Interested in everyone’s opinions on replica luxury. I ask because, as noted in the previous thread re: Chanel’s price increases, the quality of authentic luxury bags is going way down while the price increases consistently. Specifically Chanel and LV. I’m fascinated in the online rep community and it looks like rep quality has increased exponentially (with genuine materials and 1:1 markings, stitching, hardware, etc). What’s your argument for or against replicas?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Strongly against - in addition to the above, counterfeits are linked to criminal organizations and atrocious human rights violations. If you’re interested, the book “Deluxe: How Luxury Lost Its Luster” covers the topic (among others) and is a fascinating read

likefunny

Absolutely. I’d be more comfortable supporting local artisans by carrying a non branded bag. However I do appreciate the craftsmanship that goes into all of my Hermes bags.

like

Who cares lmao. These companies hike up their prices and call it craftsmanship. I have a handful of 1:1 reps that are handmade and look just as “real” as anything. Do what feels right for you, and do it without guilt.

like

Honestly, has a supply chain person, I think Hermes' approached to sustainable/ethical supply chain is relatively robust.

Not saying this is true of every authentic brand. But it's why in particular I will spend money there.

https://finance.hermes.com/en/responsible-sourcing/

likehelpful

Luxury items are a celebration of the fact that you can afford one and/or a reward for your hard work. you’re only fooling yourself with fakes

like

Good way to condone slavery too.

like

I am against it. If you don’t want to buy brands, support young designers and buy something authentic.

like

There is little to no regulation of the replica market and major human rights issues in the supply chain. This is also a problem with many mainstream brands but their data is more accessible, so it’s easier to be an informed shopper. The resale market is growing significantly and if you really want a specific luxury item, it is possible to find it used for less than full retail. Plus what A1 mentioned in terms of making a statement...

likehelpful

I buy Hermes because I want quality and the long-term service on the bag, no reason for me to buy a fake.

like

Not speaking about the ethics of such, but from a consumer perspective, i wouldn’t wear them because it will give off a false impression to people that i am richer than i am, and that makes me uncomfortable. Unless i could easily afford the real thing, wearing a bag that i cannot afford would make me super self conscious. I look young so carrying a 10K bag wouldn’t match my vibe.

A lot of rich ppl buy both authentic and reps. They honestly don’t care. And tbh, our society is looks above riches. If you are good looking and have charisma, great presence, even if you wear a fake ppl will think it is real. If you have a poor appearance, poorly shaped, etc carrying an Hermes alligator would lead to ppl thinking you’re wearing a knockoff.

I feel like luxury has been destroyed by social media. Decades ago, only the wealthy class would carry luxury. Now, because of our exposure to these ppl through social media, we want to be more like them, to have their things, and we save up a month of salary for an item that is supposed to act as a function to carry our stuff. That’s not what luxury is supposed to be. To the original target customers, they can easily pick up a luxury item like we buy a bathrobe. And after coming back from Paris, I realized that a chanel bag looks better on a middle aged, sophisticated women than a 18 yr old influencer.

This would be an unpopular opinion, but in conclusion, from a consumer perspective, i would only be comfortable carrying reps if i could actually afford the real thing.

like

Also, let me just add that I have not purchased a fake! But I’ve gone down the Reddit black hole of how to obtain one, their comparisons to auth, etc and was surprised at what a thriving community it is and how different from the Canal street image I had in my mind from childhood trips to NYC.

like

Totally! Regardless of one’s view, the industry has certainly evolved 😅

like

Why? You can get quality nonluxury bags. Why put on a front?

like

Against: replicas aren't going to get things 100% right. Many of these luxury items have a lot of thought put into every detail of design and a rep manufacturer can't possibly catch all those little tidbits.

I've actually compared my Cartier watch, for instance, against a "high-quality" fake and could definitely spot some key differences, and the authentic is absolutely superior in every day especially in the finer points. That said, YMMV based on product type and all.

Are you interested in quality or the name? If you want quality then by the real thing. If you just want the name then get the fake. At the end of the day it’s your preference. For me I’m about quality regardless of name and I would rather put my money on something that I can proudly wear. Just know that if someone realizes you’re carrying a fake regardless if all other bags are real you’re now seen in their eyes as a fake bag carrier.

Related Posts

What is the variable component percentage in UST global

I have an offer of 19lpa with 5% variable component. What will be my expected monthly in hand salary excluding taxes ?

like

Hi Fishes

What would be the in hand monthly salary of 12lpa?
Thanks in advance.

What do you guys think about municipal finance

like

Anyone work in the Healthcare industry? I'm looking into joining Healthcare. I'm currently a Senior in tax compliance.

like

When someone is in probation period (also bond), is it advisable to discuss with HR first, or to apply directly to portal?
Also suggest some good plots to get release soon.
Thanks :)

like

Considering the current fall in the equity and crypto market, which would be your go-to stocks / coins?

like

Hi ENFPs! Would love to hear your tips on how you handle this. I get great feedback on people based things (client, team coaching), but continually pushed on drilling deeper (cont.)

like

Starting negotiations with @UBS for a Sr WSA. What is the base salary range for this position and what is standard team comp?

Hey
If anyone wants referral for PWC AC Dm me :)
(Mostly wfh)

like

Any marketing strategists on here?

likehelpful

Any newly FL licensed attorneys looking to learn/practice family law?

like

Anybody know if and how much I can contribute to my Roth IRA to reduce my 2020 tax liability? I’m trying to pay less taxes but Jesus this pandemic has been great for my law firm and salary.

like

Anyone working in Pune?@Stefanini

like
like

Hi, world. Amy, 45, Kansas City.

like

Best kitchen knife set under $600?

like

Any recruiter in search of a Scrum Master 🙂

like

What are the best ways of tax exemption

like

Additional Posts in Luxury fashion

Anyone wear baccarat rouge?

like

Anyone have the newer, smaller Cartier JUC? If so, is it a practical don’t take off/wear it everyday bracelet? Would it work to stack with the Love (if you have it)? Thank you in advice for any advice. :)

like

Looking for a small pouch with strap/wristlet that I can keep in my work bag to help organize that bag but also can carry separately when I need to do things around the office and carry just my phone/small wallet/access card. Budget is approx 1K - any recs? Thanks!

like

Kind of seeking validation here but also happy to take feedback. Is 22 too young for luxury goods? I’m obsessed with handbags. Like literally. I own 2 LV, 1 Chanel, 1 YSL, 1 Gucci, and just bought another Gucci. Idk what’s wrong with me🧐but I’ve been feeling super antsy and dissatisfied with life that I seek thirst in binge shopping, or even spending hours looking at handbags. Fyi I’m really not spoiled, most of the bags are hard earned and I consider myself to be ambitious

like

Has anyone bought anything from Vestiaire Collective?

like

Selling Zimmerman silk wrap dress in olive green, size 1, worn once
Pick up in NYC

Post Photo
like

Cannot make up my mind on carry on - I have a tumi leather carry on.. but need a new one..

like

How can Prada want $1,750 for a bag that’s not even 50% leather??? Why do I want to buy one???

like

Just bought my first Tiffany product! Wrap Bead Bracelet in Silver with Pearls and a Diamond.

like

Bought this YSL bag as a gift for my sister. Unfortunately she was ungrateful so I didn’t give it to her. I’m unable to return it. It’s brand new still with tag. Willing to sell for the price I paid.

Post Photo
like

recommendations for wedding bands? for both men and women (doesn’t have to be the same brand/shop)

like

Anyone own Loro Piana Summer Walks? What is your review of them?

like

Does anybody else see no point in splurging on luxury goods at the moment? Don’t get me wrong, I still love a bit of Cartier and Dior, but what’s the point when we can’t really go anywhere?

like

Is fashionphile a legitimate place to buy a Chanel bag if it comes with an authenticity card? I know that there is at least some risk, but I’m trying to gauge if this a reputable enough place to spend so much money. Thanks!

like

I know this is kind of low budge for some of the bags that have been posted lately, but I’m about to pull the trigger on the Saint Laurent Quilted Vintage Leather Camera bag in cream. Just a small everyday crossbody. Any thoughts?? Would love to hear feedback. Would love something bigger than this to throw more stuff in, but am really attracted to the design.

like

Does anyone have a recommendation for a stylist in NYC. I would like to group my clothes into outfits for specific seasons so I only have one season in my closet at a time. Assistance would be greatly appreciated!

like

I’m looking for a diamond tennis bracelet for my wedding. Any recommendations on where I can find one? I checked out Costco and Blue Nile and they were just ok.

like

Might be a long shot, is anyone selling a phoebe philo Celine large trio bag? Preferably in neutral color (not black) thanks!

like

Hi! Does anyone have any Christmas gift ideas for a 30 year old female (currently pregnant)? She loves almost all designer brands, but I’m hoping to keep it under $500... (sister-in-law).

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal