I’m in a tough spot deciding between two offers—one offers $120k with basic benefits, and the other offers $115k but with excellent healthcare and retirement options. How do you weigh salary versus benefits when choosing a position as a PA? Is it better to take the higher salary, or do the long-term benefits win out?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’d lean toward the offer with better benefits, especially if the healthcare and retirement options are strong. Over time, those benefits can save you a lot of money and provide long-term security.

like

Honestly, I’d go with the higher salary. You can always use that extra money to invest in your own healthcare and retirement options. Sure, benefits are nice, but a lot of times, you can get similar options privately. I prefer having the flexibility that comes with a higher paycheck, and then I can decide how to allocate my funds, whether it’s insurance or savings. More control over your money!

like

That’s not a big salary difference. If benefits are better consider what that value is. Sometimes the paycheck isn’t always the way to go. Consider commute costs, travel time, your mental health and which job fits better with your lifestyle and family.

like

Related Posts

What kinds of books, podcasts, TED talks, etc would you recommend for a recent college grad who has low self esteem, is professionally immature and for whom the prospect of entering the world of work is daunting and stressful?

Trying to find ideas/frameworks that will change mindset, tips, tools and heuristics for self organization, management, soft skills in a professional setting etc

likefunny

Does anyone else here have a hospitality management degree? Do you think it was worth it?

like

Has anyone moved from HR consulting to Core HR Roles?, I wanted to take some career guidance from him/her

like

Need 11 likes to acivate DM.
please help

likeuplifting

Im currently working in PwC. So is there any way to move to abroad?

like

wondering if any consultants here have switched to IB? And if so, what’s the process for doing so!

like

Joined Cibersites India Bangalore in Jan 2021 which is now htc global. There was no CTC revision with March 2022 salary, and so far, no news of CTC revision. I know employees working for over 24 months with no CTC revision. My question is are the appraisal formalities mere formalities? I'm unhappy about the pay structure. For a 65k PM CTC, I hardly get 52k in hand. With rising inflation, and no salary revisions, it's just going to be difficult. Tenured employees, please advise. 😥

Hi Fishes,
I have 6 YOE in financial reporting, if an opportunity in Morgan Stanley in fund accounting arises, should I go ahead with it or would it be a reverse step career wise, would appreciate insights on same and also of MSFS Fund accounting culture, WLB, if anyone can help with the same...
Thanks in advance, would appreciate your help

Hello IBMers,
IBM has offered me X amount ctc and i accepted it on portal....now got to know that market valuation for 10.3 yoe is greater than offered ctc....can i ask HR to increase the ctc and change the band...will they consider it?...not holding any counter offer as of now

like
like

Hello Fishes..

I am a UI designer, looking for opportunities.
YOE- 4+yrs
Location - Hyderabad

Any help is appreciated.

like

What is your toughest challenge hiring someone in their early 20’s?
For lots of different reasons I get the impression that younger people aren’t equipped for the employer, employee relationship.

like

Hi fishes, can you please tell me why do ppl say join EY GDS and not EY India. I am into Java Fullstack, yoe-4, location -Pune recently cleared online test and given interview and later get to know it's EY India not GDS. Now m worried should I join or not. I have 2 other offers from WITCH companies. EY EY India

like

Anyone have an extra ticket or know where I can get my hands on a ticket to infinite mirrors? I'm here for work and would love to check it out!

like

Will Infosys revise their offer if i show other offer which is from big 4?
CTC difference is 4 lacs.
Infosys is offering very less!

like

🐠 who have moved from an accounting background to management consulting, do you keep your CPA license active? Does it matter at all?

like

How do you all feel about the new entity LTIMindtree. What are your fears or what are things that you all excited about?

likefunny

How's Eldorado unit in Mphasis Pune. Will be joining soon as Senior Software Engineer. Any pointers will help! Mphasis TIA.

like

HDFC Bank Limited Someone having idea about HDFC bank Wholesale Credit Large ticket profile how is it ...is it worth going for???

like

Additional Posts in Physician Assistants

Anyone know of any non clinical PA positions or options?

like

Reposting: Looking for PA’s and/or NP’s for Neurosurgery practice in Union county NJ with OR experience.

likehelpful

Physician assistants in Chicago area/surrounding suburbs. What specialty are you in and what is your salary ($/hr)?

like

I’m a PA relocating to Phoenix area and negotiating an offer for home care visits full time. I am wondering if anyone in related field could tell me ballpark range what you are paid. I was considering asking for 142-152k range.

like

Does anybody work for Banner Health in Phoenix area? Would you consider the system to be PA friendly any other insider insights welcome!

like

What is the standard billing for a surgery PA? I read somewhere it’s 20 percent of what the MD bills for but I’m not sure how accurate that is?

like

Anyone planning on attending the virtual HOD meeting Friday about the name change?

like

Could use some insight on what the average salary is for a PA in philadelphia? Could you list salary and specialty please? Im in gastroenterology and IBD.

like

Does anyone know the average pay of a physician assistant emergency medicine working in Orange County?

like

I’m discussing a part-time orthopedic position that would include clinic and surgery in WA state, about 1 hour from seattle. 5 years experience. Anyone have experience with this? I’m looking for hourly rate expectations. I will be covered under their malpractice insurance, but no other benefits.

like

Has anyone regretted their decision to become a PA instead of a Physician because we end up doing mostly the same work but for less pay? I'm considering the extra education

like

Anyone have an idea what the hourly rate / salary for a new grad interested in EM in Colorado (Denver area) will be like?

like

Ortho PA in CT with 1 yr of experience. My time is split between OR and office. Coming up on contract negotiations and wondering what people in the specialty make ( even better if you have similar experience).

like

Where do you live/work & would you recommend it to a 20-something new pa!?Salary, benefits, lifestyle, etc.

like

I’m a brand new PA trying to find a job in dermatology. Does anyone know new grad friendly employers? Or are you looking for an awesome pa? 🤩 open to locations.

like

I'm considering training to be a PA. I'm coming from a slightly different vertical in the medical industry. I know salary is variable depending on location and lots of other details, but what could you expect starting out in a MCOL city?

like

Anyone leave clinical medicine for consulting or tech? What kind of role did you take? What kind of company do you work for? Pros/cons of the switch? How does salary compare? Work-life balance, job satisfaction? Any input appreciated. I’m burnt out and underpaid for the work I do. I’d love to get into Epic strategy or implementation.

like

Anyone do a lot of minimally invasive surgery and use blue light glasses? I’m wondering if they’ll help with the eye strain from staring at a screen doing laparoscopies all day.

I’m in PA school now but in the process of interviewing for what might be my dream job in medical imaging industry. If I get the job pay will start around 120k at a large company with room for growth. If I stay in PA school I will have around 120k in debt and will probably work in vascular surgery. What would you do? It’s literally the second week of school for me, I have my 3rd interview for the job next week

like

Anyone have experience with retention bonuses? Wondering if the terms are negotiable. I work for a large academic medical center, for context.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal