Honestly, I quite liked the John Lewis ad.
Not one of their best. The acting could’ve been better. But I liked the soul in it. And in a world where AI is coming for everything, it was nice to see nice, simple storytelling around a soulful moment between a dad and a son.

If you didn’t like it, I’d love to hear your thoughts.

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I liked it! Glad you started this thread to discuss.

I probably liked it more because I’m a Dad now, with a 5 year old boy. And I wonder about the age and lifestyle of those who said they didn’t like.

At first I thought it was about to be total cheese, with the dad starting to dance. Then when it took him to the old school dance floor, I was like, okay, it looks like it’s going somewhere interesting, vs just some stupid Hallmark cheese where the whole family ends up dancing dancing in the living room. I liked that we were transported to Dad’s nostalgia. When the son showed up, I was like ahh, that’s how I feel: Sometimes you don’t feel a day older than when you were in your 20’s… but you also know you’ve got this grown up life. And just when I was about to think, I wish I could go back in time—they cut to the toddler walking across the dance floor. That was a strong edit, and a strong choice. That’s when you go, yeah, despite all the hardships of living this grown up life—the love you feel for your son/family, and the world you’ve created to enjoy that, it’s very powerful.

So I enjoyed it a lot. I felt it covered the soul of how I feel now in my 40’s with a grown up life and kid.

The BTS music selection is great too: https://youtu.be/9hD9bt7b2Co?si=hZDxikiGdQjhkNqs

like

For me the execution (writing, direction, edit et al) let down what could’ve been a great ad.

Primarily, it confuses itself with what point it’s making. Is it about a dad returning to who he is (presumably lost to age/family life - doesn’t develop this)? Is it about a dad/son who are misaligned somehow (again, we have to presume this as there’s minimal plot)? Or is it about a teen son who can’t express how he feels (another presumption as all we get is a bit of awkwardness to go on)?

The challenge then becomes it doesn’t earn the sentimentality it wants/needs due to a lack of tension/arc. I.e That gift (and the endline) was about showing you really “get them”. We, the viewers, didn’t see there was an issue with the Dad’s (past/lost/true) identity or how his son viewed him.

Of course we can approximate and piece together what they’re trying to get at, but that then interferes with how you feel watching it.

like

I personally felt like the music to a bit of heavy lifting, to speak to answering some of the points you bring up. And because the song was less famous in the States vs the UK, perhaps that’s where the disconnect is was.

To me, there was a lot of subtlety, and it lets you fill in the blanks while giving you enough in the broad strokes. I hear your points, but I don’t know that the spot was less powerful just because it didn’t provide every single detail on a silver platter and tell us exactly how to think.

like

It wears the strategy clumsily. It’s a choppy cut. Too much back and forth and lacked tonal warmth. Pass.

John Lewis ads used to be synonymous with craft. Outsourcing to AI takes that away. The quality is degraded and thus so is the brand. It would be better for them to release no ad at all.

Ai? What part of the ad was AI?

Related Posts

Question about remote job negotiations

I'm currently interviewing for a remote role for a company based in NY.

The thing is I'm based in a different city (southern U.S.)

My question is:

When it comes time to talk compensation, should I base the market rate for the role on my city of residence or NY?

Would it make sense to ask them directly how they determine comp for NY-bases vs. other city-based employees?

Anyone have experience with this?

like
like

Accenture offering crazy hikes what can be the reason?

like

Something to brighten up your night 🤗

Post Photo
upliftinglike

How many days is it taking to get the physical H-1B approval notice from USCIS, after the case is approved online?

More interested to hear from applicants whose petitions are processed at Texas service center.

like

Could someone please explain the creative hierarchy in pharma? In general market the roles are normally: JR CW, CW, SR CW, ACD, CD, GCD, ECD. How are creative supervisor roles the same/different? Thx!

like

I made a couple errors at a new job. An important document to be distributed had wrong information on it, which was proofread by 2 other people. Then a couple of typos in emails, the person micromanaging me told me to send out but I didn’t fix the errors. Failed to meet a deadline but completed 95%. I was written up over all this last week, fired this week. There’s a lot more to this but I think it’s because the DM doesn’t like me.

like

Can you cut 18mg Delmosart (i.e. Concerta) to get 2x 9mg?

like

To all fellow IQVIANS, how is it going?

like

Anyone done a bourbon tour in kentucky? Looking for pointers. Do we make our own itinerary. Is there a package tour or group thing i can join.

New to the bowl and actively looking to leave the Deloitte!

funnylike

what is the years of exp for consultant rank in Accenture? how's the internal mobility like?

like

Does anyone practice White Collar criminal defense in NYC or know a decent amount about it? Is it fun or fulfilling? Is it a good way to break into government work in the future?

like

How do you handle working with teachers that give very little back to the profession, don’t appear to like children and any interactions are negative or gossipy? And they are in your grade level

Should we introduce ourselves?

Off topic.
Women - what outfits can be considered as business casuals?

like

I can refer you in Natwest . DM if you like .

Hello everyone. My joining date is 20/10/22 in natwest.But still i did’nt get any mail regarding my joining formalities.can anyone explain me that how many days it will take to complete my pes verification.

like

If you’re succeeding on all the right metrics (i.e., leadership loves you, clients love you, you’re participating on pitches, you’ve brought in clients, and you’re set up to inherit a book of business), but you’re still not super into it, being promoted to income partner won’t change things, right? Worth sticking out to see or jumping to go in house at a pre-IPO, late stage startup you find super exciting and interesting?

like

First year trainee here. Having the standard wobbles but generally surviving.

My question is - how can I tell if I'm doing well? More specifically, what common and avoidable mistakes (specific or general) do trainees make, and what attitude or actions impress you?

Recently overheard some associates complaining about another trainee and now I have the fear... I want to get this right. Thanks in advance.

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

There’s a potential partner you’ve heard is very talented - but notably mean under stress. Worth it?

like

So, I work in an agency, but recently someone reached out to me for freelance writing work. I guess it'll be long form ad copy, as they're asking me for a rate per word...
I have no idea what's standard here

likehelpful

Best work of 2019 so far?

like

Interviewing client side for the first time, what are some good questions to ask that one might not think about at an agency?

like

It’s hard to be motivated when rounds of layoffs happen and you see all your friends leave. But one thing that’s gotten me through all of this is working out. And when I say workout I mean the most pathetic, sad, barely completed beginner-level cardio dance routines. I’ve somehow forced myself to move while on lockdown and it’s somehow forced me to feel better. Whatever you’re doing, wherever you are: get up and move even if you don’t finish or end up going on a walk. Pls take care of yourself❤️

like

Have you ever got caught freelancing for another agency while you’re full time at different one?

like

Full time creatives who freelance: how do you get these freelance opportunities?

Currently working full time and have no intention of going fully freelance any time soon, but would love to know the best places/sites to look for these freelance opportunities that allow you to do your full-time responsibilities on top of some freelance work.

likehelpful

What’s the most time you guys have taken in between jobs? Is 1 week enough? What’s the perfect amount of time? I have the possibility to take 3 weeks… is that too much?

like

Is New York even worth it for advertising? I just looked for apartments and almost spit out my water on the prices for such bad quality.

likefunny

Going in house is the move, right?

like

With the way this week has been going, Friday 13th with a harvest moon seems downright dangerous 🌚 halp

likefunny

Remember The Woo? Yeah, me neither. Well, they cut everyone’s pay (except mgmt of course) by 1/4 to get the small biz gov loan, and used it to hire a $500k/yr mgmt head. Agency still working barebones

like

Media folks - how long does it take for you to turnaround a campaign results report?

like

Just had a great networking call with someone at a company I’d like to work for… should I follow up asking to be connected to another person on the team? I hear it is a good networking strategy.

How would you ask someone you just spoke with to be introduced to someone else?

Also, any general tips for maintaining a good relationship with someone you just networked with?

like

Hey Fishes. An early career question, Kindly take two minutes in your busy schedule to help me here? TIA!

I have been freelancing (right after graduation) for over 2 years now as a paid media strategist/ a performance marketer. In the upcoming months I wish to join an agency to get corporate exposure.

How do you determine an agency that's right fit for you. I was thinking about giving a shot at GroupM. What are your views about the agency?

Any better agencies that also accept remote roles?

like

Banksy on Advertising: Thoughts?

Post Photo
like

Wavemaker Any insights on wavemaker canada team. In the interview phase but want to know is it worth switching from a small agency to here. How is the Loreal team bdw. How is the overall culture and work life balance.

like

Here’s to hoping the start of the new Serena Lincoln navigator ad is the end of the Mathew mcconaughey Lincoln Navigator ads

likefunny

Any advice on how to handle an ECD in charge of your salary who says the only way to get a promotion or even a COL raise of any kind is through winning an award? Not consistently reliable and solid performance. Not keeping the client happy and profitable. “You either win an award, or all ya get is to keep your job.”
And yes, I’m aware leaving is always an option, but eager for any other advice how to navigate.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal