I guess I'm just wondering...are government jobs all they're really cracked up to be? Is the job security and benefits really worth it for whatever the cons are? Trying to figure out if this is the route I should be looking at.

Post Photo
like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

So, I've been with the Government for years now. Started in uniform, and now, as a civilian. There are a number of things that must be said about working for the US Gov. as a civilian.
1. The bureaucracy is so huge, so far reaching, it's really quite something to see. Change in Gov. comes about VERY slowly, if at all. This has lead to institutionalized mediocrity and the classic "lazy" government worker. It's quite common-place to see people sitting around, chatting for many HOURS per day about anything BUT work.
2. Leadership is deeply entrenched, and poor performers are "promoted" away when firing them becomes too costly. Want to get in good with the boss? Go golfing with the guy, and join the same clubs. If you think that calling attention to issues that need to be fixed will get you brownie points, think again.
3. There is a never ending baseline of lip-service. You are absolutely expected to be a 'true-believer' in each and every 'program'. While the top-dogs will say so....i.e. "we promote and value diversity", it's still VERY much a good-ol'-boys club.
4. Benefit packages are good, but pay is FAR below private sector.
5. You will expend copious amounts of time protecting yourself from 'leadership', and completely inept management.
6. Personality conflicts are the norm; and if you find yourself on the 'outs' with the boss, you are in for a really rough ride.
7. If they can't terminate you for cause, they'll make you so miserable, (constant office / cube changes / re-orgs PIPs) that you'll go of your own volition.
8. Bosses setting you up for failure is the norm.
9. Nepotism, and cronyism are RIFE! Where I work even just a glance at the distro or the org-chart reveals a phenomenal number of 'husband-wife', cousins, paa-paw, maa-maw, and uncles, nieces all working on the same base. One trick that is used is the "contractor" route. Get the wife a job as a contractor, then they "write" on a Gov. job and... just like that whole families work in the same facility. The other trick is... "I'll hire your wife... if YOU hire my son"... sort of thing.
10. Overqualified people are habitually assigned well below their skill sets. Engineers are consistently pushed into business and management roles for which they are completely ill suited, not to mention untrained and un-educated. Those with business experience, and even advanced degrees find themselves in the bottomless pit of miss-categorized hoards driving forklifts, pushing boxes around and patently degrading and humiliating "task".
11. Nativism is also RIFE! If 'you ain't from 'round heere"... well now, you simply are not going to fit in. Frequently in my building you'll be asked 'what school ja go to'... well, they mean HIGHSCHOOL, and truly, their world-vision ends at the county line. You will be setup for failure, and habitually shunted off to the worst desk, in the worst room at the back of the building. Don't ever rock the boat, and calling OSHA will get you black-listed permanently.

likesmart

I just retired from DHS. And the bureaucracy. Is crazy and yes you dont wNt to rock the boat for sure. 

Every job, sector, industry has its pros and cons. I think the overall pros of government jobs outweigh the negatives for me. Especially the benefits, they cannot be beat. It’s one of the few things that offers a pension anymore and that is huge for me. But to each their own, different people want different things and some people could make more than enough to live great and save for retirement in the private sector.

like

It very much depends on the specific job, of course. And with that, it can depend on the agency or organization (and whether state, local, or federal). But generally speaking you have a good idea going in what is expected of you, and things do tend to be more steady than employment in the private sector. It may not be as lucrative or as exciting, but the excitement can have its downsides.

like

Benefits for one, stability as well. Any jobs where they make compensation allowances for your schedule (this is especially true for infrastructure jobs) are going to be the most stable ever. Add onto that any professional licensing and training, even more secure.

like

Job security alone outweighs pretty much most of the cons, whatever they may be. You're not really going to find any job out there that'll give you the guaranteed employment that most government jobs will (caveat usually being grant-funded positions that can go away if the grant permanently ends or dries up).

The benefits are also very difficult to beat. I get pretty good healthcare benefits for a modest monthly sum compared to peers who pay more. Plus, with enough of the right government experience, you could end up being worth more in the private sector so you can technically make it fit into your career goals.

like

Agree that the stability is huge pro. As a single parent, I made the decision to stay in a government job to have steady income and good healthcare benefits for my children. However, that was a deliberate knowing that I was sacrificing much better pay in the private sector. Although not as common, I have witnessed reductions in force (layoffs) and stagnating wages. The benefits where I am at have been reduced significantly for newer employees. I was grandfathered in and have a full pension with health insurance. However, that is always subject to legislative appropriation. Considering that my state's retirement account is not fully funded, I may not see the full benefit I sacrificed for, so that is also a consideration.
Student loan forgiveness - don't count on it.

like

You'd be much better getting a good industry job and paying off your student loans. All that is forgiven, if you even get approved (very rare!), is the compound interest that you would have avoided in the first place by paying them off. Meanwhile, very difficult to buy homes, cars, send your own children to school. It's a trap.

I think it depends on the government sector itself. I know Cities that went through (including mine) went through massive layoffs during the 2008s and then again in the 2020s.
The downside to me is the whole last-to-hire, last-to-fire thing. There are people who should have been lit way before, and I have gone through interviews that took up to six months to get a hire.

like

Definitely good job stability in government. The pay is often lower than the private sector but hard to beat the stability and benefits. But of course it depends on the job

like

Over the past few years, I don't think our government benefits are all that much better than industry is paying. I've been surprised reviewing my spouse's benefits package as he moves up in his career. Maybe before Obamacare, but lately, very little incentive. My agency fires people all the time.

like

I was just fired from a job with high reviews after 7 years in the private sector by EMAIL. So there is that

like

I work for the government and we fire people by e-mail too. It's 2024 :(

Best of luck in your job search!

like

Perks outweigh the cons for me. One being cost of living raises; others: benefits package and the GS pay scale.

like

You can actually watch the bureaucratic gears grinding slowly, almost matrix like. 😆

It's so bad. Signed, ~Golden Handcuffs

Read my reply above yours. Im so glad I retired from a government job at 62 years old. (The county of Los Angeles). I get retirement benefits the rest of my life now.

Just want to mention some government jobs will make you lose 2/3 of your future social security. It is called the windfall elimination provision. It’s been here since president Regan felt people getting a government pension paid by taxpayers shouldnt also get social security. They no longer pay into social security. (The employer or the employee). The govt employee also has another hit where they csnt draw a higher amount from spouses account either.

Speaking for Federal only, Government jobs are great up until the point that your get furloughed, or your agency sees funding cuts.

The pros are that you can make an okay salary and decent benefits while skating by - just don't expect the raises and advancement you'd experience in private sector.

My advice: get someone to sponsor you for a TS/SCI and then go get your PMP - you'll make money hand over fist in the private sector.

Even in my relatively short 12-year career, it's changed for the worst. Benefits cost have skyrocketed, mandatory retirement contributions have tripled (for the same benefit), and morale is in the toilet across most (all) agencies. Despite the marketing, the government absolutely does not embrace innovation or creativity.

Lots of cons eith government jobs be very careful. Thats sll im going to say.

I am going to guess this is an american government job? As we do not get student loan forgiveness working for the government in Australia. Unless you in with the politicians, they would be the only ones who could make a HECS/HELP debt disappear.

Related Posts

I joined IBM around year ago.
i have 9 YOE and i was given band 7A saying its lead role.
However in project i was treated as team member l. Initially i was okay as i thought i will be familiar with environment and later will take more responsibility.
But then they gave me release after few months.
No hike also this year.
Future also seems unclear as i feel low self-esteem seeing collegues my experience earning well and having better roles.
I really think joining IBM was wrong decision.

like

Add a comment with the designation levels in your bank.

like

Is it wrong that I’m just not into PE/VC? It seems to be the most desirable exit for most people that I work with. The work seems like it’s not a good fit for me but it feels crazy to pass up trying to get that amount of money when there really isn’t a realistic alternative to that amount of wealth (and I do want that amount of wealth).

like

Hi all - any advice on how to make the transition from BigLaw to IB / PE with circa 8 years experience working as M&A and PE lawyer? Many thx in advance 🙏🏽

like

Are there any specific resources (books, articles, individuals, courses) for someone who wants to focus on being a Group Product Manager?

like

What are good sectors to specialise in if I wanted to keep my options open?

I’m still a generalist but see people 1-2 years above me beginning to align. I frankly don’t really have any particular sector interest, but choosing based on “who i vibe with” sounds a bit silly (esp if you plan to exit)

like

Hi fishes, how's the hiring status in your companies. Heard that hiring is freezed in many
I am thinking to change. Java Developer with 5 + years of experience . Is this a good time to switch??

like

What are flexi car benefits in Nagarro?
How to avail it ?

like

Anyone successfully go from SEC reporting to an FP&A role?

like

Hi,
I have been working as accountant for past 10 years at a logistics company. I want to change my route and join different industries for better challenges and opportunities. How can I approach new firms with this single industry background.

like

Senior attorneys at v100, how common is it for attorneys who start at small firms to lateral to biglaw? Have you worked with any? Conventional wisdom is always that if you don’t start there it’s hard to “trade up”. My coworker and I just did it to two different great v30 firms, and I’m wondering if it’s really that uncommon? Just out of curiosity. We’re not special counsel with special niche skills or anything, just associates. Pitfalls to beware? Positives?

like

Can someone help me transition from advisory to IFS?

like

Hi Team,
Need your inputs. Is stability more important than the opportunity?

I have an opportunity to explore how ever it's been only 6 months in current organization.

Can I take the offer and switch? Does it affect the stability?

Please help.

like

Hi All,
I currently have 5.5 Ipa package in LTI working hear from starting of my career having Total 3 years of experience in Data Analytics field. Skills Tableau, SQL, Python. I also have done post graduate deploma in ML and Al from IIIT BANGLORE while working. I have notice period of 3 months. And this will be my first switch.I want to switch in MNC's like TCS, Accenture, Infosys, wipro, Capgemini, Etc. in pune with Tableau and SQL and Python as core skills. Can you please reffer me.

like

Has anybody passed their CPA but still has their Becker login? Help a brotha out please?

like

Hi,

If we survive the notice period in BNP are we allowed to take block leaves?

like

How difficult is it to lateral to other areas of tax without prior experience in the area? (Ex: Income tax planning to estate planning, corporate tax to exec comp, or estate planning to controversy work, etc.) Assuming you have an LLM or a couple years of experience in your first tax area.

like

Hi fishes, I'm a Java developer:
YOE- 3
CTC- 7 lpa
Working in a MNC service based org.
I am looking for a job in a product based organisation and my company is offering a 2 week client visit in Europe somewhere around oct-nov. Should I stay for that will it add any value? Or should I just give my papers (resign) and focus on looking at opportunities outside?
I need a better financial state till what can I aim for?

Do any of the top consulting firms hire into the Engagement Manager level after an M7 (if they had manager experience elsewhere)? I know MBB probably doesn’t but what about other tier 2 firms after that - and asking for US or Canada

likehelpfulfunny

Anyone work in the Healthcare industry? I'm looking into joining Healthcare. I'm currently a Senior in tax compliance.

like

More Posts

Add a comment with the designation levels in your bank.

like

Do visa employees have laptop options upon joining? What is the standard laptop?

like

Does the addition of “(level) II” make a difference to anybody? I am the only marketing communications specialist for a lead child-welfare nonprofit. We oversee four counties in two circuits. Director recently gave me add’l merit-based raise (after my annual raise, been here 14 months) & slight title change to Marketing Comm Specialist II. No plans to add a level 1 (would be lower) specialist but will add level 1 engagement specialist to team. Should I update resume/cards or is this confusing?

For the educational program reimbursement, after it's approved, do we get reimbursed with our next paycheck?

like

So. MBA from a top 20 program (if that matters), working in the southeastern US with 10 years experience in private practice and hospital administration. Salary thoughts?

like

Is it wrong that I’m just not into PE/VC? It seems to be the most desirable exit for most people that I work with. The work seems like it’s not a good fit for me but it feels crazy to pass up trying to get that amount of money when there really isn’t a realistic alternative to that amount of wealth (and I do want that amount of wealth).

like

Anyone here deal with Reines HH before?

likehelpful

Tomorrow I have an interview with the partner of a fundraising and M&A boutique for tech startups, who’s also an active VC. Any tips? Although I’m currently at a B4, I have some corp dev experience at a tech unicorn. Thanks.

likehelpful

I'm launching a small PE firm and need advice on structuring equity for early founding team members.

I don't want to give up equity in the firm for several reasons but I do need to incentivize my team.

Should I offer phantom stock or form a subsidiary LLC and issue stock in that but always own the parent co? Or just offer carried interest for deals they each manage?

like

What is the average bonus and hike rate?
Team: Model Validation (Credit Risk)

like
like

Accepted a verbal offer at a large company, how long does it typically takes to issue offer letter?

like

Can we say that we already have an offer in the other company interviews?

like

SAG on a rampage these days....

like

First HR starting co-opting our Talent Manager titles. Now Account teams are using Business Manager. Guess we’re just trend setters. 🤷‍♀️

likefunny

I am currently pursuing my B.tech in IT. I wish to work as an intern at Paypal Singapore. Can anyone tell me what's the criteria for selection and whether paypal sponsors visa?
Any help would be highly appreciated!

Best prework that won’t kill me? F 32 looking for a morning pick me up before gym/cardio
Low cal/low sugar if possible

How is the KPMG client in wipro? Anyone working for KPMG in Wipro? TIA Wipro KPMG

like

Are there any specific resources (books, articles, individuals, courses) for someone who wants to focus on being a Group Product Manager?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal