Midlevel here. Made a big clerical (honest mistake) error on a deal. Delayed closing by 4 days and the Client was pissed. The client didn’t want to pay for my work on the deal. Partner called me yesterday and told me I had until the end of May. They needed to recoup costs w my salary. I haven’t heard from HR yet. Possible to negotiate the standard 3 months severance here?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I feel like this could just be a downsize play and they’re using the angry client and “recoupment” as justification since their deal pipeline is weak. If they have work they’re not just going to slash an attorney…. So odd.

likesmart

This bowl is full of people who tend to think any conspiracy is more likely that what the actual evidence says so people not "liking" my post means nothing. You could be right but honestly do you think this is about $50k in severance or something or someone being furious over $500k or more in lost billings and potentially losing a client? I don't think this is secretly about the firm trying to save money because they were already planning to downsize, I think someone screwed up and a partner over reacted.

like

Shouldn’t senior associates and/or partners be checking your work lol That’s a crazy way to handle the mistake - I’m sorry this happened to you.

like

In a perfect world there would be a second (at least) set of eyes on everything, but unfortunately there’s rarely the time/capacity.

like
Recent IconRecent

Nothing to add but sympathy here — I’m sorry, that sounds like an awful situation.

like

You can ask. Weird way to handle this situation.

like

This is an insane way for the partner (and firm) to handle this situation. Makes sense not to charge the client for fixing the problem but eating costs of mistakes is part of the business.

like

This is odd. Are you sure you’re being fired?

like

It’s always standard because they want the liability waivers. They may be fine without them if they think they have a well-documented cause to terminate you. If you have a friendly partner you might be able to check with them to see if they have any insight. Otherwise it’s pretty opaque, this is fairly abnormal in this field. Again, really sorry.

like

Dude I’m sorry - this sucks and is not a normal way for them to react. You should definitely name and shame.

like

It sounds like you’re being scapegoated. It’s the partner’s responsibility to make sure the work is correct. The partner probably threw you under the bus when explaining the issue to the client.

I agree with the comment above that it’s also likely an excuse to downsize headcount when there’s less work coming in.

Mistakes happen all the time and write offs are common. The deal still closed. It’s not like you gave wrong legal advice that ended up costing the client millions.

likehelpful

This seems wayyyyyyyyy more grizzly and cut throat than I’ve ever seen/heard of. Why the aggression? I made a similar issue at my firm (V10 NY)

like

Wow this partner is WILD. I’m seriously upset for you. I’m like agitated. Wow

likehelpful

This doesn’t sound like big law.

likesmart

I’m so sorry this happened to you. Doesn’t seem like the sort of thing a real NY firm would pull (even in this market) - so guessing one of Jones Day, White & Case, Paul Hastings, O’Melveny, maybe Cooley.

likesmart

Does an individual partner really have authority to single handedly fire someone like this? Is it possible he is going a bit rogue here, not speaking on behalf of the firm, and hoping you’ll just leave without making a scene?

like

I have no idea if that’s allowed. I’m going to ask for a separation agreement since that seems standard

like

This is insane. These types of things happen more often than you think. Sorry. But, it sounds like your departure is for the best — you’ll find a better place to work.

like

Does this happen, someone makes a mistake and they get fired for one mistake?

like

OP, any update?

like

What the fuck.

+1 for the separation agreement and severance, because it’s not just the liability waivers they want, in this case they’ll definitely want a non-disparagement because this is FUCKING CRAZY and they will not want you to name and shame

Is 3 months severance standard? Sorry you’re going through this though

Related Posts

All of my experience is in litigation but I think I might like real estate more. Any advice on how to sell myself to a real estate firm?

like

Looking for Senior Researcher & Strategist in Dallas Fort Worth area to come work in tech. Message me for more information.

like

Hi All,
What is the market range of salary of an Assistant Manager in compliance (regulatory, Insider trading, AML) with 6 years of experience in a listed company?

like

Hi Fishes,
How much salary hike is expected in Tech Mahindra when an associate is promoted from U2 to U3 band??
Current CTC at U2 is 6LPA

like

That Friday feeling...

like
like

Is MBB serious about DEI? How is the environment for minorities (both at the bottom and top, including for East/South Asians)

like

Abu and Rajah.

Post Photo
likefunnyupliftingsmart

Can somebody from Amazon refer me for training Coordinator position if it's open.

Please help!

like

My resume got shortlisted for Operations Associate/Engineer-Amazon Managed Services role. I am an experienced AWS engineer with 5YOE.I feel like this role will be degrading in nature for me. Is it worth joining for this position. I would love to join Amazon based on my experience and skill set. But Not to some position which doesn't require AWS experience.

like

Is anyone working or knows anyone who works at Oysterhr? I've been looking at their glassdoor and it's full of positive reviews. I wonder what is it really like and also what is their salary range for project managers?

Looks good but I need some verification to know if this is not a sham.

like
like

I’m curious about the enlisted versus officer ratio as well...here’s a way to better survey the group. “Like” your respective group below.

Is there anyone who can discuss the current development trend of the world economy? I am very willing to learn and share what I know.

like

Is it worth using a recruiter? I am a U.S. Dist. Clerk in non major market targeting NYC. Didnt summer at a firm. T6, good grades (3.5-3.6).

like

Hello fishes,
I am a fresher of this current year looking for jobs in backend roles related to java and Sql . Could anybody help me with the current openings.....

like

What’s your long term career goal?

like

I find myself struggling the explain things with the same eloquence as my colleagues. How can I improve my consulting speak? Any recommended books?

like

Right now I’m a data analyst with TSQL/PLSQL/MySQL experience. I have experience writing complex queries/views/stored procedures/etc. I have intermediate excel skills and have dabbled in Power BI. I also taught myself PowerAutomate and now am automating my weekly/monthly tasks. My question is what will make me more marketable as a data analyst? Will getting my certificate in PowerBI help? What is a good ETL tool to learn?

like

What is the firm per diem for accenture strategy? You can spend this on travel engagements ?

like

Additional Posts in Big Law

Did the NYSBA forget about re-takers? Is this a grave travesty and denial of Art 15 rights to those who are not being allowed to sit for the exam? What about their financial distress and their ability to retain and seek employment?

Post Photo
like

Stop asking if we can unionize after being asked to work over the weekend.

likefunny

When should a stub start getting worried about not having much work and low billable hours?
I’ve asked for work but no luck. I know they say this is normal for a stub but when should I start getting worried and consider looking for exit options? Fyi, I like my practice group, so I don’t want to change to a different group within my firm, hence would have to lateral, if I have to. Also, other co-1st years are churning in high hours.

like

Any insight into Fenwick’s tech trans practice? Are they still hiring fully remote associates?

like

I accepted an offer to work at an Am Law 100 firm in June. I just graduated law school in May. They offered a stipend and reimbursement for bar expenses. I am currently still waiting for any word on when the money will come. They have not started onboarding me or anything. Should I be concerned? Why are they dragging their feet? I have contacted them 3 times since June.

like

Lit attorneys: have you ever been sanctioned? How many times and what was the justification?

like

Has anybody on the more junior side asked a new firm to move out of state (where the firm has another office with the same comp) for tax purposes? Still working with the same team in the same office in state one, and okay to fly back once a week even if the “two days in office” become a thing…

like

As a junior associate, would it be better to work in an office where my practice group is stronger (in numbers, prestige, etc.) or live in a city I love but where the practice group is very small?

like

After leaving BL, what salary do most people settle at or is that way to general of a question?

like

I’ve been at a job for a few months and hate it - partners set unrealistic deadlines, micromanage, and create work that truly is not necessary/push urgency when there is no real urgency. I had other offers prior to accepting this job that may still be options, and going back to my old job (for a pay cut) might also be an option. I can’t tell if this is just burnout, growing pains, or just an untenable work environment. Would you ride it out for a year at new job or pursue other options? HELP!

like

What is the typical first level of “off grid” salary (ie 2022 base salary for class of 2013)? Asking for NY, M&A, AmLaw100 market.

like
like

Should I complain to a firm's HR if the interviewers laughed at my answer during an interview? Maybe it sounded scripted but it was still heartfelt and genuine: my immigration story and how that made me appreciate the rule of law. I said it soo many times during OCI's that maybe it eventually sounded robotic, but for the interviewers to laugh and one to say sarcastically "nice elevator pitch", I thought was rude. Thoughts?

like

New to due diligence and not sure the timeline of projects. Tips to stay organized of the project and timeline, and how to update those leading the deal? Just keep track of new info and provide as necessary?

like

Which firms that pay market have no hours requirements for bonus?

like

What’s your firm’s billable hours requirement? Name + whether pro bono (or anything else) counts please

How many matters is typical for one associate to handle (BL lit)? I know it is group-specific, but just trying to get a general idea. I’m a 2nd year and I am the only associate staffed on about 30 cases-meaning I keep track of all deadlines, do all day to day assignments, keep on top of following up with client/OC, and all research/drafting. Partners handle deps/court but that is about it. Is this a normal case load to be responsible for as a jr? I being dramatic by thinking this is too much?

like

Beginning to consider going in house (4th, corp) - I really haven’t thought about what I want, partly because I’m not sure what’s out there/attainable. Is it a bad idea to start by applying to a couple positions that interest me and seeing where that gets me? I’ll of course prep for the interviews but am afraid to burn potential bridges if I ultimately decline because I’m still figuring things out.

like

Does anyone have any experience transitioning to a different practice area, specifically from tax to T&E? I’m a 4th yr associate trying to make this change and finding it a bit challenging. I would love to hear from anyone who made a similar transition and what they found helpful during the process… many thanks in advance.

like

How viable/easy is it to move from patent prosecution? I’m assuming patent lit is an obvious option, but what about tech trans? Other general practice areas? Bird law?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal