Sr. Writer/ACD in LA laid off twice this year. Horrible luck. Previously worked at Ad Age A-List agency and trying to get back in the big game.

Anomaly, TBWA, R/GA, Etc. Anyone have a lead?

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’m sorry op. You seem like you have great work history and you’ll make it out on top! I believe in you

like

Yeah, no need for anonymity when you need a job! www.JonathanJMiller.com

likesmart

Wait, I got let go twice this year too :-/

like

Don't you just love when you wake up and everything is broken?

like

Is bad luck worse than no luck? I’ve been looking for 18 months and haven’t gotten hired yet in LA. This LA market is real tough these days. I’m sure you’ll find something before long....your hiring stats are pretty good.

like

OP you’re not getting hired because you’re book is just not great.

And looking at you’re CV, none of the shops you’ve listed are notable.

My suggestion... reposition yourself as a designer. Aim for a better agency and find a more jr. role. Rebuild you’re book with a National brands (not regional work) and go into any new role ready to burn the midnight oil and ready to learn and check any previous experience/ego at door.

Good luck!

likefunny

@ACD1 it's tough to let the work speak for you aaaaaaaalll the time. I believe at a certain level pretty much everyone in advertising knows what a good idea is and how to make one. But clients don't always know. And they don't always trust. So you can end up presenting cannes level concepts with no chance of them ever seeing the light of day.

Sometimes a guy just needs a chance, yeah?

like

Both sides of this are fair points! I have experiences that count. I know how to run a video production and talk intelligently to a front end dev. I've pitched big accounts and collaborated with c level executives. So whatever I can say about how "creative" I am or not, these experiences are why I personally have the confidence that I can walk in anywhere and be successful. And sometimes you can be damn good and never given a chance at awards. I worked at an agency for three years that never once pitched new biz or submitted for an award. But I had a great deal of success there.

But also, I'm in LA. It is super competitive here. So if you've never done a huge budget TV campaign, I understand the hesitation on the agency's part at the level I'm aiming for. But we all also know too many talented people get ignored and too many not great people get rewarded because of names on a resume.

like

Care to share a link to your work?

like

Thank you to everyone who reached out with constructive advice. It is clear to me now that I haven't been presenting my work as clearly as I should. I've already invested lot of time in improvements to launch soon.

Just because there aren't huge TV campaigns there doesn't make my work "regional"; everything there was national work for a national brand. Major web redesigns, national franchise rebrand, and even global work. So if the takeaway is otherwise, then it's a failure on my part.

like

I was gonna say exactly what cd1 said above. If you want to more conceptual work, you'll need a more junior position to prove you're capable of the work. Just not seeing much of it in your portfolio and agree that the agencies you've been at aren't as noteworthy. I've been in the same boat so know that you're not alone.

like

That's fine but I would sooner take a mid-level writer position then junior designer. I don't know why any big agency would hire a jr designer with no bona fide design experience. I'm a writer. A growing writer still? Yes. But a writer.

Even if the agency was an A list, no ecd or cco will care unless you have work that made them say "wish I thought of that." The only agencies in the states that have the power to get you a job even if your book is meh are 72, w+k or maybe Martin agency. But having to defend your work this hard vs letting it speak for you should be a sign that you need to make a change if you want a job at an r/ga etc. Go look at what's winning at Cannes and d&ad for inspiration. Stop leaning so heavily on a resume that's not doing you need any favors and know your time as a strategist while a nice to have isn't gonna show up as years of experience as a creative.

like

How long were you in each role?

More than two years in the first. Less than three months in the second before the office closed suddenly

Ah man well that's no good! No issues on my end. Maybe try and go directly to www.jonathanjmiller.com/work ? Thanks for looking either way!

@Creative Director 1, could you elaborate on the drawbacks of regional work? I always assumed that if the work was truly excellent work, it wouldn’t matter if it was regional or national

Sure... regional doesn’t have the same stakes. It’s harder to prove regional is real. Regional doesn’t have the same stake holders. We want to see you can think and operate on big huge brands and big budgets and sell and execute great work through the many layers inside an internal brand and big agency. Regional doesn’t have the budgets. Regional doesn’t have the media. Finally, If i don’t know you’re little regional store, it’s harder for me to judge whether the creative is great for that particular brand/product.

Not saying if you do something regional and it’s amazing you shouldn’t put it in your book, it’s just going to be dismissed easier, and for it too catch my eye, it has to be that much better.

Also for hrs, it’s a great way to show you can think when you’re starting out...

But if you want to work at the shops he mentioned, as an ACD or Sr. Writer, well fuck man you gotta have more than small time mom and pop stuff in your books.

If he was a designer like I originally thought, looking at his book, I might say, he may not be a big thinker or he may have yet to have the opportunity, BUT. As a CD he can layout print, decks, OOH, design a site etc... I’ll bring him in as a mid level designer and after he gets settled and into a rhythm give him the opportunity to learn/prove he can think bigger.

And not harp on Duder, but the trampoline gym for example wasn’t great writing, and while the design was fine, there wasn’t anything conceptual or big thinking going on. So strike one is it’s small local gym. Strike two the thinking and concepts aren’t great.

If the writing was 30 percent better and it was Nike or something, you might not get many points on creative, but it’d show you know how to sell and work with a big national client.

Unfortunately for this work it does neither.

Hi Jonathan, what did you make/do on INFINITI? Saw it on your resume but didn’t see any auto work.

That's the job I was only in for three months before they got rid of everyone and went back to CP+B. Nothing really produced.

helpful

I agree with what you all are saying about the lack of "conceptual" work---to a degree. Like I said, there aren't massive TV campaigns here.

But A: the trampoline gym is one of INC magazines top ten franchise businesses every year. 150+ locations in US. It's international. Completely rebranded and repositioned with a new look, tagline, everything. Completely reversed their failing business.

Integrated global launch campaign for Kawasaki? Yes.

A three-part animated web series starring an influencer that I created and co-wrote? Yes.

But really, it's my interactive and social work that should make me a decent candidate for an R/GA or HUGE or something in my mind. There's a lot of interactive in my book. This is far less conceptual work and in no way less important!

Y'all have your manifestos but I've broken sales records and grown investment from multiple national clients through digital campaigns.

So all I'm saying is that there's a bit more to the story here. And I'm sorry but even though it's right, the "no notable shops" thing is BS. #1 it's not completely true as I started at an A-List agency working for the marketer of the year--its where I learned a lot of what I know. #2 let's maybe realize that at small agencies a lot of good talent exists doing good work that doesn't get recognized because you're small.

I know intentions are good here, but I'm a writer and a strategist for 9 years. I'm good at what I do. My clients like me. I win new business. I mentor other writers. If I'm doomed to lesser known agencies for life so be it. I am not a designer. That ain't happening.

Congrats on your accomplishments. That's "your": y-o-u-r.

Thanks for your advice and salary details.

I'm still working on trimming some case studies but I've made some pretty significant updates to my site if anyone cares to look. Thanks again to those who offered feedback and encouragement.

Related Posts

Can anyone at Intuit give me referral for SDE Intern role?
I have good hold on DSA

like
like

Anybody know of any art director positions open?

I’m looking for developers with react and angular skills for an Indian product company. I’m not able to get good resources from job portals. How & where to find candidates with decent skill sets..??? I’m looking for just 2-3 years of work exp.

like

Hi all
I am a senior system engineer with 3 years of experience in ReactJs.
I am desperately looking for a change right now.
It will be greatful if I can get few referrals

like

Hi there, I want to be referred in the organization

like

Hi all!
Want to break into IB in London (BB's and EB's) as an Associate.
Anyone willing to refer or can share any info?

Thanks!

like

Deloitte USI Anyone willing to refer me for Oracle SOA and OSB? I am having 9+ years of Relevant exp. Deloitte USI Deloitte Deloitte India

like

For referal in Amazon, DM your profile

like

Can any one refer me im KPMG GDS? Working in another big4 GDS AWM sector as a senior. Having experience of 2 years.

like

Bain & Company I’m an Indian seeking work opportunities in technical and/or consulting space in Europe/UK region. Have almost 4 YOE in BI/Data Analytics domain.

Any leads would be appreciated.
EY Deloitte PwC Zalando Accenture HelloFresh Delivery hero Glovo KPMG Apple Google Boston Consulting Group McKinsey & Company Roland Berger Oliver Wyman Simon-Kucher & Partners Amazon Bain & Company OC&C Strategy Consultants Arthur D. Little IBM Bolt Wolt

Good morning everyone, Anyone open to referring me to a role at Amazon.

Can anyone refer me for EY Canada?

like

Anyone have any idea when the hiring freeze might end within AWS ProServ? I’m currently at Amazon and have a TS clearance, PMP & CSM. I come from a Big4 consulting firm with a background in Enterprise Performance. I’ll be honest and say I’m not feeling very safe in my current role with the ongoing layoffs. Instead of leaving, I’d love to go back to my “consulting roots” and join the ProServ team. I’m taking my AWS Certified Cloud Practitioner exam next weekend. Hoping this freeze is lifted soon.

like

Any news on layoffs/recession in banking industry?

like

Looking for a job change. 9 YOE as BA/PM. Can anyone provide referrals? I can DM details or email/LinkedIn. Appreciate your help!

like

Layoff in IQVIA?
@iqvia

like

Happy Wednesday! Any Citi folks willing to help? . I’ve been eyeing consumer banking analyst role at Citi, and I would appreciate a quick resume review/ possible referral. 🙂 would be so grateful. Thank you.

like

Meta/Facebook lays off 11k employees

Facebook (Meta)

Post Photo
funny

More Posts

Thoughts on the new Ariana Grande track called God is a woman? Everyone in my creative department was loving it and I felt like the only one who wasn’t 100% on board.

like

No better way to start the week than sitting next to a passenger with awful BO 🤢

likefunny

Making my to-do list for the week:

Post Photo
likefunny

Can someone on H1B claim education tax credit?. Prior to H1b I was here more than 5 years on F1.

likehelpful

Wipro


Impetus is giving me 14 fixed for 3.5+ YOE- Big data? Could it be negotiable? They are saying they can negotiate more if joining date is near 🤣 wtf

like

For rent paid below 1 lakh there is no need to submit landlord's PAN. I have calculated based on my HRA and if I show rent paid as around 96k my tax refund will be around 13k.

However there is no rent agreement or rent receipts.

Will it be a problem later on if I show this in my ITR?

like

What are the raises like for a Registered WM Client Associate at BOA/Merrill Lynch? Are they on an annual basis and are they competitive?

like

I’m a Junior accountant, recent MBA grad in Finance, located in NYC, just got laid off due to a merger. Anybody hiring or know any opening positions?

like

Hello 👋

After about 18 months of hustling, I’ve been offered my first AD role. My background is in engineering so for what feels like forever I’ve been building (and rebuilding) my book with creative work and it’s finally paid off 🎉

I want to hit the ground running so I’m trying to learn as much as possible before I start.

Can anyone recommend some books, shows, talks, social accounts etc that I can learn from?

Thank you!

Pivoting from five years of insurance defense litigation at a mid-size firm to family law in a small/boutique firm (3 partners and about 4 associates). What do you wish you knew when you first entered the field? Any advice is appreciated! So excited for this leap of faith into what I truly believe is my calling.

like

EY M&A (SaT) or RSM TAS? I’m split on deciding where I should go to guarantee better exit ops and pay

like
like

Any insight on Chicago’s Jackson Lewis office? Have an interview there soon. Would appreciate any insight on salary, culture, reputation, etc. (4th year attorney)

like

Headed to nyc for the weekend! Any hotel recs near fun bars?

like

Hey fam, I'm going to Banff in 2 weeks. How bad are the lines to get into parks for lake Louise and lake moraine. I'm staying at the kananaski resort for distance consideration

like

My wife is worried about her job. She works as a vendor to wipro.her manager told her to send resume and docs to upload, they will transition her from vendor to wipro payroll. Her parent company is asking her to tell wipro not interested.she wants to get converted to wipro permanent payroll. Is there any NOC required from vendor?pls comment

like

Worst part about being unemployed is the pity face everyone makes when you tell them. If I hear one more "don't worry you'll find something soon" I'm going to scream. Trying to be helpful is one thing but pitying me helps no one and makes me uncomfortable.

like

Hi Fishes,

Looking for some better opportunity now .
Overall 5 years of experience
Incident Management Profile

like

Car collision repair shop recommendations? No idea where to start. 🫠

like

Additional Posts in Advertising Careers & Job Hunting

startup Gig Alert: I am looking for a brand designer to join our startup team at Lifelines (truly a startup and we’re not in stores yet). We’re a product company set for revolutionizing how people approach sensorial wellness and I’m looking for someone with holistic experience in branding / art direction with a clear, bold visual style. Around 5 years of experience preferred. But work and personality trump years in experience. Always remote+unlimited PTO. Send me books / portfolios.

like

Are there in-house opportunities for a writer in Chicago?

like

Our client, a Manhattan pharmaceutical digital advertising agency is looking for a VP or SVP Brand Strategy.. Needs experience working on a brand with multiple indications in the oncology space (ideally) and be actively working on approx. $7 mil. of revenue.
1st. round of interviews will be internal. Candidate will be asked to present to the agency, then meet the client. On-going work will be remote. The salary range is $165 to $210++ negotiable
Contact us for job description
Stay Safe

like

Saatchi LA is looking for an ACD/CW

Post Photo
like

I’m looking for a writer to help us with unique content for a heavy machinery/industrial website. Any idea how I could locate such a niche freelancer?

The consumer electronics division in my company needs creative management/direction for a team of packaging designers, well probably more than that really. But there design team is not very organized or reliable because of their control freak owner, who is very indecisive, and probably micro-managing.

Anyone up for the task?

Location Central, New Jersey
80-90 range with flexibility for the right person. Possible hybrid schedule.

like

I’m looking to hire a full time strategy director. Big agency experience. NYC based agency, but remote for the foreseeable future. Drop me a DM with you email or website if you’re interested!!

like

We’re hiring! Looking to fill open spots across our analytics team at an IPG agency. Can be remote for now. DM if you are interested!!

like

Applying to Creative Agencies and it got me thinking-

Do recruiters or hiring managers care if you provide an "optional" cover letter? Do they even look at these?

like

Looking for a couple of very strong social strategists with agency experience. Open to remote working. Hit me up if you’re interested!

like

AE’s looking for a new gig in your stocking? Great, longtime agency in Boulder...

Post Photo
like
like

MullenLowe NC is hiring with 10+ openings. (Link in post)

Post Photo
like

Any LA agencies looking for Associate Producers?

like

Currently working as a mid weight AD in Amsterdam, thinking about making the jump to NY. Thoughts on whether it’s worth it?
And how much is the average wage at this level?
🇳🇱 🇺🇸

like
likehelpful
like

Anyone know the average salary range for an experienced ACD or first time CD in Los Angeles? Would it be comparable to NYC?

like

📌Sensedia is a Global Company and We are Hiring in the USA!!! We are Growing and We Want you to Grow with Us! 🚀

Senior Marketing Manager
lnkd.in/dX6QpuQQ

Presales Solutions Architect
lnkd.in/dwYmPMCm

Analyst Relations Manager
lnkd.in/dQD-_EMU

#usajobs #solutionsarchitect #solutionarchitectusa #usamarketingexecutive #marketingcareers #workwhereyoubelong #sensedia #marketing #hiring #architect

Post Photo
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal