Hi Compensation 🐠Received 3 offers from Deloitte, Accenture and Workday but can’t decide in which direction to go in. They all are competitive offers and would be a good pay bump for me. If you had to choose from the offers below, which one would you choose?

ACN Offer: Base - 146K, Signon - 10K (Assoc Man)
Deloitte Offer: Base 148K, Sign on - 15K (SC)
Workday Offer: Base - 120K, Signon - 24K, 70RSUs

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Accenture culture is great and has arguably better WLB of the large consulting firms - I would tell them you have a higher comp offer from Deloitte and try to get them to match if you choose to go the consulting route

likefunny

The Accenture offer is for their delivery center / services track, which is a 2nd tier class in the company. It’s a great track for those seeking better wlb and stability, but you need to be ok with not being in ā€œconsultingā€.

like

OP is clearly a Workday practitioner who's not looking to join management consulting to begin with.
Accenture's entire tech consulting is in that track.

The comparable offers at Deloitte and Workday are also obviously in tech implementation roles.

Recent IconRecent

Seems like ACN didn’t give you the consulting track so you can immediately rule that out

likesmart

Accenture. Your salary at Accenture will grow more quickly than your salary at Deloitte in the short term. WLB will be better as well.

like

Consider Accenture also has ESPP and the stock tends to perform well - an advantage over working for a private company

If you are really sado masochistic- take the Deloitte offer. It will make you feel better.
Else take ACN.

Workday will be acquired.

likefunny

At 60 billion market cap...they’re not exactly small

like

Workday is 70k in RSUs vesting over 4 years?

like

I see, I'm used to seeing RSUs as a dollar amount.

I read another poster say the accenture offer is not consulting track. If true, I agree you can forget about it.

The deloitte SC is a great offer. Do it for a year and if you don't like it you can leverage it into something better.

like

Workday āœŒļø

like

How’d you get Workday offer? Can’t seem to land interview. Go there though

like

Workday does a LOT of 'shell recruiting'. Where like OPs example, the hiring manager already has someone in mind and the rest of the candidate's are simply taken down 5 round of interviews and rejected for no reason. It's ridiculous!

I was in a similar situation where I simply applied to a role and was instantly called for interviews with a suspicious level of ease. But I could tell me interviews were going VERY well ... But was constantly reminded along the way that "there are 4 other applicants" (like DUH)..

At the end of their stupidly long process, I was told that I did great but they will reach out for the next opening. And they DID as well! I'm guessing I would have been the 'target' candidate in that second iteration. Lol.

Meanwhile I got an offer for 160k at a better firm and asked them to kindly FO!! LOL..

How many yoe?

like

4 years

like

As the folks mentioned the A offer is great though for their 2nd class citizen track bennies are different and upside is different on that track. Would not recommend.

D offer is great. definitely on the high side for that level so don’t expect crazy salary bumps for the future unless you are promoted. This is excluding bonus.

Having worked in their WD practice I think the comments about the terrible WLB is over hyped.

It depends on the project but i personally have not had that issue though I see that burn on very senior people, like PPMDs/SMs

WD is not known to pay very high in terms of salary and though the RSUs aren’t a lot it’s something to consider since it can appreciate value overtime. In addition, you have to look at the overall benefits that are offered at each company. The 401k match at deloitte is terrible but they offer a modest pension.

helpful

Dang 148k for SC in D is a lot. Advisory or Consulting?

I agree. Originally the recruiter told me anything 130+ was out of range for SC. But I notified them that ACN offered and then D countered.

What’d you end up going with OP?

Take the deloitte offer and throw their salary ranges for a loop.

What role is this for?

Related Posts

What will be the average hike % Promotion with HC rating staff (66) to senior(65)?

like

Got Differentiating rating and progressed from senior 2 to senior 3 in business consulting. How much hike and bonus I can expect?

like

Hi, how is zepto interms of job security

like

Hi Fishes,
Any Idea about Pega Practice at Optum?
Please do reply as I have joining in 4 days ,So honest replies are welcome :)

like

Hi fishes aand sharks,

If we are not happy with the hike percentage in appraisal. Can we ask more in the meeting with the PM? Wil they consider this request?

@kpmgindia @riskadvisory #frm

like
like
like

what is the years of exp for consultant rank in Accenture? how's the internal mobility like?

like

Hello 🐟 🐟 🐟,

Which is better to join oracle or ey

Thanks

like

I need help. Anyone have information of being an advanced medical support assistant for veterans affairs? I got offered a job in the SF valley . The pay Is a bit less but it's about 5.5 miles from my house.close. Why do people pray for government jobs? At the moment I'm with ucla health as an admin assistant float permanent& have been offered permanent placement at a site in LA about 16 miles . The pay seems pretty decent& also have the pension plan. Been here about 2 years no issues.

like

Does HCL take onboarding feedback after the joining

What’s the comp range for L4 Product Strategy/Ops in Mountain View?

like

Hi guys, I got an offer of 8.93 lpa from ibm which includes the pf and gratuity. What would be the in hand salary after deductions?

like

What is an average pay for a clinical lead medical assistant in Philadelphia area?

Does Automation testing / QA engineer have good scope and good salary hike or should i go for devlopment ?

I have personal interst for automation testing


Please suggest

like

What's the timelimit for accepting the offer letter from EY GDS?

like

How is the dot net work in publicis sapient? Is there any . Net department and team? They have project in dot net?

@publicis sapient

like

Partners, what are some of the most memorable and effective ways/reasons your team has asked for more comp? If someone is a high performer/emerging talent, what is the typical comp increase you’ve approved?

like

I am looking to work for a bank or financial institution in the US with presence in Latin America, I know about Citi and JPM any other?

like

More Posts

Is 80k decent for south east at a RSM/BDO/GT size firm for S1?

like

MBAs don’t make financial sense anymore (for those already in selective industries), change my mind

Post Photo
likefunny

Has anyone noticed that you’re more depressed working fully remote? Having a quiet and non collaborative team is really making me think if I would prefer a hybrid position.

like

Will people on notice period get hike letters?

like
like

If a headhunter approaches someone for c suite position but you know a friend who knows key decision maker/chairman. Do you just bypass headhunter? Its in round 3 shortlist.

like

Costco is selling washable black fabric masks by 32 degrees (brand) that are far more comfortable to wear than those medical masks. Highly recommend especially if you are not at high risk.

like

What’s the average GMAT score required for booth/Kellogg’s executive MBA ?

like

Anyone here from Hudson County NJ and follows politics?
I am NJ-8, and would like to vote for most progressive candidate on the ballot but no candidate except for the corporate shill/ son of corrupt nepo Menendez, has a fully developed site and I just cannot in good conscience vote for him just because he has a D next to him. Just moved to this district 2 months so any guidance appreciated.

Hello, I was wondering if Amazon is providing TN visa? I recently applied to the Quality assurance engineer role and wanted to know if they are sponsoring. Thank you!

Location constraint:

I have got a very good offer that i cannot deny, but location is Hyderabad, I want this in Bangalore location. I am not onboarded yet, spoke to HR , he said it is not a big problem,
Thoughtworks is very flexible.

Currently it is WFH, but once it is back to office.. I dont want to relocate. How easy it is relocate from Hyderabad to Bangalore, Thoughtworks

like

What are cutoff dates for hike in EY GDS?
Is it twice a year?

likesmart

How do the Scon bands fare up in USI ?
Engineering vs B schools

like

I have a dual citizenship (recently got my US citizenship). What are the odds I could ever get a clearance to work in federal branches (i.e., NSA, Cyber Command, etc.)? And what would be the career best path towards those areas?

like

Does Google project management certification helps in getting a PMO job??

like

Looking for advice. Based in the Bay Area and have 3.5 yr exp in IT Audit mostly SOX with a little SOC exp (ex big 4, couple of regionals) and have been applying to industry (mostly tech companies) since May. made it to final interviews only to find out hiring freezes were in effect or they went with a LCOL candidate.Would like to exit to a GRC role or a mixed role thats 50% sox, 50% varied projects, or a SOX role if the team culture is good. No luck getting in non sox work at current firm.

like
like

One of my friends has been given a choice, to work with an extremely outrageous target or to leave the firm. If he chooses to stay, he will be bound to serve a total time of 6 months. And if he refuses, tomorrow will be his last day, what can I suggest to him?

It's a critical decision and he is overwhelmed by this sudden obstacle. Any leads would be helpful.

like

Looking for a great espresso machine – willing to pay whatever as long as it lives up to its hefty price tag. Any recommendations?

like

Advice or Book recommendations on how not to get bothered by others/ friends/ peers? What they think or what they do!
Been struggling lately

like

Additional Posts in Compensation in Consulting

Sa1, 98 base so ya a little. Depends on what you do too though

like

Currently my base is 139K, SC2 commercial and the target promotion year is 2022. What % of base salary hike I can expect with exceptional ratings if I get promoted as planned? šŸ‘

like

How much additional comp would you personally need to seriously consider a non-consulting job?

like

Product Manager offer is 120k salary, sign on bonus of 15k. 4 YOE total. Undergrad degree in computer science. Am I underpaid? This is a legit question lol. I’ve only done federal contracting/consulting work.

like

What's the typical performance bonus for new experienced hire? Joined in Feb. I'm MBA S&O SC2 if it helps.

like

Hoping for promo in about a year with ~30% raise. How long would I need to stay at the firm, after raise, to be able to get more money in a lateral move to another firm?

like

Idk if this is the right bowl, but it's technically comp related. What do people say when asked about current salary during interview process?

like

Does anyone have insights on salaries at Accordion?

like

How much salary to quote to a google recruiter for a role that requires 15yrs of exp and a preferred qualification of an MBA degree? Also please let me know what level would that be 5, 6 or 7?

like

Hi can anyone share insight into Bain’s M1 salary, bonus, and profit sharing? In early talks for a potential lateral -1 YOE move. Chicago office in case that matters.

like

What’s the high-end base salary one can expect for a commercial SC without an MBA?

like

Interviewing at Deloitte for the position of Retail/Consumer Data Management Manager in a T2 city. What's the expected salary, is 190k too much to ask for?

like

Deloitte SM reporting and innovation pay band? Tier two city... 11 years exp with MBA from non premier uni

like

Anyone familiar with EY’s Goverment and Public Sector division? Looking for a pay range for a job listed as Senior in ā€œCustomer Experienceā€

like

MBA? / yoe consulting / title / company / age / salary

like

A team of 2 starting a very niche consulting firm want me to join and lead the first engagement. I’m very confident in them & the product/market fit. Do I ask for an ownership stake?

like

Anyone have a sense of the salary range for a Data Science Consultant with Adventure Federal Services? DC area, TS-SCI but no master's degree.

like

Do you say ā€œremunerationā€ in place of Compensation or in place of Total Rewards? For some reason I thought it was more related to TR and both Comp and Remuneration were used globally.

like

Salary for Accenture Big Data consultant - level 9. Based in Chicago for the Accenture Digital Applied Intelligence group. 4 years of experience, non-MBA

like

What’s BCG digital ventures comp model like?

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal