Is it normal for a Product Owner to lay out specs for how a feature should work?

I thought that was my job as the ux designer to figure out the best way to solve a need. But I’m getting handed projects where the PO, and sometimes the senior designer has laid out exactly what should happen (components used, flow, etc) to design a feature. It’s really frustrating because I don’t know if I’m supposed to be speaking up on what I think or just do the UI work I’m asked to.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If you are mid-level, then 1 + 2. If you are asked to do only 3 after showing that you understand then start spending that creative energy looking for a job in a diff place.
It’s somewhat common in immature product teams to have PMs think they are the brains, and the designers the hands. If they are not flexible, bad sign.
As to the senior designer, I’d ask them 1:.
Maybe they’ve been burnt by jr designers that thought themselves geniuses and were incapable of building a shippable feature since they had no concept of the design constraints the team/tech has to work under. In other words, if you’re going to pitch everyone on your revolutionary idea that doesn’t use their existing patterns/flows/components, you better have a really incredible design that demonstrably offsets the design/dev/usability costs of doing things differently in your one little corner of the platform you’re designing.

like

Ask instead for user stories, acceptance criteria & tech requirements. That is what they should be giving you. The puzzle of how to best solve the problem with that information is what we do.

like

Do I :

1. Ask if there’s room for interpretation? (Also who do I ask, the PO or the senior designer? I’m mid level, new, and really scared to overstep or challenge too much)

2. Come up with two versions of the design and show them both?

3. Just do exactly what the specs outline to do?

PMs job is to manage the roadmap and provide ideas. UX is in charge of research, journey maps, wireframes, etc…

Related Posts

hiring aggressive... anyone looking for referal at Accenture technology operations strategy consulting drop cv @ mail ayush.splunk@gmail.com

minimum 2.5 years experience mention you skill - Date of Birth nd mobile number. (mandatory fields in referal form ) Accenture #refer

like

Hi Fishes,
I am currently looking for a job opportunity. I have an experience of 6.6 years in Messaging (Exchange and other messaging appliances), Office 365, Azure. I am serving notice period and will appreciate any referrals where possible.
Location preference: Hyderabad, Delhi NCR, Bangalore, Pune
Thanks in advance!

like

Does anyone else check in with their employees within 45 days of their hire? If not, how are you guys going about employee experience and engagement/onboarding?

like

What should be the ideal package for a SAP ABAP consultant experience of 5 years?

like

Anyone have any tips on finding great content creators? Ty in advance!

Hi IBMers,
Do we need to mandatorily submit the rental agreement, rental proofs and landlord's PAN to claim HRA for any amount?
Please help me with your suggestions. Thanks in advance 😊

like

Hi Fishes,

Do these 2 points in the JD allude to modelling requirements?

• Prepare transaction specific and marketing materials (teasers, information memorandum, pitch books, corporate profiles, and industry data and analyses)

• Perform in-depth company and industry research supporting specific client engagements and marketing opportunities

like

Has anyone gone back to school for their MBA? Did help further your career?

like
like

Hi fishes, i am working as a .net developer role in Publicis sapient had 1.7 YOE with 8 LPA CTC and I gave an interview for TCS on Nov 3rd 2022 but still no response, whether rejected or selected. Filled TCS application with exp

CTC: 9.5 LPA

Concerend about TCS can't give exp CTC Shall i move on by other company interviews or wait. A bit scared of recission a head so need some secure job for 1 year

Please help me and suggest fishes thanks in advance.

like

Hello everyone! I got a screening phone call with HR for a staff accountant role. Any ideas on any questions I can ask that an HR person would know? Thanks!

like

What are the steps to turn in two week notice? Email a word doc to HR then let me counselor know?

like

Engineering influencers to follow?

like

Is anyone noticing keyword manipulation (price hikes) for search campaigns or fake traffic/bots hitting their remarketing campaigns on Google Ads? I seem to be experiencing a bunch right now

like

Friendly reminder: please clean your phone as often as your hand 🖐

Post Photo
likehelpfulfunny

Last song you listened to.. go!

likehelpful

Best books on entrepreneurship? Trying to find a good birthday gift for a friend thinking of starting his own company and exploring business ideas

like

Graduating with my finance degree in about a year. I took a part-time healthcare position fill my employment gap but most of my previous experience is in manufacturing logistics and customer service. With my background, how do I break into a finance or accounting role? What positions do I apply for? I would like to make at least 45-50k a year min starting if possible.

like

How much should an Orthopedic Tech specializing in casting make?

like

Had anyone gone from a med tech (MT/MLS) to LIS? What the pay more or less? I was offered a position with their second offer being 7k less than I make now. How can I negotiate more even if it’s a “change of career”..

like

Additional Posts in User Experience

Anyone work at or know of firms that have data engineering roles? I discovered the world of design services and they seem to do the general type of work that I think is practical and useful. I'm love to find a firm that works with the public sector and social impact organizations, but can't find any that have data-related roles

like

Question: market research - do you hire for in house talent our outsource?

like

Hey guys! I'm working on pivoting into ux research (background in product management and an MSc in marketing). Any recommendations for ux research certifications? Something that is well respected and well known and also provides a solid foundation of ux?

like

UXRs: what products/services do you use the most in the course of your job? Would you recommend them?

Starting up a UX research discipline in my new company and looking to start us on the best footing.

likesmart

Trying to get out of consulting. Ux is so watered down and I’m terrified that it’s going to stunt my growth. I’m overall just not happy. Sure, consulting pats decently but I love the field of UX and just get stuck making wireframes that the customer requests. The field is so competitive right now and I can’t seem to land another job. Struggling hard

like

I think I may have finally had it.

A couple of decades in this field and now I want to just walk away. The grind in tech is soul-destroying, and the vast majority of the time, coworkers outside of UX have no idea what it is, what it’s for, and how it’s applied. I’m at my wits end and the constant problem is a kind of “willful misunderstanding” of our process and value.

After wasting too many years on design immature companies, It’s senselessly depressing. I’ve given away too much of myself.

likesmart

My product owner doesn’t understand the value of standard practices like information architecture, use personas, and just want to get to wireframes as soon as possible. Even after a few of us demonstrating that value and the founder chiming in to agree with us. How have you all combatted this before?

like

How do you approach usability testing for new onboarding sequences? I work with a variety of SaaS businesses and recently requests have come in to test onboarding prototypes.

New users are the first to touch onboarding so how do I recruit the appropriate participants to test? Recruiting new users doesn’t seem feasible, I would think we should run A/B tests and cross-check analytics to measure success? Any insight is appreciated!

like

I am switching careers and trying to get into the field of UX design. I made it to round two of the interview process for a UX Designer position, an interview with the hiring manager for this role. I have not made it this far before, are there any standard questions that get asked in UX interviews I should be aware of? Thanks I’m advance! I want to be as prepared as possible.

like

Has anyone done a UX bootcamp? I am still in the beginning stages of mine and NYC summer has been crazy distracting. Has anyone gone through the same? If so, how did you overcome this?

like

Any advice on getting started in UX?

like

How’d you rate your company’s UX?

UX (website) awards worth entering? UK/Europe/Global?

Ideally with full end-to-end and UR/discovery categories, not just design.

Looking for anyone who works at Rivian! Just applied for my dream job and I would love to chat with anyone someone who works there currently! Thank you in advance!

I joined a project that had already started and the team already settled on creating a user journey map, even though none of them are designers or in ux. I also have no experience in this field as I'm a data engineer. The user journey map was for mapping out the process for tenants finding housing assistance, so not a technical product. Given this new field and type of work, I've been having a really tough time. Anyone mind sharing what helped get you through your first ux project?

Any recommendations on tools to catalog user research findings in order to share findings and reduce duplicate studies?

like

How important was your portfolio to land your first UXR job? There are mixed messages out there...

like

This is pretty niche, but I have an emergency management background and am interested in transitioning to UX. However, I would love to find a way to combine my experience in disasters with UX research. Does anyone know of any tech companies that have an emergency management focus that would need a researcher for their products?

Have you enjoyed working in UI/UX/Product design for a startup? Why or why not?

like

UX Designers - how long did it take for you to find a junior role when starting out in UX?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal