A T1-consulting firm I am interviewing for is asking to share counter offer evidences during the title/salary negotiation stage.

In all integrity I have some pretty good offers but how can I share those? Does this tell a lot about whats to come?

Is this fair practice in globally? How should I respond to this?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’d consider walking away. If you have other good offers then the market has spoken.

So either this firm wants you or they don’t. This is a negotiation. They don’t get to see your cards

like

Have you countered at more than one place? Or just 1 and that’s the place asking?

Seems odd and it’s pretty easy to doctor up a document so not sure why anyone would want that. I have to assume there’s no way they can validate any of the information.

Yeah it screams something not good… toxic or whatever that is

Wow, I thought only Indian HR's had the audacity to ask such.

Anyway, you MUST tell them that you will be sharing the offer withholding some key details by hiding certain facts.

So ofcourse you must show your name and Salary, and the name of the title.

But you must leave out other details like terms of contract.

Disagree. Don’t share anything

I'd redact all the details except the offer numbers, then edit the offer number to add 20%, then send it.

You have no clue how the world works, and it's going to break you eventually

Agree I would share the numbers but not the names of the companies. Either screams toxic work culture or you have a really dumb recruiter that you’re negotiating with

Related Posts

Has anyone considered moving from NYC to Houston? Any advice of why not to do it apart from the Texas heat. The homes are so much bigger and taxes much lower.

like

I am appearing for an interview next week for .Net profile. What should I expect in the interview Resume based questions or DS and Algo related questions?

Shot in the dark since it’s an expensive, niche, and quartz watch… but does anyone have a Breitling Emergency? I wouldn’t say I *need* the emergency beacon aspects of it since a pay for a satellite communicator, but as an outdoorsy guy I’m intrigued. $15K+ seems like a lot for a quartz watch even with the plb functionality but bonuses don’t spend themselves

like

How do your firms do payroll? This is like the 5th time in 26 months that paychecks weren’t timely deposited. Allegedly, the boss did everything right and this is something in the payroll company. But his stuff is getting crazy and everyone is out on PTO, I’m kinda like: meet minimum ethical obligations and no more. Once or twice, I understand. But this is becoming regular.

like

What are the new technologies that apply to health plans products?

like

It all starts with: "Hey, wanna grab coffee tomorrow?"

Post Photo
like

Hi everyone - I made it to the final round of interviews with Amazon for a Program Manager position. They initially asked if I would relocate and at the time I said yes - however, due to my husband’s new job I’m no longer able to relocate.
Has anyone ever negotiated to work remote for Amazon?

like

SIL and BIL told us excitedly last weekend that she was pregnant (had literally just found out, so barely four weeks). This week she tells us she’s not pregnant anymore :(. They did not seem super torn up about it and were very practical about it. We said how sorry we were, etc etc. should I do anything else? Should I not mention it again unless they do?

like

Has anyone dealt with coming to terms with an emotionally abusive relationship? I struggle to admit this (because more drastic examples come to mind), but my therapist mentioned that things like yelling/throwing things/blocking me from leaving the room are also abusive traits my ex demonstrated. It makes me feel alienated from myself — like “how could I have allowed myself to be treated like that?”. Also feeling ashamed to tell anyone

like
like

Who was around in 2008/2009 at big 4? Specifically in advisory? How were those practices affected during the layoffs? Any insight to ease some of the worry/unknown would be greatly appreciated.

likehelpful

Hi, is anyone at Deloitte willing to refer me to their SOX accounting & advisory roles they have open? TIA!

like

Anyone here works in PwC PCS in New York? How’s the culture/hours?

like
like

I’m completely new to Google cloud but I’m from CS background. I know programming, SQL, networking concepts, operating systems concepts etc. How long will it take me to prepare and pass GCP solutions architect certification? What’s your recommendation for preparing?

like

Has anyone exited or considered exiting to being a realtor? There’s decent income potential there, good WLB, and seems like consulting skill sets would absolutely crush the average entrant.

likefunny

Hello,

After onboarding in Deloitte USI Hyderabad do we need to report immediately from next day to office as per hybrid model or we can continue wfh until assigned to project

like

Mink farms still exist? I thought everyone was cool with fake fur.

like

Additional Posts in Healthcare Consultants

Does anyone work / know someone working at the startup Truveta?

like

Anyone willing to refer to a role at Flatiron Health?

like

I need of UPenn health undergrad cap, gown, and stoll!! Must live in Philadelphia area

I’m surprising my girlfriend with a graduation photo shoot. She never got her cap and gown bc she didn’t do in-person this spring.

I will pay for rental and to have it dry cleaned after use.

Bookstore does not have any.

like

Does KPMG’s federal healthcare advisory practice get Veterans Day off?

Has anyone heard of Sandbox industries and can share any insights?

like

What are the new technologies that apply to health plans products?

like

Is there a firm that does a lot of consulting work for hospitals in Texas Medical Center (MD Anderson, Texas Children's etc.)?

like

Is olive the next theranos or what?

likefunny

How many pages is your resume/CV?

like

Any McKinsey consultants in the Provider Improvement domain here? How’s WLB? Still remote? How many hours per week are you working?

like

Centene Corporation how much does a VP at centene make? Focused on innovation, ops etc

like

Anyone heard of Stax, Inc.? Any insight to culture, wlb, pay etc?

like

Looking to get some more certifications under my belt so I can grow my career. What certifications are recommended for becoming a more knowledgeable healthcare consultant, and what certifying body/program would you suggest I do it with? Looking for any/all options that are most desired in today’s market

like

What is annual salary increase for SA at Alvarez and Marsal? I applied for director role but offered SA since I have extensive industry experience but no prior consulting. I was offered additional compensation paid out over first year but concerned the annual increase will be less than the first year additional pay. If 15% increase reasonable for SA or only with promotion?

like

Any pharmacists on here? I am trying to read a label and the notation doesn’t make sense.

Oral Solution 100mg/M

What unit is M? Is that pharmacist for milliliters (ml)?

like

Which of the Big 4 is best for a new MPH grad looking for their first time role healthcare related, esp project management focused? (Assume east coast)

like

I am doing my MBA on side. I am looking for ideas on what workshops or session series I can conduct that relates to exciting non work topics or work related (this would be boring though). If you have any other ideas throw it my way.

like

Oliver Wyman how is recruiting there right now..?

like

Anyone in A&M’s Healthcare Industry Group willing to chat? I have a few questions around work, culture, and compensation.

likehelpful

Am I wrong that physicians are the millennial snowflakes of the healthcare industry?

likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal