Need advice- I am a Partner at MBB. I have been a Partner for 3 years, just starting my 4th year. I feel my compensation is very low compared to the fees I generate. ( around 4/5% of total sales I do independently). My current firm network, sponsorship and profile is really good. Should I plan to switch to another firm or wait out while the comp adjusts?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Three years in and comp less than a million with those numbers is pretty rough

That said - if you play the long game and keep putting up those numbers the 15-20 year total is going to be very good

Smaller firms often pay a higher commission rate on sales but at McKinsey if you make senior partner you get the benefit of all the more junior partners under you getting 5%….

Its the new reality unfortunately if we are talking in year cash

like

My advice is to stay and your comp will go up considerably as you get closer to Sr. Partner level - regardless of whether it's a formal title and recognition.

We often underestimate the value of our email address (and everything that comes with being associated with a large, well-recognized name) and overestimate our own role in our success. Among many I've seen lateral, very few have replicated a similar level of commercial success. You may be an exception - you will know this best yourself.

like
Recent IconRecent

Agree - my question is how much are you “executing” vs “generating”

like

This is what I generate and others execute.

OP defo at McK. We have been delaying bonuses for 3 years now…

like

Over the last years the annual bonus has been tranched over the subsequent years with the year 1 amount being 0

like

If you are truly generating all those fees on your own, then you need to be marching into your bosses office.

like

A&M would pay you about 25% of what you truly generate and run

like

If they're good, of course it is

like

What’s the split between people buying you v. the McKinsey brand? Got it? And then cut your half by 50% and then decide if you should shop around.

like

What does your parsing suggest BCG1? It’s not BCG either since the comp model at BCG is more sensitive to in-year economic MDP contribution. So that leaves only Bain (which appears sus too).

MBB senior partners are definitely preying on economics of junior partners (esp. as a lot Senior Partners are unproductive on internal roles etc.) that being said level of unwanted attrition of junior partners is very low so why would they change behavior and give away more economics…

like

Preying is correct. More work is sold based on expertise now, which most Sr Partners don’t have. OVPs are increasingly coming with real expertise and compensating for the fossils who are just coasting along.

What is your TC?

like

4/5 %???

You're being taken for a ride if they're not giving you any equity

Something doesn’t compute here. If you’re an MBB partner (not a PINO), your comp is more than $1M (at a minimum). It’s impossible to believe you’re solely responsible for “selling” $20-25M of work at BCG (or Bain). What are we missing so we can be helpful in helping your next move?

So in a given year I would close between 15-25 Mn of sales and my comp is less than 1Mn USD. The real question for me is if I leave to another place and let’s say I take a 50% haircut on above sales numbers, would I still get above comp? Is it worth taking the risk? Or should i continue on auto pilot mode and the comp will catch up in 4/5 years ?

Hmmm… let’s say you originate $10MM at new firm per your hypothetical. At 50% margin we are looking at $5MM. But alas some other partners have to execute this work, and you probably went to market with others for some of this (even if you’re the main person). So let’s say you merit ~ 1/3. You’re north of $1mm but I don’t think you’re at $2. Let’s say $1.5 for sake of argument. Is that enough to be interesting given risk and current trajectory? Maybe but doesn’t feel like a slam dunk.

like

The business you originate is a function of the ability to deliver and that ability is created by the firm, not by you alone.

As a P&D at BCG, I periodically considered approaches from other consulting firms, including the other 2 MBBs. I ultimately always concluded that the execution risk and switching costs of a move (rebuilding internal network, hiatus in external relationships due to non-compete & gardening leave provisions etc) substantially outweighed the potential benefits. In particular I observed the huge significance in MBB careers success of building your constellation of trusted internal colleagues. Is the grass really greener (or redder or bluer :-) ??

You’ll note that lateral moves at partner level between MBBs are relatively rare and typically only happen when there are distinctive particular individual circumstances (eg major personal fallout with sponsor, change of firm strategy in your practice area, massive over-supply or lack of required capability/commitment in the local office etc.). So most people have arrived at the same conclusion. Of course there’s some inertia and risk aversion in there too.

N.B. Given the above, interviews often assume (perhaps unfairly) that a desire to move is evidence of damaged goods eg individual performance issues, and subtly probe for evidence to the contrary. So important to have a compelling storyline.

One good thing about MBB comp is that it’s *relatively* mechanical and so you’re less vulnerable to individual discrimination than in situations where your bonus is entirely at the whim of your boss. So sticking around is likely to work well in the long term. Of course you can still suffer from individual politics in internal negotiations e.g. over revenue sharing and client access, with material career implications.

Last thought is that one of the few structural distinctions between MBBs is that I understand partner comp (and equity influence?) at McK is materially skewed in favour of the senior partners (Directors?) whereas at BCG (and Bain??) it’s one partner one vote and a more equitable share of profits. That presumably means that if you plan on being a partner for ~5-8 years before moving on / retiring you’re better off financially at BCG, whereas if you’re determined to stick around as partner for 10+ years and confident of making that final up or out step at McK, there’s significant further $ upside.

Related Posts

Want to join new company after h1b transfer completed. Need to give 2 weeks notice to current employer. Can I work for current employer for those 2 weeks notice period after h1b transferred to new employer?when does the current employer get notified of h1b transfer, in case that happens?

like

How is this service line at EY GDS for a Data Scientist role? EY

Post Photo
like

I just defended my first depo and I feel like I did a terrible job. The questions and answers were so fast I feel like I didn’t even have a chance to think what objection was appropriate. Any resources for learning objections better. Or tricks on how to tell when a question being asked is not good?

like

Hey, new to investing looking at initial mistakes I made. I have $1k in VOO, $7k in VT and $4k in VTI in my brokerage acct; in my Roth IRA I have $6k in VT and $7.7k in VTI. I know isn’t an ideal portfolio because many of these funds overlap. However I’m in for the long term and am willing to reposition to a strategy that will do the best over my life. Id appreciate to hear feedback on these 2 accounts and better approaches from others. Thanks!

like

If I move to the Bay Area from Austin, are there any major negatives that will be really hard for me?

like

If Yahoo wanted to rebrand, a la Meta, what would it be called? 🤔

like

“The shaft is not always welcome, but but hole always is.”

likefunny

What are the best options to get in on Monday?
Please mention strike and expiry as well

like

I'd love to see some photos of people's favorite plants or wishlist plants

like

any telltale signs of layoffs in tiger?

like

Did we ever learn who was behind Saatchi LobbyCarpet??

like

TS9 comes out tonight!

like

Any Gaylors in this bowl? Bejeweled is the gayest thing I’ve seen in a long time… and I watch lesbian 🌽…

like

Hello everyone, I’m trying to validate the Business model through market survey. The business is a kind of agri investment model where one can get an ROI of above 8% annually. Please share your thought process on form generations, target audience, Channels like Linked In , paid promotion etc.,

like

Hello Everyone,

I am relocating to Bangalore. My office would be in doddakananahalli village. Looking for single room in shared 2/3 bhk flat.

It would be helpful if flatmates are from IT sector as well.

like

PwC US ADVISORY
Line of Service: Advisory
Industry: Management Consulting
Designation: Senior Associate
I have second round of interview tmrw and have few queries as below-
1) I have current offer of 12 CTC from other company so now how much can I ask in pwc? My current experience is 5yrs.
I am on notice period and in present company I got recent hike and my salary is now 9.5ctc.
2) generally how many rounds of interview will be there?

like

Anybody getting into DraftKing?

like
like

How to get release from a project? Hating the work environment and pressure here.

like

Hi All, just sharing what on mind to vent it out from my system. Maybe with this I could gain some insights and inspiration.
I have been working as a data scientist since 2018 & have been the bread winner. I have neither been under a proper mentor nor with a team of peers from my field to help me out. I was alone and confused. I have never really got the chance to prove myself which makes me all the more depressed. I'm not sure what to do with my future, indecisive and low on confidence.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal