Anyone have any good advice for getting students to think/respond on their own? So many times when I ask them to write their own thoughts about something and to explain why they hold that opinion, many students get stuck and/or turn to the Internet. And then I find myself repeating, I’m asking for YOUR thoughts about this, not someone else’s. I teach grades 9 & 11.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I know what works for me when I run into a problem like this is asking the student to start with a one-word answer. Asking them directly, how do you feel or what do you think about this? Then I transition to a "why do you think you feel that way?" and that leads them to tell me something about it. Usually, I can say to them after that "Great! that's your answer!" and have them write it down. Depending on the type of question I might have to do more follow up like "where do we see evidence for this" or "what in the text makes you think this?"

likesmart

My big help with this is a lot of in class free writing. We read something I want them to respond to (or I have them come to class having read something), and then we do X minutes of free writing response. If I want them to do a longer assignment on that response, then I make sure they attach their free write to the final assignment so I can see the evolution of their thoughts.

like

A prompt I use is to ask them a categorical question first. Then ask them why they answered that in a way that invites them to write on a personal level because the question resonates with them. The response is usually good

Start with stems:
I noticed
I wonder
I predict

Are you always asking them to physically write on paper? Some of my students can’t or won’t elaborate using pen and paper but will type up a storm. And for those who struggle with spelling and grammar, I let them use flipgrid to verbalize their reasoning. If the goal is to get them to form their own views, giving them choice in how they express that is a good place to start. You can always build on the structure after.

Try searching for NY Times Activities for Students online. They have lots of current and relevant topics. I have students choose 1 bulleted question (listed below editorials, articles, and photos) and they respond to it in their reader/writer notebooks. Then I have them do a stand-up meeting with someone they don’t usually talk to and take turns sharing how they responded. Time permitting, we share out as a whole class.

The articles that they really liked were the ones on cancel culture, mental health days for students, and one on social media. Now that we are in our persuasive unit and studying rhetorical modes and strategies, we also discuss HOW the writer communicates ideas and what writers’s craft tools they used. They always provide links back to the original NYT article if you want to use that to differentiate instruction for more advanced kids.

I ask them something about a school or home rule they don’t like and then we discuss it. Soon they see they have plenty to write. The question just needs to trigger them in some way.

My go to strategy is to ask students to read the assignment then respond to what one event do you feel was most important and why? Next day we have Socratic seminar where they have to speak and either relate how their chosen event advances the plot, deepens character development, adds to theme, symbol, or motif, etc. I also give my kids the standard study guide questions to help them frame context but I don’t grade those ever.

Related Posts

I work in construction and spend a lot of time out in the field, can I get some recs for sturdy shoes that will last me a while?

like

Help the baby executives please! For the seasoned executives - Thinking back to your first executive role - what were the biggest mistakes you made and how did you recover?

Post Photo
likesmart

PwC India Does pwc india consider counter offer if i day to joining date is left plz give suggestions it’s urgent PwC India PwC Deloitte KPMG India Accenture India Mindtree Tata Consultancy IBM

like

Hi fishes, does anybody know anything about Lubrizol Advanced material, like hows the organisation. Hows the WLB and perks of the company.
I have not heard very much about the company as this is new for RPA.
If anyone have any idea about the organisation, will of great help.
Thank you

like

Are Google , IBM , Meta learning certificates, worth it? Do they really impress employers? If had an IBM data science certificate without any experience for example what type of role can expect or should I expect any?

like

I look at this bowl- half of the issues here are visa related... I am 2nd gen desi and citizen by birth. Will it be considered +ve/-ve to talk about my this credential when dating desi girls? Punjabi desi here M 26. My favorites are those in research/teaching profession.

Any tips on landing a full-time teaching job in middle school math? My applications are largely being ignored by hiring districts. I live in central CT.

like

Looking to move to the city during the spring! What are the best areas to live in terms of easy access to grocery stores, cafes and restaurants?

like

Hi everyone, I need referral for JP Morgan Chase & Co.
Thanks in advance 😊

like

Got a job offer for Wells Fargo, anyone knows what the Quarterly Bonus for a personal banker looks like?

Pluto is 5 months old today! 🥳

Post Photo
likeuplifting
like

Hello fishies, Amy offers for VMware/windows administrator. Please refer me. Yoe: 5.6 notice period : 1 month left Current CTC: 7.17 Expected : 12 Thanks in advance

like

Good morning, this is a great group to be apart of.Hope everyone has great day. I started off with listening to some really inspirational podcasts and meditation. What are some things you all do to get moving in the morning?

like

How is the medical insurance policy at HCL Technologies?

like

Hard to focus on anything else when wearing a Lange...

Post Photo
likeuplifting

[Expats] How many of you have requested an absentee ballot?

like

At what point in your first role are you actually expected to contribute vs learn on the job out of undergrad?

Additional Posts in English & Language Arts Teachers

I have a student who is a strong writer and wants to be a blogger. How can I support her in this?

like

There seems to be countless ways to build in grammar/vocabulary into the curriculum. How do you all approach it and keep it as engaging as possible? Thanks, and have a great school year!!

like

The skills & academic stamina of students in adv. classes are the lowest my colleagues and I have ever seen across ALL subjects. Students also seem not to care about the quality of their work, goal setting, & improvement like they did pre-C-19. Being back in person for a year has not erased the learning losses; in fact, this group is worse off than last year’s classes. Do you see this trend in your advanced programs? I wonder if it’s a district curriculum & philosophy issue or more widespread.

like

I refuse to do any type of planning until the absolute last minute.

likefunnysmartuplifting
like

What are some general warm-up prompts that can be applied to different texts & get students' wheels turning before a lesson or discussion?

like

Any 4th grade teachers that use LearnZillion curriculum?

like

How do you deal with absences during ongoing group projects? Or just kids not doing their part, coming to class unprepared, etc.? It feels so messy and hard to manage! Frustrating for everyone! Is group work even worth it in the end?

like

Have you shared any online reading resources for your (2021-22) students to use over the summer? If so, what? I have found that First Book offers a good program.

like

Top reading recommendations for 2022? Looking for some new/diverse recommendations :)

like

Suggestions on tools to use to pre-assess grammar reading and writing skills-6th graders

Can a principal ask a teacher to use some of their planning time to write late students tardy slips when they get to school every single day? Keep in mind this is the only planning period the teacher gets and it’s only 50 minutes long.

likefunny

What are some of the best books you've had your students read recently?

like

Are there any other teachers out there working toward National Board certification? Can we get a bowl started??

like

Looking for suggestions about what to do if a student returns to school and they have not completed the required summer reading. Our curriculum for half of the first nine weeks revolves this book.

like

What is your favorite online site for grammar instruction ?

Does anyone have any recommendations for mentor texts for writing (3rd grade)?

likehelpful

The Book Fair is coming! What ideas do you have to get middle school students excited about the fair? What are some creative ways you get teacher book fair donations for your classroom?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal