Performance reviews rarely reflect true performance. The assumption that hard work leads to raises or promotions is often untrue—managers are limited by small budgets and end up giving standard raises to most employees. Recognition tends to go only to those who fail badly or who grab leadership’s attention, while meaningful rewards are reserved for senior leaders. It’s left me with little faith in the review process and senior leadership.

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Performance reviews are nothing more than official documentation to deny raises and promotions while justify firing people. When people realize that, our approaches to them will change. I hate that it is that way, but the more you learn about HR, the more you learn they are not your friend.

likesmart

Congratulations for lifting the veil, OP. You’re seeing reality for the first time. This is how it works.

like

@EE Yes! Any time I’ve ever gotten a significant raise, it’s always been by job hopping. Staying in the position limits you to their raise standards, if that. My last job hop, I went from $85k, with the promise of $87k during the raise cycle, to $110. Now I’ve been stuck at $110 for 3 years lmao but I would have still had less with the minute annual raises at my last gig.

Each department has their own department standards that need to be met. When first hired, it is tracked weekly. After 90 days, it is tracked monthly. Each time the supervisor reviews with the employee so it is clear where they are. All this information is then placed in the annual review. I say we have done a great job grooming our supervisors to review and discuss this with each of their employees.

Also, each evaluation is reviewed by HR prior to presenting to employee. We review for things that may be too subjective. If a supervisor rates an employee higher than meets expectation, we make sure specific examples are provided to justify the rating. Same holds true if it is below expectations. Goals are developed and verified completed by the due dates.

These evaluations are done on the employee's anniversary date. The are not used for merit increases. It is an interactive discussion between the two individuals. The employee is allowed to express their goals, as well.

funny

It is interesting that you separate evaluations from merit increases. That may help reduce subjectivity, but it also highlights why many employees lose faith in reviews because they feel disconnected from recognition and reward. Without meaningful outcomes, reviews risk becoming a box checking exercise.

like

It's all about visibility, you have to be decent at what you do, but you need to make sure to be seen doing that (presenting the process and results to your team leadership), otherwise it's really hard to stand out

Related Posts

What does the technical assessment at Wynshop go over?

like

Female 🐠: basically all of my pores are visibly clogged and enlarged. I get breakouts from this regularly. What do I need to do? I assume I need to go to a spa or derm. Should I be seeking an extraction facial?

like

Has anyone faced this that Capgemini HR expect you to respond fast till they collect documents. After that they stop responding. This is frustrating and funny as in why to waste everyone’s time

like

Any REIT ETFs that people like?

like
like

Hey all. I lost my passport 😔 what’s the protocol for getting a new passport and a valid US visa back?

Is it possible to get visas from other countries back too?

I’m an Indian citizen.

She doesn't know the real reason why I'm lukewarm about kids: I don't think she's matured enough. I'm trying to plan for retirement and a house, but all she wants is her next overseas vacation

like

Does someone help me to get good instructors for SCM certification

Infosys Infosys Limited can anyone please help to know the in-hand salary from this break up

Post Photo
like

Hi All,
Please guide do Joining
Cognizant on Contractual role is worthy or not?
Current Situation - due to bgv not completing as one of my company as per CTS is black listed so they changed my hiring from permanent to contractual role.
Please guide as I have no knowledge of contractual roles. 🙏

like

I have cleared Technical Round in Cognizant and I have also given HR round (telephonic). Just now i recieved a mail from talent acquisition team having subject "Invitation for Live Interview with Cognizant ".

I am not sure what kind of interview it is.
Can anybody help me?

like

Any openings for freshers for BCA in CTS.. is Genc is still in progress?

like

If that’s your Art Director, then why is he in my google doc?

likefunny
like

Hi All,
In Capgemini they gave provisional offer letter and I am waiting for the offer letter from the last week? From last two days i am following up HR?May I Know when will they release the offer letter?

like

Hello everyone,
Can someone share amount of hike and bonus received this year for 2 and 3 rating and with promotion?
I got 15 percent hike and 10 percent bonus

like

Any of you guys in Hong Kong?

like

I’m working on a food-related passion project with an art director friend! Looking for people in advertising who like to cook and can provide us with recipes and food pics. Interested (or know someone who might be)? DM me.

Hi All,

I would like to know the process of PF withdrawal in CTS, please help.

like

Additional Posts in The Worklife Bowl

Most exotic name you’ve heard: drop below!

like

It is TOO HOT in San Francisco today 🥵🥵

like

Started a new role. For 9 years I was the go-to for every question for my team. It was exhausting and I was killing myself to please everyone, but I also kind of thrived on it. Now I’m the new kid on the block, know nothing, and feel like I’m adding very little value to my current firm pulling half the hours. I know eventually I will get up to speed and pull my weight. Feeling guilty for accepting a paycheck knowing I’m not adding value yet. Anyone else?

like

Thoughts on what to get wife for her bday. Shes turning 30 and because of covid we cant do a big birthday bash like we were planning. She also got laid off b.c of Covid and has been in a bit of a rut and I want to make her feel better and have a great birthday. Shes an amazing wife and mom and I want her to have a great birthday. Appreciate the help fellow fish

like

Home office preference question. I am getting ready to redo the layout of my home office. One option I'm considering would have my desk facing a wall. I am wondering if anyone with this current setup has any feedback about it. I would face the wall so that I would have a better background for video conferences (am on about half the day) and also my cord situation would be cleaner.

like

My mom turns 60 at the end of December. What would be a unique experience to get her (not stuff)? We want to spend around $1,000.

like

It’s a vibe.

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

What's a fair share of taxes? In my view, ideally 0. But curious to hear what people here think.

like

At Sunday brunch rn like

Post Photo
likefunny

considering a trip to Hawaii, looking for Marriott properties that have a beach access, probably October through December. Would prefer more on the value side than all glitz and glam. Any recommendations

like

Female 🐠: basically all of my pores are visibly clogged and enlarged. I get breakouts from this regularly. What do I need to do? I assume I need to go to a spa or derm. Should I be seeking an extraction facial?

like

I’ll be honest the marketing for this app is bad. Fishbowl is really useful but dang stop trying to relate to the kids and just tell us what fishbowl is

My 64 y/o mom is really struggling with her mental health and refuses to acknowledge it or take action. She is already difficult to have a relationship with, toxic, always shaming, blaming, dismissive and refuses to have important conversations.
6 years ago her husband/my step dad was killed suddenly and tragically. He had a man cave room that she has not touched since. It is beyond filthy, unsanitary and poor living conditions.

If I make attempts to clean, she has a meltdown. How to fix?

Every job application rejection is one job application closer to finding a job.

likeupliftinghelpfulsmart

Are they really answering the questions? I am confused.

like

Hi all! My past role was a pretty toxic environment - extremely unrealistic & ever-changing expectations & condescending behavior & an overall mean & anxiety riddled atmosphere. Any advice on what to ask future companies when interviewing to really dig & uncover any red flags? Getting real feedback & a true sense of things can be difficult bc typically you get back what they want you want to hear. Probing questions that might allow to read btwn the lines & uncover negative atmosphere? Thanks!

likehelpful

Anyone who is ex-consulting and moved to industry miss the events? I don't miss the lack of WLB, but I miss getting tickets to conferences, team events and DU.
Pandemic has been good and bad, since I guess no one is going anywhere, but also because industry office is closed so no in-house events either. Miss getting varied experiences across different clients and industries that consulting offered.
Anyone else feel like their world shrunk a ton when they left consulting for industry?

like

Anyone have a standing desk recommendation between the Fully Jarvis vs Uplift V2 vs Autonomous Smartdesk 2? Leaning towards the Jarvis but the Autonomous one seems 50% cheaper, but can’t really tell what the drawbacks are according to their website/reviews

like

Born in US and have always been proud to be American, but this 4th of July I don’t feel the same. We have a 🤡 as President, completely failed response to the Coronavirus, banned from entering Europe, and racial tensions and divisions all around. We are the laughingstock of the world. Anyone else feel the same way?

likefunnysmart

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal