Art Directors, please help me understand: why do you feel that it's easier to cut and paste copy from a marked up pdf than lifting the changes from a google doc with updates highlighted?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Every art director I’ve ever worked with has been totally fine with highlighted Google Doc updates. I think this is maybe an issue for your AD, not ADs in general. Ask them.

like

Google doc = God.

like

Depends on how big the project is. If I’m working on a large multi-page brochure don’t make me search my document for where some google doc small edit is.

like

I (art) would much rather work from a google doc.

like

i don’t prefer that. I’d rather use google docs

like

It makes double work for the writer. We have to update the manuscript in the google doc, highlight the changes so we remember what to check in the next round, then add those corrections using post-its on a pdf. Genuinely asking, why does it "take forever to cut copy edits from a Google doc."

Though I prefer to copy/paste from a Doc... A lot of times the copywriter takes too long to update the doc so it's faster to make the changes directly from the marked up PDF with the change request.

You probably are running that by your partner first to make sure they’re good with the changes, I think. But if you’re not then you should talk with them first because they may not agree with/want to implement all the changes.

likesmart

Thanks guys. I have had four ADs flip out about it. They wait til the fifth round to say they'd "prefer" a marked up PDF.

Okay, point taken. You work with weird art directors. Sorry. Maybe you can glean some more info if you ask them why they prefer it.

Related Posts

I’ve given up trying to better my life.

like

Hello fishes.. I have an offer from Nokia but got some more offer higher than Nokia .. can we negotiate and ask to match offer at Nokia ?

On a project with higher level teams, and my partner and I can’t seem to crack the brief or keep up. Can anyone else relate? Will it always feel this way?

like

To those who have delivered. Are they still doing photography at the hospital after you deliver?

like

I started as an IFS manager less than a year ago. What should I expect for a raise and bonus this year assuming I come out in the middle in terms of performance?

like
like

I was approached by recruiter for Senior Manager level IT position at PWC . Can someone give me insights What is "IFS - Internal Firm Services - Other" at PWC ?

Also , how the work life balance is for IFS ? I am fully remote currently and having good work life balance. I worry about working at Consulting firm with offshore/onshore model & you have to put more than 10/12 hrs a day. I will really appreciate all the details you can give including salary range/benefits / hikes etc

like

Amazon:

Cons:
Software engineers can easily work 50-70h/week.
They are constantly trying to get the most out of you.

Pros:
You might be able to transfer teams and life will be good again? :D

I think I’d love a job working at Stetson in student affairs but even the JD required positions pay $50k or less. 🤯😥

like

i had applied for SQL DBA role in HSBC and other companies

i m being interviewed by hsbc people in wipro 2nd round interview but how come haven't got any call from HSBC
Anyone from DB background can help me with this

like

I am experienced tech with 1 year under my belt. What do you all get paid per hour?

like

Nothing quite like ripping your suit pants wide open on a door handle mid-sentence with your client sponsor.

like

I bring to the table over 20 plus years of extensive experience in steering Customer Relationship Management and Operations, Process Initiatives, Business Process Transformation & Controls, Process Improvements, Business Continuity Planning & Strategic Business Operations. I have innate sense of task prioritization, managerial aptitude and result oriented attitude towards accelerating organizational growth and that too in a high pressured, time bound and competitive environment.
Pls guide

Hey Everyone,

Could someone please help me with in-hand salary?

Thanks in advance.

Post Photo
like

Sup single consultants!

Has anyone shifted to Dubai without a job offer? As a freelancer?

like

What are the best strategies for hosting your first Professional Development Workshop?

like

As a data analyst with 5+ years of analytics experience what should the base pay be in Chicago and what is it in DC metro area?

like

Additional Posts in Creatives

Which do you use/prefer for being assigned a project:
tangible job folders/job jackets
or
digital tracking software

3+ years into building a brand at an intense startup. Saw lots of growth years 1 and 2, but now that weve scaled considerably, the leadership in place now is supressive and dismissive to career goals.

The follow up to the P&G “The Talk”, “The Look”, is Terri-fucking-ble!!! Whoever made it should be ashamed of themselves. They should have stayed with BBDO who made “The Talk.” Anyone as irate as me?

like

How did your career change after your first big project?

Any insider info on how it’s like to work on the Master Card account at McCann NY? They did a couple interesting activation ideas in the last few years. But not sure if that’s just luck or the account is actually looking to do good work.

like

Got an offer from an agency who needs my help. It’s a great salary upgrade with an opportunity to grow, but the agency and client in question don’t have great reputations creatively. Do I join and try to change it? Or stay where I’m at (a creatively reputable shop) and keep building my portfolio for a year or two. The money is legitimately tempting, but I’m worried about my portfolio output at the end of the day.

likehelpful

Always worked in-house. 4 yrs experience digital/retail/ecomm. Working on spec portfolio. Is It worth exploring agency opportunities? What are some solid in-house gigs in NYC?

I think my creative director is disappointed with the quality of my recent work. I am, too. I’m giving 110%, but my work isn’t great, or even good.

I’m on different types of assignments than my prior experience prepared me for. In the longterm arc of my career, I know I’ll learn and grow just like I have with everything else I’ve worked on. But in the short term, what do I do, and what do I say?

likehelpful

What are some of y’all’s favorite online ads? And why? Is it your ad or another companys ad? Post a link or screenshot, show and tell:)

like

Why is ok for a creative to feed off of data and strategy, but not for a planner to think/project creatively?

like

Making hard push to go in-house with a startup, billable work has dried up.

Question: what’s a good salary for VP Mkt & Sales? And commission?

like

what’s the general rule of thumb for being able to put something in your portfolio?

like

Does anyone know who does @theNorthFace_City on Instagram?

How is it working in house at Nike?

like

A random question for anyone that went through Miami Ad School. So we list those “agency labs” as internships on our resumes and experience but don’t put them under background check since they were never paid. I’ve never had a problem with them but wondering if anyone else has?

like

Any full time freelance Art Directors out there? How did you start? I’m thinking of transitioning from corporate retail to being my own boss. All constructive advice appreciated!

like

So. Is in-house worth the £10K less salary?

Post Photo
like

How early is too early to ask about salary when interviewing? First meeting w HR? With the CDs/ECDs? Or do you have to wait all the way till the end? Just went through a long interview process only to find out they never had enough to hire me without me taking a pay cut 😭

like

Personal projects: I'm a great enthusiast. Sometimes the agency work is not enough, among other reasons... Do you guys also dive in creative personal endeavours and showcase them on your book? Cont.

like

Reason number 12,534 why you should hire a professional...🤦‍♂️

Post Photo
likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal