Related Posts
Rising Star
Thoughts/reviews on Indian Matchmaking?
Anyone ready for NYC gathering?
Additional Posts in Accounting
When does the fiscal year end at the other B4?
New to Fishbowl?
Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
One approach that might work is this. When you confront him via email and he responds that he wants to talk by phone, have the phone call and tell him all the issues you have with his performance and ask him if he agrees with your assessment. After the phone call send him a written summary of everything discussed on the phone call and request that he reply via email comfirming he agrees with "each point below." And make sure it is specific and lists all his failures.
Confront by email it’s not a solution talk over the phone get better clear the tone of voice. Right after a conver you send an email on what’s been talking
Sorry this is happening to you and it is a thing. The non performers/low performers will fight really dirty in these cases. I'm proud to say I walked off of a job because of it.
What I learned is just start documenting everything the minute a low performer or non performer shows red flags.
For anyone who is hired to transform an accounting team or go from quick books accounting to more mature accounting processes, start documenting everything from day 1, because some people will need to be fired in these environments as they will refuse to change or adhere to actual standards.
Document, document, document. Obviously, they don’t want to get fired. They’re trying to cover their ass by creating their own documentation with these claims. Your documentation just has to be better. And you need to get whoever is in charge over at HR to advise and back you up. You don’t want to get into a legal situation where this person sues the company for wrongful termination.
Well stated. Document EVERY intereaction and who was present. Document meetings, emails, verbal conversations every time.
That's pretty much what everyone who actually creates a hostile work environment says. Need specifics for anyone to comment.
Right on, GT1! He's blaming the whole leadership team, not just me. He will take no accountability for when he misses a deadline. Everyone on the team works OT consistently, he never does. And I have time sheets to prove this to HR.
How are you holding people accountable? How you approach this show if you are a good manager. Is there low morale and high turn over in the company? Have you actually sat down with each employee to see what they do all day? Chances are they are doing more then their share and are overwhelmed. If they were under performing then surely you would have long term proof of that. Sit and listen to your employees before accusing them of under performing.
Reply
Share
terrible advice on every level. you are advocating for low performance, putting the work back on the manager with the standards, gaslighting, and encouraging sunk costs. you have zero soft skills.
Just document, keep emails, show how you act. All you can do. If you are being hostile that will prove out, if they can’t handle critiques that will prove out.
Good advise
I stop being hostile. Boom, done
Did you talk to this person face to face? How this person performs before or if it’s been always messing deadlines?
Give us an example of what he/she is saying is hostile.
OP, i also agree with what EY2 says. All I am seeing here is your side of the story and your defense. No one can tell us more what he really thinks. Poor relationships come from lots of factors. Your staff may have noticed your action to document things which might have made him anxious and stop communicating with you openly. You gave him twice as much time than others to perform work, but is the time you usually give out to others reasonable to ordinary people? I have seen a few people that just do things fast, but it wouldn't be fair to apply their standards and pace to others. Have you found out any strengths from this staff? A supervisor has to be likable from people above and under you. So usually when I see such poor relationship, I would wonder how come the manager did not win his/her own staff's heart.
Pointing out that someone missed a deadline is not hostility, it is a fact.
They get help all the time. Been here a very long time. We have a trail of saying the same things over and over. He's let IRS notices miss the deadline and doesn't even say he's sorry. Honestly we've let it go on way too long, but have had a soft spot to give him time.
Something like this happened to me. The senior would just not log in some days and then I’d have to send him emails stating facts like “hey, it’s 11am and I see you are not logged on yet. You need approval to take PTO.” And then I would have to micromanage him constantly as a result of his actions. He blamed his mental health and emailed me a 4 paragraph email saying he’s quitting and was going through a lot personally and the last straw was that I him he shouldn’t have visited a family member in the hospital. In reality, what happened was we talked about him coming into the office on a specific day because we had in-person meetings. The morning of, he texted me saying that his family member was having surgery and he was going to work from home in order to visit them. He logged off at 10 am and then never logged in until the next day. It was a routine procedure that he knew of ahead of time so I said he should have let me know before the day of.
Long story short, I made sure my superiors were aware of this behavior and included them in my meetings with him so they could see how many excuses he made for why deadlines were missed. When he sent that email, my superior said that they knew I would never say that he couldn’t see his family member. They still didn’t fire him, though, but he just eventually dropped everything and put a notice in saying he quits immediately. OP, hopefully your issue resolves itself like mine did.
I suggest to listen a DaleCarnegie podcast in their website leadership with love
Sounds like gaslighting. It all depends on how you go about the exposure. It’s definitely a balancing act and should include tact and respectfulness. a “hostile workplace“ has very specific criteria so check with HR is needed.
If possible, have an open conversation with the employee to understand their concerns and ensure your expectations were communicated clearly. Continue holding staff accountable, but reinforce an environment of fairness, support, and constructive dialogue. If the accusations persist, involving HR for guidance can help ensure proper procedures are followed and protect all parties involved.
Are you a manager? Then it is your job to make sure people are performing properly. What makes me laugh is people think they know everything about how others work when they don't work in the same room or office. Stop with the office politics. If you aren't in charge of the person and made a complaint to your supervisor then you did what needed to be done. If your boss is doing nothing about the employee then you take it to HR. If you arent a manager then you aren't is the place to delegate.
Same thing happened to me. The staff was making complaints behind me saying I did not care for their well being. I noticed the two staff kept working either from home or different offices. They only had this one client. I made the suggestion that working in the same office might be beneficial - because it is for more at times. I also was training them on how we stay organized with the client. All of this turned into me being the monster when I was just trying to teach and train .. considering they’ve only been at the firm for a few months fresh out of college.
I no longer work on this team - but I documented everything through email and when I had calls I made sure to have someone else present.
The accounting firm that I have worked over 20 years is trying to streamline processes of flow by using some sort of computer suite. Right now we have separate systems and are paperless. Looking for a better document management system that integrated with Intuit products and Thomas Reuters or something all in one that would work in a public accounting environment. Suggestions please😁
I have went to the same thing. Start documenting the errors making. Document the conversations you have about the errors. You can also document that you are providing answers to technical accounting questions which they should already know..
of evidence, you them on a pit them on a PIP
that can eventually lead to termination.