth it for a big account?

like

I put in my two weeks! But now it's weird here haha. Agencies should ask you to leave and pay you out. This is silly.

like

What advice do you have for someone who wants to make a quick and seamless transition from operations to creative?

Which is the right move for a young creative: free ride to portfolio school, or take a full time junior position where you’ve been interning?

can a writer explain the new season of Dave to me?

like

Hi. Can I bounce some ideas for a spot off one of ya?

What are benefits of working with a content strategist on a project?

What are strong must-have traits of a good content strategist?

Trying to build a case for my agency to hire our first CS!

like

New writer on an account. Being pitted against the other existing writer on the account for every project. They take it very personally if my work is chosen over theirs

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal