We pay for the role, not your grocery bill.

I asked for a raise citing inflation/rent increases. My boss said, "We don't base compensation on your personal expenses." It’s technically true, but feels heartless.
How do you counter this argument?

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I don't see that there is any counter to that argument, which is why I've never made it. Employers honestly don't care about my bills, once they issue my paycheck that's it, they don't care what I do with it or how far it goes. I agree that it seems heartless, but it's just cold hard logic.

like

I don’t get why anyone would increase salary just because time passed on the calendar. I’ve never asked for a raise, but I’m always targeting the next promotion.

I would lead the conversation with all you accomplishments, value you added and skills you’ve gained that make you more valuable.

I would layer in where market rates are for someone of your experience and skills. If you do your research I’m sure you’ll find your salary is behind. This is intended to help your boss understand your pay is not competitive in the market and he should address that.

like

You could adhere to a strict 40-hour work week, since that’s all they pay you for. But before you do, make sure you want to get fired.

I work this job to pay for those personal expenses? Not sure that would go over well, but that is the truth. I’d lead the conversation with the positives of why you should have a raise, work/accomplishments/projects, which are terms that management tends to understand.

You leave.

They’re selfish and only care about themselves, which is why corporate is annoyed people woke up post-pandemic and started treating them the same way. I’ve heard it’s best to leave out personal expenses when asking for a raise and focus on what one has done during their job. This way they’re forced to pay attention to your work and not try to weasel in anything else that can jeopardize your chances of getting one

Weird flex from boss. But I'll bite.

Your boss's response, while "heartless" is not a reflection of wider economic system.

It is between you and them. If your boss is not the owner, then this comment is super weird and misplaced power/aggression. But I will assume that your boss is the owner for this post.

remember that there are misaligned incentives between employer and employee. Employers incentive is maximize value at lowest cost. Employees incentive is to maximize pay (owner see this as cost) with as little value to company as possible (thus increasing free time, family, vacation, etc)

That is the gig. That is it. Full stop.

No matter what is put in between (great benefits, great bonus, they care about me, they really treat their employees well) -- all can be true-- the incentives are always misaligned. even if altruistic and genuine.

Back to your post. Harsh...sure. But a good reminder. Set you mentals, keep the job, look for a new one, or start one.

Your boss is right – don't anchor raises to personal finances. Reframe to market value: "You're correct. Let me rephrase: my role now pays $X-Y in our market, and I'm currently below that range. What's the path to market-rate compensation?"
Inflation affects everyone's expenses and salary benchmarks. When they say "we pay for the role," hold them to it – make them prove they're actually paying market rate for your role, not 2021 rates frozen in place.
If they won't budge, someone else will pay you properly.

Related Posts

Hey Everyone! Can anyone throw some light on what the interview process looks like for Director level at EY Parthenon - Deal Management team? (experienced hire, non campus). How many rounds, case study or behavioral? Thank you.

like

My anxiety makes me good at my job. My incessant checking, and double checking, and analyzing has earned me praise, trust, and early promotions. Sometimes I wonder, if I were to take medication to give myself some relief, and to stop the panic attacks, would I be less productive? And then I wonder, do I value my own health so little? But I’m so validated by my performance...sad isn’t it? Hope I’m not alone.

like

Tips for how to start off on a good foot at a new job? Also on how to balance that with taking ownership of the work/asserting yourself, especially when the people there are used to you freelancing (which was less assertive, and similar work but a lower title)… thanks!

like

Looking for better and competitive compensation according to the industry standard in delhi NCR region either in core IT industry or IT Consulting.

Current CTC - 250000
Expected CTC - 400000

Suggest me please.

like

What's the DL on your city? Might be making a move there from Kansas City for my husband's job.

like

Does anyone know anything about Anytime Fitness or the Self Esteem Brands team?

Budgets? Personalities? Culture?

Hello! Looking for a recco for local alcohol/bottle photographers? Thank you in advance!

Travel and TTC combo haven’t worked. After 6 months, the only offer I got included 4 weeks paid and FLMA only after 1 year. So 1) go and risk laughable benefits or 2) stay but risk TTC. So shitty 😭

like

Headhunter recommendations in London?

like

So I'm in a weird space at the moment. I've been interviewing with a lot of agencies in the past couple of months, and I keep getting the same response of "I need more agency experience." How am I supposed to get that experience if one of the things holding me back is not having enough agency experience?

like

Do you anyone looking for opening in Infosys. Please do inbox me.
While sending profile share your location preferences and date of birth.

like

Starting in Chicago in July, anyone have an opinion on the value of being in the city the first month? Worth saving the money and commuting at home, or will I miss out on social value

like

I had one of those VERY nonproductive days today. I think I accomplished maybe an hour of billable work, even though I had a bunch of stuff to do. I just came off a 300 hour month, and unexpectedly got a continuance on a deadline on Wednesday, and it’s like all of my motivation leeched out of me at once.

like

Hi,

can someone highlight as how much we can expect for band 8 with 14.6 yrs exp as a security professional.

like

Just confirmed an interview Salesforce as a Financial Analyst! Looking for tips from anyone who has gone through their process, would be greatly appreciated. Nervous as this is a position I'm been trying to get!

like

Hi all! I work at a nonprofit and am looking to leave the organization. As I browse available positions in my area, I’m realizing there is a LOT of crossover between my current org and others, for example shared board members, folks who are on our board and employed at one of the institutions I’m interested in, etc.. Is there a way to say “my current org doesn’t know I’m looking, so please treat my interest with discretion” that doesn’t raise red flags? Thanks!

like

Hi, after each interview, the recruiting agency will call me to get feedback and ask me if we're still good on X salary?

What's a good way to not agree on a set number on these calls until I get my offer?

like

I’ve been with my company for 4 years and I’m thinking about applying for a new job. For references, I would like to use my coworkers but I also don’t want to bring up the fact that I’m applying to other places. How should I handle my references when it comes to applying or interviewing with other companies?

like

I have a little over a year of experience as a Partner Success Manager at a Tech company. My company is looking to do salary negotiations this year. When I started out, my base was 70k plus commission of 10k minimum extra. Curious to know what others are making as a PSM and also looking for other opportunities!

like

How can I DM people? I just joined!

Update: I need to get likes. Please help me get likes so I can DM someone.

Follow up question: do I need to get likes every-time I want to DM someone or its a beginner thing? And how many likes?

like

Additional Posts in Salaries in Advertising & Marketing

Besides salary is there any additional bonuses, stock options, etc to expect as you advance to SVP and EVP?

like

Was recently offered 110k for Creative Director in DC at a large for profit organization. . . felt low for 8+ years of direct management experience. Thoughts?

funny

What’s been your most impressive/successful salary negotiation when you’ve received an offer? Did you manage to get way more PTO or other perks?

like

28 / F / LA / 73k / Im underpaid, huh

What’s everyone giving as their ACD rate range for freelance? Specifically in big cities like LA, NYC, SF

likehelpful

How much do CCOs make? Mid to large size agency in a major city?

like

Do you get a bonus? How much? Do you count it in your salary when posting here?

180 base, 50 bonus, plus 50-75k profit sharing and 50k equity a year.

Still feel underpaid on initial base salary :/

funnylike

Anyone from Canada? I’m considering moving but I don’t know what the salaries are like.

Any producers from Publicis want to share what they’re making? Please specify whether integrated, executive, broadcast etc

Does anyone think it’s out of the question to ask for a 20% pay increase without a promotion? My duties on our team are closer to Director-level and no other Senior PM is managing half of what I am, so I feel like I should be compensated fairly.

Someone bring me back down to earth if I’m asking too much

like

Hourly rate for freelance Sr Designer in NYC, any ranges?

like

What’s the Assoc. Strategy Director pay range in Boston? Glassdoor says 140k. Does that sound about right?

What should a Managing Director make at a global shop in NYC? Not office MD but runs a group of accounts. 15 yrs experience.

like

How much should I contribute to a 401k?

like

I think I just screwed up on a call with a recruiter. He asked what my salary expectations were and I wasn’t thinking. I threw out a number that is about what I’m making now including my bonus.

Finance - Highest salary? After how many years? Is Ad better paying than typical accounting?

like

VML Sr Art Director position assuming 7-10 years experience. What’s a fair salary expectation for the Midwest? Chicago/Kansas City area.

like

Are annual raises really not a thing in this industry? I’ve been with my company a year and a half and asked for one and was basically told they don’t happen unless the company does really well overal

like

Jr. Cw Salary in LA?

like

Do New Business roles pay higher than traditional account roles?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal