Out of curiosity, how do you all feel about the “haha, recorder is a joke” jab from other teachers? While I enjoy a good laugh, it kind of bothers me coming from non-music teachers.

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I laugh along with them but play serious recorder music and “show them all”! We do the standard Hot Cross Buns but we also do some Ode to Joy, something from Quaver, something classical, etc. Last year we did a dinner theater production of Tikki Tikki Tembo in conjunction with the beginner and middle school band concert. It is a dinner fundraiser for our high schoolstate solo and ensemble students. They made their best profit partially attributed to the elementary addition. The public loved the integration of recorders and orff!


That’s pretty mean. My students actually love it, they can’t wait to show off their Hot Cross Buns skills! I actually didn’t care for it growing up, I preferred my piano lessons, but there’s plenty of kids who love it recorder. But to answer your question, disrespectful non-music people are the main reason I am planning on quitting. I’m part of this team, you jerks, not some babysitter so you can rest your weary bones, and the instruments I choose for instruction are not a joke. And neither is music education.


I am grateful that I don’t get that kind of response. I get the “I don’t know how you can stand it.” Comments, but I have very supportive teachers for the music program. My students also love to start in 3rd grade, some are not as enthusiastic during 4th and 5th grades, but most are.
If I was to get a comment like that, I would remind that teacher that I am teaching reading skills, a foreign language, and math skills to all of my students when I am teaching music.


Anyone concerned that their recorder program is going to be “banned” in the future because of what’s going on now with this virus?

I ask this because I store student recorders on spindle platforms where they sit about 2 inches apart from each other. They did not come with cases.

My routine has always been to spray them with mouthpiece disinfectant shortly before and right after the kids used them. I brought them home at the end of every marking period and ran them through my dishwasher. Just like band instruments, the recorders are reused each year.
Never had any problems with or found students questioning their recorders cleanliness, but after this virus, I imagine they will.

So it will be interesting to see what changes we’ll see regarding recorder sanitation and storage and any impact that has on recorder instruction.

I hear your concern. In my program we provide a recorder that comes in a case to every student and offer them the option to buy theirs at $4 each. Each year, I have several students who bring in sibling’s previously purchased recorders, and sell about half to three quarters of the recorders to students. If they don’t buy them, I store them in a grade level box over summer and hand them back in the fall. It means keeping a list of numbers and names in each box. As we use them for three years, this works out well. I always keep a few clean ones for kids who forget them at home. And I wash a bunch in the dishwasher every summer. But, there are always kids who lose their cases and I have never been overly concerned. But this week, I told everyone who lost their cases that they need to provide a gallon size baggie to keep them in from here on.
As I sent packets home reminding everyone to practice while we are off, I encouraged everyone to wash their recorders.


Ignore their stupid remarks and go ahead with your plans. The recorder is lovely and kids need music! Good for you for making it happen.
Are you going to teach the recorder in live in-person sessions or on zoom?

Related Posts

Is Glassdoor pay to play? I’ve posted an honest and fair review and it’s gone and it seems like my employer is astroturfing the reviews to cover for bad management.


Breathing bubbles calm the class even for just a minute.


Fellow students, what kind of jobs do you have now? I recently got promoted to project engineer and looking back on how much I worried about grades it all seems so silly now


Anyone have a good suggestion for hotels (Marriott guy) in Nashville ? I like to walk to entertainment and dinner but still drive to the client site near the zoo.

Hello everyone,
New here. Can everyone give a like please so that I am able to DM


I want home loan of 57L. My in hand salary per month is 1L. What are the best options available in India?


Recently joined Deloiite consulting. Has anyone gotten their green card sponsored within 1 year of joining the firm ?

How do you deal with your boss taking your resignation badly?


Hi fishies, does Deloitte India (not USI) considers renegotiation ? I already have an offer from other company with higher package. Should I consider renegotiating with Deloitte?


Filed for I-140 and I-485 concurrently and awaiting all the approvals,,, planning to get married in interim and move to a different state,,, what needs to be done from my end to inform USCIS or attorney? Can I apply for GC for my to-be-spouse? Urgent help required.


How’s your work-life balance? New job at a new company and wondering how to clarify standards on this


New gf said she’s addicted to me. What does it mean?


Does anyone know what the pattern is behind the Kellogg R2 interview roll-outs?

Obviously, by "know" I mean has some speculative idea grounded in some logic or data.


Any BCG Fishes out here.. Looking for Ops Analytics referral ( Supply-chain). Thanks in Advance

Is TCS resuming work from office for all of the employees by Nov 15th?

Hi Everyone, Looking for a job opportunity in Calgary. I have 8 yrs of experience in marketing of SaaS and advertising and customer marketing in e-commerce like mobility & households. Any referrals will be much appreciated.


25 F 🐠 anyone free for a drink in midtown?

Signed up for a matchmaking service a couple months ago after getting tired of the apps. And while I’ve been underwhelmed with their process so far, I finally have my first match date this weekend. Haven’t been on a date since pre-pandemic. And never been on a true blind date like this. Wish me luck.


What are everyone’s best productivity tips? Fairly early in my career as a SWE looking to learn :-)


Is there probation period in FIS Global ? If yes how much notice need to serve in probation period in FIS Global ?

In my Offer letter nothing is mentioned about probation period , only notice period is mentioned.

Additional Posts in Elementary Music Teachers

Hi can you advertise here? I teach private piano-flute and violin lessons online

So how are you planing to do mallet work this year with disinfecting in between kids, classes, etc?

Hey! I’m planning to take an Orff Level 1 course this summer. Any tips, tricks, or advice as I prepare? Also, what other trainings would you recommend for elementary general music teachers? Thanks in advance!

If anyone needs awesome, fun music activities, search Vincent Bates on youtube. He's a music education professor and has his music education students play music games so we can learn, too!


What are some of your favortie end of year activities?

Did anyone else’s back-to-school plan not include music at all? I’ve been told I’m still supposed to teach music this year, but they haven’t announced any plans for it yet. You’d think the classes that contain the most students per day would be a higher concern 🙃


What are some VERY SIMPLE yet engaging activities (that don’t involve paper and pencil) that you use on the first days of general music? I teach 4th and 5th grade.

Just heard that my district will have classroom and live-recording learning. I’m thankful because I now can feed my family, my newborn and a recent-sponsored wife! I’m scared because I’m almost 50 and I’m afraid I might catch the virus and die leaving behind my 1 month baby and a wife who is not legal in the state yet! The USCIS or Trump’s dept. thinks she’s not good enough to be in the US!! We applied for green card and SS card since August 2019!

Any advice for how to get tarnish off of glockenspiel bars?

How often and for how long do you see your kids?

I have a hand full of k-5 students who have gone the first half of the school year without music because of remote learning. Our district is moving to 100% traditional teaching after the MLK holiday. Any suggestions for reintroducing concepts to the group of students that’ll be joining us f2f for music the first time this school year?

How do you set up your classroom? What can you tell me about how often you use instruments? What do you do to make them accessible? Thanks so much.


And now you know the rest of the story

Post Photo

Hi! Can someone recommend a source for learning how do simple, fun music lessons on Zoom? I teach first grade and use music for my transitions. I would also like to play songs for them with my guitar, but am concerned it won’t sound good on zoom (the guitar, not my voice, which is bad, we established that long ago)

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone


Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or