Do you think all English & language arts teachers should have to be bilingual? Why? Heard this argument for the first time today.

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If all biology teachers should be licensed medical doctors

funnylikesmart

I mean I think in a perfect world sure, all teachers I mean in a perfect world sure, all teachers would be bilingual or know multiple languages. That being said, I don't think making it a requirement is smart unless the education department is ready to pay teachers to learn 2nd and 3rd languages. Especially during a teacher shortage

likehelpful

Q- What do you call a person that speaks two languages?
A- Bilingual.

Q- What do you call a person that speaks three languages?
A- Trilingual.

Q- What do you call a person that speaks only one language?
A- An American.

I don’t know the answer to your question, but I definitely think we can all do better.

likefunny

🤔 Can’t get enough teachers, let’s make it harder! That will work! 🤦🏻‍♀️

And EL and ELA are neither the same thing nor the same major. Maybe if the proposal was that all EL teachers know a second language, that might help… but EL teachers can have 12 languages in a class of 15, I don’t know that a second language would make that much of a difference. 🤷🏻‍♀️

smartlike

No

like

The state of Texas required every ELA teacher to get ESL/ELL certified, so that we would have strategies when kids are scheduled into our classes. We do the best we can.

Meanwhile our busy ESL/ELL teacher has multiple languages represented in her classes: Spanish, Korean, Mandarin, Vietnamese, Russian, Farsi, Urdu, Turkish, Hindi, Arabic, and Hebrew. It is the United Nations! There’s no way that we will ever find bilingual teachers for that many different languages. Our kids seem to learn BICS quickly, even if they only speak their native language at home. They need supports with CALP because many take AP classes and the vocabulary is very advanced. As long as they come to school, they do well even without having bilingual ESL and ELA teachers. If there is a problem, it’s generally because they were not literate in their home language or they have attendance or possible learning disabilities.

likesmart

ESL teachers? Yes. ELA teachers? No! Of course, if my salary is doubled, it’d be worth my while because this sounds like a ploy by school systems to reduce staffing and increase teacher responsibilities. 🤫

likesmart

No, since it's not attainable. In what language? I'm gonna guess there are places where Spanish isn't the main language. Being bilingual also doesn't mean the teacher will know best practices about teacher ELLs. That's what is important. And btw, I'm Spanish bilingual.

smart

What was the premise and why English specifically?

That’s what ESL programs are for. Perhaps the person who suggested that just means that ELL students need more support in Language Arts classes.

I’m a Bilingual English Teacher. Actually English English from Manchester in the UK. Spanish is my second language with a C2 level. Helps a great deal explaining the Grammar side of English. Being able to understand how Spanish is constructed gives me, at least, that advantage. Actually, giving teacher training in the Canary Islands and having a whale of a time. (Pasándomelo en Grande!!! )

It would be helpful as far as teaching students grammar. Most of us can't teach grammar very effectively because we don't learn it. Not like you learn grammar when it's your second language. We learn the grammar "rules" through immersion. But then we are kind of half-assing it a lot of the time. When you learn a different language, you learn the grammar as you are learning the vocabulary and you learn it very methodically.
Otherwise- I would say no. The only people that really even need grammar that much are editors. And as far as I'm concerned- they can learn it in college.

Related Posts

obligatory post: how will COVID impact human capital? The types of work we do, factors in making a healthy organization, etc.

like

Any recommendations on law primers that have been updated rather recently?

like

Anyone been to bluebird cafe in Nashville? Worth the hype? I’ve done the honky tonks on a prior trip and looking for something new to check out

likehelpful

Have you, or anyone you know, gotten covid twice within weeks or months? I’m being told that you can catch omicron 2 weeks after recovering…

like

Best Chinese food in the Valley? My favorite place closed down during the pandemic. 😕

likehelpful

Anybody know what's up with QS?
Good to buy the dip? They down 40%

like

Do you feel explicitly femme / butch / futch / stud ? I feel like I’m not femme or butch and I’d be more butch personality wise in a relationship but definitely more of a futch / soft butch physically? Getting a better handle on this might make me better able to find the right folks for me, dating wise... I know some people are super strict about their “type”

like

Why is this bowl so dead?

Sink or swim. I applied for a position as a “STEM Coach” that I don’t qualify for via university degree, but do qualify for on experience and self initiative. Got nothing to lose:).

like

Hi All
I have joined Cts on 10 oct.
I have 2 year of experience as a Java developer.
If anyone have any suitable project opening, please dm

like

Hi guys, a plea for help here 🙏🏻 have any founders here gotten an O-1 visa or an H1B transfer into their startup? Would greatly appreciate hearing your advice / experience over DM

like
like

Is anyone working or worked with Wissen Infotech before? I wanna know the work culture and work life balance over there. How is work life balance over there?
Is it a good option to join if I get an offer from it?

like

What’s your wiki of choice? Are orgs still sticking to the Sharepoint/Office365 and Confluence or trying out Notion/Coda/Quip?

like

Going to Denver mid December, would like to drive up to the Rocky’s. What trail would you recommend for a day trip and wouldn’t be too difficult with weather conditions at that time? Is it possible?

Everything's a toy when you're a kitten!

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Does anyone know the work hours for a virtual financial advisor - national branch, for the Tempe location?

like

Found thread to gain status through match stream for all rental companies and 5 hotel chains

like

Anyone know why our miles didn’t carry over to the next year? Had 20k miles over Delta Platinum

Hi Everyone, I am trying to apply for a Technical Support role at Dropbox I’m entering all the required fields but there seems to be an issue, when I hit submit after filling the form, it doesn’t submit and throws error ‘Looks like you left this blank! Please fill out this required field’ when all the fields are entered already (I have checked so many times, and filled the form from scratch several times too). Anyone from Dropbox who can put me in touch with HR or suggest what I should do next?

Additional Posts in English & Language Arts Teachers

Hi All! I am teaching English 4 for the first time this fall, and I’m just wondering what ideas y’all have for starting off. My class will be TINY (less than 5) so I want it to be super-engaging. All Black and Brown students. Help!

like

I recently moved to a different district and am starting to plan ahead for next year. What novels and plays do you think are worthwhile and essential for 10th, 11th and Pre-AP? I have many in mind that I have used before but am really looking for some fresh ideas!

like

I’m a 7th grade ELA teacher in Texas!

like

I'm a first time Junior English teacher. What are some tips for differentiating an honors class from a regular class?

like

Is there any writing prompts that stand out to you in the responses you get from students? Preferably ones that are outside the box, but I'd love to hear some tried and true traditional ones too!

like

What are pet peeves you have as a teacher you have let go of? For me it is subject verb agreement.

like

What are some projects you’ve had students do to show the influence of classical works in a genre?

What is THE BEST professional development you've ever been to? (Conference? District workshop? Etc.)

like

How long have you been teaching? Also, what does self care look like for you?

Those of you who do First Chapter Fridays or similar read-alouds, do you edit out curse words when you’re reading?

What's a piece of advice you love to give to your senior students who feel very uncertain about the future?

like

When beginning a piece of literature, I first help the kids access the relevant culture. I have used web quests, but I have found that the kids researching their choice of topics and creating Slides containing information and pics results in more students participating. Recently they researched heraldry for the Medieval Era and reproduced either a family crest that they found or created their own personal crest. Anyone have other activities they use?

like

What are some fun ideas for projects about describing setting? I was going to have them create travel brochures about the setting of a story of their choice but I think this might be overdone.

like

When you teach a novel in class, do you assign pages for students to read at home? They never do it! How can we finish anything?

like

What are some reading centers you do with your 5th - 6th graders while you pull a small group?

like

How do you engage your students in more reading outside of what is required in the classroom? With each passing year I am finding an ever shrinking population of students, including honors students, who actually read beyond what is posted in social media or video games. Students willingly volunteer that they do not read and most parents see it as a non-issue. I tell my students that the best readers are usually the best writers. What are some strategies that you use beyond reading logs ?

like

I’m a 6th grade ELA teacher. I am struggling with teaching writing. Any advice to give?

like

How many of you have a set curriculum and how many of you get to choose the literature/create your own content? Which do you prefer?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal