I got a McKinsey offer last week (North America) and here are my reflections:
- PEI is slightly more important than the case but case prep takes more time
- Casing methodology is more important than how you ace the case (I'm grateful to my coach for pointing this out to me early on)
- Many people, including experienced casers, have no.idea about PEI. Be careful on receiving feedback from random folks

[IMPORTANT] Direct feedback, even offensive ones, is the way to get ahead (cont. in comments)

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Congrats on the offer and welcome! One note - not sure where you heard that PEI is more important than the case. Both are important

likefunny

What is PEI?

I can relate to parts of this OP. In my own experience, it is most important to select people with whom to case/PEI that (1) know you well enough to push you to your potential and (2) trust you enough to do what is necessary to get you there. It’s only offensive if you get offended so create safe space.

helpful

Thanks, M3.

like
Recent IconRecent

Regarding direct comments - many people (including experienced casers and current MBB consultants) are afraid to say it "as it is" thinking they would offend you or concerned about being perceived as unprofessional. This is a genuine problem in case prep. Find those who can give you direct feedback and tolerate them even if they sound mean or insulting.

like

Feel free to ask any questions here or through DM

Is this a post MBA role? What type of prior work experience did you have?

Private school in the South

OP - Congrats! Can you tell a bit about your coach? Tbh, I am skeptical about the value they offer.

Ex-McKinsey consultant, has great insights about how McKinsey interviewers think, not a clock-watcher (which I love), tough feedback but may sound rude

likehelpful

How did you prep for PEI?

PEI was mostly guided by my coach. I had my stories, and he would comment on them. Sometimes, he pointed out what I thought to be a personal impact story is in fact an inclusive leadership story. That was an eye-opener.

smart

F

How much did your coach charge? How many sessions did you need?

Related Posts

Anyone selling a Mitsubishi Outlander in the NE tristate area?

Or really any van/SUV under that has third row seating and decent safety features. Preferably under 100K miles.

like

What sort of opportunities are available in Canadian government for commercial insurance professionals?

like

Can someone give some input on the difference between an Underwriter and an Underwriting Analyst? I'm finding a lot of companies use this title synonymously.

like

This executive I support has given me an e-gift card for the 3rd time in the past 5 months. Each gift card is $300.

I had already told him monetary awards were not necessary as the "thank-you" and words of appreciation were enough for me.

Is it normal to receive such large monetary awards? I think 50~100 is acceptable

like

I had an interview with IBM for band 8 , completed salary discussion with HR and Bgv forms.HR was told yesterday that I will be getting offer letter today but when I check with HR today she was saying g that the position is on hold and let me know after a week.

May I know whether I will get offer letter by next week.

like

Hi Fishes,
How is work culture, job security in Tech M. I have offer from Tech M and from other companies and Tech M is paying more

like

Tips to build my brand and network as a junior practitioner navigates their career to the next level at the firm?

like

How to tackle gap periods in IT interviews?

like

Long drive tomorrow. Does anyone know of any on demand CFP continue education courses out there? I’d love to knock out 15 hrs of CE on this drive, if able. 🤦‍♂️🔫🤢

like

Hello Team,
I had recently applied for Technical solutions specialist - Infrastructure.
Not sure why my resume got rejected.
I highly doubt the resume got rejected by some automation tool.
Is there a way my resume can directly reach to hiring managers?

like

For those who have been driving the daily thread posts (senior tax accountant / KPMG / etc) please DM me if interested in becoming a community leader for this bowl. I’ll put you in touch with Sam from Fishbowl. Thanks!

likeuplifting

I know that people say it’s all about story, but with a certain gpa/gmat score is there a “floor” that you’re safe on? For example would someone with 4.0/780 (not me) be pretty much assured at least 1 M7? Or is there a reasonable chance that all M7s will reject them? Or is their floor just lower (T15 for example)?

like

Thoughts on inviting co-workers to your wedding? I joined a new team a year ago during the pandemic and haven’t met them in person - I’ve developed some cordial working relationships but not sure if I’d consider them wedding close! Any thoughts or advice?

likefunny

What is flexible compensation in KPMG? Is it like variable pay which depends on company’s performance or your rating? And what is the % of performance bonus which we can expect?

like

Will anyone be in Ghana this December participating in Ghana’s “Year of Return” initiative?

like

Has anyone tried AdvisoryCloud ?? Is it worth it ??

like

I have newly joined KGS but still at home location wfh, i was told by a colleague that they received an invite for a New year party for all KGS employees on 20th dec, does anyone receive it? Can I attend it from a different office than the base branch?

like

Who is working on Walgreens pitch?

Ogilvy + WundermanThompson?
McGarry?
DDB? Energy BBDO?

like

What's the best comms agency you've worked at where TEAMS actually communicate well?

like

Additional Posts in Case Interview Prep

I am having final rounds with consulting firms and corp strategy soon and I am looking to do a couple of cases with experienced caser (25+) in the next couple of days. Anyone wants to practice?

like

💪BEST STUDY TIPS THREAD:

Drop your top tips, ninja tricks, and most important intel in the comments below! 👇

likehelpful

I need to do a case prep. Let me know if anyone is available today or tomorrow? Based on ET

like

What books have the best Mckinsey style cases?
Currently using Hacking the case interview and the case interview:20 days to ace the case. TIA!!!

like

Please wish me luck on my final interview today. The salary would be life changing for me. 😬

likeuplifting

When doing profitability calculation or NPV, do interviewers usually ask candidates to come up with their own estimates/assumptions for costs, both one-time and recurring?

Does anyone in LA want to practice cases?

Looking for McKinsey PEI prep buddies - final round next week!

like

Looking for a casing buddy! Fairly new to casing and come from a science background not business. 2nd round BCG interview coming up. :)

like

Hi all,
Does anyone have any availability to case prep today? Based in ET and looking for someone relatively experienced. I’ve done/given around 20 cases

like

Hi all, for anyone that’s gone through associate level interview at McK, can you speak to the turnaround time for offer after final interview?

like

Just found out, I'll be interviewing for a role at BCG next month. Does anyone want to practice casing together?

like

McKinsey & Company Any experienced McKinsey casers interested in casing? Prepping for second round in Canada McKinsey & Company

like

Anyone down to practice case this weekend. Have an interview early next week.

like

Best tips for studying/prepping for case interviews? I am overwhelmed.

like

I seem to always bomb the first round of any case interviews despite practicing and prepping… Anyone have any tips or am i just stupid? 😂

like

Have interviews coming up for McKinsey- any suggestions on how to prepare? Also if someone would like to case me?

like

Anyone interviewing with Simon Kucher for healthcare? Let’s chat!

like

Anyone looking to case in the next few days?

like

Outside of practicing with a partner, what are you guys doing for prep? I’ve looked at LOMS but wondering if it would be enough.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal