Is this a group for socialists or also for those that (in a constructive way) enjoy discussing socialism?
I’m Scandi and more social democrat than socialist, but have respect for socialists and enjoy trying to find a way to convince myself of certain aspects.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yes, absolutely. Just don't attack the validity of socialism as a whole here, e.g. argue that capitalism is a better economic model. That would belong in a pro-capitalism group.

funny

So you can come at the answer from a few angles.

In its purest sense, the incentive is that you'll benefit from it. Not the most satisfying answer, obviously, but that truly is the core of it. If you're the guy who makes chairs, you also need to sit down. You'll want to put in more effort to make better chairs so you can be comfortable when you sit. If you're a farmer, you'll want to invest time and research into methods of farmers that will allow you to eat better and allow you to work less for the food.

Another angle is admitting that sure, a lot of individuals will not want to put in the extra effort, especially if it's a benefit that they don't see, or if the job is particularly unpleasant. A socialist economy will recognize that, and that's why it needs to be done with some form of direct democracy. That means that trade unions will vote on working conditions, and product consumers will vote on product standards that trade unions must adhere to. The incentive to maintain good working standards and product quality will fall on the workers: you can get fired and replaced if you don't meet those standards, and you'll have to find something else to do.

Another angle is to reframe the idea of innovation altogether. 9 times out of 10, innovation is in service of capital. Are people going to innovate on data collection for targeted marketing if there's no capital incentive? Sure, but a cashless society doesn't really need that. You wouldn't need to innovate on tiered pricing models. Or better ways to trade stocks. Or banking and budgeting apps. More generally, the economy doesn't need to grow and is allowed to stagnate, so there's no need to innovate on growth for growth's sake. It wouldn't make sense without capitalism.

But if people vote for tastier apples after a botanist (who genuinely loves being a botanist) finds a way to do it in a way that doesn't violate the standards of the apple growers' union? That innovation is going to happen.

Related Posts

Any good gyms in the West Village/Soho area (excluding Equinox)

like

Vettel you beauty ❤️

like

Anyone have any recommendations for home office ergonomic desk chairs?

like

Is it too late to buy the FAANG stocks? Still feel that Amazon and Google are undervalued.

like

Anyone did a H1B transfer recently using premium processing ? Trying to understand timelines

like

Persistent offer letter has huge component of Other Bonus, In my case it's around 8 lakh rupees... Anyone working at Persistent can tell?? If this is paid 100%(in monthly salary) or there are some terms and conditions around this?? Persistent Systems Limited

like

Ok. My lads and ladies of FB. I need a watch suggestion in about the 8k range. Just got married on Saturday and wife wants to gift me a watch. Here is a SOC in picture form so y’all have an idea of my pieces. 1. Rolex Daytona TT, 2. JLC MUT RG 3. Tudor GMT 4. Tudor Prince 4. Omega Speedy 5. Mont Blanc 1858 and various assorted pieces.

Post Photo
like
like

Harman connected services vs CGI.
Please help

like

Progressive insurance claims: to work there or not?@

like

Hi all! I was curious if anyone had any connections to someone Grammarly inc. I have admired their work and would love to sit down with someone and chat.

helpful

Hi everyone!

I recently just finished my interview with Accenture and is looking very promising. We have yet discuss salary, I would like to know other people's salary who work in the Industry X so that I'm not getting low-balled. I currently work at HDR inc. making 69K (Salary).

2 YOE., Mechanical Engineer

The position is "Analyst - Industry X Development Program" in Detroit, Michigan.

like

Any smart, funny and caring Desi F Interested in connecting? Trying really hard to avoid the matrimonial route.

like

I spent three full days creating a case study for an Executive Assistant position I’m interviewing for. Has anyone else come across this? Do you think it’s overkill?

like

Hi fishes ,
Anyone can share the data privacy in India and across aisa pacific regions

like
like

I have cleared all rounds with KGS  and pending salary discussion. What should be my expected salary with 6 yoe into BI development role? CCTC is 15 Lakh.

KGS KPMG KPMG India

Got an offer from talentica for around 11 lpa as a software developer.issue is they are giving 2 months to join whereas my notice period is 3 months.
Can someone guide me what to do?
Current ctc- 7.2 lpa
Total exp- 11 months

like

Can anyone share what is the avg salary for client experience specialist at ADP India. YoE 5 with MBA from tier 1 Bschool.
TIA

Additional Posts in Socialism

Welcome, comrades! My hope is for this group to be a respite from the bleak capitalist wasteland, as well as a place to share resources and information about getting organized and supporting socialist endeavors. This group needs an admin, I can't do it myself. Comment here if you're interested!

like

Happy Friday comrades! Sorry this place has been pretty quiet, I've been moving to a new apartment.

Fun thread time.

Comment with your favorite garbage capitalist takes on socialism. I'll start:

If you love socialism so much, why don't you empty your bank account and live as a feral mountain man in the woods?

like

I admitted a bunch of people just so that we can have more of a critical mass here. Welcome again comrades! Try and be respectful and above all, no simping for capitalism!

likeuplifting

Thought you’d all find this funny.

Post Photo
likefunny

I would suggest having a thread or threads about defending socialism against capitalism. In the real world anti-socialist ideas/arguments are made all the time and for those lessed versed in socialist thought, it can be hard to defend one's position and perhaps even be persuaded bythe capitalists. Just an idea

like

For those who want some lighter reading on Marx, I can recommend this. Each chapter starts with a standard anti-Marx argument and then gives the rebuttal. The left can sometimes be a bit “I can’t believe you disagree, I won’t even engage’ but this means we are often not well rehearsed to oppose the other side of the argument.

Post Photo
like

Happy Friday comrades! How's everyone doing in the broken capitalist dystopia we find ourselves in? Any exciting plans for the weekend?

like
like

Anyone considering voting for Trump?

Would love to hear your considerations if his neo-hegalianism within economic policies are worth voting for even in the face of his fascistic tendencies

Hey. I was wondering, what are some jobs that you wouldn't take on the basis that you don't feel it's ethical? For me, I just would never work for a defense contractor or anything to do with the FBI, CIA, etc. I also don't ever plan on being a manager.

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal