What has gone wrong in Chicago in the last two years? There wasalways at least one major piece of work the whole world noticed, usually from Leo Burnett or Ogilvy. But the tone and energy of work from San Francisco and New York agencies is just light years ahead of Chicago now. It all just feels so mediocre and dated. Where is the groundbreaking idea? Do you need financial backers for the most forward thinking teams to open a place? You can’t blame clients, clients ared the same everywhere.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Been saying this for years. Love Chicago but the agencies barely have a pulse. Lot of it in my opinion, is they’re not diverse. Homogeneous, same type of work all around. How much flavor do you expect from a bowl of only yellow skittles vs a bowl of all the different colors of skittles?

like

Agencies in Chicago talk about respect and diversity. But if anybody brings them an idea a white suburban mom wouldn’t get, they don’t know what to do with it and throw it away.

like

IMO, Chicago agencies are bottom line agencies. I’ve worked in NYC, London, L.A. and now Chicago. The agencies here run super lean and a lot of the clients are CPG clients, which doesn’t help. In short, NYC is where you get great transformative brand campaigns and Chicago is where brands get their banners and social posts made.

likesmart

Right. But not just talking about Leo and DDB. Ogilvy, Y&R - now VMLY&R, BBDO, etc.

like

Rotating creative leadership is a big part of how it started. Tutsell out at Leo. Liz Taylor to Leo from FCB. Brit Nolan from Leo to DDB. Andres from BBDO to FCB. Jordan promoted to CCO at Leo. Jordan leaves Leo. Joe is elevated at Ogilvy and is less in the day to day. It was nearly a year of musical chairs. Then, accounts started leaving or getting shaky. McDonalds. Allstate. Capital One. State Farm to name a few. We haven’t been able to get our legs under us, and then a global pandemic hits just as these leaders should be starting to find their stride. No good work gets made without these people supporting it, and we have been in a constant state of transition for two years. It has been frustrating to say the least.

like

Sometimes leaving is the only way to grow and advance.

like

Hey now I made some rly cool banner ads that are on millions of browsers behind those ad blockers. The whole world knows they’re there, they just can’t see them. They actually have to consciously think to install something to block them. How’s that for impactful???

like

What I’ve heard is that the big difference is how the agencies are structured. That the leaders and decision-makers at Chicago agencies are all from the account management department. Razz everywhere else, the leaders of the agencies come from the creative department. Is that true?

like

I would say that is true. I’m working with our NY office and the creative Dept and leadership is quite different.

like

The Bigger the agency. the more they need to feet the beast. I have freelanced for 3-4 big names and I would say that about 30-40% of the stuff you need to do benefits the work or client. Meanwhile, You have a handful of small to mid studios in Chicago that do 40-60% of all the work because it's just getting farmed out. The Creative is just a checkbox to justify the retainer.

Related Posts

Moving to atl- what are typical 1x1 rent prices?

like

Any input on job offerings I’ve received. Morgan Stanley CRU risk officer pay is $70k with a less than 10% bonus. And KeyBank position is a private client advisor pay is $67k but bonus can range from $10k -$25k depending on performance and other compensation factors. Currently a Investment Consiltant at WFA making $62k with a $7k bonus. Both are in office positions in SLC, UT. TIA

like

Hey fishes, curious which San Diego companies you think give the best work-life balance. Can be public, private, start-up, etc. BONUS: If you work for one, do you like it there?

Which SF neighborhoods to consider? Lady 🐠 looking for safe 1br with public transit / walking accessibility to FiDi and not far from SFO. Hoping to spend $3k-$3300, but could go up to $3500.

like

Happy to be here! Politically speaking: I consider myself a Classic Liberal (JFK Liberal: “Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.”) Constitutional conservative, fiscally moderate, socially liberal.

like

Hi! I’m looking for a producer role out in San Fran (coming from Chicago), does anyone know of places looking? Or good agencies to reach out to? Any help would be greatly appreciated!! Thanks!

likeupliftinghelpful

San Antonio food and things to do???

like

I have solid experience in technical program management, any recommendations on companies in San Diego that are looking for program mangers or general technical leadership

PwC A recruiter from PWC reached out to me to ask if I’d consider a different office the one I applied to, since it’s full. It would be Boston, Hartford, Chicago, Minneapolis, Little Rock, Denver, San Francisco or San Jose. MSA candidate. Is there a fully remote option? Do you have to be in the office all the time? Is the compensation high at PWC? Is there a possible moving expenses? Any insight or advice would help me make a decision. Thank you!

like

Are Uber/Lyft drivers reluctant to drive from DC (Logan) to BWI?

We flew back from Ireland today on Delta. Our connecting flight from JFK at 6:10 was cancelled while we were flying over the Atlantic Ocean, and we were rebooked on a 3:40 instead (2.5 hours earlier) but not notified. I received no email, text or app notification of the flight cancellation or the new flight we were placed on, so we missed it. They now cannot get us home tonight and won’t even guarantee they can get us home tomorrow, impacting my work, (cont)…

like

Typical prices for wedding photography in a high cost of living city? (San Francisco) 2 photographers, 8 hours, no travel. Much appreciated! ❤️

like

What should a commercial claims account manager be making as a salary ? Handles asbestos claims only. Works for a TPA handling claims for 4 carriers. Law degree with many years trial experience as in house ID but for personal lines. This is first job handling commercial claims

like

Looking to refer a friend in the Las Vegas area to an independent advisor for term insurance and basic retirement planning.

Ok -- let's hear it. Best restaurants in ATL - go! My parents are coming to town and I want to wow them, they are serious foodies and very adventurous. Tell me your recc's!!

like

Hi Fishes,
I am working as a Sr Manager/Team Lead in service based industry since 10yrs, my total experience in leadership is 6 years. I want to shift my focus into product based companies. Any guidance/tips for me? Also dm if you know about any product manager roles in your sea.

Person on my ATL to SFO last week was wearing a full construction respirator with a surgical mask across the front. (Like in photo, I had to photoshop it together because I couldn't get a pic on the plane)

Like... why?

Post Photo
funnylike

More Posts

Any insight in "innovation" or "transformation" type roles at large pharma companies? I don't generally see these roles listed but would be interested in learning more

like

Hey Guys,Can anyone who is a Data Engineer and working with Big Tech Companies share some light on how you guys are preparing for interviews?How are you learning so fast/so much?Can you please share some plan or guide me on what resources you are following?There are too many things. And in my current organization I am not able to learn those.I want to learn fast and more.I see profiles on LinkedIn that are filled with big data techstack.Please guide. Adobe Amazon Walmart Expedia, Inc. American E

like

Hello, I am applying for internships in Robotics and Manufacturing Automation for a while now. But I guess my resume is not going through to the HR. Please suggest me if my resume needs to be updated.

Post Photo
like

Hi did anyone recently join Morgan Stanley . I heard that after joining we need to transfer a demat account. Can anyone help with this . I just read about this in some comments no info from hr side.

like

Does anyone here have any experience working as a White House Correspondent?

like

Does anyone want a ticket to the Mets/Phillies game

like

Found an apartment by W 39th street and 8th ave - any know if this area is safe?

funnylike

So...I started my own company in 2018. Things went off like a ROCKET. Its a small Remodeling company and we specialize in higher end bathrooms and kitchens etc. I love working with my hands. I also have my education though and...I am going to return to tech work. I just wonder..when is enough enough? When do you pull the plug?

like

Anyone from Mindtree banglore??

like

Yearly hike at optum??

How is the CoRE research services team?

like

Hi Fishes,

If anyone is looking to buy Life/Health insurance product please connect, we can avail good deals and discounts.

like

Does anyone know of any sf consulting firms offering equity as part of comp package?

like

What is a look back analysis?

like

Looking for an SM+ leader in healthcare financial due diligence and analytics to join our team. DM for more information!

like

Hey friends. Recently joined a startup with a heavy reliance on outbound sales strategy. Without a phone number... what are some of your best ways to get meetings booked with prospects?

Our product sells itself, but how do you set yourself apart to get the initial meeting booked?
What mediums do you use with cold outreach that you find most effective?
What copy have you found gets the best ppen/reply rate?

I am not a sales PRO, but I'm also not a newbie. Really just looking for a think-tank.

like

Help me ask for a raise in my upcoming performance review? In sum, my company’s HQ is in Texas and I feel I’m being paid a Texas wage when I live in Los Angeles (the role is remote). We do have a San Francisco office and I want to ask my boss to match me what staff are making there. As that’s more comparable. Based off of Glassdoor, my salary matches Texas’s exactly and SF has the same role at 10k more. Should I show him the Glassdoor page? Don’t want to come off too strong. Please advise

like
like

Additional Posts in Chicago Creatives

Two questions for the price of one—
How’s work life at DDB Chicago?
How’s the Skittles work out of this office?

SOS in Fulton Market. Does anyone have the ancient MagSafe Power charger for an old MacBook Pro (2013 era)? Can I borrow til 5?

like

Anybody looking for writers?

likehelpful

Anyone looking for an AD partner? Or any job openings? DM if you here anything or just wanna look at my book. I’m ooking to boost my portfolio.

like

Opportunity for Chicago Creative Directors! My company is looking to bring on a new in-house CD, whose background leans heavier into art direction. Must have solid e-commerce experience. Reach out on here and I can let you know about the company, job description, and fast track your resume to the CCO. Cheers!

likehelpful

How's the Chicago job market right now?

like

How’s Golin Chicago?

like

What shops are looking for new copywriters?!?

like

Anyone looking for SAD with UX/web skills? Agency or in-house. Email Hagioart@gmail.com and I'll send website link/password for website and resume. TIA!

Out of curiosity, what agencies have multi cultural groups or teams within - including bilingual teams for Hispanic market advertising?

like

Does Publicis network have a cap on freelance time, the number of weeks or days one can freelance?

What freelance company should I reach out to? The job opportunities lately have been limited.

Anyone hiring for account management?

like

What’s the best creative shop in Chicago?

like

What are your top 3 picks for best Chicago creative agencies? I’ll go first…

1) FCB
2) EnergyBBDO
3) Leo Burnett

like

Hey hey, anyone know if Leo or others are hiring freelancers right now?

like

Anyone have info on Huge Chicago? What is WFH policy? What companies they working with? What type of projects come out of there?

like

I’m almost 40. (Yes, I’m practically dead.) If there’s one piece of career advice I can give to young creatives: keep your portfolio updated. Don’t wait long periods of time. Just keep it going.

likehelpful

Summer is rolling through town like a freight train! It's gonna be over in the blink of an eye. What's going on this weekend?!

Anybody got a sibling who is obnoxiously cheap yet has a ton of money?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal