Engagement Manager here. Is being an EM from McKinsey something to be proud of? Or is this a job like any other?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I think it is a valid question. I believe yes and yes. You should be proud, lots of people want the role you have. The firm believes in you enough to trust you to run day to day operations on very costly client work. However, it’s still a job and when you leave someone will replace you. So it’s yes to both.

likefunny

mck 2 your responses in this thread are wonderful. keep on doing you.

I hate consulting slang, I think mck slang can sometimes come across as even more annoying than normal, and honestly I might hate consulting in general. but everything mck 2 said here is totally spot on and reasonable... C4, sorry, but you are 100% in the wrong

like

I'd be proud to work for McK. I'm a higher level but can't beat the prestige of that firm. I applied in B school but got rejected from final round. All my clients hate you guys but they keep hiring you - your partners have great C level connections who pressure them into it (my clients are director/VP level). We act like we hate you but honestly if I could get a job in that firm I'd be there

likefunnyuplifting

....as you're chained to a wall with a ball gag getting whipped every time you try to talk.

like
Recent IconRecent

🤦🏻‍♀️

likefunny

You are pond scum.

likefunny

I once swept floor at McKinsey and my current LinkedIn title says “Ex-McKinsey”.

likefunny

my current ex is ex-McK so I am Ex-McK-ex

likesmart

That’s not a real question or you’re not actually an EM, right? No EM I’ve ever worked with or met would ask a question like that.

likefunny

Good for you, and I empathize with the existential questioning. Like so many others have said, it’s both. And you probably won’t feel “both” most days, just one way or the other—especially if you keep your critical distance and away from the kool aid. You seem neat :)

like

MBB brand value sinking with the economy.

likefunny

His daughter works for BCG so it would have been a conflict of interest if he said us

like

OP, if you’re working 90 hours, I’d revise the question. Is working 90 h/week at McKinsey instead of [insert hobby, family, health, social life, or whatever is being sacrificed] something to be proud of?

Only you can answer that for your self, your values, your goals.

For me, 90h isn’t worth it because it took too much from other things I value.
I started putting limits on work and changed who I worked with.

like

My 2c. You should be proud of whatever post you are in... if a person doesn’t take pride in their work, what’s the point of that job/post...

like

Whats ur salary and age we can base how proud you are on that since you need approval🙄

likefunny

Dont forget your net worth

It’s important to look at the value of your work. I think that being an EM at Mck is a huge accomplishment, but pride sours that accomplishment when it makes you conceited and boastful. So I applaud your achievement, and I hope you stay humble and grateful for the blessings in your life

like

Thanks

likesmart

We have over 2000 EMs so it’s not such a big deal. Keep giving those 90 hours

likefunny

PL at BCG here. I ask myself the same question. Think doing introspection along your career is key to success. Some days I feel proud, other days I wish I had a different job..
I try hard to ignore what people around me think and focus on what brings me joy, passion and energy. The people I work with are a big part of that. I have also identified a few areas I want to focus on and try to build these skills with a longer term perspective irrespective of whether I will be at BCG or not (vs short term just getting next promo) So I would return the question: do you feel proud or are there jobs out there within your reach that would satisfy you more? Would also recommend doing 1-2 headhunter interviews in your field each year to know what is out there...

like

When your dead you tombstone won’t mention your job

like

Yes and yes

likefunny

Interesting reads. EM here too. Not proud, it’s just a job and we make good money.

like

the critical responses here are completely missing the point. OP asked a legitimate introspective question. none of us are wanting for opportunities on FB to be critical of consulting mindset... I know because I do it plenty. this isn't one of them. move on

like

Manager at Kearney here. I’m sure you’ve worked hard to be here. You’ve proven that the firm can count on you. There are thousands who would gladly take your job, but the firm picked you. That’s absolutely something to be proud of as an accomplishment. Just don’t let that in and of itself define you.

like

I understand it’s the bare minimum to achieve before exiting. What’s the pay like btw?

like

Glassdoor is very accurate

like

Also EM generalist or like QuantumBlack

like

Generalist. Not smart enough for QB

likefunny

It's not a big deal

like

Related Posts

Hi Sharks,

Please let me incase of any opportunities for 15 yrs exp in the role of technical Project Manager or business analyst

like
like

Let us remember our noble forefathers, the righteous defenders of the free market: Senator Sarbanes and Representative Oxley

Post Photo
likefunny

Corp tax people, do you like what you do?

I am S3 and have been put on promotion readiness. But I really don’t want to pursue partnership tax compliance anymore and really have no passion on what I’m doing now, which is processing huge amount of data and cranking out k1/k3s. I got burned out in every busy season and not sure if I’m ready for the upcoming one. So I’m thinking if it is worth to pivot to corp tax since it’s closer to accounting and tax.

like

What is a good multi tool- I currently own wingman

like

Anyone deal with panic attacks related to anxiety? I started getting them after my divorce some years ago and then went straight to grad school. Since then, I started to work in big4, done a ton of therapy, but can’t shake the anxiety. It usually comes from “doing too much“ but this career is defaulted to doing too much. Anyone go through something similar? For the record, I workout regularly, eat well, don’t drink, and meditate sometimes. I’m worried the stress will prevent me from advancing…

like

Hey! This is a difficult question but here it goes...

I started freelancing in digital marketing in 2018 and I created an agency, it's not legally registered but I have been using the name and putting myself out there as an agency.

In 2021 I started working at another agency and they made signed a non compete agreement. I left that job a few months ago and I'm back to freelancing but I'm worried about the agreement potentially being a pain in the # now or in the near future. Any advice?

like

How do you do the bare minimum but still have people think you’re a good associate / hard working?

likefunny

Out of sheer curiosity - how much credit card debt is too much credit card debt? I have none (pay off regularly) just wondering what other people consider “a lot of credit card debt”.

like

Patient scheduler specialist: anyone out there been a scheduler for 3 years and feel they are underpaid? Drop

like

Just finished this bench with my girlfriend. Started with an idea and managed to come through! Really pleased with the result. Still need to add some artwork/ plants for above. Any suggestions?

Post Photo
like

Has anyone tried Noom, the health and fitness program? What’s your take on it?

like
like

Is Tiger Analytics laying off their new joiners, one of my friends who is a new joiner has been said that they need to pause his activity. Many campus joineers received this mail

like

Hey Fishes

I am confused as which career should I choose. Data Engineering or Software Engineering.

I've 4+ years of experience in Backend Development using Python/Django, SQL.

Please help should I move into Data Engineering or into Full Stack Software Engineering?

like

Anyone have tips on writing a cover letter without referring to anything in the resume?

like

EYP como is "confidential" we won't tell anyone above MBA pay lol

helpfulfunny

Thinking of getting a place in Houston around the summer and think Houston Heights is my spot + looking to rent out a couple rooms, would that be easy in that neighborhood?

like

It's difficult to come up with a compelling ad campaign for some of these products; why would someone "need" a specific set of kitchen knives or the like

like

How can I get God’s cell phone number?

Post Photo
funnylike

Additional Posts in Consulting

What's with this thinkcell bullshit

like

I don't understand how the women next to me can elbow me so many times in a 1.5 hour flight....I'm not even using the armrest between us. Personal space??!

like

Junior on my project is struggling with attention to detail. Have given feedback several times on this along with suggestions on how to improve, but no difference yet.

Managers: have you ever seen someone actually improve on this skill? And if so, what did you do that helped?

like

Rant here. Why is it necessary for people to this talk on speakerphone in public? On a plane and entire section of plane can hear her call.

likehelpful

The amount of snow in front of my apartment is correlated to the amount of work I need to get done. Do I want to do it? That has yet to be determined.

like

In the ORD B6 United Club - a dude filled an empty water bottle from the community dispenser - touching the tap. When done, he filled his personal sanitizer bottle from the community dispenser. Irony?

like

Hello there!
So recently I have kind of realised I’m very very burnt out. Is something I should maybe discuss with my CC to try and find some projects that help me bounce back? Or just zip it and keep seeing my therapist privately.
Thanks

like

Thoughts on getting credit for success stemming from my work?

Former peer, now boss in a new role, leans heavily on me for strategy, comms, planning & analysis - admits to me they can’t do what I do.

like

Anyone else feel queasy about their Chair/CEO taking a ‘firm’ stand on democracy and decency while shoveling PAC money to the sedition caucus?

like

What is a great way to make mentors during r WFH period? I’m a new college hire and would like to network and form mentorships in the age of zoom/webex

like

Bed bugs at the W Hotel. How many points?

like

What are some tips you have to be more efficient at work and/or life outside of work ?

like

Toronto Westin anyone?

There is genuinely nothing more annoying than when you’re on a call with someone and they’re very clearly not engaged in the convo (emailing, texting, pinging). Ask to reschedule if you can’t give someone 15 minutes of your time.

like

Was anyone here fully against getting the vaccine initially, but then ended up getting it?If so, what made you change your mind?

like

Hot take: Why don’t owners of doodles get poodles? What is so great about goldendoodles, labradoodles, and all these other designer dogs? Most of them have weirdly shaped faces and look bad.
My Australian Shepherd is great, why should I mix it with a poodle?

likefunny

Anyone in Vegas attending Success Connect?

like

How do you resign without burning bridges?

like

Recommendation: Any good tools to improve grammar and sentence structuring in written communication?

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal