TLDR: help me figure how much pay-cut I can take moving from Hoboken, NJ to Chicago for comparable QOL/ savings.

Longer: Been in NY for 7 yrs, but my spouse is starting PhD in Chicago, and we both LOVED it.
Ps. Hoboken is a walkable, young, urban city right across the river from Manhattan, $3200 1b rent.

Stringent go-to-office mandate means I can’t keep my current job (I tried various routes for 6 months)
We’re a single earner HH, 250k+ TC

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Over the past 3 months we have done ample research to shortlist we would like to be in wicker / buck town / or any where between armitage to Irving park, east of 90/Elston rd.

We have visited multiple times and Airbnb-ed to get more feel of the city and have really landed on the decision that we are ready for the move. I understand that I pay not get paid as much in Chicago but what to assess what’s ‘reasonable’ pay cut.

like

It’s very tough to calculate imo because it depends on your savings rate. I would say you could take a 30% haircut and not notice

likesmart

Id only add that at your income/rent ratio, you need to take it with a grain of salt. You probably won’t spend less than $2k on rent in those neighborhoods and you might well spend closer to $3k. However the place will definitely be bigger than Hoboken lol.

like

I moved from NY to Chicago several years ago / was dating a PhD in a similar campus situation as you (opposite though - primarily Evanston and secondarily downtown) / maneuvered a job change as part of the move. Feel free to DM me.

Don’t underestimate the commuting demands for both of you would be my only suggestion (Northwestern has free buses between their campuses and pickups on certain routes for instance, which could reduce need for multiple cars/ generally make dealing with lakeshore traffic more bearable). If you’re out West closer to the highway you’ll both be dependent on either driving potentially or complicated transferring between buses / blue line, which is not nearly as reliable as you’re likely used to in Hoboken / NY.

Pay cut also likely depends on what industry you’re in (eg finance related might be a tougher salary to maintain vs management consulting or big law etc. just given the makeup of firms in Chicago vs NY).

Do research of job postings you’d be competitive for and cross check pay estimates on Glassdoor etc. then check post tax income from a site like smartmoney. From NYC to Chicago the tax drop was significant (a months rent roughly).

Generally speaking - I tell people it costs about 60% to live in Chicago vs Manhattan (so maybe 75-80% vs Hoboken), as that’s generally been my experience (can get a lot more space / newer homes or apartments for your money, food etc. cheaper for the most part, childcare eventually, parking if you choose to drive).

like

Depends on lifestyle. Which neighbor you live in will make a big difference on cost (rent, availability of cheap groceries, cost of restaurants, parking, number of Ubers). You’ve picked some of the priciest areas of the city. Unfortunately Chicago salaries are based on COL of the suburbs & cheaper areas. Also keep in mind Feinburg isn’t a great area for public transportation. I lived in Lincoln Park/Lakeview during grad school and drastically underestimated how much I would spend on taxis to get to campus late/early and during the winter. Red line isn’t great at the moment so I would do your diligence based on when they will be traveling.

like

I’ve been taking the EL between LP/Lakeview and downtown for 20 years. In my 20s we would take the red line at night to the bars. Red has never been the greatest of the lines but has progressively become worse post CoVid. Midday this summer I’ve personally witnessed on the train individuals going the bathroom, individuals with their pants down, feces on the train, physical fights, open drug use, and aggressive harassment of other passengers. Last straw for me was downtown this summer when I witnessed a guy grab a gun from his waistband while fighting with another woman. I still take the El but walk farther to brown line. If someone is going to depend on the redline they should ride it at their expected times to make sure they feel comfortable. A quick google of “stabbing” or “shooting” and redline will give an overview of recent activity.

I’m ex big tech with what was a comparable salary. Chicago is doable on one income at $250K +. That said, the job market here is horrible, and the cost of living is even higher than it was since a slew of taxes were imposed on July 1. Don’t commit to moving here without something lined up first, and aim for the same salary. Good luck!

like

PM1, we hereby revoke your gender card and declare you an AH.

All you said was BS. You clearly don't live here.

like

If they’re a PhD student, you should probably prioritize living closer to the institution as they will be spending 80-100 hours on site and will be commuting back and forth often. I lived in Chicago and commuted to Evanston for grad school and it sucked. I had a car too so it wasn’t even public transportation.

like

I’m not familiar with commuting from bucktown to feinberg campus but I’d look into potentially one of the east side neighborhoods with better bus access than relying on the red line/L. You could probably go anywhere from Lakeview east up to edgewater and be a little closer if you do have to go to Evanston!

likehelpful

What do you do / industry?

like

I used to live in jersey city paying over 2k for a 1 bedroom.. I now live in wicker in a walk up that’s a 2 floor 3bed 3bath and rent is $3425 so aka you should be fine as long as you aren’t looking to move to west loop, Gold Coast, or LP wicker/west town/bucktown/logan square all young and fun neighborhoods you’re gonna be saving regardless

Related Posts

Anyone know salary range for level 4 at United Airlines US ? It will be IT QA Manager position United Airlines

Currently working for Genpact AR Billing Walmart. I have also worked with BT Global services for the UK Billing production team. Job responsibilities raising billing for multiple products for Media broadcasting, Collections and payments. Responsible for RPI activities and more. I have good experience in billing, Invoice generation for multi currencies, collections, payments , DSO billing. Looking for a good job opportunity in Noida in Similar profile.

WNS Global Services Can anyone please help me understand the organization hierarchy and if possible minimum years of experience & salary brackets associated with each level? SalaryBox WNS Global Services

Why associate consent is necessary if he/she is got SA project?

like

Comforting others:
When someone tells me bad news regarding their health, I say everything I am supposed to say (I’m sorry to hear that, I’m here for you, etc) EXCEPT “everything is going to be ok”. Because I can’t guarantee that and I really don’t know if everything is going to be ok. I was taken aback recently when a friend told me I am calloused and cold-hearted for not being able to say those words. Is she right? Should I start saying this for the purposes of providing comfort only??

like

Been through all interviews, recruiter said it's looking good but they would let me know early this week and asked if that works from a timing perspective since they know I was interviewing with someone else also. I said yeah that's fine. Would it be weird to follow up today or should I wait to hear from them? Want this one over the other but don't want to seem desperate..

like

Hi.. I am happy to join here. Seems to be an amazing platform.

like

PWC SA2 got an offer for 34LPA fixed.
Currently at DUSI at 24 LPA.
Worth the jump?

like

Are people who joined in January not receiving any hikes this year at ac kolkata?

like

Can someone help on how to get a burner?

funny

I have given Credit Suisse exam on 22nd May. And it was good but till now i haven't received any call or message from them. Whom should I connect now?

If I have got an offer letter from Infosys and I accepted the offer, then I can be sure right that they will give joining for sure on the said date?

like

Anyone ever considered contractor gig in Meta/Facebook or any other big players in tech? I'm full-time in a smaller company and it's pretty stable. Wondering if the move could be worthwhile. Mostly want to explore other areas. Other things to consider: planning for babies in the next 3-5 years; maternity leave in current position is basically what's legally required.

like

What are the leaves policies in Accenture we have ? Can anyone share the leave calendar for this year in Accenture

I’m having a really hard time with my changing body. 13 weeks, I don’t have too many bad side effects of pregnancy or anything so I consider myself lucky (no nausea ever etc) but I’m depressed at work, my skin is completely broken out and showing new broken face capillaries, and I’m not showing a bump yet so I just feel fat and big. I don’t know where this “glow” is but I look in the mirror and literally am grappling with not recognizing myself :( it’s been impossible to find any clothes too.

like

Is there a growth in GOC, how is work life balance.

like

I recently visited for the first time the Santiago Bernabeu stadium, the stadium of the world-famous Real Madrid team, and despite being a physical engineer, I can not help but recognize that civil engineers are magicians, my congratulations to them.

like

I'm almost at the point of an offer, and also just started a 6 month long engagement since my utilization was taking a hit. How do you fish recommend dealing with the situation once the offer comes?

like

Additional Posts in Chicago

Anyone in the suburbs find it harder to make friends compared to the city? I don’t want to move back but I don’t know what else to do..

like

Hi Chicago - just moved here from the UK (via 7 years in Germany) and looking to make some great new friends.

Moved to River North and into trivia nights, most sports, movies etc and would love to find some people open to adding a city newbie to the group!

42m if that matters 🤷🏻‍♂️😁

like

Anyone know of any stores in Chicago that buy used furniture? I have a massive and heavy executive desk I want to sell that will require movers to transfer, so I feel like I can’t go the usual routes of Facebook and Craigslist with much success. Any recs would be SO appreciated!

Post Photo
like

Found a random engagement ring.

Hi all, so I found a platinum ring (which I assumed it's an engagement ring as it has dates and initials engraved on top.) And a Divvy tag (I have no idea what it was until I googled it. Apparently it's a bike sharing service in Chicago) in a briefcase I ordered online. I was thinking of returning the item back to the store but that wouldn't help the person who lost the ring. Attached is a picture of them.

What should I do now?

**I'm not in Chicago

Post Photo
like

What is the best Chicago NYE party? Are the hotel ballroom parties worth it?

Thoughts on Chicago athletic club? Would likely be going to lincoln park / lakeview locations

like

Is anyone else finding ubereats, DoorDash, etc to be less reliable in recent months? I’ve had several deliveries go missing or arrive hours later than expected.

like

It’s snowing today and I’m not ready for it, mentally at least.

like

Anybody on here send their kids to Francis Parker?

likefunny

I’m interested in joining a networking / professionals club in the city to meet other ambitious people in industry / banking / consulting. Anyone have a good experience with any groups like this? Thank you in advance :)

like

Any other recruiters in this bowl?

like

Looking to make friends near Lincoln Square! 30M. Into chill things to light activity, e.g., going to the movies, archery, escape rooms, etc.

like

That guy who posted the backpacks post got ratio’d in to oblivion and deleted his post.

Glad to see cool heads prevail

likefunny

Come on Bears we need a win!

likefunny

Are there any well-off suburbs around Chicago where there's a significant amount of black or mixed race people? Significant meaning 40-50%+. I've seen a lot of nice black suburbs in southern and eastern cities but less in the midwest. In an interracial relationship and want to get an idea if there are any suburbs where our kids would feel represented or if we'll need to move down south for that.

like

Where are the dark skinned male professionals in Chicago? Where do yall hangout? .. dark skinned SINGLE men 🤪

funnylike

Who does the best NY style pizza in Chicago?

Evaluation Criteria:

Delicious pizza sauce
Cheese pull (cheese that melts when the pizza is pulled apart)
Crust crunchiness

like
like

All these announcers do is talk about how Aaron Rodgers is God… it’s worse than Brady.

like

Best Christmas things to do with a two-year-old?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal