I'm struggling with students who are so afraid of failure that they're not even willing to try. Are any of you in similar situations? And/or do you have suggestions of things that have worked with your students?

If it matters, I teach high school Precalc and Calc 1.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Seems odd that students in such high level classes (obviously optional) are unwilling to try.

The tough part about Math is that you can't fake it. In most other disciplines, you can at least make a guess. But math problems (especially your level) are multistep, usually include choosing from one of a large number of formulae, doing the steps right, doing the algebra correctly, and reporting your answer correctly. If a student is weak in any one of those areas the whole thing blows up.

I was a strong algebra student who got a BS in Math and my teacher certification later. I remember my college Calculus quizzes. I knew many algorithms but couldn't always figure out which one I needed. If someone told me which formula to use, I could whip the problem right out. But minus that help, I found I had to do a lot of trial and error. I'd start with a possible formula, see if the data in the problem substituted reasonably, and hope to eventually recognize something that looked familiar. Sometimes I chose right. Sometimes I had to restart with a different formula. Sometimes I never got it.

The point is, the most difficult part for me (and I think a lot of students) is knowing how to start. Some ideas.

1. Give a lot of problems where the assignment is not to solve but to set it up. Points for choosing the right formula. Points for setting up correctly.
2. Tell them exactly what algorithm is required for a problem.
3. Maybe for tests and quizzes (since you are trying to instill independence) you could allow them to "buy" the correct starting formula for some grade points. In other words, if they aced the test but had to get all the formulae from you, the best grade they could get would be a B. To get an A, they ultimately have to be able to get there on their own.

And that is the goal. You want to wean them off dependence on you. But some need a lot of support to get to that point.

like

Awesome response

I hate, hate, hate when a student responds with idk on a test question. Surely you must know something about the question.

like

Get to know them. I give analogies, like, “does anyone play soccer? Ok, does anyone just show up to soccer practice, but just sit on the bench and watch while everyone else practices?”

Where I grew up, what you’re describing is called the “ghetto mentality.” If they don’t try, then in their minds, everything that they do is not a failure because they never tried. It’s a self-fulfilling prophesy. The only way you break it is to get them to work for you, as a person that they respect. After that, you introduce self-motivating strategies, like characterizing their work as paying themselves.

Giving a presentation about the difference in yearly and lifetime earnings between college and non-college educated people will also help. Our AVID classes usually do that, but if that isn’t happening...

like

I celebrate the failure! The only way we get better at ANYTHING is through failure.

like

Some great input here.
I am in the same situation and courses as the OP.
I have found most of my students that are struggling fall into on or more of the following categories:
1: They are putting in the time but with very low intensity (texting, music and playing games while taking notes and getting practice)
2: They are putting no time into the course
3: They are under prepared (gaps in math especially algebra skills are obvious)
4: They have reached this course with minimal effort and don't know how to study or take notes especially in what I affectionately call "a big girl math class"
5: They are overwhelmed in many high level courses and have Teri-bad time management skills
6: They have "early onset senioritis"

Though most of this is fixable with individual plans, some are very difficult to fix. I suggest asking your students to reflect on their performance and see if they can self diagnose their problems.

like

I model failure early. I often make "mistakes" in class that students can catch. This makes them more comfortable taking risks and admitting their struggles. I ask them to check me work, to model that too.

Related Posts

Hello Fishes.. Need your suggestions Wipro or Pwc India? Domain : Oracle ERP EOY : 8

like

Hey guys
Is
Salesforce hiring for platform solution engineer for mulesoft in canada, I see lot of opening but not getting any call.any reason
My skill set and resume is definitely a close match

likefunny

Hi team, I joined Accenture recently ( 20) days however I received an offer from product based company with better pay and profile.

How should I quit Accenture. Will it affect my future job prospects and I need to show this company in my resume. Will Accenture blacklist me to join in future if quit it.

Other company is aware of this situation and they don't have a problem and they have already considered me.

Result i need to give while I quit.

like

Hello Fishes, I have 3 years of experience in HR ABAP, should i further choose project in HR ABAP or should i go into generic/normal ABAP? Which has more better opportunities?

like

Hi guys,
I am currently working as a servicenow consultant in Infosys and I want to get into a BA profile in future. I have an MBA in HR and marketing and a BTech in CSE. I have already cleared my ECBA certification and I wanted to know what all skills should I acquire to transition into that role in or outside of ServiceNow.

Looking forward to your tips and suggestions

TIA

like
like

Any good and simple investing/financial Managment podcast? Looking to get more serious about my finance and don’t want to be overloaded with info

Wish we had Dhoni in this worldcup.. miss him as a Captain!

like

What is the CTC being offered at a consultant level at mastercard?

Hi,

Can you please let me know how much will be my in hand salary.

Post Photo
like

Employment post college: will internship experience or type of degree earned speak more to employers? I’m a psych major & landed a wealth & investment internship with Wells Fargo. I’m trying to break into consulting fields.

like

Hi fishes, How can I know whether my BGV completed in CTS or not?
Do I get any mail or need to check from 1C portal?

like

It’s worth it. My Animal Crossing life is so much more fulfilling than real life rn.

Post Photo
likefunny

Hello , anyone in this bowl working in the internal audit department of DB?

What do Goldman Sachs senior analysts do and what would be the average pay? Is it similar to investment banking or something different?

like
likefunny

Can anyone provide good templates for a NY law governed will and POA? I don’t practice in this area but would like to draft something super simple so my family has them in place

like

I'm considering taking on some freelance web design projects to earn a little extra cash for the holidays, any ideas on where I can find projects?

Anyone know anything about Marsh Strategic Risk Consulting?

likehelpful

I'm searching for an EA opportunity either in the LA area or remote. I'm open to working on site, hybrid, or remote and open to most industries. I've been interviewing the past 3 months after a company-wide lay off and haven't landed anything yet within my salary range or that feels like a good fit for me. Message or comment if you have any leads for me - I so appreciate it!

like

Additional Posts in Math Educators

like

I have students that need to make up a missing test. I want to keep the integrity and validity of a test.
Any suggestions??

likesmart

Who in this group does groups with Eureka Math?

like

I was given a pie for teacher appreciation week.
The note said "I figured nothing would make you happier than knowing I asked for two pi of a pie, and proceeded to try to explain the unit circle to the bakery guy at the store. Thanks, for ruining pie, but making me love pi"
I actually felt appreciated.

likeupliftingsmartfunny

How do you incorporate warm up/bell ringer problems so that kids actually complete the problems and not just use that time to socialize?

like

Anybody have a different word to use for ‘quiz?’ The kids can do the HW with me/on their own- but as soon as you pass out a quiz- everyone freezes. 🙄 I get test anxiety, seriously.

like

I am interested in pursuing a doctorate degree in Mathematics Education. Any recommendations or suggestions would be helpful!!

like
like

With kids returning physically back to school, are you planning on having students work in groups or more of individual learning? Will there be team work in your classes this year?

like

Any good, and FREE professional development out there? High school math (geometry) teacher. And yes, I realize I can pay for great classes, but I’m not 🤷🏽‍♀️

like

Any recommendations on fun games or breaks you give your students? Recently I've really been making an effort to keep things more light-hearted while still engaging them. I think everyone appreciates it but I am running out of ideas! I remember in high school I had a stats teacher who read "random facts" to start the class - both funny and interesting!

like

Hello! I’m looking for other Elementary Math educators. Preferably in the roll of Math specialist/Math Interventionist to chat about our jobs. Thanks!

like

How do you keep your material (notes/worksheets/quizzes/tests) organized? I have a hanging folder system now, but currently irritated with it. Like binders, hate 3-hole punches- love ‘clean’ paper 🥳

A little math humor 😂 translation: “vampires learning to add”

Post Photo
likefunny

I'm always looking for good technology/apps/websites to use in my HS math class. Any suggestions?!

like
likesmart
like

Does anyone pay to use the premium version of Peardeck? Is it a good resource to supplement classroom instruction or not worth it? Thanks for any info you can provide!

likehelpful

Would anyone be interested in participating in a research study? The only requirements are to be a school district employee and have a child in the district with special needs. Please help!!!

like

Geometry Teachers! Does your district classify transversal angles using the words “Consecutive” or “Same-Side”?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal