The question is, is graduation from law school, not minimum competency? With this line of reasoning we are saying that law schools do not produce competent future lawyers, so should we instead switch to a system of taking the bar without the three years of a measure that frankly bar associations have deemed not an adequate measure? Dash this comment aside if it is fallible, but there is something here that has been overlooked. Competence is not regurgitation and memorization.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I had a very similar conversation with a friend about this! If graduation from law school isn’t enough, why have the bar?

like

I think both are very much needed, especially the bar exam. I didn’t when I was getting out of law school but after working for years now it’s become apparent how needed they are. I would even require lawyers to retake some version of the bar (maybe a watered down one) every few years to retain their license.

The point of law school and the bar is not to prepare you to practice the specific field of law you choose right out the gate. That’s impossible. How would a single or multiple classes in a law school be able to teach students how to file something in court when there are so many jurisdictions in the country (and each state) and each varies as to filing and students will spread out in different jurisdiction after graduation? Even during the bar exam, why is it fair to require someone who doesn’t intend to file a single document in court cause they’ll do M&A work to learn how to file a document in court within a specific jurisdiction, or require someone who never plans to do M&A work to negotiate reps and warranties for example (especially when those things can further vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction in single state and subject matter to subject matter). It’s very difficult to get specific.

Law school and the bar exam are meant to make sure you have the basic ability to reasonably learn and do legal tasks once you start practicing in your particular field. When you’re faced with a legal question, you (unlike an everyday non-lawyer) should be able to situate the question within the general legal framework, spot the legal issues, sift through information (i.e. facts and legal rules), apply the rules to the facts, and communicate your opinion in an organized, clear, and concise way. This requires you to have two things: (i) a general understanding of different field of laws (torts, criminal, contracts, etc.) and procedures (I.e. civil, criminal, evidence, contract formation, etc.) so that you have the big picture and can situate yourself within it and (ii) a basic level of intellect, reasoning, and memory to be able to sufficiently go through a lot of information, analyze it, and communicate it clearly (I.e. think like a lawyer). Once you develop these things (and showcase that you have them on the bar exam), then you should be set to specialize in whatever law you want and pick it up quickly enough. That’s why on the bar exam, you’ll get a question for example requiring you to go through a packet of materials containing facts and legal cases, analyze it, and communicate it via writing when answering a question. You likely won’t get that time pressure or organized materials to review in real life, but your ability to pick up new material, comprehend it, analyze it, and communicate it is literally pure legal skill no matter where you go.

I’ve encountered so many attorneys (and people wanting to be attorneys) who need improvement in the two skills I noted above. When I clerked, I would see so many attorneys lose their clients’ cases on summary judgment cause they failed to comprehend the legal standard enough and go after the evidence needed to survive summary judgment during discovery. Or they cite inapposite cases (or cases that hurt them) or stuff that’s soooo simple you can’t believe someone would do it. Maybe law school and the bar aren’t the best gatekeepers but if someone can’t pass the bar cause they’re not able to remember basic info about torts, contracts, etc., or can’t sift through info and analyze and communicate it effectively (when all these other bad lawyers could do it), it’s hard to feel bad for them. At the end of the day, clients aren’t paying lawyers to do secretarial work of filing, mailing, proof reading, etc. They’re paying lawyers to use the skills law school and the bar exam test for in the clients’ specific situation.

Edited to also say: As much as people complain about memory tasks, clients are not paying you to research issues from scratch either :)

like

I just graduated from law school 2 weeks ago. My take is that law school is valuable in that it teaches us to “think like a lawyer”. But as I’m studying for the bar, I’m realizing how many rules, elements and details I don’t know off hand. The bar forces you to memorize all those rules and be able to recite and apply them quickly.

To me, the question is “do we really need to memorize the law to be effective lawyers when we will almost always have the ability to simply look things up in the real world?“

After first year, you have a lot of freedom as to what classes to take - some real fundamentals like evidence usually aren’t required. And my professional responsibility class was geared toward the MPRE, not state ethics rules. So I do understand the argument that the bar is to ensure that all lawyers in a jurisdiction have a core set of knowledge. But then, part of me thinks that the bar is just another gatekeeping mechanism (and financial drain) to keep people out of the profession.

Related Posts

Automatic red flag to have an engagement kickoff just before the holidays, receive emails at all hours of the day (to include weekends/holidays), be told there’s a lot to do but “it’ll be a great opportunity”, and then be told leadership wants people to prioritize work life balance? Figured I’d be looking for an exit soon, but this just pushed it up.

likefunny

Hello, I have 4 years of experience between Financial decision support and pricing. However, I feel like my experience is too narrowed to how my current company operates. I am looking to pivot into consulting at one of the big4 ( for ~2-3 years)or any other consulting firm to have a well rounded experience that could be applicable to any industry. Any advices ?or thoughts ?

Hi all,
I'm a Software Engineer with 14 months of work experience. I want to move on to Product Management as my current job doesn't align with my long term career aspirations. I'm pretty confident in the tech aspects of my job and am undergoing a course in Business Foundations.
Any suggestions on what career steps I should take?

like

what is working at a crisis management firm like? broad question, i know, but i don’t know much about the field! (i currently work at an ad agency, but i’m considering a career pivot.)

like
like

Having 2 offers in hand one is Capgemini’s(Hsbc) and Coforge(Hsbc). Both companies offered same package. Any suggestions for job security and onsite which one is good. Having 7 years of experience..

How can I try to get into VC? Particularly tough tech and things like robotics, automation, transportation, etc. I’m currently at T2 consulting in industrials and I’ve tried networking with a few VC firms in this space, but no luck.

like

Does anyone know anybody coming from the Merit America IT Support program that have been successful in their roles? This is a career change for me and I'm worried that employers won't be patient while I learn or that IT teams will be overloaded and I won't have a proper mentor.

helpful
like

Many young people don't consider supply chain management as a career option. In your opinion, why is the interest minimal, and what could make it more appealing?

like

Hello! I’ve been in Compliance now Dow approx 6 years and want to make myself marketable. Besides a JD what other masters can I obtain?

like

AWS Cloud question- what the difference between an SCP and IAM? Thanks in advance

like

I’m currently an HR specialist and trying to decide what I want my future to look like. I would like to step away from the transactional, administrative HR work. I’m fascinated by employee satisfaction and like the idea of helping to improve retention and leveraging metrics to improve toxic work environments (I’ve seen a fair share of dysfunction in my career). I’m thinking the Consultant route may be best for this. Any other thoughts of roles or titles that may align?

like
like

Hi Sharks,

I am a product owner and want to learn all aspects of product management and to transition as a product manager in leading Tech firms. I had completed my engineering and mba but never worked as a software engineer. I started my career in sales and am now working as a PO. So I lack technical knowledge as well. Can some experienced product manager guide me and PPL like me here on this fish bowl a step by step plan to achieve this goal. What courses we can join, what books to read

like

Ex-consultant now in marketing. Used to be an avid follower here and got great insights on companies when trying to exit consulting so thought I’d try here for advice. Outside of FAANG, what are good large CA-based tech companies that provide good pay, WLB, and culture? DD has great people and WLB, but pay is low and you’re not given the tools and resources to succeed + truly make an impact. Google and Apple are ideal but need backups. Like is Salesforce still good? A company along those lines.

like

How difficult is it to transition into banking when your experience in mainly from Fortune 500 businesses like FP&A?

like

Anybody with Big4 exp made the switch to salesforce as business architect recently? What does this job entail and qualification needs? The jd says “extensive” big4 exp

like
like

Hi fishes,

Need your help
Currently I am working as a PMO and have 3.2 yoe.
I wanted to switch my careee into Salesforce.
Can you please guide me how shall I proceed with the same?

like

More Posts

Considering an exit to a small (<200 person) SF based SaaS company with 140k base vs a large (>1000 people) Fin Services company with 145k base. Advice on what to consider?

What happens if i didn't attend the 2nd day of the virtual onboarding session in infosys .

like

What is the salary range for Data analyst at Thoughtworks? I have overall 4 years of experience.

like

What does the “four corners of the abstract” mean? Title, authors and??

like

MBA? / yoe consulting / title / company / age / salary

like

Looking to fully refresh my ski equipment (skis/bindings, boots, etc). Midwest places are starting to close up (wtf I know!). Anyone have recommendations on solid ski shops? Prefer Denver/Colorado Springs Metros but open to all.

like

Im working in AUM reporting side and looking to automate some daily and monthly processes that are done in excel. I know it is possible with python but I know little to no python any suggestions? Or any other software that may be able to help!

like

I’m in asset management sales and keen to accelerate my learning in alternatives (private equity, private debt, real assets, liquid and semi-liquid alternatives) so I can have more productive discussions with clients. 1) What are some good news platforms to stay updated on alternatives space in Asia? 2) Besides CAIA, any educational platforms to learn more about alternatives?

like

What's your absolute favorite dinner spot in Chi-town? I'm willing to travel, but I'm moving soon so want to hit all of the greats I haven't been to or didn't know about.

like

Who is planning for next year's draft?

like

Recommendations for bachelor party destinations aside from Costa Rica and Mexico City. Preferably under 5 hour flight time from Atlanta outside the US.

like

What is the best way to search for remote job openings in the IT sector in Canada provided you already have a PR and everythg is legal

like

Anyone have a sense of the salary range for a Data Science Consultant with Adventure Federal Services? DC area, TS-SCI but no master's degree.

like

In my offer letter it stated a signing bonus to be paid on the first available payroll after my start date. Its been a month since my first paycheck and HR and the Payroll team are incredibly unresponsive to my inquiry on where this bonus is. What’s the next course of action? Legal? I’m not at ACN anymore so not looking for ACN-specific advice.

like

What is the typical salary range in NYC for a strategy director with 6.5/7 years of experience? Was offered 100K but seems low.

like

Is verizon service based or product based company?

helpfullike

What is the standard billing for a surgical PA? 20% of what the MD is billing? Does anyone know?

like

Are there any Infrastructure related VC funds that hire PhDs ? Thanks

like

Additional Posts in Law Clerks

As someone who is interested in public interest law (open to impact litigation or policy work), does it make sense to clerk in state court -- trial level -- and if so, for how long? Are these clerkships only useful for becoming a state court judge down the line or can they open doors to other paths?

like

Is anyone expecting clerkship bonuses to be a bit higher within the next year considering the current hot market for laterals and mass exodus from big law? Or will things die down and keep clerkship bonuses at about the same level?

like

Dating. How do you navigate dating attorneys and being a judicial law clerk? Conflicts? Awkwardness?

likefunny

Any insight into clerkship bonuses at BakerHostetler?

like

Got an offer to clerk for a DJ over the phone a couple of months ago. Silence since. I start in late summer, but when should I expect HR to reach out with onboarding materials? Is an offer letter usually sent?

like

Anyone feel way over their head when they started clerking (district level, but fine with hearing appellate perspective as I’ve got one of those locked down later)? I did not feel this way when I started big law.

like

For writing samples in clerkship applications, can you edit/revise a final work product already submitted to the court? For instance, if there's a typo or something. Can more substantive edits be made to improve the work product?

like

I’ve been at my clerkship for 5 years (4 with a different judge) and one with my current judge, and I heard horrible things about him before starting, but I assumed they were exaggerated. Turns out they’re all true, and I’ve had to start therapy to deal with him and the incredibly toxic environment. I’m trying to get out ASAP b/c he also has a history of firing clerks without cause or notice, but I think I’ll only be able to give two weeks notice if i get the job I’m interviewing for. Thoughts?

like

Hi everyone! I come from Big law and have an interview at a federal court (dream job) and will be meeting two federal judges. Any tips for a successful interview? I’ve worked previously at a lower court. Any qualities / skills I should put forward? Many thanks

like

Hey I'm a lawyer who has a few years of experience. Do people hire guys like me for clerkships

like

I am roughly 4 months away from finishing my clerkship in the US District Court, and am looking for a big law litigation associate position in NY or DC, but have had only a few interviews and have yet to receive an offer. Any advice?

like

Did the NYSBA forget about re-takers? Is this a grave travesty and denial of Art 15 rights to those who are not being allowed to sit for the exam? What about their financial distress and their ability to retain and seek employment?

Post Photo
like

What are your hours like as a clerk? I’m sure it varies a lot based on the judge but curious to hear people’s experiences

like

Who thinks the Florida Bar will be online in July?

like

Does anyone have any recommendations on how to conduct the post-clerkship job search if the goal is big law? I am coming from a state appellate clerkship in a major market.

like

I went to a T14 law school, got great grades and glowing recommendations, and wrote (what I thought was) a great writing sample. But I got rejected from all 70 federal clerkships I applied to. The only thing I can think of is: I took a non traditional route after law school and did a 2 year public interest fellowship in a niche field of administrative law. The rejection gave me a lot of self hatred. I still really want to clerk. Any advice? What is wrong with me? I feel like a failure.

like

What's your career path? I know firm life, govt litigation, or in-house arent for me, but I do like clerking for a Justice. I guess my question is, are there any other options aside from the first 3?

like

Has anyone ever said no to a federal clerkship and if so, why?

like

I clerked right after law school and I’ve been working in BigLaw since (last 3 years). I’ve always thought career clerking for the right judge would be incredible and I may have the opportunity to do so in the next year. Has anyone gone from BL to career clerk? Interested to hear about others’ experiences and if anyone can advise where I’d likely come in on the JPS with 3 years experience and a year of prior federal clerkship service. Thanks!

like

Clerks, at what point in your clerkship did you start applying for jobs? I’m about halfway through a two year clerkship in my intended market and I am trying to figure out when I need to seriously start applying.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal