Considering GLC vs Q5 vs X5 ... any thoughts? Are these German models really that unreliable with maintenance?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Not to split hairs, but X3 is the BMW equivalent of Q5 and GLC.

Ultimately you can’t go wrong with any of these. Personally I grew up with BMW and am partial to them (plus I think they have the strongest tech integrations), however all of these cars will be good. If you are buying new, don’t worry about reliability… shouldn’t be a concern during the 3-5 years you’ll have the car and will be covered under warranty.

likesmart

Doesn’t matter which model, the BMW is always the answer

funny

Depends what you value
BMW - performance and driving dynamics
Mercedes - comfort and refinement
Audi - good at everything, great at nothing

Edit: I’ve owned a GLC, iX, and C300.
GLC - zero issues, was very solid
iX - very solidly built (amazing fit and finishing) but has had annoying tech issues - key fob battery replaced 4 times within a year and each required a service appointment and had to leave car there overnight 3 times. Sometimes doors won’t open (have to push button 10 times before it opens). CarPlay doesn’t connect maybe 5% of the time.
C300 - has some annoying interior creaks from the plastic but otherwise solid

like

If I were single with no kids, I’d go with a CPO Macan 😈

If considering X5, a few points: folks can get 8-10% off in stock models (can get close to the same if you negotiate on a custom order) and BMW is doing 0.9% financing on X5s right now. Free money.

like

These are all completely different sizes. GLC is the smallest, followed by the Q5 then X5. From personal experience I’d avoid the Mercedes and lean toward the Audi or BMW, depending on your size preference and budget. Try to negotiate included maintenance and extended warranties.

That’s fine - just wanted to clear it up. I’d still avoid the GLC

like

I love my X4 and E400 coupe. The X6 would have been a bit more convenient over the years for the extra size, though now that we are down to one pre-teen at home vehicle space is less of an issue. Even still, more space would be nice. I mentioned the E400 to say that I love the build quality, quiet engine, and smooth ride, and I would imagine having no issues owning a GLE.

Post warranty I've done all the maintenance myself without issue. If you aren't handy a local shop won't charge the luxury rate, though new parts can be expensive. Neither car has been less reliable than my Fords over the years.

My GLC63s has had zero issues. 2020 model.

Same, had the exact year/model in alpine. Miss that car

like

Related Posts

I interviewed at Amazon for a PM role in Dec. 2020 and was ultimely rejected. I was told I have to wait a year to reapply. Fast forward to June 2022, another recruiter reaches out to me re: a PM role. I pass the screening interview, and move on to the virtual on site interview stage. I randomly get a call from the recruiter telling me there is now a TWO YEAR reapply policy in place so I'm not eligible to interview for any PM roles until Dec. 2022. Anyone ever heard of this policy? Seems strange

like

Can someone please refer me to Walmart?
I have the job ids

like

An out of office email i read somewhere.

Hi,

Thanks for your email. I am currently OoO.
For emergencies conatct below
USI -112
US - 911

All other things can be taken care when i am back.

funnylike

I've been approached about being an expert consultant. Has anyone done this before? I'm interested to hear people's experience.

like

Anyone from Google willing to refer? Or perhaps have any tips on the application process and interviews?

like

Hey folks, I’m about a year into my new SE career and looking to continue to invest in professional skills. I’ve obviously been thrown into the fire learning the sales side of things, but what areas (technical skills, certs, books, etc.) you all would recommend I look to invest in? I’ve been looking at some beginner coding boot camps and scrum product owner certs, but interested in what you all have done to further advance your career

like

Got a personal email from HR asking to evaluate our executive team’s performance. Thinking this is a no win situation.

likefunny

Hi Fishes, I am looking for a new role / job change into Broker Vote or Reference data.
Having experience in (Client Strategy)Broker Vote, Deep Dive Analysis, Account Review Meetings, Consumption Reporting, Reference data, Corporate Access, Corporate Actions.

like

Anyone at Capital One willing to provide a referral?

like

What’s your top 5 companies in the world you want to or have worked for? Any industry.

likefunny

How to check if Bgv is completed or not ?

like

I had Technical and Managerial discussion with TCS on 2 sept. I was told I will get HR call.Then on 11th sept i got onboarding email to submit documents and the next day all the documents got verified but since then I didn't get any update and it has been more than two weeks.Ibegin portal shows evaluation in progress. Any idea if they will be sending an offer?

How much more, if at all, do Cravath / Wachtell attorneys work than S&C, Skadden, Davis Polk etc.

likesmart

Who feels this way sometimes? Haha

Post Photo
likefunnyupliftingsmarthelpful

Why are some entries on the creative circle shortlist in red? Have they accidentally leaked the gold award winners?

like

Any agencies going back into the office next week? We’re finding remote work is more productive, and safer right now.

like

Hi fishes,
I have 4.5 years of experience in .net and angular in cognizant I'm working I got call from
Genpact but In Genpact they are asking me join as lead consultant is it normal software engineer position or what any idea ..for only 4.5exp is it sufficient for lead consultant position.. firstly what is the responsibilities for lead consultant in GenpactGenpact

like

Do McKinsey make your own slides or do you outsource it all to your graphics team? Asking specifically for NA.

like

I want to know how UBS (UK) reach out to you for interview purposes I mean through a phone call or over the email.

like

Which advisory group has the least travel out of AAS, FDD/TAS, and risk advisory? Or is it all dependent on the client and team nowadays? And is the travel schedule comparable to consulting? (ex. M-Th on a plane)

Additional Posts in Automotive

911 Carrera S vs GTS

I really want to do a low key spec on my next car but it’s almost impossible to spec the GTS without black wheels/accents turning it into a more aggressive looking car.

Thoughts on if the GTS in a 7 speed is more engaging than the S enough to justify the compromise in wheel selection?

Post Photo
like

Anyone have experience with the 2014-2016 Audi diesel sedans ?

like

Can anyone share hands on/ownership experience with a CX-30?

like

The new X7 looks like a faakin’ Kia….

likefunny

Is the 2018 Macan turbo w perf. Pkg the best Macan ever made?

like

For me the Mclaren P1 is the best car in the world? Which is your favorite car and why?

like

Thoughts on buying an older Aston Martin? (mid-late 2000s DB9, V8 Vantage, etc.)

like

Thoughts on new M3? 😍😍

like

Whats the most reliable among german cars? I am worried about paying a lot for maintenance and repairs but also dont want a japanese tin can

like

Can we consider cars from the 90s to be classics?

Sub question: what's your favorite 90s-era car? Extra points for pics.

like

Is Carvana legit? I've never seen any reviews just a hundred commercials. I could google this but wanted to know if anyone in here sold through them successfully. Thinking of selling my Benz E350, 2013. Let me know.

like

Been seeing a lot of gt500 slander in this bowl what’s up with that 🤔

like

Alright auto fishes, I’m in the market for a entry level luxury car. Open to used or a lease. I don’t plan to use it as a daily driver, live in an HCOL. Only restriction is that I’d like to keep my monthly costs at no more than $600-$700/month (including insurance, financing / fees, etc; have a parking spot already). Doesn’t have to be a European badge. Thoughts?

like

Thoughts on the S5 sport back? Better alternatives? Reviews? Hate it? Love it?

like

Not the typical post seen in this bowl, but I would hope someone appreciates it, spotted at a local cars and coffee.

Post Photo
like

How to best calculate the loss of value(diminished value)to my car due an accident? Insurance agency quoted a really lower amount.

like

Going to Italy end of October, planning on visiting the Lamborghini and Ferrari museums. Which Ferrari museum is better? Modena or Maranello? Or is it worth it to visit both?

like

Which would you pick:

Range Rover Classic (c. 1992)

OR

Hummer H1 (c. 2003)

like

I own a 1973 Chevy nova and and a 1988 Dodge ramcharger. Eventually I want to put a 6.6L duramax in the nova, and make it into a sleeper/fun weekend car, restomod the interior for comfort, convenience and tech etc. Then I want to put a Cummins in the Ramcharger and make it into kind of an overland/back country truck that I can still take down the road to get to the back country. Also restomod it for comfort, convenience and tech. Thoughts ?

like

Will mods hurt the resale value of a car? I'm considering selling my daily and am debating on whether or not I should put the effort in to return it to stock.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal