Start over completely as a BA at McKinsey, join S& as an A3, or EYP as an SA?
Comp: McK- $115k S&: $100k; EYP: 135K. All have bonuses but idk what they are yet.

Could you please rank these if you had opportunities for all of them? Assume 2YOE just starting C at Deloitte. Thanks :)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Bonuses are EYP are negligible. Though after one year you'll be at 170 base so that'll be good

✋ for getting 2 written offers!!

McKinsey if you can get in. S& next if you’re in a Booz-heavy group. EYP next.

EYP bonuses are 5-10%. S& are double for a middle performer and triple for a top performer. And your base at S& will be 148k in your second year. So make the decision on experience rather than money there

like

I think our Fit for Growth platform came from leaders in the Org Strategy group. So actually may be a pretty strong group.

Recent IconRecent

You’re getting base $115k at McKinsey? That’s not fresh BA. I think I would lean McKinsey if I were you. It looks like the comp difference isn’t that big of a deal, but the brand gap is. If you were coming in at the post-MBA position for S& or EYP then my answer would be different, but you’re not.

like

Well that is either all in comp and the recruiter misspoke, or it’s a Senior BA role. So you should clarify if it actually becomes relevant.

EYP→ McK → S&

like

This is what I’m thinking too tbh

like

Do you have all of these offers? But Mck or EYP depending on when you’re planning to leave consulting

like

I would say take EYP then - you’ll get 170K in a year and it’s not industry aligned

like

A3 at S& means you’re less than a year away from making 150k base / 200k all in, the jump between A and SA is big

like

I believe you can be A3B at Strategy& if you need an extra year. But it’s not as common

I feel like mck for better brand and long-term growth? Ey wouldn't be bad either. What's the work look like for both roles?

Related Posts

What’s the typical salary for an Associate Account Director in NYC working on Pharma?

likehelpful
like

What is revenge Job Hopping?

It is a phenomenon observed when a candidate frequently jumps job in order to have a market correction to his salary.
Say person A got settled in his job for 5 years and his current salary is 7lpa..He joined at 4 lpa.
Now for his experience, he can be paid upto 30 lpa for the role.
So after switching for 13 lpa.. He keeps job hopping from 13-19 and 19-28 within a year where he finally feels he is paid adequately.

like

Exit opps at a manager level - Big4 vs industry jobs? Security Architect at FAANG vs the normal career path at PwC. If compensation being slightly better at FAANG, which one would you pick and why

like

Hey fishes,
I’m bit bad at calculations of take home salary.
Can someone please help me out in knowing the take home salary?
Note : I have declared 1.50 in 80C and HRA as 15k month !
Thanks in advance to all the fishes !

Post Photo
like

For a 3 Year Experienced React Developer shifting from Service based company which is better Comcast or Verizon? Pay wise 1.5 LPA is the difference between two companies. Designation is same. Both have variable pay upto 10%.

like

Hi

For some reason TCS HR did not responded on quoted compensation and was lowballing. The call was not fruitful. As i have already resigned not sure even if they release the offer letter no.

Can you please help me on finding jobs for Devops 10 YOE.

like

Kyndryl Or Atos??

Kyndryl is offering 2 lakh more for Microsoft Technologies SME role

like

In-hand for below offer?

Post Photo
like

Hi everyone, I got hired on as entry level sales operations role back in January. It quickly turned into sales, and eventually all the sales for the small company once the head of sales left. I am happy to take on the additional role for my company, and they are going to let me. But they feel that without multiple people in a sales department the title head of sales might not be the best title. I have input in what my updated position title and salary would be. What should I ask for?

like

Microsoft, Salesforce, Amazon? Same TC.

like

What is project specific BGC in TCS?

like

Can we talk about Rates?
What is your:
1) hourly rate
2) years of practice
3) size firm
4) state

My answers:
1) $350/hr
2) 5 years
3) solo practitioner
4) New York

like

Got an offer from Kantar Consulting to work on their retail/cpg product.
Currently working with IBM with 10+ yoe having joined IBM 10 months back. Currently at 25 lpa and getting an offer of 32 fixed+15% variable.

Now my question is - Is it worth the gamble to leave IBM and join Kantar consulting which btw is known for market research and not consulting.
Also would leaving IBM after 1 year look bad on CV?

like

Has anyone requested for an experience letter from Deloitte for Canada PR? The automated letter doesn’t provide job responsibilities. I requested an exception and they want to know the reason for it.

Leaving my current job for a career pivot. Current job has been challenging to say the least and senior management never hears what others have to say. Employment is an at will state.
Senior leadership is so unforgiving that I fear by giving notice, I’ll be asked to leave and lose out on two weeks pay.
Thoughts and feedback on not giving notice or reducing the typical two weeks?
Thank you!

like

What's the longest amount of time before starting a new role that you've been able to negotiate with a company?

like

Anyone in EY Advisory in NYC know how annual pay increases are distributed as a staff? I’ll be in tech advisory and have heard of pay increases from 5% to 12%. Is it domain or performance based?

Hey guys,

I have an interview at Microsoft next week for the role of SharePoint consultant. What should my preparation be like?

Any idea about compensation of Deloitte Netherlands? Yoe: 7 years Deloitte Nagarro Deloitte

like

More Posts

Is the executive order from June impacting people who had an h1b stamped and moved jobs? Since the h1b would need an amendment if someone changes jobs, would that pose a risk? Any folks who have moved jobs on h1b in the last month or so?

like

Any F in the Bay Area wana have some exciting time?

funnylike

Is there anyone in this bowl who has switched to GSK from ZS. I have few questions. Won't waste much of your time. Please let me know if we can connect over DM.

Thanks :)

like
likehelpful

I believe improving one’s sales conversion rate is something everyone want to improve but no one wants to admit they would like to work it. Funny how lawyers will spend thousands on seminars to improve trial skills. But this topic is not discussed in our profession. I have read books in sales. But am unable to find any for lawyers. I want convert every lead I can. Does anyone have tips, books, cle’s or studied this topic?

like

I have 11 years of experience in Automation Development and currently in RPA development. What is an average salary for an associate with 11 years of experience

like

Any Hilton recs in Charleston?

This would be hilarious if it weren’t an indictment on an American president.

Post Photo
likesmartfunnyhelpful

Deloitte New Member makes me want to apply to Deloitte.

likefunny
like

McKinsey & Company Where do McKinsey employees usually invest their money in India? McKinsey & Company

like

Do people in studios get paid substantially more than other offerings or practice (exploring to switch, thus asking)? what is the average consultant income bracket in studio? I was also wondering if anyone aware of gender centric wage disparity in DUSI?

I had a call w/ a recruiter and after hearing about the job, I *really* want it. But I’m worried I priced myself out of the role. I sent my resume/portfolio after and haven’t even gotten a reply that she received it, and I’ve followed up. I’ve been getting recruiter messages offering salaries up to 120k for copy/senior copy roles (which surprised me) so I gave 110-120 as a range on the call. She hesitantly said she thought 115 would be OK. But wondering if the salary could be the issue? Thought?

like

anyone else hype about the new macbooks 👀

already pre-ordered

with apple silicon, adobe better get indesign running faster than i’ve ever seen it.

like

Is there any remote work available with base pay?? I’ve exhausted myself with Indeed, Zip Recruiter, and Glassdoor job searches and my unemployment is over 😭😭

like

UI designers everywhere: Please stop making “peek-a-boo-only” interfaces.

likefunny

Reason #101 why noise canceling headphones & drinks are critical (when status can’t solve travel nightmares)

Post Photo
likefunnysmart

Deloitte OP is an imposter 🐝

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Kinda feel the same way when writing a business proposal, then defending it.

Post Photo
likefunny

Anyone want to aspire and get their real estate licenses together for a side hustle?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

Any folks at EY willing to refer ?

like

Just switched firms, in hopes of greener pastures....and I’m miserable. Not totally sure where to head next, debating some non-traditional means of employment/next steps. I def can spin the story but am I risking my whole career if I say, took less ‘prestigious’ role for the next year? I just need to mentally recover...feels like I’m losing time off my life longevity for $$$. Just looking for others thoughts or real life examples

like

Interviewed for internal manager role at BCG and moved to second round but across another role at BCG that is a better fit. Should I tell the recruiter and withdraw from the current interview process?

like

What are the pros and cons for working at your consulting firm? (salary, benefits, culture, growth opportunities, international projects , etc). Trying to figure out where I might want to go next.

likefunny

Has hiring slowed down?

like

Anyone know if any Tech/FAANG companies hiring in Sourcing and Supply Chain management roles?

like

If you exit after your first promo (~2 YOE), what level roles can you expect to be competitive for in industry? Analyst/sr analyst?

like

Best books about product management for a good exit to industry? I already have an MBA and PMP but looking for a refreshed perspective since it’s been years since my formal education.

Currently reading “Product Managements Sacred Seven” but it’s geared toward the startup world. I am in healthcare and not looking for a startup role. TIA!!!

like

Completed final round interview at FAANG last month and was told that if all looks well with headcount on 10/01, they will reach out on my status. After I reached out on Friday on headcount update, if HR doesnt respond after few days should I not follow up anymore and move on or follow up once more even if they dont respond?

like
like

Is anyone willing to refer to a major retailer in the US (Walmart, Krogers, Walgreens etc) for an intern role in finance? 🙇‍♂️

like

Have been approached for a "Transformation Officer" role at a PE held port co with high probability of getting it. Torn staying in consulting ( 1.5 year post MBA till now) or new role? Suggestions?

What to do if you love consulting work but hate the travel?

like

Can anyone share any insights on Guidehouse Healthcare Strategy - comp, type of work, culture, etc?

like

Just got confirmation that my background check went through successfully! Can I give my 2 weeks today itself or is it standard to do it on Friday/Monday?

like

Would you take a paycut / same salary you were making to move from NYC to Philadelphia, if the role was an industry opportunity in the tech/product space and more aligned with your interests and career goals?

Always read about people moving to industry for 20%+ increases with RSUs, but the offer for my move is about the same I'm making now in NYC. Think I will take it anyway but curious to hear the consensus view.

like

Be honest, does company name matter. Looking to exit and some nice startups have approached me. They have less than a 100 employees. Pay is double my current pay.

like

How is EY tech practice in SAP? Looking for SM role in EY? How is the comp and working environment?

like

Phone screen with Accenture Federal Services this week. Recruiter found me on LinkedIn and set up 30 mins on my calendar to chat. Said camera is not required because it will be a casual chat. What should I expect here?

like

Want to take a 1 week vacation solo between jobs in 2 weeks. Any recommendations? Budget of about 1.5K for flight + hotel / stay accommodation. Based in Chicago.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal