Why’s it so hard for agencies to be transparent with their own employees?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Because it’s an industry that rewards con artists and charlatans. They’re the ones who rise and exploit the people who possess the actual talent and skills.

like
Recent IconRecent

Been freelancing at WK PDX for a year now and I’ve NEVER experienced a more transparent agency in my 25 year career. They have bi-monthly all agency Zoom meetings. So there’s 1.

like

Could you put my name in?

Even the most simple feedback is a big secret.No one cares about your development.

like

Of course they don’t! People only act with their own best interests in mind. I’m not saying that to be nasty, but it’s important to know. No one has your back.

like

I've been in the industry for 15 years and have had this same thought since day 1. It's wild that every agency has this same problem, in my experience.

like

Because they want to exploit you and lowball you and crush your dreams, all without you knowing.

likesmartfunny

Isn’t this a Corporate America problem in general? Keep status quo and be quiet and keep making money for the company.

like

Counter point to all the cynicism here:

I’ve been in agencies that tried to be hyper-transparent and it really didn’t go well. The truth is that the combination of employee cynicism, habitual breaking of confidence, and a tendency for juniors to misconstrue and make up narratives made it more headaches than it was worth.

Turns out transparency only works with mature and experienced staff. That’s why there’s a waterfall approach to disseminating information.

TLDR: because agency leaders have seen over sharing blow back on good-willed transparency and they just don’t have time to babysit staff who can’t handle/process the information.

likesmart

Ogilvy1: sorry, I may not be tracking in your point. I’m telling you I’ve seen genuine attempts to be transparent fail due to the behaviours of junior staff. “Doesn’t make it any better” seems like a lazy response/dismissal. What would you advise leaders do differently?

Because if we knew how much money they made, we'd all ask for raises.

like

It’s right there in the published accounts. The bit they don’t tell you is that most agencies aren’t actually very profitable, and can struggle on cash flow if clients aren’t paying on time. So the bit they may not be being fully transparent on is how precarious the whole business/ business model is.

Transparent about what specifically?

like

I was wondering this, too.

like

Because imposters isn’t just a syndrome…

like

Lawsuit. Duh!

likehelpful

It’s just not really in their interest to be transparent, sadly. ‘They muddy the water to make it seem deep’

like

What would you like more transparency on specifically? Salaries? Business results? Performance?

likehelpful

Because they don’t want to reveal how they’re exploiting their workers.

likesmart

Employer and employees relationship is one of power unbalance and exploitation, no matter how much we want to dress it up. So companies naturally push agains anything that could level the playing field

like

^ listen to our comrade

like

Because transparency means HONESTY and LOYALTY, and a company can’t be loyal to people they claim to value but are really just exploiting

likesmart

Lmao so true

like

LOL i'm glad it's like this at other agencies too...always think it's just us

like

Related Posts

Thanks everyone for supporting and sharing.

Post Photo
like

I am feeling so low. Not sure if I like what I do, but I like staying in this country. Am I ruining my life chasing this impossible American dream? I need to talk to somebody, not sure who can help 😣

like

Has anyone used the annual elite gift to buy a mattress through Marriott? If I buy it on my Boundless card will I get 6x points?

like

TONIGHT, I will be on NBC Nightly News with Lester Holt!!! @ 7:00 pm EST.

Post Photo

Penni living large

Post Photo
like

A colleague told me today that Google separates Product Manager and Product Owner as two separate roles. I believe that one PM role is preferred in the industry and most modern software companies, especially FAANG companies, only have PMs. Just curious what others have experienced and if I'm correct in my assumption.

like

Hello, has anyone filled in the Forte Fellows Kira video questions?

Are they any different from usual Kira interview questions?

like

Hey how is appraisals in altimetrik ??

Hi fishes

Need a reality check-
Profile-
Btech (mech) + MBA (non-IIM top 15)
4 years enterprise account management- US based personal computing OEM
1 year Management Consulting- Sales transformation

Input required on-
1. What is my profile fit for account executive role like?
2. What is the salary I can target? (Current- 19.6 fix+ 3.5 JB+ 4 variable) I am gunning for at least 30% jump on fixed.

like

I joined Capgemini on 15 th September. But didn't receive salary. Can someone please help on this. When can I expect that.

like

What designation i can expect iat Capgemini of joining as a Lateral?

I have total 11.5 YoE

like

What are different roles in LTI. I have got offer as P4 .May I know other roles from P4 onwards.
My exp is 11.10 years

like

LTI or EY GDS
OFFERED SALARY SAME

Hi,

What will be the in hand salary for this?

Post Photo
like

What policy changes are expected post LTI - Mindtree merger?

like

Hey everyone is there anyone who works at American Airlines? I could use a referral.

like

Hi! can anyone please refer me in ZS? I’ve the job Id.

like

I kind of feel that the HR I am talking with isn't that approachable. Is this kind of a norm. In VOIS. I am little hesitant to proceed with accepting the job offer from VOIS due to this.

Is this usually the norm in VOIS, where HR are quiet like this

like

Hi peeps,
On the day of joining (at Vois), when do we usually get the joining confirmation form to submit?
Today is my joining and I don't see any invite or communication from vois.
What happens on the first day? Please help.

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

I’m trying to write a nice short recommendation for a content strategist - any thoughts?

like

Seen many posts about "The Many", just wondering how many people actually like it there and how many of it is just vacancies from many people leaving.

Many thanks.

likefunny

As a female thirty-something in the industry, feel like I'm just starting to be aware of pay discrepancy 🙄. Curious to hear from others which of our agencies adhere to standards of gender equal pay?

like

Anyone have good recommendations on free Social Listening tools? Or scrappy suggestions on evaluating general topic volume over time?

like

I have an idea for an App, like a really great one, what do I do next? I’m not a developer or an entrepreneur.

likehelpful

How long can you go without having anything to do before you get laid off?

like

So many people on PTO. Job search has really come to a halt. I’m just waiting on a bunch of people to get back from their PTO after labor day. I HATE doing nothing. I feel so useless. Ive been trying to work on extensions for stuff in portfolio but my CW partner on the projects has been busy with actual work (she works in a diff state). What do i do? Lol. Anyone need help? Wanna chat?

like

What's the best way to gain visibility by those holding 3-4 positions higher than you? I like learning from them and growing mentorships but can't break the AE-level wall with my responsibilities. Being remote also makes it harder to interact.

I'm on the client/business side but would love to hear anyone's thoughts.

like

I know we could go on about the load of shitty recruiters out there but let’s try this… what makes a great recruiter?

One thing they don't prepare you for when you're getting into advertising is the extent to which being a cheerleader propels you. I'm not a misanthrope, but I'm definitely not naturally wired for cheerleading and it for sure has had an adverse impact on my career.

likesmarthelpfulfunny

Is WKNY on a hiring freeze? zero jobs listed on the site

funnylike

Exit strategy: Where do people work after a career in Advertising or PR? Add examples of your past colleagues.

like

Is working est hours worth it if you’re based in the west coast?

like

2020, career change anyone?

like

Hi! What would you say the average salary for a first year Art Director would be? My role would go from Production Designer (first job out of college) to Art Director. Thanks!

like

I want more money

likefunny

what is the standard process of asking to switch office locations? has anyone done it successfully? did you go through HR or apply for the position directly? any advice welcome.

like

What do you read daily to stay up to date on life, current events, advertising, pharma advertising, etc?

like

Why do recruiters try and use length of a project as a tactic to try and get a lower rate out of freelancers. One more time For every mushy brained “talent specialist:” IT IS NOT A PRIVILEGE TO WORK FOR YOU FOR LONGER FOR LESS MONEY

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal