Do you honestly believe law is a meritocracy? Or is it mostly politics, connections, and luck once you get past a certain level?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Definitely not a meritocracy. Lots of politics, ass-kissing, and luck. Not saying being good is not necessary. But being mediocre and being a master at politics is more likely to get you there than being amazing substantively and being an a-hole.

likesmart

I'm not sure it's an either or situation. Politics and connections won't get you to partner if you're bad at what you do.

like

Have a lot of behind-the-scenes experience that says otherwise.

like

Once again for the kids in the back: “put your head down, work hard, and you’ll be rewarded” is a lie told to children to keep them obedient. In nearly any profession, advancing requires more than just technical competency.

like

Asked and answered

like

There is no such thing as a meritocracy anywhere in human society.

I think it’s fair to describe law as a profession that is more meritocratic than many others, but other elements are hugely important to be successful.

like

Billing a lot of hours and doing exceptional work can get you a long way. But it’s not going to get you chosen to go to the client meetings or to the informal business dinners or drinks with those who make decisions. It’s well documented that attractive people are treated better, make more money, get promoted more often, etc. I think it’s the same thing in the legal field. Sometimes being attractive will mean being physically attractive, other times it will mean being a bro who plays golf, or a woman who can handle sitting through a dinner with only men. It comes down to this - by the time you get to the interview stage, the expectation is that you’re qualified to do the work, but people are going to hire you based on whether they want to hang out with you or whether they think the clients will want to hang out with you. Life is just like high school over and over and over again.

like

Define merit. Pre-existing connections aside, soft skills and hustle in making connections and meeting people is just as important as legal skill. If you’re a litigator going to jury trial, soft skills ARE legal skill.

like

It's not a meritocracy. Knowing the right people and having them in your corner is key.

like

It is a meritocracy- at least at my firm. You advance as far as your ability and effort take you. The other consideration is having clients, which I suppose may be impacted by factors other than merit in some cases. But having clients is not necessary to become a working partner here. Only necessary to become a rainmaker.

I have not seen “luck,” “politics” or “connections” playing any role in anything (except for rainmakers who have clients via connections). I have seen people’s advancement and stature within the firm pretty much perfectly mirror their competence.

Our business model is originating, managing and trying complex cases and I have found that the partners (and senior associates) are quite adept at determining who is good at those things. Their own success and compensation depends on it.

I have heard a few people complain over the years about not advancing for reasons they think are unfair, but without fail, the actual reasons have been fair - namely, that they are incompetent (or at least not nearly as good as they think they are).

Lucky you

Related Posts

Whomever is doing the tv placement for Advocate Healthcare in Chicago: do you have to have the ad going every other commercial? If I hear “come on get healthy” one more time, I’m leaving the state.

likefunny

It’s hard to be motivated when rounds of layoffs happen and you see all your friends leave. But one thing that’s gotten me through all of this is working out. And when I say workout I mean the most pathetic, sad, barely completed beginner-level cardio dance routines. I’ve somehow forced myself to move while on lockdown and it’s somehow forced me to feel better. Whatever you’re doing, wherever you are: get up and move even if you don’t finish or end up going on a walk. Pls take care of yourself❤️

like

Workout before (4:30 am) or after (6:30ish) work?

like

so turns out BLR office peeps are spreading covid to fellow coworkers… leadership plz send help

Has anyone ever pivoted to Product Manager at big tech? Thinking about making a switch and would love to hear some of y’all’s experience. Thanks in advance!

like
like

How is interview process at Nvidia ? How many rounds for 11 yoe , sr. system s/w engineer role.

How much time nvidia takes to finish all interviews and if everything goes well how much time to release offer ?

I am done with 1st technical interview. 2 more technical round schedule. Which kind of questions to expect in 2nd & 3rd round ?

like

Hi fishes, How Risk Mitigation team is in Citi?? I will be working on Global CRM financial application. How is the work here? Is there WLB ?

like

Anyone have a feel for the networking value at Union League Club or any other city clubs for lawyers under 40?

like

Anyone currently working at Peloton and able to provide a reference for a Senior Product Manager role? Thanks!

like

Feel like I missed the boat years back to get into Director of Product role. Back in the day there was only Senior in between a Director role, now there’s Lead and Group levels, so much hierarchy now.

like

Hoping to receive a referral to McKinsey or BCG for a generalist consulting or communications focused role. I have over 2 YOE at Deloitte and enjoy market research and strategic communications. Looking to hone in on that passion and make a switch to a more specialized role. Would be happy to send resume and chat to see if there’s a good fit. Thanks so much!

Which consulting firms are hiring for experienced Associate position? Have a friend who got laid off and looking for another job.

like

Hi Folks,
EY GDS is hiring for multiple roles spanned across Data Visualization, Data Engineering, Digital, Data Science, QA, RPA, UI. DM me for complete Job Description and Referral for a suitable opening.

Post Photo
likehelpful

Does Google value FAANG experience over consulting? Say if a person is trying to get into Google from Apple, will it be considered easier?

like

Acceptance is the answer.

Post Photo
like

Favorite song right now. Mines "Wherever I Go" one republic

like

Any thoughtworkers with 5 years of experience in Full Stack Development? How much does thoughtworks pay in average for 5 YOE?

like

Hey guys! What is the standard CTC for a non-qualified in Big 4 currently with 5 years of experience?

like

Additional Posts in Law

Well I learned my lesson. Never work with Wells Fargo. Any good banks I should switch to?

like

Any non-US lawyers who have been hired by an Am100 firm without having sat the bar? Looking for an opportunity in the US, if possible DC or NYC, and currently working for Big Law in Europe.

Would like some tips re hiring process + visa from those who have succeeded. Looking for a 1-2 year stay and open for longer term

like

Parental leave: do you have to be at a company or firm for a year before being eligible to take parental leave? Are there any companies/firms that don't have this requirement?

like

Mid-level associate at a mid-size regional insurance defense firm practicing coverage litigation. Salary is capped b/c my firm only does I.D./coverage and has no direct-hire comm clients. Second round of interviews with a comm lit boutique where I would be the only associate with 5 partners. Other than partner track, salary/benefits, and switching from coverage to general comm lit, what qualities of the move should I be thinking about as I weigh my options? I've never worked at another firm.

like

When negotiating a sign on bonus with a new firm based on the fact that you were anticipating a bonus for that fiscal year and are leaving before that is paid out, do you have to do anything to prove you would have actually received a bonus/the amount of bonus you would have received?

like

I’m my partners only associate and I went on parental leave two weeks ago. I feel horrible for leaving him to handle our cases alone, but am trying to focus on my wife and new baby. That being said, should I still offer to handle minor matters that come in to ease the workload off my boss? He’s been super cool during my entire leave, so I don’t feel pressured to one bit.

like

I am concerned with fulfilling billable hours requirement. I’m required to hit 2100 hours yearly and I’m at ~1,500 hours and I think I’ll hit 150-180hours this month. What will happen if I don’t hit my targeted amount by the end of my year.

likehelpful

I went through all the stages of interviewing with a firm then they chose not to fill the position. They said internal priorities changed. I saw about 5 months later they posted a similar position. Guess who has another interview!

like

Which one would you choose?

1) Am100 firm with 1900+ billable hour requirement, very reputable in the region
2) Am200 firm with 1750+ billable hour requirement, less reputable in the region because it’s a satellite office, pays $35k less than option 1

like

Best divorce lawyer in NYC?

like

Tips on discussing reimbursement for travel expenses during the “interview” process? I was invited to travel to a different state to discuss joining a firm. Should I even bring up the topic of expenses , or just pay my own way?

like

Brand new baby lawyer dumb question - I am tasked with drafting response to request to produce. How long should this take? And follow up… how do I bill this?

like

Anyone here work in litigation for a few years after law school, and then leave to clerk for a federal judge for 2 years? If so, did you have any difficulty finding a job at a law firm for after the clerkship is over / did this set back your career progression law firm-wise at all?

like

Does anyone enjoy lender work? If so, what about it did you find appealing? I’ve somehow been saddled with all the lender work at my firm (despite never having expressed an interest in it and having no experience with it) and it’s miserable. Having said that, our other practice areas are slowing down significantly and I don’t know if I want to rock the boat. Any advice would be much appreciated!

like

Does anyone else work as in-house for government? Local? Provincial/State? Federal?

Thinking about applying as a lateral to Quinn Emmanuel LA. Thoughts on hours, etc.?

like

Does anyone know the salary for a westlaw account executive? also a contact for a westlaw recruiter?

like

I am traveling out of town for callback interviews. One firm wants me to commit a full day of interviews. Would it be reasonable to ask for a half day so I can fit 2 callbacks in the same day?

like

I’m on the Board of entity A (volunteer basis) and I’ll have an interview for a legal counsel position at entity B. Entity A and B have a partnership such that me working for entity B will create conflict of interest. Should I disclose my relationship with entity A during the initial interview with entity B’s hiring manager? If so, what should I say? I don’t want my volunteer job at entity A potentially jeopardizes my full-time job at entity B.

like

I have an interview at a firm that focuses on criminal defense. I currently work in ID and have years of previous PD experience. I’ve never worked in private criminal defense. What questions should I ask in the interview? What should be looking at to evaluate whether it is a good practice?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal