What makes a good manager? What makes a bad manager?

I’ve had a few bosses over the years and have been wondering what sets them apart and why. I’ve had very calculating bosses that think many steps into the future which I really appreciate. I’ve had some, that flip flop what they say weeks later which creates confusion.

I have seen that the environment plays a big role in how it can affect people. I’ve seen bosses become super chill and different when they are away from work.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Duty Manager or upper management? For a duty manager or direct manager it is quite simple: does he or she protect his or her team from the questionable decisions of upper management or executives? When the good idea fairy strikes, does your direct manager try to stop it? They say the "expletive" rolls down hill, does your manager try to shield you from it? To me, a manager is never just someone who hands out assignments and gets on your back, but also actively protects you.

like

In 4 year's I had 3 managers. Two of them treated me like a human being...the other one was sarcastic and rude!

You have mentioned a few attributes that you have observed. I'd suggest that a good manager is honest, consistent, forward thinking, fair, and works with the team to start. One thing I'd like managers to remember: they do not have all the answers and growing professionally is key.

like

I would say that a bad manager is someone who micromanages everything you do. Instead of using initiative and also some autonomy you always feel you have to ask your manager for constant approval to get the job done. Whereas as good manager is more like a leader because they give you the autonomy to get the job on your without any approval. Good Managers know how to lead because they want the people who work under them to succeed and become great leaders themselves. Bad managers tend to set you up for epic failure because they don't want you to succeed in anything. Bad managers will always take away credit from you where is credit is due because they don't care about the hard work you have put into while doing a task

like

Because the micromanaging process is eating into the productive time. Which translates into the total energy waste per day. It’s cheaper to just have people fill out a weekly report of what they accomplished than it is to micromanage them to death. On average they feel more confident and have less mistakes in my experience.

A good manager is a leader not a manager.

like

At my last job, I had felt like I had a supervisor that had my back. That transitioned to him becoming a "yes" man for his boss. I was thrown under the proverbial bus for things that weren't my fault. I took the reprimands for it all and retired rather than quit. So unfair, and also still so invisible. It's a horrible quagmire. Makes my tummy upset quite frequently. I didn't do anything wrong, but was treated as if I were the devil incarnate.

like

Someone who gets in the trenches and shows you how vs, behind a desk telling you how!

like

I have found that the managers that encourage growth & learning. Much like Teachers, will garner the most respect. The managers who want to constrain/limit an employee's potential is limiting the success of that manager's team. If you want to be a leader, allow your students/apprentices/employees to excel in what they're good at. Talent shouldn't be a hindrance to a business, but an asset to have and celebrate the knowledge they bring to the table.

like

My favorite boss was actually our Director. He was open to us. He protected us, he worked with our main manager and our direct supervisors and he didn’t hide things from us, we knew in advance when layoffs were coming. We knew why. We knew what the problems were affects projects we felt like people like he treated us people and gave us the tools to warn our people. He fought RTO for teams that it makes sense for and although that battle was lost for some employees and I was one of the people laid off thousands more kept their jobs under his leadership. I still use him as reference and honestly I’m glad I worked with him.

I’m

Accountability, or the lack there of.

Related Posts

Hi Fishers, What can my expected CTC be for a PO role at Servicenow? My current profile is 6 years experience with 19 LPA. I have couple of offers with 23LPA and 25 LPA.

like

What are the best areas to live in w/ easiest commute to south station/seaport area? I’ll be moving alone so looking for a fun area for 25 y/o to meet people and go out. Will also want to have a car (either on street parking or off is fine)

like

Has anyone tried Bohme? Thoughts?

like

Which one is better?
24 LPA - wfh in himachal
38 LPA - work from office in Noida

like

How much time did hsbc will take to release offer letter after 2 rounds of technical discussion?

like

Salary vs rent poll: Salary / Monthly Rent / Living Situation (roommates, apt type, borough?)

like

Just randomly browsing through Expedia. Check out hotel rates in Manhattan

Post Photo
like

Thinking of getting a peloton. Anyone actually experience weight loss and overall health improvement from having one?

I make excuses for not going to the gym and the number 1 being convenience so I figure if it’s in my actual home then I have no excuses!

Be nice, thanks! 😊

like

This is just GOLD.

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

What happens at RIMS? Is it worth going to?

like

Hi folks, can anyone provide lights on what will be yearly hike for java tech lead position in Accenture. And what is average variable pay payout percentage

like

Accenture lateral joiners! What all to expect as part of joining kit? Accenture Accenture India

like

I was informed today that my employment would be terminated at a tier-2 consulting firm in Toronto. The reasons for my dismissal are unclear and I would like to get legal advice on the termination agreement and severance package that was offered. Has anyone experienced a similar situation and can refer a good employment lawyer?

like

Was watching YouTube about MEME COINS. More hype towards SHIB AND SAITAMA INU. Is it really worth investing little on those.. views pls.

like

What is the interview process for Medtronics for QA position .

like

How do you collect and analyze feedback for your product designs?

like
like

For the people who earned the SHRM-CP, did you feel it was worth it? I have an indirect HR position, been applying for more HR focused positions and wondering if this would help. I got the CAPM (certified associate of project management) in December, but that hasn’t really changed things. Would love some opinions before working on another certification!

like

Looking to get my first tatoo! Any suggestions on a talented tattoo artist?

like

Additional Posts in The Worklife Bowl

Updated my wifi SSID

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Is anyone’s company offering to pay portion of your rent as home office expense? Especially if company is no longer paying for commercial office space?

like

This is so dumb, but I hate when superiors say can WE do this...when it’s really can YOU do this

likefunnyhelpful

I have a yahoo email address. Does having one appear to be outdated compared to google?

funnylike

Any good office chair recommendations for ~$100-150?

like

I am just starting my weight loss journey, trying to figure out what my BMI is and what types of food makes me more fat. Any one here can make recommendations? I googled but so much info...

like

What website can you use to play simple games over zoom (Chinese checkers, chess, checkers)?

likehelpful

Looking for ergonomic office chair recommendations, budget is $500. Any suggestions?

like

Anyone else burnt out from work not because of the hours/stress but because of the actual work itself? I’ve reached new peaks of hating my job.

like

How much should a shift lead make west coast

like

Looking for a home office chair…I need something really ergonomic/comfortable but given the visibility of the office in the house the wife wants something stylish. She keeps calling all my ideas ‘gamer chairs’ even though they’re definitely not. Anyone have any chairs they really like that may be worth looking at? I feel like I’ve looked everywhere (Steelcase, Herman Miller, humanscale, Haworth, xchair, etc).

like

Sometimes I love my job, other days I really feel like an employee.

What does your boss do to remind you you’re an employee?

like

My food life these days...

Post Photo
likefunny

Happy Florida Halloween y’all. This only took 4 days, and yes, we did the hairspray trick.

Post Photo
likefunny

Do you put pop tarts in the toaster or the microwave?

like

Proost guys! I am almost running out of all my whiskey and beer ha. Let’s see what you guys are drinking tonight?

Post Photo
likehelpful

I am meeting my girlfriend’s parents for the first time this weekend for dinner at a pretty nice restaurant. Her parents are fairly traditional Chinese mom and dad and I am not Chinese, or Asian for that matter… I don’t want to show up empty-handed - any ideas on good gifts for first time meeting Chinese parents?

likesmart
funny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal