Has anyone ever been asked to concept and present ideas as part of the interview process?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

For in-house shops, yes. Three times. I Rejected all three. Interviewing is iffy enough...I’m not investing a day in prepping ideas and a pitch for these clowns so they can string me along for months.

like

Never have. I'd like to say never will. You need ideas on something and want to see what I can do with that particular project, bring me in freelance. Otherwise, look at my portfolio.

like

Yeah, buy only did it because a friend said "they're cool and won't steal your shit." It's pretty silly. I've been fighting like mad to get them to stop. Unfortunately, some VPs don't know how to judge a portfolio or trust their hiring manager.

like

Yes, once. Never again

like

Pretty par for the course these days.

like

Yup. I got asked to work on a pitch for an agency which I thought was ridiculous.

like

Anybody who has ever interned.

like

My very first job. Didn’t go to ad school. Had no book. Barely had any writing samples. And I got to pick the brands so it wasn’t like they were going to run the work. Seemed fair because they really didn’t have anything to assess me by.

I have occasionally asked junior-ish peeps to come up with a few ideas if I like them but their book isn’t totally cutting it. Again, they can pick the brand. Done in the spirit of giving them a chance to get the job, it has felt very fair.

like

Yes, once. It was horrible. Bunch of people in the room just staring at me nodding their heads, writing notes and not saying a word. Felt like I was a science experiment or a chimpanzee throwing poop (concepts) at the audience.

like

You mean it felt like a pitch presentation.

like

Especially at senior level and non creative role jobs, I'm seeing more and more assignments at the final stages. Strategists pitching, PMs creating work plans.

like

I have twice. First time I was paid a lower freelance rate to do the work. Turned out the work sold, got the job and produced it as soon as I started.
Second time I wasn’t paid. Didn’t get the job. But two months later they lost the account and shortly after that the agency closed their doors. So, that worked out too in a weird way.

like

Yeah a couple times

In my experience these kinds of places just want you string you along and keep you busy while they figure out their own shit show. Even when you do well they may not hire you, and then blame your work. It’s just tacky and bad.

I did when I was hired as an art director...but it was done as a paid freelance assignment after the interview. Went well..got paid...concept chosen to move forward...got the job...the rest is history. Was fair all the way around

if we like someone and it works logistically we’ll always try to get them to work with us freelance on something, if they’re interested in us. of course we pay them their regular rate. and of course we want to be able to use their work. but it’s also the best way to get to know each other on both sides—& learn if f/t will be a good experience for them & us....

sometimes they’re freelancing already so it’s easy to fit us in when they have some time. if they have a job already, sometimes they’ll be able to spare some time over a weekend, and of course we’re very respectful of that time. it’s not about expecting someone to do a weeks work in a day. just seeing how they react to a brief and whether they’re psyched & are interesting to work with & have ideas. of course it works best with more senior people who are used to thinking quickly in short windows of time. and the goal is to get to know each other. we’d never expect anyone to quit their job to freelance with us - and we’d never hand out an assignment that required so much time it wouldn’t be practicable for someone who was already working....

I have for brand side. I got the job and couldn’t be happier.

If you’re going tech side, it seems kind of common since they do the same thing for programmers and engineers

I’m not in the creative industry, but have done 3 too many “projects” and “exercises”, 2 times of which I did not get the job. In the future I will be giving my hourly rate to complete them if I decide to do so at all. One was with recent dates and everything and was definitely to get free work.

Related Posts

An agency interviews you for 3 rounds (job involves a move). Is there value in saying “I have an offer” just to get them to say yes or no, so you can finally know if you’re moving or staying?

likefunny

Any advice for preparing for KPMG Tech - Deal Execution - Integration and Separation competency/ technical interview. Thanks

like

Working on a take-home case study for a direct lender, I was given a public company take-private scenario and build a model around it, want to get you guys thoughts on whether I should include a few pages on historical financials?

like

Tata Consultancy Hi fishies, I recently interviewed for a Big data dev role for Autodesk but it's via a third party called Applicantz. Initially the contract is for 1 year, which can be extended. There is also scope of Autodesk hiring permanently after 6 months or 1 year. Can anyone provide some reviews about Autodesk and third party Applicantz. Usually I would not have considered anything via a third party, but the company(Autodesk) seems great and work discussed seems good as well.
Publicis Sapient Citi Tata

likesmart

I got an offer from firm 1 before the memorial holiday and have been stalling because I am waiting for an offer from firm 2..
I was working with a partner from firm 2 who got me an interview with the managing partner.. I got a verbal offer last week.. the staff told me they are processing the paperwork.
Should I still wait for firm 2? I feel like I can’t stall anymore.. I feel like I really should give firm 1 a response this week 😮‍💨 but I don’t want to lose both offers

likehelpful

I have my final interview for a recruiting position at a well known company. Are there any questions I should be prepared for or be prepared to ask? It is a remote position and I’ve had 2 previous interviews. The manager who I will work for said he likes me and definitely want to move forward but I just have to get through this last interview so I really want to make a good impression and pass.

like

Dear Fishes,

I am Java developer, I have cleared L1 interview round of 
Valuelabs and another round L2 is there which technical + hr. Can anyone please help me how to clear L2.

Infosys Tata Consultancy Accenture Amazon Deloitte Genpact

I have a Microsoft onsite interview coming up for an SDE1/2 role. Any tips from current employees or people who took the interview before on how I can prepare for this? I have been doing top leetcode questions for the technical portion but I am not sure how hard the questions can be and how they pick their questions. Also not sure what kind of systems design high level questions/answers they're looking for.

like

How long does it typically take for a company to reach out to references? I gave mine a week ago after the whole interview process and they still have not been contacted.

Any product manager here from mastercard.
I have given 2 interviews for different product management related positions already and after 2nd interview 2 rounds there is no reply from HR and every day I am getting call for product management related positions in mastercard. Even on LinkedIn they are promoting it heavily.

On workday as my profile it is seen like 5-7 pm position which my status in "interview"

I just want to know the status if it is rejected or not .

What's going on ?

like

I have worked as Data analyst and BI but companies are mistaking me for Data Science roles in interviews. How to tackle this?

like

Good DFW tax recruiter?

helpful

Hi

I'm in the final stages of interview with Telstra for Senior data engineer role. My cctc is 20 lpa. I'm considered for band 2 in Telstra .How much i can negotiate max with Telstra? Thank you.

like

Can someone provide me some insights into the Senior Solutions Developers roles at Amazon AWS? What are expected TC range for remote positions with 10+ years of experience? What kind of questions should I expect during the first technical interview(90 minutes)? Specially for the coding part(20-30 mins) what level of LC questions do I need to prepare for? I already got some ideas about System Design and LP parts however there is not any info out there regarding the coding part for this position.

like

Please suggest platform to practice SQL, which can build confidence for interview..... TIA

likesmart

Anyone have experience with Capital One’s mini case? Applying for a product manager role. They will pick to interview me on capital one college checking (which doesn’t exist?) or capital one shopping — (they’re not doing the credit wise case anymore). Has anyone gone through this process and can weigh in? TYIA!

like

Any thoughts on holding out hope for a GSB interview invitation if you didn’t receive an HBS interview invitation today? GSB seems even less likely now…

like

What’s up with this trend of hiring managers rejecting developers who don’t have FAANG experience on their resume? People in consulting companies also work for clients who handle high traffic and complex architectures. Also, not everyone wants to work at FAANG companies due to moral issues that these big tech companies ignore and blatantly misuse personal data and privacy.

like

More Posts

Heading to Puerto Rico in a couple of weeks. Any must sees you would recommend?

like

Some people have to already RTW!

Post Photo
likefunny

When a partner goes on their third vacation in two months.

Post Photo
likefunny

Do we have NPS component in the salary if not can we ask get it deducted monthly from our salary ?

like

Any possibility of postponing the LWD by the manager here in CGI, even we have not taken any leaves?

like

Freakin @NonEquityPartner on IG 😂

Post Photo
likefunny

Just curious what the salary ranges are for Benefits Managers within this group. Trying to determine where I currently align. I have 16 years of experience with 6 being in the role of a Benefits Manager. I have continously grown within my career and taken on more responsibilities and added new skills. I have both my PHR and SHRM-CP and working on my Cebs certification. Current salary is $80k.

likesmart
like

What made you choose and stick with STEM? Was there anything that discouraged you from pursuing a career in STEM?

like

How are LIC and Astoria to live in? Looking for more space and proximity to Manhattan

What's a ctc offerd to a deputy manager in axis bank.?

Any scoop on THNY? Tommy Hilfiger in-house agency?

Anyone else have an influx of kids who were virtual coming back because they were failing? We’ve seen a 30% increase in class sizes in the last week.

like

Anyone got a Google Cloud contact or know what their email format is?

like

RE has slowed down IMO. Still some work in multifamily and new construction/development (and workouts/restructurings/foreclosures), but hotels, office, retail not doing great at the moment for obvious reasons. Have heard of multiple layoffs, but not mass layoffs yet, and I don’t think we’re going to mass layoffs since this is clearly a temporary pandemic related issue.

Would love to hear from others on what they’re seeing in RE. Please share your geographic market/firm size/relevant info.

like

What are the best mid-late game weapons for a faith build? Feel like my winged scythe +8 is starting to get outscaled in Leyndell, but idk if that’s just part of the difficulty curve

like

Recommendations for gyms around the Yonge Waterfront area? Looking for one that is decently priced and includes classes as part of membership.

like

What’s it like working at Mandiant?

like

Hi all,

How's the work life at Accenture as application development analyst.

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

With layoffs slowing down. Does that give anyone reassurance of things going back to normal?

likefunny

When a lackluster creative director complains that they’re never on any projects but continually bails on creative briefings....? 🤔

like

Congratulations. You just won the lottery and now have an additional 5 million dollars. What do you do?

like

What are your thoughts on Wunderman Thompson?

likefunny

Starting my Sprinternship on Monday. Any advice?

like

Let’s say you accidentally invent some incredible thing—at what point do you give up the in-house and go to an agency? But... you’re you, and you’re supposed to know how to do this.

like

Which agencies have sabbatical programs for years of service?

like

R/GA layoff updates: 20 cut in Portland today, bringing stateside count close to 100 on the year. No official statement from Bob.

like

Most aesthetic agency spaces in NYC? Don't judge a book by its cover but some offices are 👌🏼

likehelpful

Would you rather live in Williamsburg or East Village?

like

Just got a one year contract to work in London UK for 1 year. Where should I live in the city? (30y.o woman)

like
likeuplifting

Pharma, is it the career kiss of death?

like

What are the pros/cons of moving from WPP to IPG? I can’t give specifics about which agencies but I’m curious in a general sense about benefits, compensation, career growth, culture, etc.

like

Chip on your shoulder for the win

like

Current status: questioning every career decision I've ever made.

like

In this current advertising climate, if I get a freelance gig in pharma, I’ll be extremely grateful. Am I the only one who feels this way?

like

Any advice on how to transfer internally to another team/department?

likesmart

Laid off at Ogilvy yesterday

like

Getting so over the grind of New York but don’t want to give up the pace of my career. Where should I consider moving (PR necessary, healthcare preferred)

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal