Curious about a few topics:
- How does feedback work at BCG and Bain? How are reviews structured? Does your comp change based on an EOY rating? How is your bonus determined?
- How and when do you become a Manager? What’s the process like? How does it impact your comp?
- What’s the difference between your BA-equivalent and Associate-equivalent?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

This is a 1+2 4 week engagement, I’ll send you pricing

likefunny

- Mutual Development Agreement written with direct manager before every case, committing to develop 3-5 strengths and areas for development in speechify ways
- Informal biweekly feedback with direct manager on strengths, weaknesses, specific development opportunities
- Post-case (or every 3-4 months) formal feedback from direct manager with MDP approval of draft and Talent calibration. Overall 1-5 score, sub scores and in depth qualitative feedback on 7 key areas, 30-40 sub-sub score dimensions, 4-point “Staff again” question
- 2x/yr Career Development Committee where you’re placed on performance/potential matrix relative to standards for your tenure (eg 12-18 month C2). Includes pre-CDC meeting with Career Development Advisor who solicits downward and upward feedback beyond what’s in reviews.
- Output from CDC includes comprehensive summary and development plan delivered by CDA and debrief/discussion. It also includes a very clear statement on promotion timing, even if you’re 18 months before the window.
- Promotions (A to C, C to PL) are recommended by CDC and ratified by MDPs. They are are more or less rolling (you can be re-evaluated every 3 months between CDCs). There is some flexibility but also a strong median/model tenure eg PL to P at 18 or 21 months is “early” but common for high performers, “on time” at 24 months, and late at 27 (or very rarely 30).

- Base fixed by level/tenure and automatically adjusts on promo and/or anniversary date.
- Bonus range is well known internally, with target and max increasingly with promos and tenure. Placement within the range is closely linked to matrix placement.

like

That’s a lot!

likehelpful

Interesting. Pretty similar to McK except that we don’t have a formal end-of-study feedback and our ratings determine base for next year and bonus. We only get ratings at EOY, so the mid-year review doesn’t technically count.

Yes - that’s true. It’s not a committee. Your “staffer” decides on your designation, alongside your “evaluator”. You don’t have to do 2x EM to get designated. There’s no formula - it’s when the “staffer” believes you are ready and attractive to studies as an EM (e.g., teams are willing to pay Manager per diem for you).

like

Interesting. Don’t have much time so I’ll just speak to the review process for now - we get reviews after each case, then an agggregate “PD review” (basically a cover letter about overall performance, with all of your case reviews attached as supporting info) every 6 month review cycle. For cases that are longer, you’ll have a review triggered every ~3 or so months so there are enough data points for your file.

Each case review has a rating attached (you get the review from your case manager, but you can’t see the rating, while your PD advisor can), and each six month PD review has a rating attached (which you can see; your PD advisor decides that using the input from individual case reviews).

You get to pick your “PD Advisor”, who’s the one responsible for that “cover letter” every six months and acts as your advocate and mentor outside of the formal staffing manager.

Feedback you receive on an ongoing basis from your case manager - generally every 2 weeks, though some like to do weekly feedback.

Base is the same for everyone of a certain tenure. Bonus is contingent on the rating for your six-month review.

Oh wow that’s a whole different world out there 😦 No wonder people say BCG is the most socialist MBB, the promotion process is VERY structured, every 2 years. Personally like it because there is no real point to competing against peers (I’m busy enough competing against the minimum performance bar), but I can see how it must be frustrating for extremely ambitious high performers

Agreed. I also think the competition is overstated at McK. My path is independent of those in my office. It’s not me against them.

Related Posts

Hi Guys,

I got selected at Infosys with 13 LPA, Axis Bank with 14 LPA and Blue Yonder at 14 LPA. Which one to join ?
Please Suggest

like

What to do when HR is refusing give salary range for internal jobs ?

like

What is the average salary of a Sr. Technical Manager with 20 years of exp.

like

Interviewing with Apple next week for the roles of Global Supply Manager (GSM) and Worldwide Procurement Analyst in Austin. Does anyone have any tips or advice for the interview? What kind of questions do they ask?
Also, what’s the compensation like in Austin specifically? I would think the compensation would be different than Cupertino. Anyone have any offers or salaries for these positions in Austin?

like

Jp Morgan HR round scheduled tomorrow, what kind of questions to expect?

Having 7 years of experience in Mainframe current CTC is 20.5lpa fixed, how much Max package i can ask for?

Please help as this is my first switch in whole career

like

What is the range of average salary increase and bonus in EY OTS this year?

like

Infosys 17 lpa 15%variable pay how much i will get

like

Please help me to know minimum variable percentage accenture gives?

like

Looking for salary range for X-ray techs with 15 years experience or more.

like

Hi Fishes,

I have been selected at citi bank.

Yoe - 5.7 years,
Cctc - 17.85 lakh fixed
What should be expected ctc for c11 position?? And what is c11 position??

like

What should a commercial claims account manager be making as a salary ? Handles asbestos claims only. Works for a TPA handling claims for 4 carriers. Law degree with many years trial experience as in house ID but for personal lines. This is first job handling commercial claims

like

Hi Fishes,
What should be the salary for Manager / Sr Manager having 14+ yoe in project/product service operations? I am at 32 lpa which I think is quite low having worked with top consulting firms for close to 12 years.

like

How much Salary should a Senior project Manager working in localization industry should be getting.
Also what all courses would be beneficial for upskilling.

I have cleared 2 rounds of technical interview and shared all documents with HR. They are giving me lesser package than what I have asked for. Does Capgemini give counter offer if I get offer from other organisation and share with them ?? Yoe-10, tech stack - big data Hadoop developer.

How is work life balance in automation testing in Publicis Sapient as a sr assosiate l1?

Giving 17.5lpa for 8yoe

Publicis Sapient

like

Hi Fishes, what can I ask as expected salary in Deloitte Malaysia for Senior consultant level? Any input on current salary slabs will be helpful!

like

Hi Fishes

Does EY GDS give 10% Variable and EY India give 20% variable?

like

Hi BNY employees,

What was your last rating ? Hike % & bonus % of CTC ?

Provide your input in comment.

like

Is everything getting 800 INR has Internet allowance over your salary? Or does it need any special approval?

like

More Posts

Expecting an offer this week or early next week, but want to know when you start negotiating the salary? When you receive the call from the company or wait until receiving the formal offer letter? And how should the negotiation start? Through phone calls or emails? Didn’t use recruiter for this position, so I don’t know what is the process here.

like

Do you believe influencers have just as many efficient marketing skills as someone in the field?

like

Hi Fishes, hope you all are doing good. Can someone provide me information about work culture at McKinsey Knowledge Center please? I am joining them soon in a tech role. Thanks in advance.

like

Facebook (Meta) Product Management (IC5) or Google Cloud Marketing S&O/ Annual Planning (L6) role if I want to eventually be working on Product Strategy for consumer tech?
Heard it hard to pivot from Google S&O to Product Strategy even with 20% projects internally…

Facebook (Meta) | Google

like

What’s a good exit from FDD that does not travel, less meetings, decent comp & wlb?

like
like

I've seen a couple posts about unionizing, anyone know anything about the potential Kaiser strike in early October? Saw online that they're already hiring for scabs, $3400-$5950 + housing, travel transportation, and per diem. And this is for techs!!!

like

Any one working in Emirates NBD in tech roles?

like

I racked up about $20k in credit card debt due to a confluence of things happening at once (move, school expenses , etc ). I have a fair amount of paper assets but not a much free cash. Assets are down a decent amount with the current market cycle and I’d prefer not to sell them to cover the debt , although they easily could. Any suggestions how to handle the credit card debt without racking up tons of ongoing card interest?

like

I find that being a police officer tends to limit my dating pool. I love being a cop don't get me wrong, but I need a little advice on how to navigate the dating world with being an officer. The moment I am transparent about my career, I get ghosted. Then those who do stick around tend to fall in love with my uniform and not me.

like

Thoughts? What could be going on here?

Post Photo
like

Chubb anybody at Chubb knows the range of salary? Being in grade 24 means what range?
Thanks in advance

like

Been wrestling with treating myself to a Dewar’s 12 for an upcoming anniversary or paying the extra bit for the 15. Thoughts?

like

Currently working in an IT audit role, what is the best way to transition into cyber ?

like

How many days recruiter take to release letter after documents..

What does the pay range look like for a UX/UI Design Intern?
Background: Master’s in CS student based in NYC/NJ.

like

The real walk of shame is leaving work before everyone else on your team..esp when you're an analyst

like

How much can I ask for IT audit role at ZS Associates?

Currently having 2.5 years of work experience and 6lpa as my CTC.

I want to start learning DevOps, what is the right path to learn DevOps? Does TCS has good projects for DevOps.. Suggest me any combination with DevOps.

like

Who here has actually made a genuine connection from being in this group? Let’s hear your stories 🍵

Additional Posts in All Things MBB

Anyone worked in Econ consulting before (eg., Cornerstone Research, Analysis Group, etc.)? Or pick Econ consulting over MBB? Would love to learn about the pay vs MBB and long term career path/exit opportunities. Thanks!

like

What’s the standard RTO (return to office) plan for MBB as of now?

like

How does WLB/hours change as you progress within McKinsey(BA->EM->AP)? In other words, do you work less hours at McKinsey when you become more senior?

funny

Had a final round at BCG last Friday. After the interviews they said that the would release results today. Then I got an email today saying they will only give the results on the next Friday. What could have happened?? I also know some people how interviewed on the same day as mine and got a rejection email today.

like

Fellow MBBers, any of you think the banking raises will trickle over to us (110k starting) or nah?

like

Anyone know if any of the MBBs are hiring experienced hires in India?

like

Hi
What opportunities are available for someone with a background in sustainability (Masters degree) and around 1 and 1/2 YOE

like

I have my first round interview (phone case) with McKinsey tomorrow. Any tips on what to expect with the phone case? Will there be an introduction (elevator pitch + why McKinsey?) or will they jump straight into the case? It’s only 30 mins.

like

What is first year partner compensation?

like

Accepted an offer with BCG! Looking forward to the transition next month. Will be in BCG Federal. Anyone in this bowl also in federal?

like

Could someone send me the link to the BCG bowl? Didn't come up in search

like

Is it possible for someone with anxiety to have a career at MBB? Anyone currently in this situation? How do you cope?

like

Anyone Hiring or willing to refer for a new role Within industry/strat consulting for TMT (Telco,Media and Tech)

Background : 8YOE (7 for TMT)
4 years in telco strategy (industry)
2.5 years Ex MBB
Currently at Boutique (TMT focus)

LOCATION: UK/London
Thanks!

like

Worked a few years at a small company and wondering what it actually takes to make the big jump to MBB. Anyone willing to connect and share insights?

like

I have an interview coming up for BCG but due to some personal reasons might need to push it a few weeks. What’s the likelihood the firm will be OK with pushing / is it even worth asking?

like

Has anyone used RocketBlocks for improving their chart interpretation skills? If so, do you recommend it?

like

Can Mck fish please advise on the role of a sponsor? How is different from role of mentor? TIA

like

Is the cover letter for BCG necessary? Do they really read it?

like

Is it worth making the time/money investment to make the switch from big 4 FDD to MBB. This would require getting into and paying for a top MBA program and my net worth would be way negative after that. Are the MBB financial returns worth it? Im 26 years old for reference

like

Anyone willing to offer referral for lateral hire consulting opportunities at MBB. Is it possible to share the profile internally with someone at Partner level for consideration.
12+ yrs experience in strategy, transformation, change, process improvement, cost optimization & analytics. Helped F500 clients on Future of Work & workforce transformation cases in pandemic.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal