I've been in Comms for 30 years. Last year, I interviewed for 15 jobs. Every one of them asked for an unpaid work assignment to demonstrate my writing skills. I refused. Before last year, I was never asked to do unpaid writing assignments as part of a job interview. What's with this? Is anyone else experiencing this?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Standard operating procedure. If you refuse, you make it easy for them to weed you out.

like

I've been in this industry for 15 years and every single job I interviewed for at every level had some sort of skills assessment involved (writing exercise, presentation, etc.). I've also been on the other side of the hiring table.

Is it annoying and time-consuming? Yes. Are some companies unethical and using it as a way to get free work? Also yes. But most are genuinely trying to figure out if you can actually do all the things you say you can do.

(And who among us has not experienced the hire who interviewed spectacularly, but then it turned out they were just very good at taking credit for others' work while doing nothing of substance themselves?)

like

I’ve always had to do a writing assignment or a strategic plan going back 20yrs and I’ve asked candidates for them as well. Even at senior levels. Never look at it as unpaid work - more a skills test. Don’t think this is new or unusual. Also agree it’s going away with AI.

like

I’ve actually had the opposite experience recently. For the last 15 years of my career I’ve always been asked to do unpaid labor during the interview process. Now with ChatGPT, that’s completely gone away.

like

Yes! I only interviewed for a couple of jobs recently, and this happened to me, too. I have a portfolio, and I have a proven track record of what I’ve done. There is no reason for me to provide you with unpaid work that accomplishes the same.

like

So you want a job in writing comms but aren’t willing to prove that you can?

like

that was my thought. Maybe they would’ve been interviewing for two had they done writing samples.

The assignment is the last step before the offer. Why go through the process endless rounds most companies demand now and then bail over a writing assignment?

like

Yes and it was for a County job. I failed because they gave me a PC - I am a Mac user...

like

I interviewed for one role they asked me to do a fairly extensive project. I just got it, it’s a step up to VP for fortune 100 company. It was worth it.

Very common and tbh I prefer it. It’s the fairest part of the recruitment process nowadays. Gives you a chance to actually showcase your skills instead of being assessed based on things you have done in the past, some of which may not even be relevant.

Related Posts

Does PwC provides joining bonus

like

Is it really that difficult to get hired for a federal job? I was interviewed for a GS12 job but never heard back, they still didn’t hire anyone and I didn’t get a rejection. I applied for another GS07 job, was accepted, I took it, but I believe I can do better. I have a master’s and have extra graduate research experience. I am still applying to new jobs but I was told it is impossible to move up the grade level now. Everyone is telling me to stick with the government. What are your thoughts?

likehelpfulupliftingsmart

Thoughts on this Grey Mother of Pearl Vintage Alhambra Pendant? Personally, I think it’s gorgeous. Really hope they release this in the Sweet size, as I prefer dainty jewellery.😍

Post Photo
like

Anyone here counsel for a parent company with a lot of subsidiaries but the parent company’s legal department is really really small? I’m wondering if a small legal department for a large company is more of a pro or con? On one hand I suspect it’s less organized, on the other it might be a great leadership opportunity. Any insight? Thanks!

like

I’m 26 weeks pregnant and trying to figure out my leave. I live in NJ and work at PwC, any fishes know the policy for NJ and PwC? The leave center has not been much help and I want to plan NOW not like 60 days before. I was told NJ gets two weeks before due date and PwC gives you two weeks as well.

like

One of the team member has applied leaves for continuous 3 days this month. Later she applied for a 15 days leave saying a medical emergency. Both the leaves were rejected from her manager saying connect with HR. though she is on leave without PM leave approval and this is not even prior notice to the team.
Now'what and all would be the consequences she might face. Is there any chance of these things are being escalated? Please advise!

like

Hi, what salary can I expect for 2 year full stack developer experience at a product firm. It would be great if someone can give an insight.

like

What is the salary of a associate product manager at Gartner India

like

How I look after carrying all my personal belongings to the office, airport, and home every week

Post Photo
likefunnysmart

How to look about for opportunities for Acca candidate who has 3y experience in external audit ? Looking for suggestions ! Thanks

funny

Attorney 🐠 - my female SO is moving over to big law in the coming weeks. Need ideas on gifts. Any suggestions? Thanks in advance!!

like

Cheapest way to get from Grand Central to LGA Airport that's not the subway? Are there shuttles? Thank you!

like

Can someone recommend a good photographer for headshots? I’ve tried two so far with mixed results. Don’t really like the final product and most are not great for a professional setting.

like

Traveling to Italy for 1 week. Is it better to get the int'l data plan or get a SIM card when I get there?

like

Hey guys,

Does anyone currently live in an all electric Aparment? If so, do you feel like it’s expensive or cost effective?
I’m moving in to a 2 bedroom apartment with my wife and the tenant is responsible for electricity. The heating and the stove are both electric so wanted to get an idea on how the electric bill is month to month.

All, planning to head to France for the race in June. Any tips?

like

Additional Posts in PR and Communications

Which recruiters do you all find have the best connections to in-house job opportunities? I am DONE with agency life. TIA!

like

Has anyone ever worked with a recruiter/headhunter? Are there any pr/mar comms focused firms you'd recommend?

like

About to start a new role as an Associate Director for a PR agency. How do I prepare for this job ahead of time? Any tips and tricks welcome.

like

I'm looking to return to the U.S. after over a decade living and working in SSA (Marcom for ecommerce startups and tech enabled nonprofits). I've been job hunting as I plan my move in the fall but haven't gotten any serious bites. Does anyone have any pointers to ease the process of transcontinental job hunting?

like

I used to work at Edelman, and would like to pursue my career in ESG or corporate sustainability communications. Any recommendations (both in-house or agencies) in the UK?

#PR #Communications #help

like

See the George Floyd trial verdict will be announced in the next hour.

How are you counseling clients around this? Or, are you not counseling clients on this?

Curious to hear from the bowl.

likesmart

Handed in my notice at Golin earlier this week and my manager said that I was disloyal and greedy. Thanks for reminding me why I wanted to leave. Enjoy the death spiral you all are in.

likefunny

what is working at a crisis management firm like? broad question, i know, but i don’t know much about the field! (i currently work at an ad agency, but i’m considering a career pivot.)

like

Weber folks! At what point do you become eligible for a yearly bonus and how is your bonus determined? Any tie to billable hours?

like

Thinking about transitioning from advertising (10 years as a copywriter) into public relations. Has anyone in this bowl done that? What types of roles should I be looking for?

Anyone know of any open positions in D/FW? 8 YOE on the agency side, masters degree in public administration. Looking to go client side to do Corp comms/public affairs. Any leads welcome!

like

Best PR firms for digital agency?

Candid thoughts on the Ogilvy LA office?

Hello all, for those working in an agency. I wanted to see what your typical client workload is? I’ve been in my role for about a year but the workload has changed dramatically without hiring help.

Can you please share:
- the number of accounts you manage
- how many support staff you have on those accounts
- how many active pitches you send per month for those clients on average

Thanks all!

like

What’s the word on the street about work life balance at Edelman? Are the hours insane?

like

I’ve been at Golin for a while and interested in what the outside opinion is of our agency. What are people saying about us?

like

Thoughts on MMC as an agency?

like

15 YOE, recently started my first tech PR job at a large, stable company & have been asked to get ~20 SMEs in front of media. Subject matter is not sexy. I lead PR for all of U.S. & have no other PR colleagues. My agency’s budget is 100k/year & they’re spread too thin to hit their KPIs. I feel set up to fail & feel we should be focusing on a handful of SMEs and only our sexiest topics. Any advice on mitigating unrealistic expectations for coverage? Anyone handled similar problems in the past?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal