{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "McKinsey or BCG or Bain? Offers from all and now deciding.", "post_id": "5df8fd76a518a4001ab16ff4", "reply_count": 260, "vote_count": 55, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting", "feed_type": "crowd" }
null

McKinsey or BCG or Bain? Offers from all and now deciding.

likefunnyupliftinghelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Given what you’ve written, you should pick BCG since you jive better with them. McK’s staffing model has become more regionally based (though still with plenty of opportunities for global projects and rotations) so I wouldn’t consider that a major differentiator vs. BCG for international opps. If we knew more about your professional goals maybe the answer would be different.

Prioritize people first and location second (both of which heavily factor into your happiness and the industries you serve). E.g. don’t come to Chicago for hi tech or pharma work. For most, the other considerations are rather inconsequential in comparison.

likeuplifting

Is this your baby typing?
Mind you I got banned because of my 1 year old lol

funny

I can’t speak to the other firms but some minor points to note about BCG—

1. We try hard to staff in your local region (ie <2 hour flight), and are able to do so often unless you choose otherwise.

2. Our expense policy is great (which matters when you travel often)—first class flights for 1.5 hour or longer trips as an example.

3. We partner with a lot of great non profits (gates foundation, Obama foundation, wildlife conservation funds) to enable you to work there for a period of time if you so choose, and then return to BCG.

4. We are picky about the types of work we choose, actively avoiding work that could cause damage to our reputation or work that conflicts with our values.

likehelpfulsmartfunny

To #4 I’ve seen BCG take commercial projects that weren’t in the client’s best interest while I saw McK turn down phase 2 of a project i was on because they didn’t think it was in the client’s best interest. I worked on one BCG project that Bain had refused to do and BCG agreed to do (and should have never done—killed the team and the client CEO proclaimed it a “failure”). Was also pushed at BCG to suggest major changes to a client’s operating model and org structure that we couldn’t show having any benefit while introducing substantial risk just because “the client isn’t paying us a lot of money to tell them to keep doing things the way they’re doing them.” McK wouldn’t have done that.

Agree with BCG’s better travel policy. Depends what’s important to you, I suppose...

likehelpfulfunny
Recent IconRecent

Congratulations on securing all these offers. Well done! I would advise to choose based on the people you meet and who you clicked with the most. In the end it’s a People business and if you don‘t like the culture / your colleagues, any other considerations won’t really overcompensate that. Happy to chat if you want to send me a DM. I’m a Partner in Chicago.

likehelpful

FWIW OP, I would choose McK over BCG if I had to do it again. Echo a lot of what’s been said here by other BCGers at the firm. For better or worse, there’s really one type of person who succeeds here and if you aren’t that type then it’s a only matter of how long until you leave.

I also think McK is also way better at alum relations than we are which is key to finding your opportunity after consulting. Of course, they’re not Bain, but still first class.

You lit

likefunny

Never leave Deloitte!

likefunny

For anyone curious, this is not uncommon. If you can case well, you’ll get an offer from 2+ of the MBB firms.

Over 50% of my BSchool classmates who received one offer received multiple.

Those who can’t case well receive 0 offers.

So what you end up with is a population with multiple offers, and another population with 0 offers. “Offer inequality”, so to speak.

like

Pittsburgh is not an easy place to live either

like

I’d personally go to Bain... I like the people there!

like

Congratulations. Wouldn’t go wrong with any one of them. I also had all 3 out of Bschool. I picked BCG based on the people I connected.

likehelpful

M2 - absolutely correct. The MBB and even the D S&O summer interns all stood out early on and many who had the profile for an M7 came to a lower ranked school because of $$ (that too tax free!)

like

BCG or Bain

like

McK is definitely a step above if you want international opportunities. It’s a truly global staffing system, for better and worse.

like

Join the firm in the city you want to live in. If you don’t care about location, join McKinsey. It’s better

likefunny

Ah, my fault, I assumed we were all talking about NA haha

Asl?

funnylike

You have very low standards G1.

Deloitte is the most exclusive, more so than Harvard

funnylikesmart

Google “<firm> partner prison” and see if that informs your choice.

funnylike

Google “<firm>” and see 1) how many search results pop up 2) how often this <firm> is talked about in the media

like

I also got all three and chose McK - happy to chat if you DM me

like

McK hands down

like

#humblebrag

like

Maybe, but considering this is a consulting app with many people from different backgrounds and company experiences, I'd say OP's question is pretty relevant.

like

You single OP? Looking for a sugar baby?

I make a real mean deck if you know what I mean.

I can really really facilitate your deliverables

likefunny

P1, I volunteer as tribute to take C11’s place post-canning if you can help me make it happen 😁

Congrats! I work with alumni from all 3 firms, McKinsey people are definitely the most impressive.

like

Good for you! McK would be my pick.

like

Mck. I’m a tad bias.

like

Additional Posts

TFW you know WAY too much about IAH and your Uber diver assumes you're a flight attendant 🙄

like

Come Monday 4/3 there will be another round of upset commercial consultants from Deloitte about the scatterplot. Positive note, I think it's a free pass year for almost everyone. Sucks for promotes.

like

Anyone stayed at he Ritz in Vienna? Worth it or no?

like

What would be the process of resigning?

like

In a weird situation where media was paused on the account indefinitely in the middle of Q3. At this point I’m just making media plans that get shot down. Should I bail? Hi nyc recruiters 😉

like

People Ideas and culture NY?

New staff here n tbh it hasn’t been the easiest start. Stressed AF What were some of your biggest challenges starting as a new staff your first year? & if you wanna share, how did you overcome them

like

What are typical investor relations salaries like? And hours? Either at a fund or in banking.

like

Any fish make an exit from Consulting to Account Management/Client Success for a SaaS company. Roles mostly involve owning client relationships for renewals and growth. Curious to learn more.

like

Pick your path

Post Photo
likefunny

Does anyone use mint to track their budget? If so, what is your opinion on it?

like

Thoughts on hyperbaric chamber for wellness?

like

Is it bad to let schools which you’ve been waitlisted at know that you’re still interested even though you’re not 100% sure you will go if you get off the WL?

like

Time to pop a bottle open, no work tomorrow!

likeuplifting

Any low cost shipping company recommendations to India ?

like

First holiday season with this pup means he gets to discover the wonder that is empty wrapping paper rolls 😂

Post Photo
like

Current non-equity partner at a firm with 10 attorneys; 2 equity partners). I’m currently paid with a salary plus profit sharing for a portion of the work I do (we do contingency work only). I have chance to be equity if I want. The financial benefit is that I’d profit share from everyone’s work not just my own. The downside is that I’d help pay others’ salaries. First, should I push to be equity? And second, they want me to buy in to the partnership since they have been paying salaries for ...

like

What’s my best bet to get tree ornaments this late in the game that arrive on time? In bay area

Hi,
I'm Gowri, My Designation is UI Design & Development, I'm Currently looking MNC Job in Coimbatore or Madurai, I'm Experienced Person, Kindly Job refer me

like

Anyone here know anything about Unify Consulting? They reached about looking for senior roles to build their National Healthcare and Life Science vertical.

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal