I have a new boss with objectively bad taste. He’s picked the most generic taglines from the teams that read at best like bad headlines. He doesn’t seem to understand more conceptual thinking either. Now I’m in a position where I full-heartedly disagree with how he wants to present things. What do I do?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Find a new job

likefunny

I once saw a small ad agency hire a photographer to be a Creative Director, yet he had zero conceptual ability or design experience.

Get out.

like

Maybe ask him why he likes what he likes? Start a dialogue that gives you an opportunity to explain you’re thinking?

like

The question then becomes why are generic tag lines even included in the mix?

like

RIght? Like, ever hear of a "straw dog" concept.

Taste is one of those things that can’t be taught. So he’s not going to get any better. Get out.

like

Yep those types of places will actively make you worse creative. Don’t stop being you. Or, if you want to do an experiment- purposely write the worst shit and see if he likes it. Im sure he will.

like

In the long-term, look for another job, projects laddering up to other CDs, and hope that his bad taste is the safe taste of someone with one foot out the door who’s given up the fight for good work (and eventually gets a job somewhere else).

In the short term, really make sure you’re showcasing your best, most creative ideas in a way that fits the strategy and brand. Good creatives shouldn’t need to see the same verbs and adjectives from the brief and the brand tagline to get that an idea is on-brief and on-brand, but bad CDs (and account, and clients) often do

likesmart

Leave preferably, but if you’re stuck, try exercising your empathy. Taste is by definition subjective, tho I’m sure you’re right. Maybe find the little bits of overlap where your sensibilities align and try to grow from that. Don’t make him the enemy. It won’t help. Learn anything you can from whoever’s there. And come to peace as much as possible with the fact that it’s not an auteur system. We have to work with teams. Do you best on every project and win people over with your enthusiasm, not your self-assessed taste level.

like

Maybe it’s you?

smart

The nature of taste is that it is subjective.

like

I gotta stick it out for a year, doing my best to ask questions in a conversational way …

like

You should quit. Your job I’m assuming is to support him and the company. If you don’t believe in what he’s doing you won’t be much help. You could on the other hand try and work with him a while and build some trust. Make suggestions and when he rejects them, be positive and see how you can help make his vision work.

The client specifically asked for “x”
We should include this option as an alt as it addresses “y” and let them decide.

Cash the checks, esp if he’s making the decisions during business hours. If he’s one of those geniuses that can only give notes at 1pm on a Saturday… keep cashing those checks until you find somethin new and quit.

Leave. It won’t get better.

Related Posts

Anyone here from NYC? Be cool if there was a meetup.

like

Started my law firm this month. Have a few of-counsel positions and want to do mostly litigation (civil and commercial in NY). Besides word of mouth and networking, have any of you found any websites or services that generate legitimate leads?

like

Hello, I’m about 3 and a half years as a clinical data manager. Does anyone have any advice in how I can progress my career?

like

What is COTA, for a newbie? Worth it?

like

Hi watch-lovers,
What are your thoughts on dan henry watches? Especially the 1964 bi-compass
Thank you

like

Moving to Seattle soon. I could use dates or friends 😅

like

Mercedes-Benz Research & Development India If I like a girl in office, Can I approach her directly or via social media or via teams?Tata Consultancy Infosys EY KPMG Mercedes-Benz Research & Development India Volvo

likefunny

What are pre-MBA pay bands at MBB?

like
likefunnysmart

Is it worth it to get the Amex platinum for a year for the large bonus offer if the intention is to possibly cancel it at the end of the year rather than downgrade?

like

Can anyone help me with this??
What are the differece between the two and which one should I choose?

Post Photo
like

I got a offer letter from Wipro and my stream is WSM general stream. This is a BPO right?

like

Ltts Please help me out WLB in L and T technological services

like
like

I’ve been working for my State Farm agency as a team member for 2 years. I am licensed in property and casualty as well as life and health, but only make $13 an hour. I technically can make bonuses but I’m not supposed to dig into a sale and I have to send it to a sales rep (I am service and retention mostly). My boss also has me running a retired agents office until a new one is chosen (its an hour away with no pay increase or mileage pay). Also, no benefits! Should I start job searching?

like

Me after a long day at work

Post Photo
likefunny

Two months ago applied for a "dream role" at a "dream company" (not an agency). I am qualified for the role & they are looking for ppl with agency experience. a few days after applying a recruiter

like

When you sell a dedicated website for a special deal, do you give the CRM for free? Is vTiger CRM your advice? Otherwise, what are your most common recommendations about CRM?

like

What is better hertz or Avis loyalty program? I have been on hertz (president circle status due to united status) and collected points a few free rental days now. But hertz always seems so much more expensive to me for personal trips and I end up buying Avis. Should I just shift to Avis? United has also ended its partnership with Hertz now, hence wondering.

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Thanks to the robots, there’s just not a lot left to do.

So why do we still have to spend all our waking time playing office?

likefunny

Hypothetically, what might happen, if Strat said to fishbowl they needed a virtual hug? Other than CD potentially saying something snarky and mean ...hypothetically only.

like

What’s the best agency to work at?

like

Anyone have a recommendation for books or resources on upping my sales game? Open to in person class, online class, books, etc!

like

Any fishies in new york have official snow days?

likehelpful

Best way to find a mentor? I'm trying to better my book to get better jobs but I need some guidance.

like

Considering taking a Jr CW job in pharma in NYC after being on the job hunt for 9 months. I’m terrified of getting stuck, but I also want to switch to brand strategy. Chances of escaping if I hate it?

like

Two months ago applied for a "dream role" at a "dream company" (not an agency). I am qualified for the role & they are looking for ppl with agency experience. a few days after applying a recruiter

like

If you got fired tomorrow, how long can you go without a paycheck? Assume you get 1 week of pay for every 6 months worked, and then can do unemployment after that ($425 a week)

like

I had to reject an offer from a company last year due to COVID concerns and not being able to relocate. Would it be a bad idea to reach out and inquire about it again?

like

Too late in life to start a cult? Getting kind of old for advertising.

likefunny

Any great resume-writer recos? I need help!

like

What are the best brands with work life balance? Want to leave agency and work life balance is super important, thank u!!

likehelpful

With the way this week has been going, Friday 13th with a harvest moon seems downright dangerous 🌚 halp

likefunny

Okay let's say I got a job in the marketing department at Netflix. Would it be a plus to have a company like them on my resume, or make it harder to get back into an agency later on?

like

Let’s all agree on some collective self care this week - NO early morning meetings or client deliverables the day after the election. Perhaps we extend these rules this whole week. K? Great. 😅

likeuplifting

I feel like I am not good at what I do... but don’t see myself doing anything else.

like

In your opinion, what advertising/branding/experiential agencies should someone targeting greater San Diego and Los Angeles go after? (Yes, it is very expensive to live in California)

like

Is anyone else having trouble just BEING back at the office… for a full day? Even if it’s hybrid. It’s like driving me insane just sitting here in silence and making small talk from 9-5:30. I feel so trapped.

like

In West Philadelphia born and raised...

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal